Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01626 · Session 5

Regulation of Bus Services

Closed Submitted 28 Oct 2016 Transport
Signatures
0
1,705 online signatures with a country
Comments
229
Considered
7 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to legislate to regulate bus services in Scotland and to carry out an inquiry into the benefits of bringing bus services in Scotland into common ownership.

What the petitioner did first

In the Fourth Scottish Parliament, Unite supported the proposed Bus Regulation (Scotland) Bill brought to Parliament by Iain Gray MSP.
In the Third Scottish Parliament, Unite supported the proposed Regulation of Bus Services Bill brought to Parliament by Charlie Gordon MSP.
Neither of these bills resulted in legislation to bring bus services under regulation or common ownership.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 19 Jan 2017
    1 mention
  2. 27 Apr 2017
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 29 Jun 2017
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  4. 21 Dec 2017
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    2 mentions
  5. 26 Apr 2018
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  6. 21 Mar 2019
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  7. 17 Feb 2021
    2 mentions

Signatures by country

1,705 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,239 72.7%
  2. United Kingdom417 24.5%
  3. England45 2.6%
  4. United States2 0.1%
  5. United States Minor Outlying Islands1 0.1%
  6. Wales1 0.1%

Comments

229 comments, oldest first
229 comments · showing 51–100
  1. evelyn caven 16 Nov 2016
    Buses cold and uncomfortable due to poor suspension and no seat belts. Drivers are pushed to limit by breaking speed limits on roads to make their timetables and makes journeys more uncomfortable. Could this be one reason for not using buses both from a comfort and also a safety issue.
  2. margo DAVID 16 Nov 2016
    I PAY £118 PER MONTH FOR A ZONECARD. WE HAVE NO BUS SERVICE FROM pAILSE x to todholm and hunterhill after 8pm. i work shifts and often have to pay for a taxi, on top of zone card at least 10 times per month. im a women in her 50s and have to walk along dark roads to get home, a mile away
  3. Lesley Sutherland 16 Nov 2016
    As a frequent bus user I think it is very important to protect and improve bus services and to encourage the use of public transport. Local authorities having the power to regulate bus services would make that easier.
  4. Jacqueline Mcculloch 17 Nov 2016
    Public transport is an essential service and should not be in the hands of private companies out to make a profit.
  5. Anthony totten 17 Nov 2016
    My teenage daughter had to stop workong in a job she liked and worked hard in at the back o hills industrial estate at the raploch stirling as first bus stopped the service route from stirling to glasgow via denny after 6 pm in the evening, and subsequently is now unemployed due to the bus service routes being taken off the road. Such a shame when they say that the young dont wana work and they want people to use public transport at super inflated prices which they know most people cant afford but have no choice.
    I would personally like, along with lots of family and friends, to see the bus services regulated by the local councils in every authority throughout Scotland, and i think they can all take a leaf out of lothian buses and tram services in edinburgh..such a credit to scotland's infrastructure even tho it took a fair bit of time to put in place ..
  6. Aleks Jurczyk 17 Nov 2016
    Public transport in Glasgow is among the very worst I have used in anywhere in the world. A huge contributory factor to the appalling service we receive is the private ownership of these services. In order to have a service that is fit for our city we must bring our bus services back into public ownership as quickly as possible.
  7. George Bathgate 17 Nov 2016
    I would like to see West Lothian run by Lothian buses instead of first bus. Lothian buses run a well maintained fleet of vehicles compared to first bus.
  8. Shirley Lewis 17 Nov 2016
    Public transport needs to be sorted out and updated
  9. Gary Paton 17 Nov 2016
    I live in Dalry, Ayrshire and the first bus to my work in Stevenson is 07.13. This is not acceptable!!
  10. Kenneth Mcewan 17 Nov 2016
    The bus services in Coatbridge are an absolute disgrace there are no local buses after 6 in my area
  11. ThomasTyler 17 Nov 2016
    The Bus service in Shetland is poor enough already we cannot afford to loose any more of the service.
  12. Stephen Thomas 17 Nov 2016
    Far to few far to expensive, cheaper and easierto run a car.
  13. Tanya Hennebry 17 Nov 2016
    Bus prices are scandalous and First Bus should be held accountable. In Dumbarton they are the only bus company as the other independent companies got pushed out like McColls, McGills.
    I am just back from Perth Western Australia and our MSP & MPs could learn a lot from how their not only bus services work but their public transport as a whole.

