Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Bus Services (Regulation) (PE1626)

Thursday 19 January 2017 Public Petitions Committee About 09:30–10:15 Petitions 49 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

49 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Item 2 is new petitions. The first new petition is PE1626, on the regulation of bus services. The petition was lodged by Pat Rafferty, on behalf of Unite Scotland. I welcome David Eyre, from Unite Scotland, and Ian Taylor, the director of Transport for Quality of Life. I thank David Eyre for stepping in at short notice, which was necessary because of transport issues affecting Pat Rafferty, and I invite him to make a brief opening statement.

David Eyre Unite the Union
link

I thank the committee for rejigging its agenda to try to give Pat Rafferty time to get here. I pass on his apologies to the committee.

Unite is the biggest union that represents bus workers in Scotland, and the bus services of this country are of extreme importance to us.

Since 2006, the Government has subsidised the bus industry in Scotland to the tune of around £2.6 billion, but that public investment is not delivering the bus services that the people of Scotland expect or deserve. Routes are being slashed, the number of passenger journeys is falling and prices are rocketing. Quite simply, our deregulated bus system is failing.

From June 2016, the haud the bus campaign was supported by members of Unite’s community branch in the village of Banton in North Lanarkshire. The bus operator, First, had announced plans to cut bus routes to Banton and other neighbouring villages because they were not considered profitable enough. Banton does not have any shops, so the bus service was a lifeline service. The cuts would have prevented people from getting to work, children would have been unable to go to after-school clubs or even to nursery school and pensioners were left asking what the use of a bus pass is if there is no bus. We were successful in helping local people secure a trial replacement service—the trial period is about to come to an end—but it was clear to us that we had to address the wider problem, because Banton is far from being an isolated case. Here are just a few examples from the past year of communities that have suffered cuts to or the complete withdrawal of their bus services: Saline and Steelend in Fife; Kelvindale and Riddrie in Glasgow; Eaglesham in East Renfrewshire; Kingswells near Aberdeen; Shieldhill in Falkirk; Bo’ness; Lochee; and Greenlaw. The list goes on and on.

When a private company pulls out, there is nothing that you, I, the Parliament, the Scottish Government or Her Majesty the Queen can do about it. There is no regulation that can force a bus company to maintain a service, and there is no measure of social responsibility when it comes to bus cuts. The only thing that matters is money, and the only way local authorities can help is by throwing increased subsidy at the operators in order to maintain services. It does not have to be like that, and Ian Taylor will talk about how regulation and common ownership could help us deliver a world-class bus service in Scotland.

The Scottish Parliament was brought into being in the hope that it would improve people’s lives. Clean, affordable and reliable bus services are the mark of a civilised nation. At the moment, we are failing to deliver that. Let us change that situation. Let us make this Parliament the one that finally delivers the bus services that people in Scotland want and deserve.

Ian Taylor Transport for Quality of Life
link

I want to make just two introductory points, which arise from our report, “Building a World-class Bus System for Britain”. First, our bus network should be designed as a network, not left as a chaotic free-for-all; and, secondly, significant amounts of money are being wasted.

It might seem an obvious point that the public transport network should be designed. However, the deregulation of buses in the 1980s removed the powers through which local transport authorities could design coherent integrated networks. What we have had since is a situation in which the operators, quite logically and naturally, follow the commercial imperative and cherry pick the best routes. That leaves local transport authorities running behind, trying to fill in the gaps and pick up the pieces. It is a highly inefficient way of putting together a public transport network.

09:45

To add insult to injury, it tends to be the same companies that are contracted—with further profit involved—to fill in the gaps for off-peak services and to run socially vital services to places that need them.

The first step towards building a world-class bus system for Scotland is to recognise that it should be purposely designed and operated as a public service and not primarily a vehicle for private profit.

