Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01581 · Session 4

Save Scotland's School Libraries

Closed Submitted 9 Sep 2015 Education
Signatures
0
2,651 online signatures with a country
Comments
170
Considered
9 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to set out a new national strategy for school libraries which recognises the vital role of high quality school libraries in supporting pupils’ literacy and research skills.

What the petitioner did first

We have been actively campaigning for action for a number of years
• In February 2011 a protest was held outside the Scottish Parliament to raise awareness of the issue. Protestors spoke with elected representatives Gordon MacDonald, Alison Johnstone, Iain Gray and Marco Biaigi at the protest.
• Following the protest a letter highlighting concerns was sent to the then First Minister Alex Salmond.
• Subsequently since then the professional body for Librarians in Scotland, the Chartered Institute of Library and Information Professionals Scotland (CILIPS), has formally responded to various local authorities who have proposed, and subsequently cut services.
• Individuals have also engaged with local authority consultations but have often found their responses have been ignored. For example in East Renfrewshire in the spring of 2015 the proposal to cut the number of school librarians received the highest number of responses and yet the proposal was not dropped.
• CILIPS produced School Librarianship: An Advocacy Strategy, highlighting the positive contribution school libraries and school librarians make in supporting the curricular and developmental needs of young people. This was distributed to every school in Scotland and to Education Scotland and other Education leaders.
• During our campaigning many colleagues have met with local councillors and elected representatives to discuss the issue.
• A Facebook page has been created to highlight the issue. This currently has over 900 likes.
• We work very closely with both CILIPS and the School Library Association (Scotland) to advocate the importance of school libraries and school librarians.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 24 Nov 2015
    1 mention
  2. 26 Jan 2016
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 8 Mar 2016
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  4. 29 Sep 2016
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  5. 8 Dec 2016
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  6. 2 Mar 2017
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  7. 20 Apr 2017
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  8. 25 May 2017
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  9. 9 Nov 2017
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

2,651 online signatures
  1. Scotland2,096 79.1%
  2. United Kingdom359 13.5%
  3. England127 4.8%
  4. United States12 0.5%
  5. Ireland11 0.4%
  6. Northern Ireland8 0.3%
  7. Wales6 0.2%
  8. France4 0.2%
  9. Afghanistan4 0.2%
  10. Germany3 0.1%
  11. 18 other countries21 0.8%

