Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01694 · Session 5

Free Instrumental Music Services

Closed Submitted 8 May 2018 Education
Signatures
0
9,860 online signatures with a country
Comments
824
Considered
4 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to change the law to ensure that musical instrument tuition is available as of right to all children attending state schools in Scotland who wish it, free of charge.

What the petitioner did first

I have discussed matters with my local authority and understand that Instrumental Music Services are provided by local authorities at their discretion. In these times of reducing funding to local authorities, discretionary services are easy to cut, or charge for and so I must broach the topic with the Scottish Parliament. I have also had discussions with my MSP and MP.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 13 Sep 2018
    1 mention
  2. 22 Nov 2018
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 23 Jan 2019
    1 mention
  4. 29 May 2019
    1 mention

Signatures by country

9,860 online signatures
  1. Scotland8,120 82.4%
  2. United Kingdom1,348 13.7%
  3. England215 2.2%
  4. United States46 0.5%
  5. Northern Ireland11 0.1%
  6. Wales11 0.1%
  7. France10 0.1%
  8. Canada10 0.1%
  9. Germany10 0.1%
  10. Australia8 0.1%
  11. 33 other countries71 0.7%

Comments

824 comments, oldest first
824 comments · showing 51–100
  1. Anne Bunemann 9 May 2018
    Musical instrument lesson should be available to all children, music is such important part of the human being, don't let it fade out.
  2. Sara melville 9 May 2018
    I got free violin lrssons at primary school
    - as did about a third if my class in P3 onwards. My life would not have been the same without that. There are so many important skills and sharing experiences made possible by offering free music tuition to young people. It is unreasonable to exclude those who cant pay from access to music
    - its so good for the soul and wellbeing with all the pressures life brings. Dont start me on the importance of art...
  3. Christopher Helson 9 May 2018
    The evidence demonstrates that learning a musical instrument improves cognitive ability accross subjects.
  4. Anne Marie Haughan 9 May 2018
    I owe my career as a music teacher to the free instrumental tuition I received from 1966 to 1974 Renfrewshire schools music provision of tutors , orchestras, concerts and band camps. Life long friends made too.
  5. Elizabeth Swainson 9 May 2018
    The introduction & subsequent increase in charges for Instrumental Instruction in the local authority where I work and where my children attended school has seen the opportunity to learn an instrument gradually become available only to those with money. The positive impact on all aspects of a young person's life is well documented. It is imperative that lessons are free to enable every child the chance to impact on their life long education.
  6. Mary Johnston 9 May 2018
    Music stands at the same level in education as numeracy and literacy. Maybe even above.
  7. Rebecca McGaugie 9 May 2018
    The proposed increase in instrument tuition fees in Clackmannanshire is quite ridiculous. This will put instrument tuition out with the means of a large
    potion of school children and is a way to stop
    individual instrument tuition by the back door. To
    double the cost in one year is scandalous and needs
    to be reassessed. We all understand services have
    a cost but to effectively remove music tuition from
    children when it has been proved time as again that
    this can improve attainment in all areas of education is short sighted and ill conceived.
  8. Kathy Chappelle 9 May 2018
    Music is very important, how it is delivered and taught is so very important. It would be fabulous for all children to experience the power of Music regardless of the ability to pay .
  9. Katie Mclarty 9 May 2018
    I recieved free music tuition at school and ended up joining a jazz band which led me to go on tour with them around Frace and Germany, lifelong friends and memories made. This would not have been possible if I did not receive this tuition as we would not have been able to afford it
  10. Gordon Jenkins 9 May 2018
    Had I not been provided with an instrument and free lessons at school, I would not have been able to have a career as a professional solo cornet and trumpet player in the Royal Marines Band Service ( for 9 years ) or a career as a professional brass instrumental music teacher ( for 27 years), as my parents would have been unable to pay.
  11. Kate Smith 9 May 2018
    Children can often express themselves through music and can be a form of release Can be esteem building for children who may not be academic