    Lower your prices First Bus
  14. matt lauchlan 17 Nov 2016
    due to poor service people in our area now look on owning some form of transport as essential , if working in Glasgow or further afield bus only takes one route , before privatisation we had bus service covering various routes giving access to 3 main hospitals serving Glasgow and Lanarkshire ,none of these are available now ,either car required or various change of buses to get to these important destinations.
  15. William Green 17 Nov 2016
    Buses should be in common ownership, because it puts the public first with cheaper fares and better buses, also can provide a top class service!
  16. William Green 17 Nov 2016
    Buses in common ownership produces a bus service which is second to none! I am a bus driver for Lothian buses and was recently working at first and the gulf is massive! If you want to be proud of your bus service it's the only way!
  17. Rodh Milne 17 Nov 2016
    Where I stay, we don't even get reliable buses, ie. they break down frequently. Also the last bus from the city of Elgin leaves at just after 1800 hrs which means getting a taxi for the ten mile journey home.
  18. Elizabeth Reilly 17 Nov 2016
    Where I stay we have one bus per hour
  19. Robert McLellan 17 Nov 2016
    Unite could have done this in 2012 for all Renfrewshire but as usual said a lot, promise a lot and done nothing letting paying members down member total disgrace.
  20. colin george bruce mackay 17 Nov 2016
    bus services are crucial specially in rural ares
  21. Sally Watson 17 Nov 2016
    Private bus operators are becoming less and less accountable. Last month First Bus in Glasgow withdrew the 4A from Kelvindale, leaving a whole community with no bus service. They refused to budge despite over 3,000 people signing a petition and representations from local councillors and MSPs. It's essential they're regulated or they will continue putting profit before people.
  22. Philip Connelly 17 Nov 2016
    Services through my local area have been severely curtailed making it much more difficult for non-motorists to travel. It is especially hard on vulnerable people who have become more isolated. The population of my local area has increased but the bus service has become poorer.
  23. Sally Watson 17 Nov 2016
    Recently First Bus in Glasgow withdrew the only bus service in Kelvindale, leaving a whole community with no bus access. This despite over 3,000 people signing a petition and representations from local councillors and MSPs. It's essential they are regulated, otherwise they will continue putting profit before people and no one can stop them.
  24. John Thomas Reilly 17 Nov 2016
    Not before time someone took the lead on this having worked in first bus for the last 8 years i have never known working conditions for our members to be so bad with drivers safety being put at risk by a total failure of this company to meet their license requirements .
    Having spent 2 hours trying to get from Caledonia depot to East Kilbride on Sunday night i totally understand the anger of the public unfortunatley the drivers are at the front end of this anger and ignorant staff managers have a couldnt care less attitude to what is going on.
  25. Anne Newlands 17 Nov 2016
    Would love to use the bus more but there just aren't many going at a suitable time and the price is ridiculous compared to other areas. Lower the price increase the availability and lets us see what happens.
  26. Nigel Gordon Davies 17 Nov 2016
    From my address you might think what is he on about. Like a significant minority I rely on lifts or the bus to get about
    - whether for shopping, meeting family and friends or visiting my GP.
    The main local bus operator in Fife has in the past 3 months slashed routes in Sth Fife, pleading lack of public subsidy. The truth is brutal
    - Stagecoach are a business and do not provide a public service
  27. Mark McErlane 17 Nov 2016
    Greenock has become a Wild West Town with only one main provider of buses who can then decide all timetables to suit the taxi busisness which the same family own
  28. Jim Lister 17 Nov 2016
    My City, Glasgow, has one of the lowest rates of car ownership (not a bad thing) yet the highest bus fares of any UK city, that can't be right. Why can't the Lothian Buses model be adopted?
  29. Raymond McDonald 17 Nov 2016
    Born of a half decent idea, now greed has taken over so nuff is enough. Lets take back control because people are the power.
  30. Yvonne Dunigan 17 Nov 2016
    Can't believe you can't get a bus from Cumbernauld to Edinburgh......
  31. Patricia McQuillan 17 Nov 2016
    Glasgow is one of the most deprived city's in Europe yet it has one of the highest bus fares in Europe it's a dis grace I have been fighting with first bus for years about their services and fares.
  32. Jock Lonsdale 17 Nov 2016
    Keep our buses alive
  33. James Davidson 17 Nov 2016
    we all need public transport
  34. Dave Styles 17 Nov 2016
    No wonder people don't use the buses. They are run for profit and not service, at the convince of the operator, not the client.