The second point that I would like to make is about the amounts of money. We circulated to the committee in advance some rather intimidating-looking tables, I am afraid. I will pick up on three figures in the table that is headed “Scottish Bus Company Profits”. If you go straight to the bottom right-hand corner you will see that the figure for the average percentage of profits is 8.77 per cent—let us call that 8.8 per cent profit. That is most significant, because it is more than double the level of profit that is made under the regulated system in London, which is 3.8 per cent. In absolute terms, that difference amounts to about £14 million, which could be put to good use by local transport authorities.

In London, Transport for London decides what the routes will be and lets them for a fixed price. It defines what the services will be and companies bid in. It can therefore decide that it will make money on the lucrative routes and cross-subsidise socially essential routes in places where it wants those, or services at particular times of day or across weekends when they probably would not exist otherwise. That is the approach in London.

It is possible to go one step further, as we see right across Europe. The major European cities, with world-class transport systems, tend to own their public transport networks. In our case, we could have a not-for-profit system in which the relevant figure would be the very bottom figure on the table, which is £24 million, because we would capture the whole profit leakage.

I will go a little bit further and say that it is not just the profit leakage that matters. The other pages in our submission, which I will not go into at the moment—we can look at them in the course of the discussion—reveal that other savings of an equivalent scale would come from the efficiencies that we would get from putting a network together. The bill for tendered supported services would go down. We could also build an attractive network and build patronage. It is well proven now that if we were to have a simple, attractive ticketing system that covered the whole lot—if we were to have an integrated network—we would grow patronage.

The most significant thing about the savings that would amount from that is that they would be more than the austerity cuts that have been made to bus services in recent years. Those are the amounts that we are talking about.

Where does that leave us? It is ironic that a Conservative Government in Westminster is taking legislative steps to reverse what was a Conservative policy in the 1980s: the deregulation of buses, which took place under Margaret Thatcher. I find myself astonished that something similar is not happening here in Scotland. Fundamentally, what changed in England—according to those who have had the discussions—is that the Treasury clocked that a lot of money was going to waste. George Osborne’s discussions with the regions and the devolution agenda pushed the change. I strongly encourage the committee to put this into play in the Scottish context.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Thank you. We will move to questions, and I will start. The petition calls for two things: legislation to regulate the bus service in Scotland and an inquiry into the benefits of bringing the bus service into common ownership. I can see the connection between the two, but is one an inevitable consequence of the other? Are you looking at different models of what people would define to be common ownership? As someone who comes from the co-operative movement, I recognise that there is a range of models. David Eyre, is it possible to do the regulation bit without being absolutely clear about the ownership bit?

David Eyre Unite the Union
link

It is true that we can split the two up. We can have a regulation model that does not involve public ownership or common ownership. However, it is the policy of our union to support publicly owned transport. It is the clearest and best route to providing the services that the people of Scotland need. Ian Taylor can talk about the savings that that would give us in Scotland and the amount of money that it would allow us to reinvest in the bus services.

That is why we have almost split the petition into two. We think that Parliament should definitely look at legislating for a regulation model but, as a union, we believe that the Parliament should take evidence on public ownership and common ownership—we use that term deliberately because there are co-operative models that could be looked at as well as the traditional municipal model and nationalised Scottish bus group model that we used to have. Perhaps that could be looked at further down the road and any legislation to regulate buses that was brought forward could also include the possibility of public ownership or common ownership.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Just to remind us, how much money are you saying has been given to buses since 2006?

David Eyre Unite the Union
link

It is a lot of money—£2.6 billion since 2006.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

At the same time, the number of bus routes has dropped and fares have gone up.

David Eyre Unite the Union
link

Since 2007, the number of journeys by bus has fallen by 74 million, which is a 15 per cent drop. Since 2006, the number of official bus routes in Scotland that are registered with the traffic commissioner has fallen by 21 per cent. We have fewer bus routes and falling passenger numbers, and bus fares have gone up by 18 per cent in the past five years. People are paying more and more for a service that is getting worse and worse.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

What is the balance in usage between buses and trains?

