Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01696 · Session 5

Preserving Scottish Battlefields

Closed Submitted 14 May 2018 Housing & Planning
Signatures
0
1,245 online signatures with a country
Comments
200
Considered
2 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to introduce legislation to prevent the development on battlefields as listed on Historic Environment Scotland’s Inventory of Historic Battlefields.

What the petitioner did first

We have discussed the issues raised in the petition with Margaret Mitchell MSP.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 13 Sep 2018
    1 mention
  2. 30 May 2019
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

1,245 online signatures
  1. Scotland442 35.5%
  2. United States336 27%
  3. United Kingdom113 9.1%
  4. France87 7%
  5. Canada70 5.6%
  6. England58 4.7%
  7. Germany46 3.7%
  8. Australia42 3.4%
  9. Belgium11 0.9%
  10. Austria4 0.3%
  11. 16 other countries36 2.9%

Comments

200 comments, oldest first
200 comments · showing 101–150
  1. Neil Downie 30 May 2018
    I am supporting this petition because I am appalled by the consideration of current planning proposals for Culloden Battlefield.
  2. Dr Fiona-Jane Brown, Aberdeen 30 May 2018
    Battlefields from whatever period of history are WAR GRAVES and should never ever be developed or built upon.
  3. Beverly Niland 30 May 2018
    Preserve all Historical sites from Building on them
  4. Allen Henderson 30 May 2018
    It is ridiculous that with a history the likes of what Scotland has, and the attraction that History has throughout the World, that we need to resort to petitioning to try and protect the sacred land that our forefathers fought so bravely to protect. Please STOP all this NOW and never let it rise ever again.
  5. Canon Mel Langille 31 May 2018
    A great cause. Apologies if I have already signed...sometimes I lose track. No deceit intended.
  6. Jurgen MacGregor 31 May 2018
    It would be a great shame for Scotland NOT to preserve Culloden and the surrounding areas where good scottish jacobite soldiers died for the freedom and independence of Scotland. The government should pay respect to what happened there. If it is all about money then start thinking about how all visitors around the world who had lost ancestors there will be thinking of the actions of selling out national history.

