Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Local Authority Education Committees (Religious Representation) (PE1498)

Tuesday 14 January 2014 Public Petitions Committee About 10:30 Petitions 60 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

60 contributions
David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Good morning, ladies and gentlemen. I welcome you all to the Public Petitions Committee’s meeting. As always, I ask everyone to switch off their mobile devices, as they interfere with our sound system. We have apologies from Jackson Carlaw.Agenda item 1 is consideration of three new petitions. As previously agreed, the committee will take evidence on two of the petitions. The first new petition is PE1498, by Colin Emerson, on behalf of Edinburgh Secular Society, on religious representatives on local authority education committees. Members have a note by the clerk, the Scottish Parliament information centre briefing, the petition and a submission from the petitioner.I welcome to the meeting the petitioner, Colin Emerson—thank you for coming along—and Norman Bonney, who is the honorary president of Edinburgh Secular Society. I invite Mr Emerson to make a short presentation of about five minutes to set the context, after which we will move to questions. If Mr Bonney wants to contribute, I ask him to catch my eye. We would be happy to involve him in our proceedings.

Colin Emerson Edinburgh Secular Society
link

Good morning, everyone. I thank the convener and committee members for the invitation to attend the meeting and for the opportunity that it gives us to describe our petition in more detail and answer questions about it.It is relevant to state that Edinburgh Secular Society very much supports the concept of a Public Petitions Committee. It is a progressive means of allowing citizens and organisations to engage directly with the democratic process and potentially to influence policy or instigate new legislation. Crucially, it is the democratic principles of equality of access and the opportunity to influence by the quality of the argument and evidence that are presented, and not by virtue of privilege, that underpin the committee’s success.Our petition’s aim is to ensure that similar democratic principles are introduced in local authority education committees. We contend that the current statutory requirement for unelected and unaccountable religious representatives to be appointed, with full voting rights, to all 32 education committees in Scotland is undemocratic in principle and in practice.The current legislation privileges one religion—Christianity—and in particular two denominations within that religion: the Church of Scotland and the Roman Catholic faith. That clearly discriminates against those of minority faiths and those of no faith. Surely that is an untenable position, especially given the demographic changes that are occurring in Scotland, where 37 per cent of the general population are of no religion—that equates to just under 2 million Scots. The no religion figure is much higher—at 65 per cent—among under-24s, according to the British social attitudes survey 2012.Religious representatives have full voting rights, but unless voting rights come with the right to vote somebody off, democracy is undermined. Recent events in Fort William and Shetland highlight the undemocratic nature of such voting rights. In Highland Council, religious representatives’ votes overturned the elected coalition’s decision on the location for a new £4 million school in Fort William. In Shetland Islands Council, one religious representative refused to vote on a crucial school closure issue after being asked not to vote by other councillors. It is worrying that the Church of Scotland reported at its 2013 assembly that religious representatives hold the “balance of power” on 19 education committees.Evidence clearly shows that the churches use their religious representatives’ privileged position to promote their own agenda and interests.Action of Churches Together in Scotland, a group comprising all the main Christian churches, produced a policy or manifesto document entitled “A Christian Vision for Education in Scottish Schools”. The foreword to that document reads:“The members of the Scottish Churches’ Forum have agreed that the paper should be widely circulated. We believe that it will be a useful reminder to the politicians and public servants responsible for Scotland’s schools that the Scottish Churches have an abiding and significant interest in education and will be prepared to argue for policies which embody the principles expressed in ‘A Christian Vision for Education in Scottish Schools’.” We contend that the churches are quite entitled to produce a document and argue their point of view. However, for them to use their privileged position on education committees to promote their own aims would be fundamentally undemocratic—yet that is exactly what their intention is.A Church of Scotland document entitled “A Guide to Good Practice for Church of Scotland Education Representatives on Local Authority Education Committees” states, in section 1, that“it is important for church representation on local authority committees ... to ensure a respected presence ... This may be achieved by establishing good relationships”and“by exercising your statutory right and endeavouring to influence council education policies in areas of interest to the ... church, including the development of the curriculum”and “Christian values”. Section 16 asks:“If you sought to influence the recommendations in a report through one political group how might you approach them?”Finally, section 17 asks:“If you wanted to introduce a new policy how could you secure the support of the elected members for your ideas—quid pro quo?”It cannot be right that unelected representatives in a modern democracy can have such potential influence within local government without being accountable to anyone. That has to change.We do not believe that the status quo is an option and we would appeal to the churches to support our petition for legislative change. They can show vision and leadership by surrendering their statutory positions and accepting the changing demographics in Scotland. New legislation would not prevent religious nominees from being appointed by councils under other laws, if that is what councils chose to do, just as other external committee members can be appointed. Indeed, John Finnie MSP’s proposed member’s bill—the proposed local government accountability and transparency (Scotland) bill—would allow such appointments to be made but would also address the highlighted issues of unelected representatives’ voting rights and the statutory obligation on councils to appoint. Edinburgh Secular Society endorses the proposed bill and the democratic principles that lie behind it, and we would urge the churches to do likewise.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you, Mr Emerson, and thank you for your kind comments about the Public Petitions Committee.Let us assume, for argument’s sake, that your petition is successful and that religious representatives are taken off local authority education committees. What would be the benefits of that?