Ian Taylor Transport for Quality of Life
link

The bus is the major mode of public transport. In the UK, more journeys are made by bus than by any other form of transport. It is, of course, disproportionately used—if I can put it that way—by people from lower income groups, those who do not own cars, women and older people.

I will pick up on the point about the amounts of money. It is not broadly appreciated that 40 per cent of the money that is in the bus system comes from the public purse. It is not just the tendered bus services that receive public support. Because we support concessionary fares for older people and because we give direct support through the bus service operators grant, 40 per cent of the total money that goes into buses comes from the public purse. However, we do not have any say over how it is spent. We do not control the routes, which is deeply problematic in terms of getting value for money. Your first question was about the different steps; it is certainly the case that regulation is required so that we can control what we get for our money.

Beyond that, it is interesting to look at how public ownership and not-for-profit systems are the norm in Europe. In Munich, for example, they would talk to you about having one area, one network, one brand, which they would have complete control of it and run under public ownership. Of all local transport trips in Germany, 88 per cent are made on publicly owned public transport. In France, the recent trend has been to move towards municipal ownership to get better value, and that is true across the political spectrum. When we did this report, we counted 25 municipalities of all political flavours and complexions in France that have set up local publicly owned transport companies called sociétés publiques locales. They have the advantage that, once set up, they allow the municipality to say, “We own this,” and, under European law, exclude competition.

Where we have an excellent public transport provider such as Lothian Buses, it is still fettered. It has to protect itself against the potential for incursion, which means that it cannot build the network and do things such as cross-subsidising networks. All these things run together.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

With regard to legislation, you have said that you supported the members’ bill proposals that were lodged in sessions 3 and 4. The proposal in session 3 did not gather sufficient support and fell before the end of the session, whereas although the session 4 proposal gathered sufficient support to secure the right to introduce a bill, it fell on dissolution in the absence of a bill having been introduced. Given your support for both proposals, were you encouraged by the upward trajectory of the support between the two proposals? How did you feel about that?

David Eyre Unite the Union
link

I was not working for Unite at the time, but I think that there seemed to be a change in the way the two bills were viewed. The wider debate on the proposal for the second bill was certainly encouraging, and it seemed that there was more support for regulation when that proposal was made.

It is important that this issue is being raised through the Public Petitions Committee, because it affects every constituency, and every political party that is represented in the Scottish Parliament will have constituents who are suffering as a result of this situation. The Parliament’s excellent system gives people who are signing the petition the ability to make comments, and it is interesting that more than 200 people did so, giving first-hand examples of how bus cuts are affecting them and their communities.

Obviously, this issue is important to Unite and our members who are directly employed in the bus industry, but we also represent workers across Scotland who rely on bus services to get to work, to do their normal business and to ensure that their children get to school. This demand has been growing and growing in Scotland.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

I am detecting that you feel that there is much more of a mood to go down this route.

David Eyre Unite the Union
link

That is definitely the case. For example, there are representatives of the get Glasgow moving campaign in the gallery this morning, and they have been very active in a city where 49 per cent of people do not have access to the car and where the public transport system—in particular, buses—are fundamental to people getting around. There is a growing demand and a growing expectation from people in Scotland that the Parliament will now act.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

Our briefing note says that, in preparing to introduce a transport bill later in the session, the Government is working with stakeholders to develop options for improving bus services. Is that something that you have been or would hope to be involved in?

David Eyre Unite the Union
link

We have not been involved in it directly, but—

David Eyre Unite the Union
link

We would definitely hope to be engaged in the process of any transport bill. However, the important thing is that, as the petition goes through the Public Petitions Committee, the Parliament through the committee takes the opportunity to listen to the voices of the people of Scotland in order to get a full picture of the terrible impacts on communities as a result of the current deregulated system. Quite often in the legislative process, the stakeholders are those who are already organised—they are, if you like, already in organisations—and it would be great if the Parliament through the committee were able to uncover the evidence of the people on the ground in Scotland, not just the usual stakeholders.

