Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01498 · Session 4

Religious Representatives on Local Authority Education Committees

Closed Submitted 10 Oct 2013 People & Communities
Signatures
1
1,777 online signatures with a country
Comments
78
Considered
4 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to bring forward legislative proposals to repeal Section 124 of the Local Government (Scotland) Act 1973, as amended by Section 31 of the Local Government etc. (Scotland) Act 1994.
This would end the legal obligation on local authorities to appoint three unelected religious representatives to sit on their education committees.

What the petitioner did first

The action we call for requires a change in primary legislation at Scottish government level. This is not in the gift or power of local councils or other public bodies.
Nevertheless, we have publicised our concerns in this matter, and sought wider public support. ESS has received the following statements from elected members:
Patrick Harvie, MSP for Glasgow:
“In a society in which increasing numbers of people don’t practice any religion, it’s high time that we questioned a practice which gives religious hierarchies an influence over every child’s education. I’m particularly concerned at the involvement of people who would promote utterly unscientific notions like creationism; pushing this absurd ideology at children is the very opposite of education.”
Sandy Howat, City of Edinburgh Councillor:
“Unelected, unaccountable and I would suggest untenable? Undemocratic influence over public education is fundamentally at odds with the principles of respect, equality and shared freedoms. All contributions to committee deliberations should be welcomed, yet continued undemocratic privilege of the few over the many is an outdated tradition we should remove. As we look to create a fairer Scotland with liberty at its core, we need to ask ourselves what this ‘privilege’ says about our values; it’s time for a new enlightenment.”
Bailie Dr Nina Baker, Glasgow City councillor:
“Whilst I can see that representatives of major world faiths might have a role in advising on curriculum content for the teaching of comparative religion in schools, I believe they should have no right to vote on councils’ decision-making bodies. Those votes should be reserved for accountable, elected members only. A recent contribution from the Roman Catholic representative on Glasgow’s executive was to make clear his church could never accept the principle and practice of shared-campus schools, a policy with full cross-party support.”
Further information is available via the Edinburgh Secular Society website. See link below:
http://edinburghsecularsociety.com/2013/07/17/edinburgh-secular-society-exposes-religious-interference-in-the-heart-of-local-democracy/

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 14 Jan 2014
    1 mention
  2. 18 Mar 2014
    Public Petitions Committee
    Current Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 6 May 2014
    1 mention
  4. 2 Feb 2017
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

1,777 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,145 64.4%
  2. United Kingdom317 17.8%
  3. England189 10.6%
  4. United States35 2%
  5. Northern Ireland12 0.7%
  6. Wales11 0.6%
  7. Ireland9 0.5%
  8. Australia7 0.4%
  9. Sweden6 0.3%
  10. Canada5 0.3%
  11. 28 other countries41 2.3%

