Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01626 · Session 5

Regulation of Bus Services

Closed Submitted 28 Oct 2016 Transport
Signatures
0
1,705 online signatures with a country
Comments
229
Considered
7 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to legislate to regulate bus services in Scotland and to carry out an inquiry into the benefits of bringing bus services in Scotland into common ownership.

What the petitioner did first

In the Fourth Scottish Parliament, Unite supported the proposed Bus Regulation (Scotland) Bill brought to Parliament by Iain Gray MSP.
In the Third Scottish Parliament, Unite supported the proposed Regulation of Bus Services Bill brought to Parliament by Charlie Gordon MSP.
Neither of these bills resulted in legislation to bring bus services under regulation or common ownership.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 19 Jan 2017
    1 mention
  2. 27 Apr 2017
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 29 Jun 2017
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  4. 21 Dec 2017
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    2 mentions
  5. 26 Apr 2018
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  6. 21 Mar 2019
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  7. 17 Feb 2021
    2 mentions

Signatures by country

1,705 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,239 72.7%
  2. United Kingdom417 24.5%
  3. England45 2.6%
  4. United States2 0.1%
  5. United States Minor Outlying Islands1 0.1%
  6. Wales1 0.1%

Comments

229 comments, oldest first
229 comments · showing 151–200
  1. Pam Currie 26 Nov 2016
    I've lived in a rural part of East Ayrshire since June
    - still not sure if there's a scheduled bus at our road end or not! Use the X76 from Auchinleck to Glasgow and it's appalling
    - 2.5 hours tonight, over an hour of which was standing outside in subzero temperatures in Glasgow & Kilmarnock.
  2. Craig james 26 Nov 2016
    Stagecoach buses in fife are appalling and the services are seriously disjointed. In glenrothes if u want to.go from.the train station to collydean you have to change buses at the bus station. That's just a small example. They are expensive. Their buses are grubby both outside in inside. Their express buses advertise plug and USB sockets. They never work. The WiFi hardly ever works. Fife has lost is identity on the buses. And now we are just part of a big group that is more profits oriented rather than focusing on what the passenger needs. Way too expensive for what should be a 15,20 min journey stagecoach charge over 3.00. For a journey that is 1 hour and 20 minutes on a lothian bus it's 1.60. Stagecoach frankly are a rip off.
  3. Evan Fitzsimmons 27 Nov 2016
    C'mon, get on!!
  4. Robert Greensheilds 28 Nov 2016
    Sick of paying thru the nose for journeys that begin with the bus not appearing or brakes down and you miss train connection then on way home have the bus run past me due to being overcrowded.
    Time Firstbus got their act together and remember. The people have had enough of you cutting back schedules.
  5. Robert Stirling 28 Nov 2016
    The infrastructure of Public Transport has been whittled away to such a standard cars have exploded onto our roads to the detriment of our towns and villages. Until action is taken our roads will come to a complete standstill
  6. Peter Robertson 30 Nov 2016
    Greenock buses are a disgrace. McGills have terrible suspension that shatter old people's hips, and they are the only company because for some reason the powers-that-be hand everything to the family business that started on the profits of organised drug dealing in Greenock. And the Glasgow bus that used to go to Kelvindale has been scrapped. It's a posh area, but not everyone owns a car up there. I know people who have been ploughing money into that route for over 20 years, and now they have no bus at all.
  7. David Heriot 2 Dec 2016
    The Bus Service in South Queensferry is a Disgrace
  8. Alan Heatlie 2 Dec 2016
    No smart-card system, price per mile on the Borders network over twice that of Lothian Buses. Tickets from cancelled rail system not valid on Borders buses....the list goes on and on!
  9. Susan Wilson 3 Dec 2016
    South Queensferry is a rapidly expanding town and has had a poor and more expensive bus service than other parts of Edinburgh for the 22 years I've lived here
    - This needs to change urgently
  10. Margaret Cooper 3 Dec 2016
    I live in Bo'ness and our access to a decent bus service is non existent !!!! We have no service from here to Edinburgh ....it takes me almost 2 hours to get there as I have to go to Linlithgow to get a bus. Linlithgow has a bus for Edinburgh every 20 minutes.....the bus company won't even reroute one of those buses through Bo'ness.
  11. Paul Craggs 3 Dec 2016
