Petition · PE01694 · Session 5
Free Instrumental Music Services
Signatures
0
Comments
824
Considered
4 meetings
What it asks
Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to change the law to ensure that musical instrument tuition is available as of right to all children attending state schools in Scotland who wish it, free of charge.
What the petitioner did first
I have discussed matters with my local authority and understand that Instrumental Music Services are provided by local authorities at their discretion. In these times of reducing funding to local authorities, discretionary services are easy to cut, or charge for and so I must broach the topic with the Scottish Parliament. I have also had discussions with my MSP and MP.
Where it was considered
Official Report-
13 Sep 20181 mention
-
22 Nov 20181 mention
-
23 Jan 20191 mention
-
29 May 20191 mention
Signatures by country
9,860 online signaturesComments
824 comments, oldest first824 comments · showing 351–400
-
George McCaig 31 May 2018Two generations of family have benefited greatly from Music Tuition in school.
-
Jacqueline Blackwood 31 May 2018I was brought up in West Lothian. I played percussion all the bands minus the string orchestra and I wouldn't have had instrumental instruction not been free. I left school to study music at college, however decided to go straight on to a career in the Armed Forces as a Musician... 15 years on I am most grateful to my tutors and West Lothian music services for giving me the opportunity to have my career. I have just recently left the regular Army to join the Reserves (also as a Musician). I have travelled to many different countries, played in the most beautiful concert halls and theatres and met some of the most amazing people. In Afghanistan we were tasked with tutoring the Afghan National Army Bands which to date is the most rewarding accolades I have participated in... To bring music to repressed souls who didn't have any instruments until we donated some from the School of Music because music is against the law
- a gentleman had been using a Trombone which was decrepit to say the least as he'd had to bury it under his house for fear of the Taliban discovering it. Is it then fair to remove a free service from the countries where we hold our music (apparently) in high regard? My Mum and Dad were not claiming benefits but with everything else they had to provide I would have probably had to take the hit of not having musical tuition if we'd had to... My Dad (like many other parents had to work many hours of overtime so that my sister and I could have the things we wanted (neither of us flashy just to add). I didn't have a clue what I wanted to do with my life after school but when music came along I went with it and knew that it was all I wanted to (and to be fair at the time could) do. Please rethink this. -
Andrew McGarva 31 May 2018Scotland has a rich heritage of producing some of the most talented musicians
- many of whom would never have been able to access lessons if there were charges. This is too important to be ignored
- our culture is identified through our music. -
Anna Ludwig 31 May 2018I am a certified music therapist. Without my free instrumental lessons at Biggar High School throughout the 1980s I would not be where I am today and life would be considerably less interesting.
-
Orlaith Payne 31 May 2018The ability to play an instrument, to read a piece of music and to understand the meaning behind a piece of music is vital to a child's learning and cannot be removed from school.
-
Jill Andrew 31 May 2018Without instrumental tuition at school in P&K I'd never have had so many opportunities. playing with PYO and Perthshire Brass opened up a whole new world to me and helped me both musically and also in so many other ways by boosting my confidence and affording me opportunities to see places and meet people I'd never have met otherwise. I made friends for life. I still play and help run a community orchestra in Edinburgh. I doubt we'd exist if it weren't for the opportunities free music tuition gave me and others.
-
Ellen Bogie 31 May 2018Music was the thing that made me equal despite my physical disabilities. This opportunity should the right of all children
-
Suzanne Ritchie 31 May 2018The benefits of playing and performing music
- for mental health, confidence, friendships, skills development, mental dexterity
- should not be the reserve of those who can afford it. -
Gavin Duffy 31 May 2018Creative industries are becoming more and more important as automation grows.
-
Anne Kinnell Wilson 31 May 2018We cannot afford to allow access to music tuition to become an elitist privilege when it should be a fundamental right and need for all Children.