Ian Taylor Transport for Quality of Life
link

I want to make a slightly different point about stakeholders by highlighting the issue of the bus companies themselves. One of the reasons why progress has not been made in Scotland might be that there are two very large bus companies based in Scotland, First and Stagecoach, neither of which has shown itself to be in favour of reregulation. However, there are bus companies that are in favour of reregulation, including some of the big ones such as Keolis, RATP, Abellio, the HCT Group and Tower Transit. You will not have heard of all of those, but Abellio is a big bus company that is part of the Dutch railway system; RATP runs buses in Paris; and Keolis, too, is based in France.

Those companies are strongly in favour of reregulation, and it is interesting that all of them have a lot of experience of European systems where things have been reregulated. In fact, some of them have much more experience than First, and they would prefer a system that did not have a lot of what they see as wasteful requirements that they would have to fend off and which would be seen as inefficient competition in a more European perspective.

10:00

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

You have referred to the Transport for London model. Where are its good points that would probably be good for Scotland?

Ian Taylor Transport for Quality of Life
link

The starting point is that something like a franchising system should be your default option. If you are going to adopt that, you could start with some duties on the local transport authorities. If they are going to have the powers to reregulate they should also have duties. Those should be simple duties: to increase bus use and improve bus services. Those do not exist at the moment, but as soon as a local authority had those duties, it would ask, “How do we do this?” The Urban Transport Group, the body that oversees passenger transport executives and so on, suggests that something like franchising should be the default option.

Previous transport bills have tried to set up legislation that works, but it has proved to be too tortuous. Nexus, the authority in the north-east of England around Newcastle, tried to go through the existing legislation to set up some sort of franchising system, but it was impossible to complete. The London system has a lot to recommend it, and it could be improved on by doing what has been proposed by the new London mayor, which is to have a system a bit like those in Germany, which has “Tariftreue”, whereby minimum pay and conditions are imposed across the board—so that companies must pay their drivers the minimum wage and so on. It works pretty well in London.

One of the biggest things that you can achieve under such systems, which you cannot do under a deregulated system, is to have one network, one brand and one ticket. You can achieve a smart, pay-as-you-go system in which the fare is capped.

Under the present system and competition law, it is illegal to stop bus companies setting their own single fare. That is rubbish. People want to know that they can have a simple ticket. If there is an Oyster-style system, as in London, people know that they will get the best deal. Whichever bus company they use—whether it is RATP, Abellio or Go Ahead—the name is visible on the back, but the buses are all red and they all share one brand. At the end of the day, if someone has travelled on lots of different buses, the system will cap the fare and people know that. That is impossible under the deregulated system. With a franchising system and with regulation, the fare structure is specified. In Munich, for example, there is one network, one ticket and one brand. That can be invested in.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

Good morning, David and Ian. You have put forward a well-argued case so far, and I have a lot of sympathy with it. You have done a lot of research into the issue already. Do you have any further suggestions about how bus services could be brought back into common ownership? Did anything come out of the research that you commissioned that you have not highlighted yet?

I am particularly interested in whether you can list any other nations in Europe where buses are in common ownership or where they have been reregulated successfully. You have mentioned political consensus in France and the situation in Germany. Do you have any other examples? Are you aware of any similar situations such as in the Nordic countries for instance?

Ian Taylor Transport for Quality of Life
link

Those are interesting questions, but I am afraid to say that they start to go into the 150-page version of our report. You have just been given the short summary.

Ian Taylor Transport for Quality of Life
link

I will be brief. It is quite straightforward: if somewhere that has moved to a franchising system wishes to move gradually to a publicly owned system beyond that, it is just a question of letting the franchised routes lapse one by one.