    Hopefully this will decrease the extortionate bus fares in Aberdeen
  12. Billy Adamson 3 Dec 2016
    Lothian busses best in Scotland cheapest fares best busses and best terms and conditions for employees , run by the people for the people not profiteers .
  13. Greig Wright 4 Dec 2016
    Put the customers & the Staff before Fat Cats. Delivering a service that old & infirm peoples depend on is a moral imperative. Having public transport trusted again & spoke of fondly by the household will help ease road congestion, pollution & generate jobs too. A no-brainer unless you're an economist.
  14. Laura MacDonald 5 Dec 2016
    As a Glaswegian bus user, I am in no doubt that Lothian Buses provides a customer-focussed service that is cleaner, more efficient, cheaper and easier to access than the services I have used in Glasgow. I am in no doubt this is due to the difference ownership and the focus on users rather than profits.
  15. Kenneth Higgins 5 Dec 2016
    The local bus service has doubled the fair after taking over from last service provider. Its just as cheap to get a taxi
  16. Ira MacPhail 5 Dec 2016
    I am a student living in Yoker due to low rent prices and I have a great difficulty moving around the city and especially to and back from the University. I can only use the bus for my transportation and there has been numerous times the buses do not arrive at the time scheduled resulting to many delays. The time of wait is sometimes so long that it could be dangerous for a female at night waiting at remote bus stops. Please there is an urgency for change.
  17. Philip Goldie 5 Dec 2016
    Typical of 1st Glasgow busses, today I waited for 40 minutes for a bus that should be along every 10 minutes. I watched 3 buses with the same route number travelling n the opposite direction all travel within 3 minutes of each other. After the 40 minutes had elapsed, the same 3 buses arrived within 1 minute of each other at my bus stop. The whole journey from where I live to the city centre takes half an hour. 1st be fail to properly organise it's routes, this never occurred with SPTE running the service. End profit makes G for the owners of this shoddy company and hand the buses back to be properly run for the benefit of the people.
  18. Gordon Murray 5 Dec 2016
    It's time to return Scotland's public transport sector back to public ownership. We want regulation for the privately owned transport sector in the meantime.
  19. Linda Riddock 5 Dec 2016
    West End of Glasgow bus service totally inadequate...Used to be brilliant...Why??
  20. stephen murray 5 Dec 2016
    Glasgow's buses are a disgrace
    - they should be taken under public control, as Edinburgh's are.
  21. Alasdair Kelly 5 Dec 2016
    Due to health I am not someone who can jump in a car and go where I want. I have to plan where I travel to by public transport. Regulation is something that would solve many problems.
  22. marion mcmillan 6 Dec 2016
    glasgow needs to get back to a service that was provided for the people by people who knew the meaning of common good.
  23. Anne Taylor 6 Dec 2016
    What is the point of giving free busses to pensioners if the bus stops running
  24. Karl McAreavey 6 Dec 2016
    First Glasgow buses are dirty, smelly, always late and very very often do not turn up, I have quite regularly taken over 2 hours to get home for what should have been a 35-40 minute trip as 3 buses in a row haven't turned up. I call their helpline and complain at least 2-3 times a week but they couldn't care less we need to get rid of these money grabbing greedy robbing rich fat cat directors & share holders and run the buses for the public. They should be cheap and regular and if need be run at a loss for a few years until people feel confident enough to use them and get out of their cars, until then you will not convince the majority to leave the cars in the drive or garage.
  25. Ellen Stewart (Secretary of C.C.) 7 Dec 2016
    We have had a number of challenges with First Bus. Our former MP was involved in keeping the No.64 bus in our East End area of Glasgow. No service on a Sunday or after 7pm during the week. SPT had to arrange for a bus to service the area on Sunday & in the evenings.
  26. Fiona Mann 7 Dec 2016
    Glasgow needs to be better served by public transport . Deregulation has isolated some outlying areas , and in central areas buses are vying for passengers.
  27. Alan Karas 8 Dec 2016
    Bus services in Glasgow are not joined up, far too expensive, old busses & services finishing at 7pm. Not good enough
  28. Craig Hannan 9 Dec 2016
    The bus service from my area is disgraceful , often up to three scheduled buses in a row don't turn up. I have sent numerous complaints only to receive a standard letter with no improvements made. There is no other choice to win hdraw my custom and choose another company. I had cheaper bus travel subsidised through my work but service is so bad I now pay extra to get the train.