FOR THE MANY NOT THE FEW! -
Kevin Dobie 31 May 2018Music is essential and should be valued far more highly
-
Cole Stewart 31 May 2018Every child or young person should be allowed the opportunity to learn an instrument.
-
David Worton 31 May 2018Government can ramble on about equity all they like, let's see some action rather than pointless equity funds.
-
Georgina Thacker 31 May 2018In a society where we are recognising mental health issues for children, we must hold on to the areas where children develop self esteem, music is proven to help with mental health and this will help in the long term for other services.
-
Val Cooper 31 May 2018The ability to learn to play a musical instrument should be available to all children, regardless of financial status. Music promotes amongst other attributes, patience, passion, commitment, team building and confidence in our children, key skills for a well balanced adult life.
-
Iain lambie 31 May 2018Music, releases tension, uplifts body and mind and needs to taught and widely available to support relaxation, stress relief and depression for children in an ever more stressful and expectant society. What next? Remove physical education?
-
Eric Wilson 31 May 2018As a retired Adviser in Music, Dumfries and Galloway, I am shocked and saddened that the present generation of children are being so disadvantaged compared to those of their elder brothers and sisters. In Wigtownshire alone we could form orchestras, bands, chamber groups, etc.Now we are down to one lady teaching brass.What has become of our proud musical tradition. I do hope this petition will not fall on deaf ears!
-
Morag Hunter 31 May 2018As a retired primary teacher I saw how important music was to my pupils in giving them confidence and sheer joy.
-
Morag Hunter 31 May 2018As a retired primary teacher I saw how important music was to my pupils in giving them confidence and sheer joy.
-
Louise Lenaghan 31 May 2018Music is in our core. Everyone should be able to experience and appreciate music in all forms including musical instruments.
-
James Douglas Clark 31 May 2018Both my children have greatly benefited from music tuition. I've been very lucky to have been able to afford this but money should not be a deciding factor as to whether a child has the opportunity to learn a musical instrument
-
Marisa Giannasi 31 May 2018The creative arts cannot become an elitist subject and this decision will make it so. Music and art has been a healthy outlet for young people for years. Not only that but leads to jobs in many fulfilling creative fields. This is not the industrial revolution, we are able to support music and art. It is disappointing to think that an emphasis on STEM subjects (which is commendable) should be at the expense of something so important.
-
Marisa Giannasi 31 May 2018The creative arts cannot become an elitist subject and this decision will make it so. Music and art has been a healthy outlet for young people for years. Not only that but leads to jobs in many fulfilling creative fields. This is not the industrial revolution, we are able to support music and art. It is disappointing to think that an emphasis on STEM subjects (which is commendable) should be at the expense of something so important.
-
Carol Guthrie 31 May 2018The music instructors at my school do more than just teach music to the children- they bring joy, nurture hidden talents, build confidence as well. Parents of my pupils have said that they will not be able to afford to pay tuition fees and that they will withdraw their children from lessons when fees commence. Those losing in poverty have the most to lose here.
-
Lynne Pryde 31 May 2018Total disgrace that there are charges for children to learn to play a musical instrument. Music should be free for all!
-
Jacqueline Kay 31 May 2018Our children have a right to music education. NO to music cuts.
-
Kelly Anderson 31 May 2018Music is vital, it enhances a child's learning. It teaches them to read another language which is universally used. It should be encouraged and enjoyed by all.
-
Derek Manson-Smith 31 May 2018My son received free tuition and the loan of a cello at his state primary school in the 1980s, which he continues to benefit from.
-
Andrew Dickie 31 May 2018The current state of affairs is nothing short of appalling and I believe if anything meaningful is to come of this, music tuition must be removed from the control of local authorities altogether. Constant funding threats and the downwards trajectory of provision in terms of equity has decimated services throughout the country and the relentless blame game between LA and government is neither dignified nor productive. If we in Scotland deem the equitable provision of the opportunity to play an instrument without financial penalty important, then we must pay for it
- indeed we need to evaluate and quantify the positive impacts widely quoted. Parents need to galvanise across the country to lobby for this provision not only to be free but actually extended beyond its receding fringes.. -
Dennis Hamilton 31 May 2018No child should be financially excluded from this unique form of self-expression. Free for all who wish to explore their musical talents and appreciation.