    This is a service for people that don't have their own transport, it is not a luxury or a perk it is requirement for sustainability within Scotland.
  35. RODERICK NEIL BRUCE 17 Nov 2016
    I am one of the Scottish Bus Group Drivers who suffered and lost Pension because of Privatisation, all the operators now are interested in is profit. Margaret Thatcher gave them a licence to print money.time to get Buses back into Public ownership
  36. Stewart Daniels 17 Nov 2016
    Bus fares are a rip off
  37. david smith 17 Nov 2016
    Bus services and the industry has been in a mess for years.Bring them back under public control.
  38. Jenny Kemp 17 Nov 2016
    Public transport should be affordable and accessible for all. Regulation and common ownership are both means to achieving a system that works for everyone and isn't profit driven.
  39. Donna Clark 17 Nov 2016
    My Area Aberdeen has the highest prices a shocking service & we are never consulted on changes to services.We get poor quality.
  40. Stuart Johnston 17 Nov 2016
    Only one bus from Bo'ness to Edinburgh and back, leaves Bo'ness at 06:30 then Edinburgh at 17:30. Monday to Saturday. Bo'ness is 20 miles away and a population of around 16000. Most residents who depend on public transport for commuting or a special day out feel totally isolated
  41. James Kennedy 17 Nov 2016
    Though I am on a good bus route, the problem I have with the buses is that 4 buses arrive with in one minute of each other and if there are a lot of passengers waiting for different buses sometimes the bus you are waiting on runs past the stop
  42. colin vernall 17 Nov 2016
    The phrase bus service is a misnomer, what happens involves buses but in nothing resembling a service. It's largely a lottery as to how reliable or otherwise the so-called service is, and the cost and disproportionate increases, exclude too many and are simply a way of boosting profits.
  43. Trevor Easton 17 Nov 2016
    As a very frequent visitor to Scotland for both work and leisure, I have seen the key role public transport plays both in the remote areas and the centers of population.
    Their environmental, social and economic importance requires the security given by common ownership
  44. DONALD Mc DONALD 17 Nov 2016
    Stop the Management rot .
  45. Stephen Deans 17 Nov 2016
    In the Bonnybridge area, the bus services through our village have been cut by First Bus repeatedly over the last 10 years and more. The service is threadbare, as are most of the buses which are 15
    - 20+ years old.
  46. Margaret Reynolds 17 Nov 2016
    I would take a bus if fares were more reasonable but I am actually cheaper taking my car.
  47. margaret cochrane (Unite member) 17 Nov 2016
    When government allowed the private bus companies in and funded them the bus service to most especially in outlying communities declined dramatically
    Also adult and childrens bus fares are far to high and for people on low wages who have to travel to get work this is a big part of their outgoings
    Scottish Government needs to address this issue
    its a sad reflections that Westminister seems to be addressing this but we are not ?
  48. John mackenzie 17 Nov 2016
    Bring bus services back to common ownership. Many current private license holders are ripping us off. I would also question the current license system
  49. John Middleditch 17 Nov 2016
    Time to get buses integrated with trains and ferries to form a proper integrated system.
  50. Lesley Rodger 17 Nov 2016
    I live in Dunblane which is currently undergoing an face lift with new pavements, plants and sculptures being added to the village center. However, Stirling Council had taken off two local buses in the last year which leaves us with a bus service every 2 to 3 hours. My feeling is that Councils are not recognising and prioritising the needs of the local community and that the utilities and departments within the Council are not doing a bit of 'joined up thinking'. If the Government are looking for the public to reduce their carbon footprint and take social responsibility for their way of living then this needs to be backed up by Government and local councils by providing a regular transport and bus service.