Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01696 · Session 5

Preserving Scottish Battlefields

Closed Submitted 14 May 2018 Housing & Planning
Signatures
0
1,245 online signatures with a country
Comments
200
Considered
2 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to introduce legislation to prevent the development on battlefields as listed on Historic Environment Scotland’s Inventory of Historic Battlefields.

What the petitioner did first

We have discussed the issues raised in the petition with Margaret Mitchell MSP.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 13 Sep 2018
    1 mention
  2. 30 May 2019
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

1,245 online signatures
  1. Scotland442 35.5%
  2. United States336 27%
  3. United Kingdom113 9.1%
  4. France87 7%
  5. Canada70 5.6%
  6. England58 4.7%
  7. Germany46 3.7%
  8. Australia42 3.4%
  9. Belgium11 0.9%
  10. Austria4 0.3%
  11. 16 other countries36 2.9%

Comments

200 comments, oldest first
200 comments · showing 151–200
  1. Donna McIvor 4 Jun 2018
    History should be preserved at all cost and above profit.
  2. Holly Warren 4 Jun 2018
    It is a disgrace to imagine.
  3. Patti Johnson 4 Jun 2018
    So sad when the thought of money outweighs the desecration of a historic site. If the construction goes forward, may the spirits & ghosts of valiant warriors haunt the residences
  4. Diane Lyon 4 Jun 2018
    With all the special interest groups pushing their own agenda, if we continue to give in, we will no longer have any history, pride, or self awareness. My thoughts go to all of the historical places destroyed by despots, hate and now greed. We need historical sites for our children as well as ourselves to remind us of our mistakes and victories.
  5. Meagan Wiedmeier 4 Jun 2018
    This historic site should be preserved!
  6. Linda Earwood 4 Jun 2018
    All historic sites should be preserved for future generations to learn about their history and what sacrifices were made for their country!
  7. Matthew Sampley 4 Jun 2018
    There should be no development at this location unless it honors the fallen on both sides.
  8. Karin Bruenggel 4 Jun 2018
    I don't live in your beautiful Scotland, but somehow my heart is telling me that I have to go there one day. So this saving of Cullodens battlefield is very important to me. You have this magical place, where many fought and died. It has to be remembered for the futur generations! You can't build houses there! Remember, what past generations did, tell your story to your children, grand children. Make them proud of their heritage! Please! Keep those historical places save! Thank you for listening to me!
  9. Julie Wolf 4 Jun 2018
    History is a precious thing.A very delicate thing. We must do all we can to preserve it. If the future generations can't learn from previous times, they are doomed to repeat them.
  10. Karen Belknap 4 Jun 2018
    Please preserve my heritage!
  11. Jean Dineen 4 Jun 2018
    You live in a country so full of history. Do not let it slip away due to commercialism.
  12. Rev. Brian J. Maurig, Jr. 5 Jun 2018
    My ancestry includes links to the clans Jamieson, Macbeth, Galbraith and Gunn and I feel a strong connection to this heritage. I vehemently believe that to allow the desecration of such a sacred site would be unconscionable. Please, in the name of all that is Sacred, stop this from happening. Preservation of this site is crucial.
  13. Emily Kitzmiller 5 Jun 2018
    So many historical sites have been lost in America. Your country is rich in it's history, and Culloden battlefield is vitally important to teaching your people about it's past. Please, do not lose this important site to developers.
  14. Kelly Devine 5 Jun 2018
    My ancestors fought and died on battlefields all over the world. Destroying these historic sites is a horrendous way to honor their memory, and the causes they fought for.
  15. Allison Meekis 6 Jun 2018
    I am not Scottish, I grew up with an aunt that had come from Glasgow and she taught me all about the battle of Culloden. Please do not let greed take over history, people must remember what happened so future generations can learn the history.
  16. Mrs Jennifer Langrish 7 Jun 2018
    I think it's extremely important to preserve our history for future generations. If legislation is given to build on one site, where will it end!
  17. Catherine Rolland 9 Jun 2018
    Culloden and the surrounding area is a war grave & should be protected. There are plenty other sites for house building, cannot believe that the Culloden site was given planning permission.
  18. John MacDonald 10 Jun 2018
    Culloden has to be protected by The Scottish Government.
  19. Anne Fleming 10 Jun 2018
    These battlegrounds should be hallowed ground.
  20. Yvonne Percival 10 Jun 2018
    The battlefields not only hold huge historical value but they are also war graves, & as such sacred. Please protect these sites to help preserve our history & the memories of those who died there.
  21. Donald MacKenzie 10 Jun 2018
    There are lots of empty field that people can build on. Do not sacrifice our history for the sake of profit. Indeed, there is profit to be made from history. For goodness sake, preserve these sites.
  22. Morag connell 10 Jun 2018
    Preserve our heritage and sacred space
  23. David Donnelly 10 Jun 2018
    These places are of historical significance and councils should not have the right to give these builders the right to build on recognised burial grounds . It should be a separate Scottish government agency that has control of all ancient Scottish battlefields.