  29. Mrs S Dyer 9 Dec 2016
    We live on the outskirts of Glasgow and have one bus that comes into our estate. The timetable changes constantly as does the route and is, at best, a half hourly service. We need a better, more reliable bus service with more choice. Lothian Buses is the model Glasgow should follow.
  30. Fiona Montgomery 9 Dec 2016
    Better public transport is life saving, contributing to improved health and wellbeing and to tackling climate change.
  31. R McKay 9 Dec 2016
    It's clear that bus services in Glasgow are no longer fit for purpose. Near enough constant cutting back of routes, curtailing of service hours, and rising prices are having a seriously detrimental effect on people's lives.
  32. Pat Baillie 9 Dec 2016
    Bus routes contribute to air pollution in city centre. The present transport system is run for profits not for passengers. We cannot address these issues until buses are taken back into public control.
  33. Ruth Campbell 9 Dec 2016
    We have just had another vicious round of cuts in Glasgow leaving large areas without a service
  34. Bill Burge 10 Dec 2016
    If it's good enough for Edinburgh, then it's good enough for Glasgow.
  35. Andy Higgison 11 Dec 2016
    My over 60s bus pass is one of the many subsidies bus companies rely on. This public money should not end up in the profits of private hands, but should be invested in the common ownership of a public service that is fit for the needs of the people of Scotland.
  36. Fiona Martin 11 Dec 2016
    Computerised timetable on bus shelters hasn't been working for months no explanation. Ridiculous price hikes and no stopping these increases used to be excuse was fuel increases cannot justify when price is so low. Reduced service during school holidays public holidays yet still expected to pay same price for monthly ticket and now for some reason we seem to be getting single deckers at peak times ( No 57 ) and standard excuse every time buses don't turn up and more and more cutting bus routes which are not profitable regardless of ageing population in some of these areas (withdrawal of No 45 bus through Sighthill being an example).
  37. Catherine sneddon 13 Dec 2016
    Busses in Bo'ness are so expensive I very rarely use them...£7.80 for an all day ticket between Bo'ness and falkirk £6.90 a return... we in Bo'ness don't get to take advantage of first bus £15 weekly ticket £4.50 day ticket for the Falkirk area... Bo'ness is the only area not included in this!!!!
  38. Angela Rankine 13 Dec 2016
    I work as a care assistant in a nursing home if i work at weekends i don't have transport to go to work or come back from work i need to get taxis .
  39. Evelyn Campbell 13 Dec 2016
    Buses in my area only run every half hour between 9:15 am to 6:45 pm Monday to Saturday. No service Sunday or public holidays and had no service for 4 days Christmas weekend and again New Year weekend last year. No competition.
  40. Wendy Lawrence 14 Dec 2016
    First Buses are filthy, subsidised, do not run on time and my services have been cut from three routes to one. Vital infrastructure should be owned by the people.
  41. Bruno Baumgartner 14 Dec 2016
    Buses, but also Ferries, Trains and Air service to Islands, should all be taken out of private ownership and grouped into one Ministry, Ministry for Public Transport and has a seat in the cabinet. The uncoordination for exemple on Isle of Arran is legendary. Each quango is just looking for themselves and the grapeline has it, that some quangos don't even speak to each others.
  42. Helen Jeffery 14 Dec 2016
    There is only one bus from Bo'ness to Edinburgh in the early morning and one returning at 5.30 pm. Monday to Friday only. People who work or study or want to go to Edinburgh to out with these times have very lengthy and expensive journeys! Disgrace!
  43. Kristin Barrett 15 Dec 2016
    In our area, we are fed up of badly maintained buses, which sometimes make horrible grinding noises, and occasionally (like this year) even go on fire!
  44. TOM NISBET 15 Dec 2016
    DEREGULATION ALLOWS A FREE FOR ALL WHICH IS USED TO BOOST PROFITS AT THE EXPENSE OF SERVICE TO AREAS IN MOST NEED OF HELP!
  45. Mike Smith 15 Dec 2016
    It doesn't bode well that the SNP are financially supported by Stagecoach owners. The SNP Conference has consistently voted for re-regulation but the Executive overrode the decision. Let's hope this time it's different but as so many at the top of the SNP are not bringing this forward or even supporting I'll not hold my breath. Prove me wrong! I'd be delighted!
  46. Ellie Harrison 15 Dec 2016
    I'm so pleased to be see so many signatures and comments on this petition.

