Petition · PE01523 · Session 4
Give the Tinkers' Heart of Argyll back to the Travelling People
Signatures
1
Comments
127
Considered
4 meetings
What it asks
Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to direct Historic Scotland to investigate what action can be taken to ensure the restoration and preservation of the Heart of Quartz stones positioned in a field next to the A815, opposite the junction of the B839, overlooking Loch Fyne, known as the Gypsy Wedding Place, referred to locally as the Tinkers’ Heart.
What the petitioner did first
Early failed attempts to have the area restored by writing to local councillors, Loch Fyne ‘Here we are’ group from Cairndow, land owners and associates led to me approaching Michael Russell MSP. Mr Russell has been extremely helpful and ‘hands on’ in this matter. He has written to various bodies. He has met with the Landowner, councillors, Historic Scotland, written to Fiona Hyslop and several groups to resolve this matter without success.
I did receive encouragement when Archaeology Scotland, through their ‘Adopt A Monument’ scheme, offered to help but although a representative and I have met on several occasions (Phil Richardson) nothing has materialised.
RCAHMS were more forthcoming by photographing the area and recording its position. However, this simply dictates its location. The landowner has the final say. Kate Howe (landowner) lives in England and has mostly been negative in her views regarding the culture of the people that the Tinkers’ Heart represents.
I wrote and sent all relevant info to the present Duke of Argyll, who also lives in the south of England, but he refuses to help on the grounds of his friendship with Ms Howe.
Mrs Howe and her associates have not answered my emails but they have conversed with Michael Russell MSP
- but only to voice their views on the cultural significance in a negative manner.
In June 28th 2013 I met with Mike Russell MSP, Councillor Louise Glen-Lee, a rep from Visit Scotland and Historic Scotland at A&B council offices at Kilmory, Lochgilphead but once again no positive outcome.
The Rep from Visit Scotland queried how his organisation would benefit from supporting the project. I told him the area was not about tourism but about an entire culture that had been overlooked for centuries and that the Tinkers’ Heart was all they had as a marker of their ancestors. I did add that many of the Diaspora came from these humble beginnings and would be more than satisfied to see their culture protected by law.
The Historic Scotland rep said they would not go against the wishes of the landowner.
Time and events march on without a positive outcome therefore I have been left with no choice but to raise awareness through petitioning which I hope shall reach a wider audience and allow me to gauge how the public respond to such a request.
I did receive encouragement when Archaeology Scotland, through their ‘Adopt A Monument’ scheme, offered to help but although a representative and I have met on several occasions (Phil Richardson) nothing has materialised.
RCAHMS were more forthcoming by photographing the area and recording its position. However, this simply dictates its location. The landowner has the final say. Kate Howe (landowner) lives in England and has mostly been negative in her views regarding the culture of the people that the Tinkers’ Heart represents.
I wrote and sent all relevant info to the present Duke of Argyll, who also lives in the south of England, but he refuses to help on the grounds of his friendship with Ms Howe.
Mrs Howe and her associates have not answered my emails but they have conversed with Michael Russell MSP
- but only to voice their views on the cultural significance in a negative manner.
In June 28th 2013 I met with Mike Russell MSP, Councillor Louise Glen-Lee, a rep from Visit Scotland and Historic Scotland at A&B council offices at Kilmory, Lochgilphead but once again no positive outcome.
The Rep from Visit Scotland queried how his organisation would benefit from supporting the project. I told him the area was not about tourism but about an entire culture that had been overlooked for centuries and that the Tinkers’ Heart was all they had as a marker of their ancestors. I did add that many of the Diaspora came from these humble beginnings and would be more than satisfied to see their culture protected by law.
The Historic Scotland rep said they would not go against the wishes of the landowner.
Time and events march on without a positive outcome therefore I have been left with no choice but to raise awareness through petitioning which I hope shall reach a wider audience and allow me to gauge how the public respond to such a request.
Where it was considered
Official Report-
30 Sep 20141 mention
-
9 Dec 20141 mention
-
17 Feb 20151 mention
-
7 Sep 20151 mention
Signatures by country
1,179 online signaturesComments
127 comments, oldest first127 comments · showing 51–100
-
Isabella Mcgiff 28 Apr 2014Makes me angry that historical sites even have to prove their rights . Where is the intelligence in destroying such a landmark and why would anybody benefit !! If it's not enough trying to end the travelling ways and their culture but also their history too !!!! Are you's for real !!!!
-
Sandra Macaskill 28 Apr 2014All the best !
-
agnes townsley 28 Apr 2014Hope all works out xxx
-
Gina McGregor 28 Apr 2014I'm a Scottish traveller n proud I cond off a great line a them off my granny's side wee have the Stewarts n the Mackenzie's n Stewarts again n my papas side there is the McGregors the Townsley's n the Reid's......I'm proud a my rotes x
-
jess smith 28 Apr 2014We are so encouraged by all your comments, taking the time to sign the petition and helping others understand the heart of the Travelling people. Your support gives this petition a powerful spine and we cannot thanks you all enough xx
-
Reagh Campbell Stewart 28 Apr 2014Too much of our history is being lost in the name of progress.
