The next petition for consideration is PE1699, by Amanda Digby, on the release of murder victim bodies for funeral arrangements. The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to change post-mortem examination protocols to allow for the deceased to be released as early as possible, in order to enable families to make funeral arrangements for their loved ones.
The briefing note explains that, in the event of a murder, an investigation takes place that includes a post mortem to establish the cause of death and to provide evidence for a criminal prosecution. In Scotland, when someone is then charged with the murder, the defence has the right to carry out its own post mortem, which might uncover things that were not the focus of the original examination. Sometimes, however, it can take a long time—possibly years—for someone to be charged. As the petitioner sets out, that can result in a lengthy delay before the victim’s body is released for a funeral.
The situation is different in England and Wales, where, if no one has been charged in connection with a murder and the police do not expect to make an arrest within 28 days, the coroner will arrange for a second post-mortem examination by a pathologist to take place, independent of the first. The body can then be released and the coroner retains the report for use by the defence if, in due course, an arrest is made and charges are brought.
Members will have noted that, in February, the Lord Advocate answered a parliamentary question to the effect that a review of post-mortem examination protocols is taking place in order to enable more effective consultation between pathologists who are instructed by the Crown and by the defence.
Do members have comments or suggestions for action?