    We must join together to get the Scottish Government to take this issue seriously.

    Individual complaints to First Buses do nothing! Below is an extract from the frustrating exchange I had with a 'Customer Advisor' at First last summer, which motivated me to start campaigning! Together we will win this :D

    On 28 July 2015 17:06, Ellie Harrison wrote:

    Dear David,

    Thanks for your response to my complaint about the discontinuation of the 42 bus route.

    I appreciate that this route may have not been running for some time now, but I have only come to need it now that I am injured and unable to cycle to work.

    I am afraid it is not acceptable to claim that the route had to be stopped because it was 'not commercially viable'. Public transport should be about providing a service to citizens and not about making a profit for private companies. And, indeed, it should be the most vulnerable in our society (those injured, disabled or those with low incomes) who it primarily seeks to serve
    - not the opposite as in the case in point.

    The discontinuation of this route, along with all other West
    - East routes (as detailed in your response) is just another good reason why Glasgow's bus contracts should be withdrawn from First Buses and taken back into public ownership under direct management of SPT instead.

    If you are unable to take my complaint further and to reinstate these essential West
    - East routes, I will begin a campaign to kick First out of Glasgow, so that we can finally get the comprehensive and affordable Public transport system that our city deserves. Mark my words.

    Yours sincerely,

    Ellie Harrison
  47. Claire Calder 15 Dec 2016
    The SNP claim they are a people's party, yet bus deregulation, Scotrail franchises etc all prove that the SNP ARE the tories! Buses MUST be regulated to keep them in check and RAILWAYS MUST BE NATIONALISED!
  48. David Young 15 Dec 2016
    I'm a non-driver, and over the past 30 years I've watched the steady decline of bus services in Scotland.

    Longer journeys. Fewer, less frequent services. Painful fare rises. Dirty, decrepit, ageing vehicles. Or new ones that simply aren't fit for purpose: basic, utilitarian models that would be just about okay on an airport shuttle service, but certainly aren't designed for the long rural journeys on which greedy operators run them.

    So it goes on. And I'm just glad that I live in a city (Edinburgh) where there's still a degree of local accountability, and a measure of pride in running decent local bus services (and modern, comfortable buses) for the public good.

    This is what we should be aiming for in Scotland and throughout the UK. An enlightened government would make it a priority
    - for environmental reasons, for social reasons
    - and I believe such a policy would enjoy widespread support.

    So how about it?
  49. William Featherstone 15 Dec 2016
    With every Scottish Local Authority now making Cut's to their Budgets, it is clear that any Private Operators will decrease the level of Publicly Run Services should their Grant Levels fall.
    This is why the Public MUST demand a fully funded Public Passenger Network of both Buses, and Train Services to be maintained at a level that suites The Passengers needs, and NEITHER any lower levels of Services that maybe suggested by Private Transport Companies, or by Council Executives, without consulting The Public at Large.
    We should also EXTEND the use of more Public Service Travel in the future, and not less..
  50. Angus Doyle 15 Dec 2016
    Unregulated private bus companies can never provide the comprehensive service that all communities in Scotland need. In Glasgow, where so many rely on public transport, a TfL-style system is the only sollution, ensuring that unprofitable aren't neglected and that public transportation need not 'compete' with food and fuel as a daily expense for the city's poorest residents.