There are still 12 publicly owned bus companies in the UK, of which Lothian Buses is the biggest and, arguably, the best. The essential thing is that if you invest in such a company, you can take it over gradually. On the other hand, if your authority’s neighbouring authority has its own municipal company, you can buy into that. It is not difficult to set up a bus company. You do not have to buy the whole stock—you can lease the buses. There are no fundamental obstacles. As I say, there are other European examples. One could look at Austria, where the bulk of the cities such as Salzburg and Vienna and so on have publicly owned networks that have been put together in that way.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

Around three years ago, when the second of the two relevant bills was being debated, it was suggested that the total cost of regulating bus services in Scotland would be around £1 billion. At that point, Iain Gray said that that was rubbish—

Ian Taylor Transport for Quality of Life
link

I agree.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

Have you costed regulation? Has your research produced any figures?

Ian Taylor Transport for Quality of Life
link

Table 5.1 shows the financial gains from franchising and the costs of franchising. I should perhaps explain that, if you are thinking that all these numbers are a bit different from the numbers in the other table, it is because they are the result of a slightly different approach. When we did the report, we had Britain-wide figures. In the numbers here, the Scottish totals are done as a pro rata on the turnover of bus companies in Scotland. Before coming here, we did a bit of rushed research. Unite kindly pulled out all sorts of company accounts and I analysed them on Friday and Monday. The two sets of figures are actually commensurate. It turns out that the pro rata was very close. However, with the figures in table 5.1, we have been able to exclude Lothian Buses.

To come back to your question about the costs of franchising, our estimate is that it might cost a couple of million to add capacity in local authorities that do not have it. Reregulation is as valuable in rural areas as it is in urban areas. There were some good pre-deregulation regulated systems in rural areas.

Also, bus companies have to bid in, and there is a cost that comes with that, which we estimate is about £1 million. The cost of bidding is not immediately apparent, but it will go into the system and eventually come out as a cost. It is a small proportion relative to the savings and is nowhere near the sorts of rubbish numbers that have been referred to.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Can I ask a slightly different question? Unite has the haud the bus campaign and represents the workforce. There are folk from Glasgow here today, and the Co-operative Party has the people’s bus campaign. There is clearly demand for regulation from a range of organisations. Unite spoke specifically about the consequences of a deregulated system for people working in the bus industry. Presumably there is so much competition that there is pressure on terms and conditions. Do you have examples of the conditions in which bus drivers are now operating? There are fewer routes and it is costing more. What is it like for folk who are working in the industry?

David Eyre Unite the Union
link

It is not just bus drivers; it is the people who maintain the buses and the people who carry the cash from the buses to the counting offices. There are the bus cleaners, too. All of those professions are under pressure. In Glasgow, bus depots have been closed, for example at Parkhead, and centralised at the Caledonia depot in the Gorbals. Anecdotally, we know that there are fewer pits for maintaining the buses, and that is increasing pressure on the people who are trying to keep the buses on the road. As a result, increasingly there is lost mileage on bus services in Glasgow. Quite often, buses are not available because the capacity is not there to maintain and repair them. There is that side of things.

There is also a cash side of things. Ian Taylor’s report makes it clear that, before bus deregulation, a bus driver’s wage was roughly in line with the average wage and that, since bus deregulation, the average wage has gone up by 25 per cent but the average wage of a bus driver has gone down by 11 per cent. Therefore, bus deregulation has had an impact not just on passengers but on the people who work in the bus industry. It has been bad for people. However, our members who work in the bus industry tell us that some companies are better than others. Lothian Buses stands out as one of the better bus companies for its terms and conditions, and it is no accident that Lothian Buses is municipally owned.

In London, where there is a franchise model, the mayor has started to include in the franchise discussions the terms and conditions of bus drivers and others who work in the industry. I imagine that that could be replicated in Scotland under a franchise system, and that would be good for our members. There is a franchise system in London and the Bus Services Bill that is going through Westminster could roll out a franchise system to every local authority in England, while in Northern Ireland the bus service is still municipally owned. Scotland is in danger of being left at the edge unless we take action now.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

Good morning, gentlemen. Our briefing refers to the number of parliamentary questions that have been lodged that have some relevance to the issue that is raised in your petition. For example, in response to a question on the action that the Scottish Government is taking to protect bus services, the Minister for Transport and the Islands referred to the £50 million of funding that is allocated through the bus service operators grant and the £60 million of funding that is made available to allow local authorities to support their local bus services. Do you have an opinion or position on that?

