Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01694 · Session 5

Free Instrumental Music Services

Closed Submitted 8 May 2018 Education
Signatures
0
9,860 online signatures with a country
Comments
824
Considered
4 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to change the law to ensure that musical instrument tuition is available as of right to all children attending state schools in Scotland who wish it, free of charge.

What the petitioner did first

I have discussed matters with my local authority and understand that Instrumental Music Services are provided by local authorities at their discretion. In these times of reducing funding to local authorities, discretionary services are easy to cut, or charge for and so I must broach the topic with the Scottish Parliament. I have also had discussions with my MSP and MP.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 13 Sep 2018
    1 mention
  2. 22 Nov 2018
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 23 Jan 2019
    1 mention
  4. 29 May 2019
    1 mention

Signatures by country

9,860 online signatures
  1. Scotland8,120 82.4%
  2. United Kingdom1,348 13.7%
  3. England215 2.2%
  4. United States46 0.5%
  5. Northern Ireland11 0.1%
  6. Wales11 0.1%
  7. Canada10 0.1%
  8. Germany10 0.1%
  9. France10 0.1%
  10. Australia8 0.1%
  11. 33 other countries71 0.7%

Comments

824 comments, oldest first
824 comments · showing 401–450
  1. Margaret Smith 1 Jun 2018
    The arts are equally important as STEM subjects. Music tuition should not just be for those who can afford to pay
  2. Mai Lawrence 1 Jun 2018
    The creative arts are an essential part of a child's education both academically and emotionally. In the present climate of soaring mental health problems among young people we should recognise the benefits of musical participation in all forms.
  3. Diana Taylor 1 Jun 2018
    The arts, and music in particular, play a very important part in a childs education. More free lessons should be made available not less.
  4. Donald McVicar 1 Jun 2018
    Music is classless and can be inspirational for all types of children
  5. Emma Newton 1 Jun 2018
    State education is supposed to be free and CfE is supposed to offer young people a wide range of outcomes and experiences. At present, the government is simply not fulfilling this commitment. Having such an elitist policy, where money rather than talent drives decision making is unfair, and also rather short-sighted. We only need to look to the arts funding in rising economies such as Venezuela to see the massive impact instrumental tuition can have on quality of life and learning. To develop our young people within the four capacities, change is needed now!
  6. Alan Marshall 1 Jun 2018
    This is such sad news! Expressive Arts in all forms provide children, who perhaps are not always academic, an opportunity to shine. To find their voice. To celebrate their talents and skills. To take this opportunity away or limit it somehow is just incredibly sad and fails children. Education should help children find their talents, whatever that may be, and nurture them.
  7. Ellen Larson Davidson 1 Jun 2018
    I am grateful for the music lessons I received growing up at my school in USA (small rural school district) where most pupils were in the school band. Music is important to learning and life.
  8. Diana Reeves 1 Jun 2018
    All three of my children have gained immensely from their music tuition received in school. It has given them confidence to perform and has shaped their lives by allowing them to become the people they are today. No other area of the curriculum could have supported my previously shy and timid children to overcome their fears in this way and to become the happy, music-led and confident people they are today. It is unlikely they would have been able to take part if there had been a charge for this tuition.
  9. Janie Scott 1 Jun 2018
    My child plays cello at school and goes to a school within an area of deprivation. I am very aware of the small numbers learning an instrument and I believe that it is currently completely out of reach for the majority of families. This does not sit well with me and it seems to me that only the middle class children get this opportunity. When I was at school everyone got a chance to try regardless of income. Opportunity needs to be given to all to learn an instrument and not just those who can afford it.
  10. Gemma Little 1 Jun 2018
    I was thought basis guitar and it was the best experience throughout my high school life, away from books and numbers. No child should be disadvantaged or miss out on the opportunity to learn an instrument because of their financial background.
  11. Amanda MacQuarrie 1 Jun 2018
    The wonder and joy of playing music is something all children deserve to have access to, not just those whose parents can afford it!
  12. S Clemson 1 Jun 2018