Comments

170 comments, oldest first
170 comments · showing 51–100
  1. David Robinson 18 Sep 2015
    Close a library, close a thousand minds
  2. Reuben Gallagher 18 Sep 2015
    I love my school library, I don't know where I'd be without it.
  3. Emma Stevenson 18 Sep 2015
    We need libraries in society to expand out knowledge
  4. Suzanne mullen 18 Sep 2015
    Library's are important to children's education
  5. vicky byrne 18 Sep 2015
    Librarys should never be shut down
  6. Mike Newman 18 Sep 2015
    Our High School and Community Librarian recently retired and has not been replaced, so now there is no qualified librarian on site. This is such a retrograde step. Libraries and librarians provide quality access to information which cannot be adequately replaced by internet access and Google searches.
  7. Katrina Kelly 18 Sep 2015
    At the moment the only provision for our school library is 3 days a week with two different librarians who themselves are spread across several schools. This valuable resource is unavailable to pupils for 2 days.
  8. Jeannie Thow 18 Sep 2015
    Information should be readily available in schools every minute of the school day. There should be a librarian available to assist pupils to access this information. This is a basic requirement for a good secondary education.
  9. Ivor J. Santer 18 Sep 2015
    For many children the school library is still Pandora's box.
  10. Joan MacLellan 18 Sep 2015
    My daughter is deaf and attended a mainstream school in Edinburgh. She found the library to be a source of support as well as information, and a quiet place to study. It was invaluable, and I'm sure is just as valuable to other students and staff. Keep our school libraries !
  11. Margaret Forrester 18 Sep 2015
    All those books and the quiet to read them ....
    Fifty years ago now!
    Enhance and expand. Close books and you close imagination.
  12. Carleen Parry 18 Sep 2015
    Literacy skills are key for Curriculum of excellence...The school librarian at Eastwood High, Newton Mearns engages and supports every child with their individual learning needs to help them achieve their very best . Miss De'arths library is the hub of the school and East Renfrewshire Education department may save money by reducing head cound but the education standard offered would certainly be a poorer place.
  13. Stuart Graham 18 Sep 2015
    As a Principal Teacher of English in a Secondary school, I know first hand the importance of reading and and good access to literature. Librarians are absolutely vital in helping to support young people with their literacy skills and helping them navigate the vast arrange of texts and sources they need to use. Our librarian is central to our school and highly valued by staff and pupils alike. To lose such a position would be a huge, short sighted mistake and a great irony given the Scottish Givernment's commitment to raising standards of literacy.
  14. Gail Williams 18 Sep 2015
    School libraries are a vital resource.
  15. Carolyn Fisher 18 Sep 2015
    What sort of message are we sending to our young people if we close their school library?
  16. Catherine King 19 Sep 2015
    What would be the point in giving every child in Scotland a Library Membership, then actively support a reduction in skilled staff delivering that service? Time the Scottish Government follows up and supports children when they need us most.
  17. Katie Diallo 19 Sep 2015
    We need to learn the lessons of history so not to repeat our mistakes. We need our libraries!
  18. Anne Elibol 19 Sep 2015
    School Libraries are the Heart of all schools.By closing them down you are denying children the right to learn to read,enjoy reading and learn the skills of research through books.Shame on any council or Head that feels this is the right thing to do.Also having access to a qualified Librarian is also essential in teaching children those skills
  19. Margaret Delussey 19 Sep 2015
    School libraries and librarians are vital. There is no reasonable or rational argument for closing them, or cutting back on librarians.
  20. Beverley Craig 19 Sep 2015
    Libraries give us free access to knowledge and learning.
  21. Rhonda Wheate 19 Sep 2015
    The library is one of my favourite places in the world. If libraries are properly funded, and curated by knowledgable, trained, enthusiastic staff, the sky is the limit
    - You get a knowledgeable, enthusiastic nation!
  22. ruan peat 19 Sep 2015
    Every study has shown a society with better literacy has a better society, but school are not supported to have library's and librarians, we are the specialists that need to help promote, support and spread literacy and the a love of books.
  23. Helen Melone 20 Sep 2015
    I think there needs to be a national strategy
    - too many local authorities are dumbing down their school libraries and reducing librarians' hours. Government needs to act quickly to stop this from happening. School librarians are doing an amazing job teaching young people how to access information and research. It is such a shame that this resource is being lost as all these cuts are taking effect. Please do something now to stop this.
  24. Lesley Workman 20 Sep 2015
    To create a real culture of literacy we need a librarian at the heart of schools to inspire young people to read.
  25. G. Ghatoray 20 Sep 2015
    Absolutely despicable to get rid of school Librarians. Our school Librarian is much more than just the Librarian
    - she covers so many other remits and the pupils love going to our library. Politicians and councils must be utterly mad in what they are doing
    - I pay my taxes and want to be heard not just brushed aside in a feeble attempt to save money. Why not cut down on the unnecessary staff in the directorships of education authorities with their colossal salaries instead of picking on the low paid?
  26. Nancy Davis 20 Sep 2015
    My school library helped me progress from being a junior reader into much broader interests. It felt a very accessible place to explore new interests.
  27. Cleo Jones 21 Sep 2015
    School Librarians make a real difference to children's lives, they are able to help close the gap by promoting reading for enjoyment, which it is evidenced that children and young people who read for pleasure do better across all academic subjects. I have worked in this area for for over 25 years and we are now looking at the decimation of services across Scotland without there being an overview from Central Government who say that Literacy and closing the gap are the most important things that we can give young people and yet they are presiding over the loss of these valuable services. A review now is essential to make sure that young people don't lose access to these valuable services and people.