Ian Taylor Transport for Quality of Life
link

Do you mean an opinion or position on whether that is good money that is being well spent?

Ian Taylor Transport for Quality of Life
link

It is good money, and it is great to see it going into buses. The case for supporting buses as a public service is very strong indeed. However, it is my strong contention that, for that money, the Government should be able to achieve its policy objectives for buses, and I do not think that there is the required level of control. The Government puts the money in and the bus companies can do what maximises the profit for them. Logically, they will do that, and they will do it well. At the moment, if the Government wants concessionary fares for older people, for young people or for disabled people, it will pay through the nose for that—that is how it works—whereas under the London system, it is just part of the deal. The route is contracted and the company has to carry those people free of charge or whatever.

Our fares system is quite controversial, as the bus companies know that they are going to be reimbursed more if their fares are high. I happen to live in Wales, and one of the reasons that we tend to have high fares in rural areas is that, if a bus company sets high fares, it gets reimbursed more for its concessions. Also, the regime does not work well because, if the bus company decides to run a whole new route, the Government ends up reimbursing it for something that should have been cost neutral. There is therefore a question of how the money is spent.

The issue goes beyond that, because that is only the money that the companies get directly. We should be aware that the public purse is also building bus priority measures. The local authorities build bus stations and bus stops, and the local transport authorities have to run around doing the timetables, the leafletting and that sort of thing. In many places, there is no overall network map. You can get a network map for Leicester from Arriva that purports to shows the bus network in Leicester, but it is not a map of the bus network in Leicester—it is just a map of the Arriva bus network in Leicester.

The point that I am working towards is that the local authorities provide bus priority money and all sorts of other money, and that money is doing a lot of the work that the bus companies should be doing themselves. We do not expect to pay to market Tesco but we do it for the bus companies, and yet they call it a commercial service. Given that 40 per cent of the bus companies’ income comes from the public purse and all the infrastructure is laid on by the public purse, we do not have sufficient control over the system.

10:15

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

Are you concerned about the fact that the subsidies are not spread equitably among larger and smaller bus operators? Is there a need to strike a balance between commercial and social needs? I presume that that is what you were alluding to.

David Eyre Unite the Union
link

As I said in my opening statement, the only mechanism that we have for dealing with a situation in which a bus company decides that a route is not profitable is for the local authority to subsidise that route. There is anecdotal evidence that less money goes to support subsidised routes in Lothian, where we have a publicly owned bus service, than is the case in other areas of Scotland. As another example, the service in Banton that I mentioned has been running for the past six months only because North Lanarkshire Council is funding it.

Ian Taylor might have more figures.

Ian Taylor Transport for Quality of Life
link

Some of the smaller bus operators might find Mr Whittle’s question quite resonant. Since deregulation, the large bus companies have had the muscle to exclude—or to buy out—small operators, and we have ended up with the big six across the UK. To put it really bluntly, we have a functioning cartel of local monopolies. That is not what was meant to happen under deregulation, and it is, I presume, one of the reasons why people have turned against it.

The franchising system provides quite a simple way in for smaller operators. Johann Lamont asked about different forms of not-for-profit ownership, such as the co-operative model. Hackney Community Transport is a not-for-profit group that started as a community transport group in London and operated under the franchise system. It has since grown into a nationwide group with a turnover of £40 million, and it runs all the buses on Jersey and Guernsey under the franchising system there.

Some of the smaller operators have very good reputations—they have had to be really good to survive against the big guys. Local authorities attempt to sustain those operators under the present tendering system because they do not want to be held over a barrel by the big operators. Almost universally, the cannier local authority officers who are doing limited contracting at present are trying to cut contracts into pieces that the small operators can bid for.

