Petition · PE01523 · Session 4
Give the Tinkers' Heart of Argyll back to the Travelling People
Signatures
1
Comments
127
Considered
4 meetings
What it asks
Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to direct Historic Scotland to investigate what action can be taken to ensure the restoration and preservation of the Heart of Quartz stones positioned in a field next to the A815, opposite the junction of the B839, overlooking Loch Fyne, known as the Gypsy Wedding Place, referred to locally as the Tinkers’ Heart.
What the petitioner did first
Early failed attempts to have the area restored by writing to local councillors, Loch Fyne ‘Here we are’ group from Cairndow, land owners and associates led to me approaching Michael Russell MSP. Mr Russell has been extremely helpful and ‘hands on’ in this matter. He has written to various bodies. He has met with the Landowner, councillors, Historic Scotland, written to Fiona Hyslop and several groups to resolve this matter without success.
I did receive encouragement when Archaeology Scotland, through their ‘Adopt A Monument’ scheme, offered to help but although a representative and I have met on several occasions (Phil Richardson) nothing has materialised.
RCAHMS were more forthcoming by photographing the area and recording its position. However, this simply dictates its location. The landowner has the final say. Kate Howe (landowner) lives in England and has mostly been negative in her views regarding the culture of the people that the Tinkers’ Heart represents.
I wrote and sent all relevant info to the present Duke of Argyll, who also lives in the south of England, but he refuses to help on the grounds of his friendship with Ms Howe.
Mrs Howe and her associates have not answered my emails but they have conversed with Michael Russell MSP
- but only to voice their views on the cultural significance in a negative manner.
In June 28th 2013 I met with Mike Russell MSP, Councillor Louise Glen-Lee, a rep from Visit Scotland and Historic Scotland at A&B council offices at Kilmory, Lochgilphead but once again no positive outcome.
The Rep from Visit Scotland queried how his organisation would benefit from supporting the project. I told him the area was not about tourism but about an entire culture that had been overlooked for centuries and that the Tinkers’ Heart was all they had as a marker of their ancestors. I did add that many of the Diaspora came from these humble beginnings and would be more than satisfied to see their culture protected by law.
The Historic Scotland rep said they would not go against the wishes of the landowner.
Time and events march on without a positive outcome therefore I have been left with no choice but to raise awareness through petitioning which I hope shall reach a wider audience and allow me to gauge how the public respond to such a request.
I did receive encouragement when Archaeology Scotland, through their ‘Adopt A Monument’ scheme, offered to help but although a representative and I have met on several occasions (Phil Richardson) nothing has materialised.
RCAHMS were more forthcoming by photographing the area and recording its position. However, this simply dictates its location. The landowner has the final say. Kate Howe (landowner) lives in England and has mostly been negative in her views regarding the culture of the people that the Tinkers’ Heart represents.
I wrote and sent all relevant info to the present Duke of Argyll, who also lives in the south of England, but he refuses to help on the grounds of his friendship with Ms Howe.
Mrs Howe and her associates have not answered my emails but they have conversed with Michael Russell MSP
- but only to voice their views on the cultural significance in a negative manner.
In June 28th 2013 I met with Mike Russell MSP, Councillor Louise Glen-Lee, a rep from Visit Scotland and Historic Scotland at A&B council offices at Kilmory, Lochgilphead but once again no positive outcome.
The Rep from Visit Scotland queried how his organisation would benefit from supporting the project. I told him the area was not about tourism but about an entire culture that had been overlooked for centuries and that the Tinkers’ Heart was all they had as a marker of their ancestors. I did add that many of the Diaspora came from these humble beginnings and would be more than satisfied to see their culture protected by law.
The Historic Scotland rep said they would not go against the wishes of the landowner.
Time and events march on without a positive outcome therefore I have been left with no choice but to raise awareness through petitioning which I hope shall reach a wider audience and allow me to gauge how the public respond to such a request.
Where it was considered
Official Report-
30 Sep 20141 mention
-
9 Dec 20141 mention
-
17 Feb 20151 mention
-
7 Sep 20151 mention
Signatures by country
1,179 online signaturesComments
127 comments, oldest first127 comments · showing 101–127
-
Lynne 10 May 2014Although I live in England, my mother's ashes are scattered near the heart, as will my father's be when his time comes. It's a place that means a great deal to us.