Colin Emerson Edinburgh Secular Society
link

First, it is a more democratic principle, and democracy in action would become transparent. However, as I mentioned, in relation to a number of issues religious representatives’ current practice is to seek to influence policy, and that is what they do, as I outlined in my quotations from the Church of Scotland’s guidelines for its representatives on how to exert influence. Behind the scenes, that privileged ability to influence policy would end and, crucially, the voting rights that I emphasised would also cease. I gave two clear examples, one concerning a school closure and the other on the location of a new school in Fort William: religious representatives would not be able to exercise such rights undemocratically. Finally, the point is that they hold the “balance of power”, to use the Church of Scotland’s own words, on 19 education committees in Scotland.

Norman Bonney Edinburgh Secular Society
link

One or two cases around the country are particularly troubling. When you think about it, it is really strange that, after 15 years of devolution and the Scottish Parliament, no systematic study—as far as I am aware—has been carried out of the role of such religious representatives on local authority education committees.Edinburgh Secular Society has compiled a list of the current incumbents of those positions. In the course of that work, we have discovered that in the Shetland Islands, for instance, the system seems to be creaking, to say the least. There has been controversy about whether religious members should be appointed, although Shetland Islands Council is legally obliged to appoint such members. The council has recommended that they should be appointed, but that they should not play their role. When I looked at the list of the members of the council’s education committee in late December, one religious appointee and two vacancies were listed, yet I read press reports that one religious representative—not the one who was listed, but another one—was refusing to cast a vote in a decision on the closure of a school. It is clear that in the Shetland Islands the system is creaking.I can identify difficulties in other areas. In Edinburgh, when the religious appointees were elected by the City of Edinburgh Council, it was necessary to go to a division on the third person. There was an ad hominem, hearsay debate about the qualities of the individuals concerned.An investigation of the details of how the current system is working raises fundamental questions about whether it is working in the right way. In the Shetland Islands, it is possible for representatives of the Shetland Churches Council Trust and for representatives of an interfaith organisation to be the religious representatives, but the law says that churches with charges and places of worship should send representatives to education committees. It seems to me that in the Shetland Islands, in particular, there are fundamental issues about whether the current system is working and whether the education committee in Shetland is making competent decisions, given the way in which it is composed.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Is there not an argument that religious representatives add value to debates in education committees across Scotland?

Norman Bonney Edinburgh Secular Society
link

Yes, I agree that they do. There is no doubt that many of them do, but the question is why those people should be in those positions on the basis of their religious confession. One member of each of the 29 mainland committees is nominated by the Roman Catholic Church, so those individuals are likely to be people who follow the orthodoxies of that church. There has to be a Church of Scotland representative on all 32 committees. There are clear doctrinal differences between those churches, so why should it be relevant to the appointment of committee members that they have different religious confessions? Although they may well be able to make positive contributions to the work of committees—I do not challenge that—if local authorities wanted contributions that were non-confessional, that could be achieved through open competition rather than through the appointment of people on a religious basis.