In addition, if a small operator is bidding for a simple contract for which the route is defined, it does not have to worry about revenue forecasts and so on—it has only to ask what it is going to cost to run the service. Deregulation has been quite difficult for small operators, but re-regulation could be designed in such a way that it would be good for them across the board. Where I live, I am lucky to have a very good small operator: we would not have a bus service, otherwise.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I suspect that we could discuss the petition for another three hours, given the number of different issues that it raises. One issue that we have not touched on is the capacity of community transport to deliver a service. I do not want to close down the discussion unnecessarily, but we must move on, because there are pressures on our time.

I note that Pat Rafferty is now in the gallery. I regret that, because of transport challenges, he was unable to be here earlier. However, it would be fair to say that the evidence that we have had has been extremely useful.

Do the witnesses have any brief final comments before we consider how we might progress the petition?

Ian Taylor Transport for Quality of Life
link

I have a small point on an issue that you have not asked us about and perhaps should have done, if you will excuse me for saying so. One of the counterarguments that people come up with is that London has lots of money and the London system is terribly expensive. That is not a valid point, for two reasons. First, until 2000, support for bus services in London had been run down to the point that it was virtually zero, but the patronage held up in a way that it did not in other areas. Secondly, if we look at the patronage from the point of view of the value of subsidy per trip, the subsidy levels per trip are lower in London than elsewhere. I thought that I would throw that in as a parting shot.

I thank the committee very much for its time.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We are not often told what questions we did not ask, but we will bear that in mind for the future. Laughter. I say to the witnesses, and to Pat Rafferty in particular, that you should feel free to follow up any issues with the committee after this evidence session.

On how we will take the petition forward, I think that the committee wants to look further at the issue that the petition raises. Do members have suggestions about what we might do in that regard?

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

We should seek the Scottish Government’s views on the action for which the petition calls, specifically the Government’s involvement with stakeholders in developing legislation options for improving bus services as part of the preparation for a transport bill.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Yes. It is essential that we write to the Government and seek its views, as Brian Whittle said, and write to various stakeholders to get their views on the petition so that we can get a complete picture.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

I agree that we should write to the Government and to stakeholders—in particular, Strathclyde partnership for transport, given that it deals with a lot of the issues to which the petition refers.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We should write to a range of stakeholder organisations, including the trade unions, the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities and various community and transport groups across the country, to ask for information. The petition raises questions about the level of public subsidy and the nature of the services that are being delivered, and I think that we need to reflect further on the second aspect of the petition with regard to whether there should be an inquiry and whether it is viable for this committee or another committee to undertake it. However, we are not closing down the second aspect at this point. We will seek as much information as possible and then reflect on it, especially on the information that we get from the Scottish Government.

We will write to COSLA, the regional transport partnerships, the bus stakeholders group, the Association of Transport Coordinating Officers and the Confederation of Passenger Transport Scotland, and to passenger groups such as Bus Users Scotland and the Scottish Association for Public Transport. We can also contact other groups that members may suggest. Unite the union will obviously want to respond, and other unions with an interest in the matter might want to respond as well.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

Given that the Bus Services Bill that is going through Westminster was mentioned earlier, I would be keen to get a paper from the Scottish Parliament information centre with more detail on where Westminster is with that bill.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

That would be helpful. As we heard in evidence, there have been shifts in policy positions on bus services elsewhere in the United Kingdom.

We have agreed what we will do with the petition. I thank the witnesses for their attendance today and their evidence. We will revisit the petition and keep you informed about that. However, please feel free to feed into the committee any further points that you might have.

I suspend the meeting for a changeover of witnesses.

10:23 Meeting suspended.

10:26 On resuming—

  1. 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 38
  3. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 7
  4. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 7
  5. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 7
  6. 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 49
  7. 10:15 New Petitions Petitions · 53
  8. 10:45 New Petitions Petitions · 35
  9. 11:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 1

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.