Petition · PE01696 · Session 5
Preserving Scottish Battlefields
Signatures
0
Comments
200
Considered
2 meetings
What it asks
Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to introduce legislation to prevent the development on battlefields as listed on Historic Environment Scotland’s Inventory of Historic Battlefields.
What the petitioner did first
We have discussed the issues raised in the petition with Margaret Mitchell MSP.
Where it was considered
Official Report-
13 Sep 20181 mention
-
30 May 20191 mention
Signatures by country
1,245 online signaturesComments
200 comments, oldest first200 comments · showing 51–100
-
Margaret Lang 25 May 2018I cant beleive that this is something that we need to petition government about. This should already be protected land, all battlefields need to be preserved, no other country worth fighting for builds on their historical battle ground. The world is watching, let our Scottish Government show that it is proud to protect its history, its identity and its people.
-
Monica Payne 25 May 2018Our history is what makes us who we are.
-
Andy Fairgrieve 25 May 2018Please act now on this to protect our heritage
-
Annette Webster 26 May 2018The world is also watching dont let big business demolish a sacred national treasure.
-
Annette Webster 26 May 2018The world is also watching dont let big business demolish a sacred national treasure.
-
Alistair Hamilton 26 May 2018To honour those people who had fought and died for a cause of their own personal identity, I deeply think that needs to be safe guarded.
-
marion mcmillan 26 May 2018this is long overdue.
-
Cathy Dube 26 May 2018Protect historical sites for future generations.
-
Jenny McWilliam 26 May 2018We look to our History to help secure our future.
-
Lora J Miller 26 May 2018I hope that when my small grandchildren visit Scotland someday that they will find Culloden Battlefield much the same as today. A gravesite and memorial to our Scottish ancestors that has endured the test of time.
-
Alex Kinnear 26 May 2018Preserve the past, it shapes the future.
-
David Gordon Aitchison 26 May 2018Disgusting to build on war graves. The councillors that voted in favour should be ashamed of themselves and some of them with good highland names I hope they hear thier ancestors .
-
Karen Doyle 26 May 2018These battlefields are historic and sacred and should be preserved always.
-
Kathleen Galbraith 26 May 2018These sites are our history and must be preserved, not built on
-
Kathleen Galbraith 26 May 2018These Historic Battlefields should be preserved, not built on
-
Per-Ragnar Jatko 26 May 2018The preservation of battlefields from the Scottish history is important, both as a way to attract tourism as well as a important reminder of the proud Scottish history. To allow development on historical battlefields is just another part of the English colonization of Scotland.
-
John-Paul Nellany 26 May 2018That is a sacred piece of Land.Should show more respect for our fallen Hero's.Wouldn't like it if someone built a house on my grave.Disgusting.
-
Ruth Kennedy 26 May 2018We must stop this from happening it's beyond belief that this can be allowed..
-
Franziska Feist 26 May 2018No peaceful future without peace for the fallen
-
John McCulloch 26 May 2018Scotland Battlefields must be protected for future generations to learn our History
-
Jo Cant 26 May 2018We need to value our sites and our history to preserve it.
-
Andrew Dalgliesh 26 May 2018Brave men died for this land protect it to honour their memory
-
Kate reid 26 May 2018Please stop and think about what you are going to destroy
-
Will Coster 26 May 2018Once these sites are gone they cannot be replaced.
-
Pamela F Gray 27 May 2018Preserve the past to secure a secure the future of Historically Important Sites
-
William Fitzpatrick 27 May 2018For the grace of God please think again, This is sacred land to Scotland.
-
Andrew lawson 27 May 2018A sad day when givernment gives the green light in destroying history for small profit.
-
Linda Harper Pope 27 May 2018Please show respect for the brave men who died and were buried on this hallowed ground.
-
Andrew Duncan 27 May 2018Blatant disregard towards historical sites. There should be no new buildings on battlefields etc. How are we going to keep these places for future generations to study, if there's no regulations to prevent new builds?
-
Keiran Anderson-Blake 27 May 2018Historic Battlefields should be preserved at all costs!
-
Jim Hamilton 27 May 2018History is important not only now but for future generations
-
William Paterson 27 May 2018Battlefields and their environs- as well as being of historic importance- should be treated with the same reverence as maritime war graves
-
Joy Gardner Boothby 27 May 2018If we donot protect these sacred grounds they will be lost forever what are we teaching our children how important history is when we do the opposite and destroy such things!!!!
-
Mary turnbull 27 May 2018We need to respect our history and those who died fighting for a free Scotland .
-
Barbara Houle 28 May 2018Yes I agree. Look at what has been done to Dundee. It is important to preserve our history.
-
Kathleen Dale 28 May 2018there should be a non-negotiable municpal law against developments on designated battlefields and gravesites that have nothing to do with preserving the site.
-
Alfie McQuade 28 May 2018I have been there a few times, and it really gives you an eerie feeling knowing all those brave men died on that site trying to protect there heritage. Taken away by people who don't care about remembering history's diabolical episode's that were forced on the Scots.
-
Michael Anderson 28 May 2018Hugh's comment is spot on.
We secure the future by holding the past
Hugh Mc Cormick
15:44 on 23 May 2018 -
lorraine vance 29 May 2018Leave historical sites alone for future generations please!!
-
Manuela Fath 29 May 2018It's such a great place to feel history. We were there last year and our 8 year old son was totally interested. He asked a lot and we answered him. Such a place needs to be protected.
-
Petra Nobes 29 May 2018It's such an important place of Scottish history. It must be protected.
-
Jan Kupka 29 May 2018It is a historical place. Never should a place like this to be used for commercial aim. There are more possibilities to bring tourists for holiday to Scotland. Nobody should build tourist accomodation near to historic places. If you intend to visit Scotland as a tourist, you must have enough time for visiting. Otherwise we will have shuttle service an short distances between tourist accomodation and historical places in a couple of years.
-
Karen Riley 29 May 2018Good luck
-
Christiane Dupuis 30 May 2018Please, stop this disgrace and show some respect.
-
Syl Houghton 30 May 2018A site of such historic import needs to kept as it has been for centuries. It already has an impressive visitor center and restaurant. Any more would ruin it.
-
Aurore Vautier 30 May 2018This site is a true historical sanctuary that should not be contaminated by buildings or facilities for tourist, agricultural or other purposes... If the government is elected by the people, it must not forget that it acts in the name of the people and for the people and that this people, by this petition, claims loud and clear that it is absolutely against this decision to desecrate Culloden. A historic place but also a cemetery where thousands of people are resting. These people deserve the respect of the Scottish Government. Without these men and others before them, there might be no more Scotland as we know it
-
Groud Jacques 30 May 2018What à pity ! Only to make money
-
Kevin Donnachie 30 May 2018An insult to Scotland and the true patriots that died on Culloden if this is allowed to happen.
-
Lee foster 30 May 2018This a sacred battlefield and history and the sacrifice of those buried there should be the priority and memory not the pursuit of profit and greed.
history is more important than money and when I speak to my kids about our nations history I don't want to take them to show them a housing estate where a sacred battlefield and burial once was. Maybe one day our history will come before profit. -
Gary Clarkson 30 May 2018These sites are part of our heritage