    Music has been proven to be one of the few things that uses many different areas of the brain, so is a valuable asset to help children with learning in general. Not all children are academic, some are creative, some have technical skills etc. Also this means children who may be gifted but whose parents can't afford music tuition will miss out and a talented person who could be successful will miss the opportunity. All children should be equal, and given the same opportunity regardless of their home situation. Music is also therapeutic for many and can help emotionally and mentally.
  13. Anna Quinn Cooper 1 Jun 2018
    Playing a musical instrument gives young people a way too express themselves in a different way.By being able to learn an instrument young people can develop not only their musical skills but their confidence.
  14. Ashley Brandon 1 Jun 2018
    I would never have been able to study at RCS if I did not have the free tuition to get me on the starting blocks, this opportunity should be available to all future generations
  15. Sarah Paterson 1 Jun 2018
    The benefits to children (and therefore to our society) of learning to play an instrument are many and varied. Confidence, self esteem, social skills etc and it music has been shown to increase attainment in general. It is such a life skill. It should be available to all, not only those who can easily afford it. So much talent will go undiscovered and so much joy will be missed without access to free tuition. A reduction in children playing would in time mean a reduced service and lack of orchestras.
  16. Evelyn Irvine 1 Jun 2018
    Music tuition is so important to the cultural futures of Scotland and should be freely available to all children
  17. Alison Noble 1 Jun 2018
    This is a most important cause. Everyone loves music, young and old
  18. Margaret Robertson 1 Jun 2018
    Music in its general form, of any genre, has been proven over and over again to give so many benefits to health and wellbeing. In traditional music, Scotland has its own world music giving identity to our culture and heritage and therefore to us as a nation. This should be championed, nurtured, protected and encouraged for free at every turn!
  19. Karen Kelly 1 Jun 2018
    My Kids get so much out of their instruments and I can barely afford the tuition for both. I certainly could not afford to pay for private lesson. Free lessons would ensure Inclusion.
  20. YVONNE FADDES 1 Jun 2018
    Children should have free tuition
  21. Madeline Spokes 1 Jun 2018
    Scotland has always been a country of musicians. We currently have an extreme lack of teachers and need investment to train more teachers to be able to teach a new generation of musicians.
  22. Molly McGavigan 1 Jun 2018
    I taught in secondary schools in Scotland (not a music teacher). I saw what great benefits music tuition brought to pupils and how the performances and achievements impacted very positively across the school. This was particularly true for those pupils who were not considered "high achievers". A very backward step to cut back on free tuition. Please do not do this.
  23. Paula Wilson 1 Jun 2018
    My son has recently started playing Violin. As a low income family we have been fortunate that this year we were able to get funding from a charity to pay for his lessons. However as our council have plans to increase his lessons astronomically over the next 3 years to over £800 there will be higher demand for funding so less people will be able to receive it. Some children are not as able academically and arts are a way for them to learn and feel included, so cutting music, drama and art classes is really not getting it right for every child, is it?
  24. Marjory McGhie 1 Jun 2018
    With the current mental health issues in young people it is essential to increase the opportunities for learning how to play a musical instrument.
  25. Sharon Ollis 1 Jun 2018
    Music tuition enables children to access something they may never have been able to outwith school.It gives them many opportunities to progress and become involved in the wider musical world. I would be greatly disappointed if this service was withdrawn. It would be much more accessable if it were free. One child in my class could not participate as her parents could not afford it. What a waste of talent!
  26. Annette Johnstone 1 Jun 2018
    Benefits children in so many ways, building confidence, opportunities to travel and meet people. Both of my daughter's played in school bands and if it wasn't for free tuition these opportunities wouldn't exist.
  27. Maura Lee 1 Jun 2018
    Music tuition was provided to me as a child and I am glad it was possible. I believe music can only enhance and improve a child's life.
  28. Michelle Macpherson 1 Jun 2018
    As a child who benefited from musical tuition in school i would love it still to be available for my children!

    I gained so much from it. Ability knowledge confidence xxx
  29. Fiona Campbell 1 Jun 2018
    Would also like to see that the instrumental services offer a full range of musical styles
    - folk, jazz, classical, rock and pop as you get benefit from all of them!
  30. James McKenna 1 Jun 2018
    A total of £90.2m is being invested into Stirling and Clackmannanshire by the Scottish and UK governments.

    The £45.1m from each government is part of the City Region Deals, which are designed to drive economic growth.