-
Joseph Taylor 31 May 2018Music is important for everybody
-
Kayleigh Bohan 31 May 2018This is horrific
- please don't make music the sole right of those who can afford it. I was lucky enough to have free music tuition at school and it was hugely important to my confidence, social skills and public speaking and presenting. It was also a lot of fun and made me less afraid of taking risks later. This is reinforcing inequality in a massive way. -
Alexander Buchanan 31 May 2018I have a musical background because tuition was free and this has been a very important part of my life.
-
Catherine Woodward 31 May 2018All music should be free for everyone!
-
Ayse Bak 31 May 2018I'm a teacher, and feel strongly this is so wrong, to many cuts in the wrong areas and in education.
-
Stephen Brennan 31 May 2018I had brass lessons at school, and it inspired a life-long passion for music, including a decade singing with the RSNO chorus. I really believe this should be available to my own children and all others.
-
Ann McGuigan 31 May 2018Don't let this brilliant opportunity only be available to kids whose parents can afford it.
-
Catherine Calder 31 May 2018Music instrumental tuition should be free to all pupils and not just be available to the wealthier families. The SNP keep telling us they introduced free education for all so how can that be when they are responsible for the decimation of this educational service. Hang your heads in shame!
-
Maggie Fernie 31 May 2018All children must be given the opportunity to experience music tuition.
-
Jilly Burns 31 May 2018Music lessons and the opportunity to play on school bands underpinned my entire school experience and achievements and made me who I am today.. you
-
Barbara Stuart 31 May 2018Music has a beneficial effect on both the musician and the audience. Apart from that children learn a lot of other things apart from learning to play an instrument.
-
Ann Edmonds 31 May 2018Music is vital to the wellbeing of all, to the cultural landscape of our country and to deny children access to being taught music is disastrous.
-
Caroline Wilson 31 May 2018If we wish to be an innovative, creative country, we need children who can think and function via many different modes of communication and use their brains in many multi-faceted ways. Music helps to embed these things, improving academic learning in other areas and improving mental and emotional wellbeing. We as a nation need to be at the forefront of education.
-
Tila Morris 31 May 2018Music tuition is precisely what every child in Scotland needs as part of closing the attainment gap. Removing music tuition is like publicly advertising a belief that music is only for the privileged and the wealthy. Scotland has a rich heritage of music and access to tuition. We should cherish this with pride and recognise it's value in all asepcts of learning including language, reasoning, memory, coordination and health and wellbeing. Save music tuition in our schools.
-
Linda Beveridge 31 May 2018Signed for the sake of my children and the future of music...learning to play intruments has had such a positive effect on my life, many years after leaving school.
-
Kirsteen wright 31 May 2018Please start understanding the need for the arts in general for all.
-
Lyn Marshall 31 May 2018As a parent of a child who received free brass tuition at secondary school and who 15 years later still plays in an award achieving brass band this tuition was crucial. The legacy of removing the free tuition will have repercussions in generations of the future!
-
Julia McGrory 31 May 2018It is not just about learning to play an instrument when a child takes music lessons. They learn so much more along side that skill, focus, concentration, listening skills, teamwork and confidence to name but a few. By restricting access to music lessons by adding a financial cost that some parents may not be able to meet, may deprive a child of the opportunity to learn those skills that enable them to meet their full potential.
-
Angela Morlotti 31 May 2018It is important that pupils have the choice to learn how to play musical instruments at school.
-
Katherine Schofield 1 Jun 2018Having a child in Clackmannanshire schools, the cost increase is unaffordable and will be devastating to the music service. Whilst I understand pressure on public sector funding, it is foolishness to make music unaffordable. The evidence of benefits to children are strong