-
Cameron Murray 28 Apr 2014This is an important site for many reasons, it needs saved, valued and its message taught to children so it's importance is passed on. There is a very important message here.
-
susan maxwell 28 Apr 2014The Tinkers Heart is an iconic relic.This structure should be preserved in as close a form as it was in the old photo, with a simple interpretive sign, and access gate through the railing. It would be good if cattle were excluded from the area and the original road layout was reinstated, to restore the ambience of the scene.
-
Liz Parkhurst 28 Apr 2014This is a piece of history. It means so much to the Travelling People
- remember we are all children of the Earth, and must all stand by each other. Please help save it. -
Suzie Doncaster 28 Apr 2014I sign this from respect for the Scottish Travellers I have been privileged to know and so that their ancient traditions will not be lost- to lose Traveller traditions diminishes us all- Traveller and non-Traveller alike.
-
Graeme Purves 29 Apr 2014Having gypsy ancestry, I am keen to see greater recognition of and protection for Scotland's gypsy and tinker heritage.
-
Nuno Sacramento 29 Apr 2014We need to shift our emphasis from econometrics, to culture, social justice and the environment. This is a prime example of the importance of a site, to one of the cultures that form Scotland. It shows the cultural and historical importance of a site, in the hands of a single landlord. We need to proceed with caution, and should this be confirmed by travelling community and Historic Scotland to be an ancient monument, it ought to be legally and phisically protected as a matter of urgency.
-
Pove 29 Apr 2014All historic places in Scotland should be preserved for future generations, regardless of culture. This site should be enhanced to include more information on the people who deem it to be sacred.
-
mel hamilton 29 Apr 2014I grew up in Perthshire alongside the tinkers and this is a beautiful and important monument to their, and so our, culture.
-
Nigel Alderson 29 Apr 2014I wish you luck. Too much of our history was been lost due to greed and shortsightedness.
-
Lucie Howard 29 Apr 2014The 'Tinkers Heart' is an important site both culturally and historically, and should be conserved to represent the past, present and future of the travelling folk in Scotland.
-
John Richardson 30 Apr 2014All Scots should be recognized regardless how the past treated and saw them
-
Katina Brooks 30 Apr 2014I BELEIVE this is a pure and wonderful place take into your thoughts for a moment if you will for you to distroy this would be an unholy act this is a place that is secret in Gods eye a beautiful joining of two lives becoming one I mean think about it would you like this done to you I think not !! We eat breath and bleed just like you we are no different God made us special was it not a gypsy women that took a spike for It not to be driven into Jesus we ask you for nothing we make a way that is us because of you people never wanting to look at yourselves and your problems instead you make others Huey cry and bleed so you and your problems don't make you look how you truly are in front of others please please I beg you let my people keep their small peice of land you have so much be Godly and hold you hand out in Jesus name I ask this of you . God bless and be well .
-
Jennifer stewart 30 Apr 2014Its my heritage please keep it
-
Yvonne 30 Apr 2014Hope someday to visit this place x
-
GMarcus 30 Apr 2014Many cultures throughout the world and through the centuries have had sacred places and their accompanying stories marked, to be memorialised for future generations. As Scotland fights for its independence this year, it would be but a small yet inspiring gesture for Tinkers' Heart to be officially recognised and preserved as part of the rich history of Scotland and her Travelling peoples. Don't bury the Heart, preserve it!
-
liz 30 Apr 2014never knew about this, hopefully will go with my sister to visit it this year
-
antonia baird 30 Apr 2014I have heard about this heart my whole life as an argyll woman
- I would want it to be preserved. -
John Lawson 1 May 2014I'm studying my ancestry and would like to see this and many other historical sites remain for future generations
-
Marc R Sherland 1 May 2014All cultures have a heartland which provides a focus for their community, sometimes in paper, or stone or precious metal. Give the travelling people back their heart, its only a tiny bit of land of which they are the natural stewards..
-
gavin mcgregor 1 May 2014hi folks a we note on the tinkers heart.
there no promises no guaranteed not here to talk with a politician jargon not here to thank you for doing this its because you want to do this and we have a past and this is what has come out of our past this is a historical avent that we are all witnessing that has never happened before it mite not make your life better but by being united in a common understanding with what is the right thing to do and if that means the right thing to do is by saving one square yard of ground for future generations so be it just to say we were not a myth we where here and we did not go quietly.GAVIN -
Twiligha MacMahon 1 May 2014I just signed the petition for the " Tinkers Heart of Argyll back to the Travelling People"" and I pray the Lady Laird of this land will approve if needed. For this is a sacred site for travelers who seeked comfort, rest, and peace. It will be celebrated again for all births and weddings, and a place of rest for all those who needed refuge without judgement. The Heart of Argyll belongs to the Tinkers.
