Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01699 · Session 5

Release of murder victim bodies for funeral arrangements

Closed Submitted 11 Jun 2018 Justice
Signatures
0
1,046 online signatures with a country
Comments
71
Considered
3 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to change post-mortem examination protocols to allow for the deceased to be released as early as possible to enable families to make funeral arrangements for their loved ones.

What the petitioner did first

I have met with my MP and written to Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 13 Sep 2018
    1 mention
  2. 27 Jun 2019
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 16 Jan 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

1,046 online signatures
  1. Scotland809 77.3%
  2. England113 10.8%
  3. United Kingdom101 9.7%
  4. Wales9 0.9%
  5. Northern Ireland5 0.5%
  6. Australia5 0.5%
  7. Ireland1 0.1%
  8. Sweden1 0.1%
  9. United States1 0.1%
  10. Not given1 0.1%

Comments

71 comments, oldest first
71 comments · showing 51–71
  1. Joyce Bowie 20 Jun 2018
    As soon as possible
  2. Lynn Mcvey 20 Jun 2018
    Please allow bodies to have a 2nd post Morton and then be released to their family so a funeral can take place.
  3. Bernard Manson 20 Jun 2018
    It's awful
  4. Alexander Miller 20 Jun 2018
    Shocking
  5. Alexander Scullion 20 Jun 2018
    Awful
  6. William McNeil 20 Jun 2018
    Signed
  7. Jacqueline Radford 20 Jun 2018
    I think this is very important to all the family's in this situation to have closure and put there loved ones to rest as soon as possible.
  8. Kevin Woodburn 20 Jun 2018
    Another shocking example of the system letting scottish families down. Post mortem rules again. The judiciary must listen to the public they are there to serve. Scandalous,Let this family grieve properly.
  9. jasmin gordon 20 Jun 2018
    please allow them some peace and closure by allowing them to lay him to rest.
  10. Jenny Long 20 Jun 2018
    Families of murder victims should be able to make funeral arrangements for their loved ones as soon as possible should they wish to.
    I would support the idea of a second post mortem to be carried out independently.
  11. Michele Burns 20 Jun 2018
    This has to be changed to allow families to grieve for their loved ones
  12. david stewart 20 Jun 2018
    perhaps some common sense and sensitivity should be applied for families in these positions
  13. Stacey Wood-Everett 21 Jun 2018
    I totally agree the law in Scotland needs to change as families are not let grieve properly after the horrific deal of murder as they cannot Bury their family member until the accused legal team say they can. My childhood friends brother was murdered they were lucky as his body was released relatively quick but still longer than if it had been over the border in England or Wales.
  14. MAUREEN Welsh 22 Jun 2018
    Please sign
  15. Tiegan Kilcullen 24 Jun 2018
    Yes I do agree , bereavement is painful enough , this is just prolonging the suffering of this family .
  16. Lynda philp 24 Jun 2018
    S support
  17. William Allison 25 Jun 2018
    It is time for the boy to rip
  18. LYDIA REID 9 Jul 2018
    It is hard for most people to understand the need to bury our loved ones
    The thought that our relative is lying with no respect in a morgue is hard to live with
    On the other hand Police Scotland have a job to do
    Rules have a reason
    It does seem that an independent Post Mortem could be carried by someone from England Ireland or Wales
    They have no agenda
    I doubt they would cost more
    It would allow the defense of any person charged to feel they have achieved an independent Post Mortem
    It would allow the family to bury their loved one
    The defense could carry out any tests on the resulting blocks and slides resulting from a post mortem
    Good luck to this family
    I hope this works out for you
  19. Mark Conner 10 Jul 2018
    No victim of murder or their family should be left in limbo like this. Two independent post-mortem examinations can be carried out ASAP and the results passed onto the PFs office and to any defence lawyer when a person is charged. The victims body should be released to their fsmikieuthin days.
  20. Mark Lilley 18 Jul 2018
    I agree that families of murder victims should be enabled to make funeral arrangements for their loved ones as soon as possible.
  21. Gemma Cruickshanks 18 Jul 2018
    Let families lay a loved one to rest so the can grieve