-
Tanya Muttitt 10 May 2014this is of huge importance to the travelling community please keep it for them x
-
ANNE STEWART 11 May 2014SO MUCH HAS BEEN TAKEN AWAY FROM THE TRUE TRAVELLERS ALREADY PLEASE LEAVE THEM THE HEART AS THIS IS A REAL PIECE OF HISTORY TO OUR STORY WHICH IS SURELY DYING LITTLE BY LITTLE
-
Michael J. Blythe (FB Admin of Blythe Genealogy) 11 May 2014This means so much to so many people. Monument status is the best thing for the Tinkers' Heart.
-
Ian Russell 12 May 2014This is a very special place for Travellers and is therefore a very special place to us all. The significance of the site is indisputable and it needs to be sympathetically restored and managed for future generations.
-
Peter Quelch 12 May 2014The tiny and crude steel fenced enclosure is an insult itself, though not much worse than deliberately siting a cattle feeding area around the monument. The site with its special history should surely merit a decent sized surrounding, with some trees planted to protect it in future. Scheduling it as a historic monument may help give the site the protection it deserves.
-
Linda Lennen 12 May 2014An important place and part of our heritage that is surely worth preserving.
-
Anne Hamilton 12 May 2014Brilliant! 1000 signatures recognising the importance of a Memorial to the Travelling Community in Scotland, a community which deserves to be remembered and valued for the important contribution it has made over the centuries to the very fabric of this country of ours. Well done Jess for not giving up on your beloved culture. I'm sure the Heart will survive for generations to come.
-
Edith Reyntiens 13 May 2014These monuments are priceless for our culture's continuity and heritage, we need to keep them. Thank you Jess, for bringing it to our attention!
-
Karen Wilson 15 May 2014I hope the heart gets restored and protected. I pass it often and have always known it as a sacred place. I would love to get married there !
-
Peter Upton 16 May 2014It's so sad that the richer people get, the meaner and smaller their hearts become. It is a rare joy to find wealthy philanthropists who aren't mean and who love their fellow humans. I hope this dream comes true. The black iron cage is ugly and this spot deserves so much better.
-
Martha Stewart 16 May 2014Some one a long time ago made this beautiful mosaic for whatever reason. It would be lovely to keep it as beautiful as the day it was created for anyone and everyone who wishes to visit it.
-
Leonard McNeill 17 May 2014Surely this small tribute should be preserved for future generations!
-
Kenneth Abernethy 17 May 2014The Heart is an important fragment of the fabric of Argyll culture and protected.
-
margaret mckay 17 May 2014There isn't much left of traveller tradition this should be protected for future generations to come for our children to be proud of their culture i hope that my signature helps protect this landmark i have never been to see the tinker hart but i would like to
-
nicole mckay 17 May 2014The tinkers heart should be protected to stay as strong as it is we need our traditions protected as there's not many of them left were all proud of the landmark that's been set there for years it would a shame to take it away now its appart of scottish travellers tradition a landmark our great grandchild could look upon and be proud of what they are!
-
Morag Donnan 18 May 2014May this petition be successful .
-
Josephine Crawford 19 May 2014Restore and preserve THE TINKERS' HEART!
-
Alexander McCallum 21 May 2014The Tinkers and Travellers Scottish Claim to be descendents of the Picts the Broken Clans , some were covenanters and Jacobites who ran to the hills and never went home they are integral every part of our history please respect them and there artistic and cultural contributions to our country
-
George Smart 21 May 2014Go on
- you know it makes sense. -
Margaret smart 21 May 2014Restore the tinkers' heart
-
Winnie Riley 22 May 2014I hope the Scottish Government will let the Scottish Travellers keep their landmark known as Tinkers Heart, My Great Grandparents came from Scotland, as well as Ireland so I think it's important to the Travellers heritage, Please consider this petition, because it would be nice for Scottish, Irish people of America to come to visit, God Bless all who are for this cause
-
sarah Hague 24 May 2014Good Luck, claim what is our heritage!
-
Barry Liddle 25 May 2014Just do it.
-
neil towsey 28 May 2014Travellers or not, heritage is heritage. Leave this landmark where it belongs!
-
rachel cassini 28 May 2014Save traveller history please
-
Gemma COSIMINI 28 May 2014Good luck