-
Vary Ferguson 1 May 2014Its their culture,please give it back,i have read all Jess Smiths books,which I have enjoyed,
-
John Muir 2 May 2014I think it pathetic that Scottish and English landowners alike, along with some Scottish organizations cannot support this campaign by Jess Smith to preserve a memorial for a race of people who were a part of society free born like all others and since time immemorial provided a service for Scotland whether farm work, tin smiths & etc or fighting and dying for King and Country. Also never awarded any recognition whatsoever down through the ages and in this 21st century when most of the above mentioned were likely as not around when the tinkers were actively going about their business all over Scotland. Judgement never the less seems to have been passed by negative action. Those in power should hang their heads in shame.
-
douglas 2 May 2014the heart belongs to our people it's been there for years it should be left a lone we have a wright as we are more part of Scotland through history and culture
-
Hamish MacGregor 3 May 2014We have been stript of everything in life by landowners. let us keep our heart.
-
Marylyn Scott 3 May 2014Tinker's Heart is a monument worth honoring. My father was born in Scotland, so my heart has pathways there and here in America. Please acknowledge and help secure Tinker's Heart by making it one of Scotland's Monument. Thank you.
-
Meredith Harley Inserra 4 May 2014I sign to honor my Traveller friends, tradition bearers of Scotland, who taught me so much.
-
Alex mackenzie 4 May 2014Good luck with the petition
-
Alexander Miles 5 May 2014"They erected three posts and wire. This was damaged. There are now cattle feeding and tramping on the Heart, leading to its destruction."
This detail from the "background information" is incorrect or, at best, very outdated. The current site is safely preserved behind a cattle-proof fence. Cattle are not walking on the heart and it is not being damaged. The heart is a well-loved local monument and is in no danger of destruction. -
Anne Jarvis 6 May 2014SNH is neglectful in its role. This site is of national importance to the Travelling People. Are they not a community?
-
Cathy Low 6 May 2014There are so many historic and listed buildings in Scotland, and that is a good thing. However, the Tinker's heart is more significant than any grand castle or stately home. Just as the great wealth of music, song and story that the Tinkers' held in their hearts and memories with no need for libraries or great literary tomes, the heart tykes up a small space, yet is deeply significant and special, pulling people in towards it. Not only is this an important site for Tinkers, but it is also (whether we are aware of it or not), perhaps a very special place for the whole of Scotland. Indeed, the world needs more Tinker's hearts! Please protect this one.
-
Joanna Gregson 6 May 2014The costs of the work required to protect the Heart will be far outweighed by the social value of protecting an historical monument of great importance to Scotland's Travelling people.
-
Donna 6 May 2014I hope and pray that the right thing is done here.
-
Ian MacGregor 7 May 2014We have been persecuted all our lives.and stripped of everything even our dignaty dont strip us of our heart.Please let it beat on.
-
hamish 7 May 2014The Duke of Argyll says "NO" ! Draw your own conclusions.
-
Eleanor O Riordan 7 May 2014Please support this cause. The settled community own this to the travellers
-
Timothy Mucklow 7 May 2014It's the little sticks and stones, the words from the past and the amazing pride and history of the Scottish people that make Scotland the country it is.
I join all others who care, to implore the Scottish Government to find the resources necessary to resolve this problem. -
Bonnie MacGregor 7 May 2014All over the world ethnic groups who had been robbed of their sacred sites, have now had their sacred sites restored to them, the Aborigines of Australia, the Maoris or New Zealand, Native Americans
- where is Scotland going to stand in this hour. Shall she be a nation that recognises all that have given her a special uniqueness and stand with the nations that have been willing to acknowledge both Equality and Diversity for all, or shall Scotland remain in the darkness afraid to release her true potential by allowing commercial interests to destroy true heritage. -
fiona macdonald 7 May 2014it is one small pile of stones in the middle of the road, it is not a enormous metalic eyesore like some of the monuments i see around clackmannonshire,on every round about in alloa there is a gigantic metal catastrophe of some sort, and they have no reference to scotland or the scottish people, yet the council paid around £30.000 each for these which are soposed to be art!, i beg to differ. surely if they can raise the funds for those statues in clackmannonshire, they can sort out this memorial for the Travelling people which in my eyes is far more significant than semi naked figures on round abouts
-
Ailsa 8 May 2014For beside the heart, the soul can flourish.
-
Bob Lovell 8 May 2014Please save this tan for the Travelling people .
We have been around for many hundreds of years and deserve the same respect for what we hold dear as all other ethnic peoples , Bokt , -
Cristina Morrison 8 May 2014The tinker's heart... The gypsy wedding place... Would be such a shame to lose such a strong part of the traveller's heritage. It's just a restoration programme, they won't be setting up camp!
-
Charlie Menzies. 9 May 2014This site is sacred to me and my deceased parents and my children, more important than any others in the country. Please preserve it.
-
Hugh Cameron-White 9 May 2014John McCorkindale the Lochgoilhead minister from 1875
- 1915 used to up to the heart and conduct weddings etc.
My family are from the area and I know this for sure.