    The investment will support a new International Environment Centre and a new Aquaculture Innovation Hub.

    It will also help develop tourism and culture, and fund a £2m digital district and the creation of digital hubs in Callander and Alloa.

    The Scottish government also announced an extra £5m of funding to deliver a new business park at Kildean and to support the next stage of development of proposed new infrastructure at Callander.
  31. Kerrie Keen 1 Jun 2018
    All children deserve the chance to receive musical instrument lessons free of charge. To exclude children from poorer households is not right. GIRFEC should apply to every child, not just the ones who have money
  32. Darren Young 1 Jun 2018
    How can we GIRFEC by putting up barriers to education? How can we ensure equity for ALL young people, regardless of their circumstances? So many young people are going to miss out and the skills and confidence they will gain will be lost.
  33. Ewing Lauder 1 Jun 2018
    As a violin I now despair at the cultural wasteland that the UK has become. In my experience, classroom music has become music appreciation coupled with an endless procession of X Factor wannabes strumming basic guitar or finding a few simple piano chords. How have we arrived at such a state where 80,000 people turn up to to Wembley to watch a guy strum an acoustic and Noel Gallagher is the self appointed barometer of musical taste in the UK. We need to show our children that there is so much. much more to music.
  34. Maggie aitken 1 Jun 2018
    A confident and successful culture is one that recognises the benefits of music and arts generlly in economic social and personal bases.
  35. Betsy Barker 1 Jun 2018
    I was a music specialist...all music should return to all Scottish schools
  36. Betsy Barker 1 Jun 2018
    Nothing more important than music in the world...every child deserves the chance to sing and play.
  37. Anne Cochrane 1 Jun 2018
    Music is a wonderful gift to offer a child and helps with so many other subjects.
  38. Leigh Wood 1 Jun 2018
    I believe in getting it right for every child and closing the attainment gap, I feel this does neither of these things and makes music an exclusive for those who can afford it.
  39. Stephanie Gaffney 1 Jun 2018
    Pupils need positive ways to explore their creativity. Learning an instrument can provide focus, drive, develops discipline and allows pupils to experience success. They can develop a host of transferrible skills through solo performance and performing with others. Music can also help with young people's mental wellbeing. I am a teacher within NLC. I studied music at school under hugely talented and inspiring tutors. I want all my kids to have the same opportunity to explore music as they do sports and core subjects.
  40. Ian Garioch 1 Jun 2018
    I learned to play piano (badly) when I was 45 years old
    - much too late. It has given me endless hours of joy. Children should learn to play a musical instrument
    - it gives them pleasure for the rest of their lives.
  41. Frances Campbell 1 Jun 2018
    This would be fab. I would also call for the EIS to ban Scottish schools to take in private music instructors, especially when the local authorities have an music instrumental service. Instrumental instructors should be equal to other teachers and be enrolled into the GTCS.
  42. Alissa Syme 1 Jun 2018
    I am saddened that we have to fight for something that all children should have access to. The benefits are immeasurable and it sickens me to think this is going to be taken from them
  43. Senga Dunn 1 Jun 2018
    This is a valuable service and must be kept.
  44. Denise Young 1 Jun 2018
    Deserves support
  45. Mrs. Elspeth McDonald 1 Jun 2018
    Only wealthy families will be able to afford tuition. Children in Scotland being deprived again.
  46. Kerry McKinlay 1 Jun 2018
    I would not have the current life that I value more than anything were it not for children having the right to free instrumental tuition.
  47. Palma Allan 1 Jun 2018
    Article 12 UNCRC Education. Children's participation takes on a special dimension in the area of education.
    Education should give children the opportunity to develop their talents and abilities to full. It should not cost money as this discriminates against families who cannot afford it.
  48. Mrs. Elspeth McDonald 1 Jun 2018
    Children from poorer families are once again being deprived of an essential part of their education. It will take us back to only the wealthy can have a musical education and a musical instrument.
  49. Mr vincent mcdonald 1 Jun 2018
    Musical education, musical instruments and tuition should not only available to better off families. Scottish children deserve better.
  50. Dale Finlayson 1 Jun 2018
    Access to music tuition should not depend upon ability to pay for it. Nor should it be an "extra" or alternative to the core curriculum
    - it should be part of it.