  28. Liz Douch 21 Sep 2015
    Librarians are invaluable members of every school community who do so much more than their remit suggests. How does the government expect Literacy in young people to improve when thy are considering paying off those who are primarily employed to engage young people in reading?
  29. David Sudding 21 Sep 2015
    I believe that using a library, developing the skills that are required to fully use a library are essential to a childs development in Scotland. Don't consider the short term savings, but the long term cost to Scotland if we have children who don't have access to a school library.
  30. D Stevenson 21 Sep 2015
    School librarians play an invaluable role within schools and they should not be made redundant in an attempt to cut costs. It is unrealistic and unreasonable to expect 6th year pupils and teachers to run school libraries.
  31. Victoria Sutherland 21 Sep 2015
    The school librarians are an invaluable service within our schools and have led the way in my local authority designing a researching skills topic that staff and pupils use. This has provided teachers and pupils with a resource that enables all pupils to access the new CFE curriculum and enable them to achieve a high standard of success. They cut down on the time taken for pupils to access research materials that are integral part of the new courses and to lose them would mean some of more disadvantaged pupils would be worse off. They host homework clubs and other extra curricular activities and it is inexcusable to think that 6th year pupils or staff have the expertise or time to run this crucial service.
  32. Ted Easdon 21 Sep 2015
    School libraries & librarians are ESSENTIAL to education.
  33. C Cooper 21 Sep 2015
    Our school librarian is responsible for getting my son to read books. This has had a very positive impact on his English, not only in that subject but also in improving all his written work. She has created a nurturing environment in the school library and by getting to know the pupils has been able to recommend books and organise interesting literary events such as author events and the CILIP Carnegie Shadowing Scheme. This has instilled in my son an enjoyment of books which I believe will continue to enhance his education in the future. I hope that all school pupils will be able to have access to a fully qualified librarian now and in the future
    - a great asset to our schools.
  34. Joyce Mcleish 21 Sep 2015
    Our school librarian is one of the best resources we have. Her knowledge of her subject and our needs in the various subjects is superb. We cannot lose this valuable member of the school.
  35. Stephen McDonald 21 Sep 2015
    The falling literacy rate amongst young people in Scotland has been well documented of late, and so the decision to implement cuts on the school library service across the country, hugely detrimental to the attainment of children at any time, seems incoherent, bordering on negligent. The acquisition and application of skills is currently high on the Scottish Government's educational agenda, as seen in the roll out of Curriculum for Excellence
    - for this to be fully realised school libraries must be protected from cuts to staffing.
  36. Roger Griffith 22 Sep 2015
    School librarians are an integral part of a school and do far more than people will realise if they have not seen them in the school context. Using senior pupils to replace them is not a functional or sensible suggestion.
  37. Alison Mack 22 Sep 2015
    School libraries are a vital resource for our young people and should be staffed by a fully qualified librarian. In our school the librarian is invaluable as a resource and fully support and is involved in the learning being taught in our school.
  38. David Robertson 22 Sep 2015
    I great resource to have and a useful additional space for children to study if they have difficulty finding that space at home.
  39. Sheila Miller 22 Sep 2015
    A professionally trained school librarian is a valuable resource to teachers and pupils equally. They are equipped to guide users to properly evaluate educational resources both online and in hard copy format. Their experience and knowledge cannot be replaced by Google and Wikipedia. The attack on school libraries by educators looking for an easy target to save money is short sighted. Our society will be poorer if their demise is allowed.
  40. Lesley Hamilton 22 Sep 2015
    My children were introduced to books from birth. Not every child is so lucky. If a love of reading is instilled early, the child has a gift for life.
  41. Gemma Orrock 22 Sep 2015
    Books not bombs or banks.
  42. Finlay Menzies 22 Sep 2015
    It may seem rather surprising but without my school library I would never have pursued my career as a professional golfer!
  43. Allison Brisbane 22 Sep 2015
    School libraries are sanctuaries, magical places where children can read unconstrained by academic demands. The right school librarian with the right book at the right time in a child's life is truly transformational.
  44. Michael Kerins author storyteller 22 Sep 2015
    I passionately belive in the importance of schools' libraries
    - ... A great and nobel Scottish tradition should not be cast aside.
  45. Rachel Cairns 22 Sep 2015
    Without my school librarian I would have no idea how to write a dissertation. School librarians are huge assets to Scottish schools.
  46. S McWilliam 22 Sep 2015
    librarians are vital in a school, they encourage reading to our children
  47. Patricia Logue 23 Sep 2015
    School libraries are a must, they encourage children to read.
  48. christine Triay 23 Sep 2015
    If resources like this are to be cut then how can we say we are providing good education for our young people. A Library as we all know is a rich resource especially in a secondary school as it provides important back up material for regular study as well as help for all kinds of pupils and especially if the librarian is creative as ours is. Authors are brought in to school , slower pupils are given better chances , youngsters are encouraged to read in this day of ict and some have their capacities for writing developed. A very short sighted and foolish act to close a school library.
  49. Susan Kennedy 23 Sep 2015
    Libraries and librarians are vital resources!
  50. Rosalind Bird 23 Sep 2015
    The school library services are vital to education. They not only provide the books for background reading, but can provide a wealth of other resources to facilitate better learning. Without them, children will miss out on wonderful learning experiences.