Colin Emerson Edinburgh Secular Society
link

The acid test is why, if that system holds merit democratically, religious reps are not appointed to the Parliament’s Education and Culture Committee. No one advocates that, because it would just not be acceptable for democratic reasons. It seems to me that the acid test is that, if the role had value, we would extend it to other committees, but no one advocates that.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

Good morning, gentlemen.I have some sympathy with any proposal that seeks to overcome a democratic deficit and to ensure fair representation, so if my questioning is a bit robust, that is simply to help me understand why you are here. Why are you here? Why have you picked this particular subject?

Colin Emerson Edinburgh Secular Society
link

Sorry?

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

You have picked the subject of a democratic deficit in relation to schools. What underlies your bringing the petition to Parliament?

Norman Bonney Edinburgh Secular Society
link

We are representatives of Edinburgh Secular Society, which is a voluntary body of concerned citizens that is unhappy with the way in which certain religious institutions—just a few among the many—are privileged in our society.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

Can you give me an example of where else, other than in relation to education, you are pursuing the overcoming of a democratic deficit?

Norman Bonney Edinburgh Secular Society
link

We are looking at the United Kingdom constitution and the whole independence debate. However, the substance of the petition that we are dealing with today is a very unusual, special privilege that is given to the Roman Catholic Church on the mainland and the Church of Scotland in all 32 local authorities to nominate individual members of local democratic education committees. It is an affront to democratic principles that those people have a role on those committees. As we have said, the Church of Scotland claims that it has held the “balance of power” in 19 of the 32 local authority education committees. What motivates us is a concern to have a more effective system of local democracy.10:45

Colin Emerson Edinburgh Secular Society
link

Our understanding is that in local government it is only in relation to education committees that there is a statutory requirement to appoint external members. Those committees therefore stand alone, and for democratic reasons that needs to be addressed.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

You mentioned that you have done checks on the individuals who have been appointed. How much analysis has been done of local membership of religions vis-à-vis local school rolls?

Norman Bonney Edinburgh Secular Society
link

Our capacity is rather limited, and that is the sort of thing that the Scottish Government ought to be investigating.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

You brought the petition, for which there must be a basis, so I ask the question again. You have checked up on the individuals concerned. Are you saying that you have not done any analysis of local membership of religions vis-à-vis local school rolls?

Norman Bonney Edinburgh Secular Society
link

There is a difficulty in attributing any particular religion to school pupils, who do not necessarily follow their parents’ religion. However, we can tell from local authority statistics that there is great variation in the percentage of the population who identify with the Roman Catholic Church, for example. Some parts of the mainland might have a small percentage of the population who are Roman Catholics, but they nonetheless get a representative on the local authority education committee. We also draw attention to Glasgow City Council, where, as I understand it, only two of the three religious nominees have been appointed. Given that we know that the most common name used in newly registered births in Glasgow is now Mohammed, the council might begin to think about how to fill that vacancy and whether someone of a Muslim denomination might be a representative on that committee.We do not have all the answers but we are raising major questions that require consideration. For too long, the issues have been swept under the carpet and it has been assumed that two particular religious denominations should have preferred membership of local authority education committees.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

As I said, I have some sympathy with the idea of securing full democratic provision at whatever level.Having reviewed individuals in 19 council areas, have you been able to establish what due diligence, if any, has been done in relation to those appointees?

Norman Bonney Edinburgh Secular Society
link

You will realise that the local authority is bound to accept the nominations from the hierarchy of the church of Rome and from the Church of Scotland. There are then arcane procedures for the appointment of the third representative, which require registered places of worship to be notified of the vacancy, usually by public advert. In 2012 in Edinburgh, it went to a ballot among the local authority elected members, who had to decide between two nominees. In many cases, it comes down to consulting the churches and so on.In my supplementary paper, I drew the committee’s attention to the fact that there are so-called interfaith representatives, although, as I read the legislation, the committees ought not to have interfaith representatives because the interfaith movement does not have places of worship.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

Given where I come from, this is difficult. I understand what you are trying to achieve; it is what it is based on that forces my questioning.Your initial written submission contains a section on specific issues relating to appointments by the “Church of Rome”. Did you do a similar thing on appointments by the Church of Scotland?