  12. Ali Ferguson 9 May 2018
    Music is one of the few things in this world that is capable of bringing people together...the more accessible it is and the earlier it is taught the better.
  13. Karen Banaghan 9 May 2018
    So unfair that children can only get lessons if they have parents who can afford it.
  14. Gill Hunter 9 May 2018
    Free Music Tuition should be a national right for all regardless of household income, not random depending on location, and local authority budget.
  15. Ryan McBride 9 May 2018
    I am, what I would regard as, a successful musician, in that music is my living, and that I make a regular income from it. This would not be the case had I not benefited from a free music education via a vibrant music service.
  16. Julie Nicoll 9 May 2018
    I received instrumental tuition as a teenager in Fife and as a result I still play and perform regularly in a brass band. The impact music has had on my life is immeasurable
    - it teaches a range of transferable skills which are vital in the work place as well as providing enjoyment.
  17. Alison Russell 9 May 2018
    I received free percussion lessons at secondary school in Perth. I am a contemporary of the now very famous Evelyn Glennie: I am just an amateur. That said, I did a degree in music from a highly regarded university, and, 30 years later, still play regularly with classical ensembles all over Scotland. My life is enriched through music, and so iit is for those who come to hear us play. Without that tuition, my life would be poorer in countless ways. Music teaches us so many life skills: concentration (for extended periods!!), teamwork, listening, commitment. It's something that is shared by humanity whether one plays or listens. We cannot, as a civilised society, discriminate against those children from families without the financial means
    - or understanding
    - of the value of playing a musical instrument.
  18. Helen Minshall 9 May 2018
    I give my full support to this petition. I would not be a professional musician and music educator now if I had not received free instrumental tuition in Ayrshire.
  19. Philip Sawyer 9 May 2018
    The educational benefits of music tuition have been proved many, many times.
  20. lynne gray 9 May 2018
    Both my children have played an instrument. It is so good for their confidence. Both are involved in the music department at there school.
  21. Patriciia coutts 9 May 2018
    I hope my grandchildren will have same chances to learn a musical instrument free like I did.
  22. John Scott 9 May 2018
    My son is now a professional musician. He had private tuition. But his school provided him with exceptional musical education and allowed him to use his chosen instrument (accordion) to enable him to achieve his Advanced Higher in music. All school children should have the right to have free of charge musical instrument tuition.
  23. Lesley Mair 9 May 2018
    Music belongs to everyone. Children have an innate ability, regardless of academic achievement, and need to be encouraged in creativity which, as has been proven countless times, enhances every aspect of learning.
  24. Carol Mason 9 May 2018
    Music teaches so many other life skills: socially our kids are retreating into screens. Music opens opportunities
  25. Frances Carvill 9 May 2018
    Every child deserves to have access to music tuition. Don't let children be excluded because of how much income their home has.
  26. Gill Ritchie 9 May 2018
    Music is good for the soul
    - everyone should have the opportunity to play, regardless of household income.
  27. Rosemary Rutherford 9 May 2018
    Music is an essential element for creative development and prepares young people to realise their potential in all aspects of their life. It offers learning how to listen and be present. 2 critical skills for everyone no matter what road they take for economic sustainability.
  28. joyce cattanach 9 May 2018
    Music lessons are not "free" they have been paid for by our tax system and they MUST remain so, free for all at point of contact in our schools.
  29. Vicky Keir 9 May 2018
    My daughter now serves with the Royal Marines Band Service. Her instrument skills were developed through instrumental tuition in school. She is a shining example of where school instrument tuition can take a person. Without it she quite simply wouldn't be there.
  30. Tom Paterson 9 May 2018
    I would like my granddaughters to get the same musical tuition that my daughter received.
  31. Veronica Davis 9 May 2018
