Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01511 · Session 4

Inverness Fire Service Control Room

Closed Submitted 31 Jan 2014 Justice
Signatures
0
830 online signatures with a country
Comments
120
Considered
16 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to review the decision made by the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service to close the Inverness Control Room.

What the petitioner did first

As there was no previous public consultations, the communities of the Highlands and Islands were never able to take any postive actions to help save the Inverness Fire Service Control Room/Centre.
I have also taken the opportunity to make the Justice Committee aware of both the facts that we wish to take this to petition and that there is a large FaceBook Campaign.
I have also contacted Local MSPs and Highland Counsellors.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 22 Apr 2014
    1 mention
  2. 3 Jun 2014
    Public Petitions Committee
    Current Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 24 Jun 2014
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  4. 4 Nov 2014
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  5. 3 Feb 2015
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  6. 21 Apr 2015
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  7. 22 Sep 2015
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  8. 29 Sep 2015
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  9. 5 Jan 2016
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    5 mentions
  10. 23 Feb 2016
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  11. 27 Sep 2016
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  12. 24 Jan 2017
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  13. 2 May 2017
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  14. 5 Sep 2017
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    2 mentions
  15. 19 Dec 2017
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    3 mentions
  16. 27 Mar 2018
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

830 online signatures
  1. Scotland701 84.5%
  2. United Kingdom100 12%
  3. England11 1.3%
  4. New Zealand3 0.4%
  5. Canada2 0.2%
  6. Wales2 0.2%
  7. Ireland2 0.2%
  8. Northern Ireland2 0.2%
  9. Spain2 0.2%
  10. Qatar1 0.1%
  11. 4 other countries4 0.5%