    Yours J. MacGregor
    Germany
  7. robert cairns 31 May 2018
    You have my support in any way to stop work around or near Culloden Battlefield.
  8. Heather Edward Henderson 31 May 2018
    All Scottish Heritage should be protected even if the cost is high.
  9. Matthew Donnachie 31 May 2018
    It really is becoming shameful that the general public are forced to object to quite obviously wrong decisions over building on sites corrupting our national heritage
  10. Mairi MacKinnon 31 May 2018
    This is a site of huge historical importance and should be protected at all costs!
  11. Michael Marcinczak 31 May 2018
    We saw the fields in 2006 ... a wonderful journey in Scotland ... These historical important places should be protected.
  12. Marilyn Ruta 31 May 2018
    stop to destroy your heritage!
    it's a shame and it's totally disrespectul for Scottish history
  13. Donna McLachlan 31 May 2018
    Scottish Heritage sites should be protected without question
  14. Paul Hewitt 31 May 2018
    Utterly disgusting that the big boys think they can build on a site that blood was spilled on. It's a war grave. Consider abandoning this crazy idea!
  15. Tammy Cooper 31 May 2018
    Save our History!
  16. Paul Hewitt 31 May 2018
    Disgusting that the big boys think they can build on a site that is more or less a war grave. Consider abandoning such an idea. Absolute madness!
  17. Andrew Duncan 1 Jun 2018
    It's imperative that Scottish battlefield sites are preserved for the education of future generations. We cannot allow further desecration of battlefields to happen. The development at Culloden being allowed to go ahead was a disgrace
    - and we can never let anything like this happen ever again...
  18. Robin Christ 1 Jun 2018
    Destroying historical battlefields is a crime in itself. They need to be preserved to educate the future generations so nothing like that ever happens again. It's sacred ground!
  19. Marjorie White 1 Jun 2018
    Historic Battlefield sites are war graves to be respected.......not building sites.
  20. Brendon McQueen 1 Jun 2018
    Scottish History and sites of historical importance should be protected especially those considered war graves
  21. Marti Morrison 1 Jun 2018
    Only in Scotland would such audacious plans see the light of day. For way to long now, those who seek gold has dictated our Nations path rather than what is best for us all
  22. Anita Napier 1 Jun 2018
    On this land, and it's surroundings, lie the final resting place of the fallen after the battle of Culloden. Under no circumstances should any war grave be disturbed, disrupted or moved. This our National Heritage and has a major place in Scotlands history. Any attempt to change this should be dismissed with all speed and authority
  23. Deb Murphy 1 Jun 2018
    The men that lie beneath the ground of any battlefield have given the ultimate sacrifice to their country. It should always be considered hallowed ground.
  24. chris mccoy 2 Jun 2018
    theres plenty of places to build unnaffordable housing so why choose a historic battlefield where dead people are, its plain disrespectful
  25. Christy Salter 3 Jun 2018
    This is hallowed ground and the resting place of those who fought for their county. Stop developing
  26. Annemarie Dunbar 3 Jun 2018
    How can you possibly condone desecrating Cullodon Battlefield ?! #dotherightthing
  27. Sonya McNaughton 3 Jun 2018
    This battlefield and the brave men buried there needs to be respected and left untouched.
  28. Gaul Ann Stuart 3 Jun 2018
    Please do not let them take this symbol of pride be taken away. We are in awe our ancestors who fought bled and died on many Scottish battlefields. Please preserve them.
  29. Catherine Liderth 3 Jun 2018
    Don't destroy an important part of our history.
  30. Theresa Garrison 3 Jun 2018
    Please consider the timeless history that this battlefield illustrates. People all over the world visit Culloden Battefield to feel Scottish history.
  31. S Cheatwood - Pybas 3 Jun 2018
    I can't imagine why this would be a good idea. There should be an established buffer area to stop encroaching. Families deserve access to loved ones and time to remember
  32. Heather carlson 3 Jun 2018
    This is a sacred place for those fallen to be mourned. Please to not desecrate this sacred ground for unnecessary development. As a visitor, I want to honor and respect your history not see it destroyed.
  33. Pamela Vogt 3 Jun 2018
    Save Culloden Battlefield for the dead
  34. Valerie Martinell 3 Jun 2018
    Absolute outrage to build anything on battlefield or burial grounds. Do these developers know where their ancestors are buried?????
  35. Marlise Perkins 4 Jun 2018
    This should be a preserved heritage and historical site. It is, in fact, a graveyard of our ancestors, and these men all deserve to rest in peace, don't they?
  36. Sandra Brown 4 Jun 2018
    Colloden is a sacred place
    - a battlefield and a graveyard. I cannot understand how anyone could consider desicrating this historic place
  37. Ann Kurt 4 Jun 2018
    Daughter of a proud Scottish warbride & a Canadian soldier. I was "made" in Scotland when my parents wed and then born in Canada when my mom came to join him. Stop messing with my country before I get to see all of it !
  38. Leslie C Martin 4 Jun 2018
    of the Clan Macleod of Lewis.
  39. James Ian Emerson 4 Jun 2018
    Preserving Culloden and the surrounding area that has already been determined as a historical site, portions of these Land's should not have been sold to begin with. It should be preserved and honored has the sacred grounds of our ancestors who gave their lives for freedom in Scotland.
  40. Kari Acosta 4 Jun 2018
    Please do not change this historical place.
  41. Sharron Trowbridge 4 Jun 2018
    Culloden is your heritage . Remember the men that have fought and died for your country. This is there home now
  42. Melissa Newhall 4 Jun 2018
    I am a descendent of Scots who fought at Culloden. Please save this historical land. It is hallowed ground.
  43. Deborah McQuerrey Gow 4 Jun 2018
    Please keep this sacred site sacred.
  44. Debra Cummings 4 Jun 2018
    I agree that it is vital that legislation is laid down now before any further inappropriate developments on any battlefields as listed on the Inventory of Historic Battlefields
  45. Laurie Hadfield 4 Jun 2018
    History is beautiful, sad, painful and glorious all in different ways everywhere around the world and more and more of these places are being destroyed for many different reasons. Please, please don't let this be one of them.
  46. NADEGE MERLE 4 Jun 2018
    As in all countries, the duty to remember must exist. We must not forget that without these deaths during all these confrontations our present generations would not be here. Let's not forget them! And what better way to preserve these places.
  47. Christina McFarland-Helms 4 Jun 2018
    Care must be taken to preserve history. History forgotten, will be repeated. Lest we forget.
  48. Elaine Boyle 4 Jun 2018
    The final resting place of anyone who fell in battle, no matter what battlefield, no matter what country, should be considered hallowed ground and should be forever undisturbed.
  49. James Alexander 4 Jun 2018
    A Nation was slaughtered here! What would it say if an SNP Government to allow this to happen? There are many other suitable sites available for development in this relatively remote area of Scotland.
  50. Barbara Fraser 4 Jun 2018
    Culloden should be preserved and respected just like any other British war grave at home or abroad.