Comments

78 comments, oldest first
78 comments · showing 51–78
  1. kevin 17 Oct 2013
    i see no reason religious representatives should have to stand for election like everyone else.
  2. David Miller 17 Oct 2013
    School-based indoctrination of children is one of the strongest reasons (I do mean *reasons*) for being against organised religions. Let the children alone
    - make your own mind up when you are an adult.
  3. Ruth Lawson 17 Oct 2013
    I am happy for elected officials, teachers and members of parent councils to vote on school policy decision making irrespective of their religious beliefs but to allow unelected officials the same rights simply because they espouse predominantly Christian beliefs is profoundly undemocratic in our multicultural society. I oppose Creationism in the classroom and in particular, the science classrooms. I am also extremely concerned at the lack of clear directives for the screening of chaplains in our state run schools. I have sought information on this from local authorities and my childrens' school and have found that screening is not evident. It would seem that the only criteria which determines whether chaplains are accepted into the school is the geographical proximity to the school. I am also extremely concerned that non-religious viewpoints are not considered important in state school education. I also recognise that as a parent I have a right to opt my children out of religious observance but most parents are not fully aware of their rights and when they are made aware of them are fearful of 'rocking the boat.' Whether this fear is real or a perception is irrelevant as it serves to undermine non-religious peoples and they are oftentimes viewed as anti-authoritarian, difficult and as nuisances. I resent the implication that any decision to opt-out of religious observance places me in this regard and agree that the fairest solution is to remove religious observance from non-denominational schools.
  4. Andy Gaffney 17 Oct 2013
    There should be no privileged positions unless every educational subject has a privileged position.
  5. Paul Starmore 18 Oct 2013
    this should have been abolished years ago
  6. Elizabeth Lewis 18 Oct 2013
    The sooner we get past these repressive and narrow minded ideologies, the better for Scotland as a modern nation.
  7. Daphne McCulloch 18 Oct 2013
    Religious beliefs are personal, cultural and family choices. Children in public education should be protected from religious bias. Avoiding legislative advantage in the appointment of representatives of one or more religious group is the first essential step in ensuring the freedom of choice for children and families.
  8. Norman Ogilvie 20 Oct 2013
    Religious teaching should not be part of the school curriculum until secondary level and even then should be optional.
  9. Mrs Anne McGregor 20 Oct 2013
    Please note that this petition email came in as SPAM. almost missed it
  10. Billy 20 Oct 2013
    Places on the panel should be given on the basis of ability and election
  11. John Wiltshire 20 Oct 2013
    Logic demands that, since truth cannot contradict truth, any government that promotes multiple, incompatible religious faiths must therefore be promoting falsehood.
  12. Gerry Moran 20 Oct 2013
    This is outrageous. There should be no religious instruction or observation n schools. Our children deserve better and should be taught facts, not have their heads filled with religious nonsense based on myths and superstition.
  13. Maria 21 Oct 2013
    Illogical and undemocratic, not even based on experience and merit.
  14. John Thomas 22 Oct 2013
    Religious organisations should have no special privileges any more than any other organisation. If they seek representation at local authority or parliament level, they should work with representatives who share their views, or put up candidates for election, the same as anybody else.
  15. Roger Nicholls 25 Oct 2013
    Why is Scotland still in the Middle Ages?
  16. David 25 Oct 2013
    What possible justification can there be -other than assumed privilege-, for there to be unelected representatives advising and deciding on such important matters as PUBLIC education?
  17. Sandy Edwards 26 Oct 2013
    Why not call religious education Philosophy?
    This would be inclusive to all life stances.
    As for assemblies, they should surely be celebrating the community of the school.
  18. Ian 28 Oct 2013
    If you think about it religion in one form or another has probably caused more conflicts in this world than any other cause.
  19. Trevor William Stone 29 Oct 2013
    A representative must by definition be representative of the whole community, not a highly opinionated section of it. That is why we have elections. That is what makes us a democracy. That is why intelligent, honourable people defend democracy throughout the world.
  20. Leslie Mitchell 7 Nov 2013
    This is a much needed sweeping away of an outdated and undemocratic privilege.
  21. Catherine Joshi 7 Nov 2013
    Please do not give special privileges to those who profess religious beliefs. Scotland is a secular country. Put GOOD before God.
  22. Linda Britton 7 Nov 2013
    Equality, respect, tolerance, all needed to ensure our children grow up in a democracy
  23. Robert Canning 8 Nov 2013
    The problem with unelected church representatives sitting on education committees is not that they're church representatives. It is that they're unelected. If they want to sit on committees and have the desirable qualities they boast, they can present these in support of their election bids, like other candidates.
  24. Bill Bedborough 8 Nov 2013
    A welcome removal of an untenable anachronism
  25. James Forbes 17 Nov 2013
    As an elected member of the General Teaching Council for Scotland, I asked in March 2010 why churches should sit on the GTC. For asking such a reasonable question I was thereafter subjected to a smear campaign of hatred. It's time Scotland liberated itself from the non-elected in education.
  26. aynslie 22 Nov 2013
    very well
  27. Kieran Pringle 25 Nov 2013
    The 2011 census had 36.7% of people tick "no religion", making it the most common choice
    - ahead of the 32.4% of people that identified as Church of Scotland. Is it then fair to give CoS members privileged access to council positions? Positions that are NOT voted for by the public? If they are elected that is another matter, but they not. What about Scotland's population that hold other faiths? Is this not also unfair to them?
  28. Joel Haylock 25 Nov 2013
    A complete separation of state and religion can be the only reasonable way forward today. This is just one good move.