  24. Grace Dunn 10 Jun 2018
    Our history is important and we must learn from it and retain it, especially today. I am only now aware of the lack of Scottish history taught when I was at school.
  25. Anne Watt 10 Jun 2018
    Any building is sacrilege
  26. Gail Topping 10 Jun 2018
    We should be preserving our history for future generations and respecting those who lost their lives in battle. Please do not allow developments like this to proceed
  27. Rosina Cargill 11 Jun 2018
    I am fed up of my Scottish Heritage and History being slowly chipped, chipped, chipped away. In the words of Cicero "To be ignorant of what occurred before you were born is to remain always a child. For what is the worth of human life, unless it is woven into the lives of our ancestors by the records of history?"
  28. Florence Gardner 11 Jun 2018
    I think it is important that Scottish History is preserved and respected . This site is part of our history and important to Scotland
  29. Angela Morlotti 11 Jun 2018
    Our ancient battlefields, final resting places, must be protected and respected. Put a stop to house builders and land developers trying to build on them.
  30. Stephen Aitcheson 11 Jun 2018
    This must be stopped. Our messsge must be loud and clear- we will not allow you to trample over our history any more than you have been trying to do wthin your skewed political and selfish mindset- an effort which has been on the increase since 2014. We are not stupid, neither are the graves of our fallen yours for vanity projects and dirty money.
  31. Anne Curran 11 Jun 2018
    Historical sites must be preserved for future generations
  32. Caroline Crawford 11 Jun 2018
    They fought for us now we should fight for them
  33. Lesley Smith 11 Jun 2018
    Surely there are other fields suitable for building on nearby
    - why detract from the landscape and atmosphere of one of the most significant battle sites in Scottish history? Pure greed.
  34. Ninian Fergus 11 Jun 2018
    A disgraceful, and politically motivated abuse.
  35. elaine robertson 11 Jun 2018
    Scottish heritage in all its aspects must be protected from these money grabbing conglomerates.
  36. Susan Smith 11 Jun 2018
    This ground does not belong to us who are here nowWe have no right to obliterate the past It must be revered and protected for future generations We mustnt forget the past
  37. Keith Ellwood 11 Jun 2018
    If you want to build on this sacred ground then you'll have another dead body there. Mine. Only killing me and thousands of others will you get to build there and that's not going to happen.
  38. Phil Scott 11 Jun 2018
    Please listen to your people and stop the desecration of our war graves.
  39. ALIX GAULD 11 Jun 2018
    It's a graveyard of spirits that must not be consumed by greedy investors who only see money and not the history.
  40. Linda Wright 11 Jun 2018
    Any battle cemetery I've ever visited, be it WW1 WW2 or Culloden,deserve the quietness of the surrounding environment. It's very difficult to evoke that same feeling of deep respect for the fallen, if you can't hear yourself think because the Number 10 bus is dropping off the screaming weans from school. I'm not too sure I'd want the ghosts of angry Jacobites stomping through my luxury pad.
  41. Marlene Halliday 11 Jun 2018
    Knowing our history is important. Being able to visit historical sites and see the actual places where significant events in that history is essential. Culloden could be developed but as a historical site sensitive to the resting place of those killed on the battlefield, not as a housing development.
  42. Robert nixon 11 Jun 2018
    Yes all scotlands battlefields are sacred grounds.for the people who died ther.
  43. Janet Donaldson-Elder 12 Jun 2018
    Building on any historic battlefield site is an abomination. There are human remains on most if not all battlefields and to ignore those and what they mean is not acceptable. This is desecration and I keep hearing about the possibility of building on various sites more and more. There are many empty building and other sites, leave our history alone.
  44. Mr Andrew Jones 12 Jun 2018
    The land of Scotland is steeped in history. There should be no development on historical battlefields on Scottish soil. It is more important to preserve the memory and the history of this great land than to profit for few.
  45. Martin Morrison 12 Jun 2018
    Show some pride. Have some care. Learn to respect the past. Please
  46. Grace Boockholdt 15 Jun 2018
    History is sacred!
  47. Fred Rutledge 15 Jun 2018
    Keep the historic sites in good order, not under concrete. Thanks.
  48. Michele Guadagnoli 18 Jun 2018
    Culloden should be kept intact and complete as a historical site with such important history
  49. Nakki Goranin 19 Jun 2018
    It is morally and ethically wrong to build on or by a development on the blood and bones of people who fought for political rights and the privilege of having the right to choose their own religious faith... Regardless of where you live we, as world citizens, must respect those who fought for the right to have dignity and freedom.
  50. James Stevenson Grant 21 Jun 2018
    Having returned from a holiday in Uzbekistan my awareness of the necessity to protect historic sites has been greatly increased. They are a legacy which should be protected for future generations.