Comments

120 comments, oldest first
120 comments · showing 51–100
  1. Linnie quail 18 Feb 2014
    Signed
  2. Pamela Burns 18 Feb 2014
    Having working knowledge of communicating with automated or central call centres I witness the problems with locality on a daily basis...not life threatening but a constant reminder as to the importance of trained local emergency response teams with a sound knowledge of the area the serve.
  3. Martin Mackenna 18 Feb 2014
    Please don't take this valuable resource & mobilising location away from the highlands.
  4. Pierre Veuger, station commander ret. 18 Feb 2014
    Do not loose local people in the control room. Real locals know a lot about local specialities, like nicknames for areas, names of farms etc.
    This is lost with large areas-controlrooms.
  5. Michael Bryant 18 Feb 2014
    Local knowledge is vital, this comes from our control room staff. They understanding the different dialects, they have knowledge and understanding of the Highlands and its single track roads, and they know the Highland areas, many with similar place names but miles apart. They manage incidents, they do not just answer calls!
  6. Brian young 18 Feb 2014
    Local knowledge is a great benefit to the control rooms , don't take that away , lives will be at risk
  7. Brian Spence 18 Feb 2014
    Not in the best interests for the highlands
  8. Mike Renwick 18 Feb 2014
    As a currently serving Firefighter in Dingwall and the surrounding area, I feel very strongly, and know, that this really is a backward step. Anyway sensible person can surely realise that reducing Fire control rooms by any measure is increasing the risk to the public.
  9. Lesley Matheson 18 Feb 2014
    Who will have to die as a result of the local knowledge being lost in the closure of this control room? We must keep it open, it's so very very wrong to let it slip away without fighting.
  10. Hilary Johnston 18 Feb 2014
    Signed in support for Inverness even though I stay in Dumfries. I have family in Inverness therefore I would like to think that should any of my relations should need the Emeegency services thatvtye person in the end of the phone would have local knowledge to be able to assist them quickly and safely.
  11. irene williamson 18 Feb 2014
    we need to keep the local knowledge built up over years.
  12. Terri Fleming 18 Feb 2014
    Shared & signed
  13. Jackie McCabe 18 Feb 2014
    I cannot believe computer's would replace human beings responding to what would be a frightening and dangerous time.. shocking
  14. jack bryant 18 Feb 2014
    See sense and keep the station, inverness is growing constantly! It needs the control room!
  15. James petrie 18 Feb 2014
    Save this lifeline service!!
  16. Mervyn walker 18 Feb 2014
    Local knowledge is a great asset
  17. Alistair Panton 18 Feb 2014
    Good luck
  18. Malcolm Hannah 18 Feb 2014
    Please members of the public you have to support this before we see loss of life.Support the control room in the Highlands
  19. Gary Anderson 18 Feb 2014
    Save the backbone of the Highlands and Islands fire service and the now Scottish fire service.
  20. Christina Maclellan 18 Feb 2014
    Please please please Do not close the Inverness Fire control Room.They know all the area names and the geographical area,other control rooms Don't and therefore will not respond as fast to send to sending out fire crews resulting in the loss of lives in our areas.Please please think again and DO NOT CLOSE INVERNESS FIRE CONTROL ROOM !
  21. Lynda Rowan-O'Neill 19 Feb 2014
    Signed and shared
  22. chris casely 19 Feb 2014
    Too much local knowledge will be lost for the Highlands.
  23. Paul Dunnett 19 Feb 2014
    I am a local taxi driver and know how much local knowledge can make a difference to how long journeys would take and how many places with similar names need local knowledge to determine
  24. Susan Mitchell 19 Feb 2014
    Very dangerous, it is essential. Would be a terrible thing if someone died because of it.
  25. neil mutch 19 Feb 2014
    cant believe this can happen for the sake of common sense this control room has to stay
  26. John Smith 19 Feb 2014
    As a former firefighter, and resident of the Highlands, I understand the importance of local knowledge and local controllers in responding to an emergency. I urge parliament to reject the proposal to close ANY of the fire control centres in Scotland, and to make every effort to protect and preserve life and property in our communities.
  27. Mairi Dingwall 19 Feb 2014
    Signed and shared
  28. myra brown 19 Feb 2014
    we need it
  29. jan mackenzie 19 Feb 2014
    Signed
  30. Paul Dinneen 19 Feb 2014
    Save the Inverness Control Room
  31. Darren muir 19 Feb 2014
    Orkney
  32. Niall inglis 19 Feb 2014
    As an ex retained fire fighter on the isle of skye the information Inverness control room provided us with was vital and I do not believe it would be in the best interests of any resident in the Highlands and Islands for the control room to be closed. As previously been stated, a computer cannot replicate local knowledge!
  33. Jimmy Geddes 19 Feb 2014
    A bheil gaelic agaibh, is some controller down south going to understand this question? Lives are going to be lost!
  34. Fraser Taylor 19 Feb 2014
    There is life after perth
  35. Angela Gunn 19 Feb 2014
    Save Inverness Control Room !!
  36. Melanie Hillin 19 Feb 2014
    It's should remain open for the safety of inverness and surrounding areas.
  37. Julie Wood 19 Feb 2014
    I so hope this petition works. The emergency services are getting shafted so much I know as I am in the Police and the cuts we have suffered are intolerable.
  38. Tony McDowell 19 Feb 2014
    Please save this highland asset, it is much needed and not replaceable by control room in the Central belt.
  39. Linda McDermott 19 Feb 2014
    Local knowledge by a local Control Room to serve the local community... This information cannot be just handed over it is gained over years
  40. Chris New 19 Feb 2014
    I am a fire fighter with 30 years experience and have been a New Zealand Chief Fire Officer for 12 years.
    Here in NZ we did what is happening in Scotland and I have found the centralised controllers do not have a good sense for the geography of distant areas. We also have communication problems with tourists an new New Zealanders. Over all I don't think it is a great idea to centralise just to save money. You must think of the people you serve
  41. Jacqui Hume 19 Feb 2014
    Local knowledge is significant even more so in this geographical area. Keep the control room and don't put lives at risk.
  42. Jane MacLean 19 Feb 2014
    There were problems before when the local control rooms were centralised to Inverness. What chance have the Highlands got without 'local' knowledge ?
  43. Karin Thompson 19 Feb 2014
    Local knowledge will save lives.
  44. Allan Young 19 Feb 2014
    All through Fire Reform we have heard about the decentralisation of the Fire and Rescue Service. Surely moving all Control Rooms to the Central belt is centralisation. If the decision was made comparing apples with apples then that would be more acceptable however this would appear to be a decision based on the desires of individuals and not common sense nor indeed for the outcomes for rural communities. It would appear the decision making process is flawed, not in the best interests of providing an effective Fire and Rescue Service to the WHOLE of Scotland and really does need to be reviewed. If Mr Salmond is serious about independence he needs to start taking the Highlands and Islands seriously as they also have a vote.
  45. Dawn Forrest 19 Feb 2014
    Those that think local knowledge is no longer needed due to advances in technology are making a huge mistake. I do this job for a living in a control room that was made up of 5 smaller ones several years ago and It is commonplace for personnel use their knowledge of their respective home towns to gain accurate incident location details. Don't leave the North without this local knowledge.
  46. sandy gray 19 Feb 2014
    Local knowledge is paramount to quick response and in turn will save life and property. This is just another Scottish Government notion to centralise all public bodies.
  47. Elizabeth Irvine 19 Feb 2014
    With the duplication of many Highland and Island names and all the Gaelic names, local knowledge is a key factor in ensuring accurate deployment.
  48. Juliet Johnston 19 Feb 2014
    We need the control room here in the highlands local know age is so important
  49. janine brown 19 Feb 2014
    Please save Inverness fire police and ambulance control rooms thank you
  50. Miriam MacDonald 19 Feb 2014
    No other part of the country can possibly understand the geographical impact on our service.