    Free tuition in school for those who wish it is a must. Not many parents can afford private tuition now and early access to music can open so many doors and bring huge benefits to ALL children. It should not be restricted to only those whose famiies cn afford it.
  32. Norma Malcolm 9 May 2018
    I was lucky to get the chance to learn to play the flute at secondary school and became a founder member of the Edinburgh Secondary Schools Orchestra. What an experience that was and I think more children should have this opportunity to enjoy music.
  33. MAUREEN MCGARRY-O'HANLON 9 May 2018
    How many times do we have to go through this rigmarole? Music Tuition and Instrumental Study improves academic performance and it develops confidence and personality.
  34. Callum Rae 9 May 2018
    Some of our best musicians developed both their talent and love of music in the Scottish school system. To remove this vital opportunity for future generations is nothing less than cultural vandalism. Charging for tuition removes the opportunity for those on low income. Keep it free.
  35. Robbie May 9 May 2018
    Why should musical instrument tuition be treated differently to any other educational topic? Our young people should be offered free instrument tuition at school.
  36. Jamie Campbell 9 May 2018
    Giving every child a chance to get some musical tuition is very important, as it can enrich their life, and give some the chance to consider music as a possible career
  37. Chris Combest 9 May 2018
    Study after study proves the importance of music the lives of developing children. Beyond that, music is a cultural identity unique to each country. Preserve the traditions and cultural importance of a musical vocabulary, please.
  38. Nicolette Girgis 9 May 2018
    It seems very wrong that mainly children of wealthier parents will be able to have music lessons!
  39. Claire Casey 9 May 2018
    Don't take such an amazing opportunity away from children.
  40. David Kilpatrick 9 May 2018
    This is more than important. It's almost as vital as reading and writing, and helps with so many other subjects from maths to arts. Schools should have music teaching staff, in addition to peripatetic specialist teachers.
  41. Andrea Cop 9 May 2018
    Introduction to a wide range of instruments at an earlier age will help to break down the social class structure. Not everyone is a violinist or pianist. Whilst recorders give easy inexpensive access to making music, finding an orchestral instrument that suits the child is inevitably limited by the means of the parent of their own interests. Free tuition is essential but so is the need to open the horizon of the full range of instruments available. Could orchestras in Universities or other partnerships provide access taster sessions?
  42. Hazel Younger 9 May 2018
    This is not just about providing the same opportunities to our children which we had ourselves, it is about helping to nurture well rounded individuals who have acquired valuable life skills which will stand them in good stead for the next 70 or 80 years, no matter what they ultimately choose to do with their talents.
  43. Aileen Whytock 9 May 2018
    The music instrument tuition my children received at school had such a positive effect on them. It increased their self confidence and improved their learning in other areas. Please don't deprive other children if this opportunity.
  44. Lesley Herd 9 May 2018
    Music is a universal language and like any language requires teachers and students to pass on and learn the skills needed to make music. It should be accessible to all, regardless of background, social standing and ability to pay. Music should be a level playing field, with hard work, talent and determination being the only criteria for access. Free for all and as important in a curriculum as maths, English language.
  45. Karen Scott 9 May 2018
    My daughter has had the amazing chance to learn violin, which we would never have been able to afford otherwise.
  46. Carol Jarvis 9 May 2018
    Music helps develop so many other skills, from team work, to discipline, to maths, to languages, to a sense of achievement. Why should it be treated any different to any other subject? About time people recognised how useful Music is in all walks of life!
  47. Karin french 9 May 2018
    This should be available to all pupils which it isn't
    . Kids with ASN don't get the opportunity
  48. Elizabeth Klein 9 May 2018
    Free music instrumental should be free to all children as other subjects on the curriculum.
  49. Shyvonne McNiven 9 May 2018
    Our children love their music and instruments. We are a working family of two parents but would not be able to afford this as an extra cost to our income
  50. Ian Donaldson 9 May 2018
    Music should be a free part of the whole school experience