Norman Bonney Edinburgh Secular Society
link

My main point about the “Church of Rome” is that it is an international organisation, whereas the Church of Scotland is a national, Scottish organisation. I think that—

Norman Bonney Edinburgh Secular Society
link

I think that particular issues are raised in relation to the church of Rome, which is an international body that appoints senior members of the hierarchy in Scotland who, in turn, appoint members to local authority education committees. It is strange to me that a Parliament that, justifiably, welcomes its own autonomy and seeks to have much greater power in Scotland should assent to appointments to local authority education committees being made by the church of Rome, whose hierarchy is under the control and discipline of people who are based in the Vatican.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

Well, I think that I would spread my attentions much wider rather than just focusing on one particular element.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

I have some sympathy with the petition, having served on Falkirk Council’s education committee for a number of years. I recall occasions when I felt that church representatives failed to grasp the complexities of an issue on which they then voted. However, having said that, when I woke up this morning, I thought that I was still living in what is termed a Christian country, despite the drop in religious affiliation that you referred to earlier. I note that your petition says that the current set-up is“inherently undemocratic, unfair and discriminatory.”I cannot speak for the Government, but I would hazard a guess that it would not wish to exclude religious representation from education committees, given the church’s historical role in setting up a school in every parish in the country. With that in mind, would you find it acceptable to have the three church representatives on each education committee continued but with no voting rights?

Colin Emerson Edinburgh Secular Society
link

As a general principle we would not find it acceptable if that was to be a statutory requirement. It would be undemocratic. As we noted in our paper, the bill that is proposed by John Finnie acknowledges that issue. It would remove the statutory obligation and voting rights but would allow councils to continue to appoint people such as teachers and parents. If they chose to do so, they could also appoint external religious representative members.

Norman Bonney Edinburgh Secular Society
link

That would give councils choice, rather than their being obliged to accept nominations from two churches and one other. If those positions were done away with, local authorities would still have the power to appoint external members and could choose whether to include religious representatives and which it wanted.

Colin Emerson Edinburgh Secular Society
link

That would introduce an element of merit, because the council could judge the quality of the candidate.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

I see where you are coming from. Earlier, you talked about what you called“the arcane procedures for the appointment of the third representative”.If a local authority were minded to have as the third member a Muslim, surely that should be a decision for the local authority.

Norman Bonney Edinburgh Secular Society
link

I think that what happens in relation to that third position is that an advert is published and very often only one name comes forward, perhaps as the result of an informal agreement on the part of religious groups. In that circumstance, there is no contest, and the local authority accepts the person. If there is more than one name, the local authority has to decide which of the candidates will be the third representative, so there is choice. However, that is not always what happens. We suggest that, if we were to do away with the compulsory places, local authorities could still appoint religious representatives to their education committees, if they so wished.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

In your submission of 6 January, you refer to the estimate of the Church of Scotland that the three church representatives hold the “balance of power” on 19 local authority committees. I would like an analysis of how they hold the “balance of power” in those 19 local authorities. Local authorities have different numbers of elected members. I am not sure about this because I have not done an analysis of it, but in a local authority such as Glasgow City Council there might be 30 elected members on the education committee and three religious representatives, whereas Shetland Islands Council’s education committee might have fewer elected members on it. There might also be situations in which the three representatives hold the “balance of power” because they are of no political persuasion and are not affiliated to a political party. What is your understanding of the situation in the 19 local authorities in which the three religious representatives may hold the “balance of power”?

Norman Bonney Edinburgh Secular Society
link

We have not done a detailed study; we have merely quoted what the Church of Scotland itself has said. If the petition goes further, you might want to clarify with it what it means. However, it clearly claimed that the churches exercise influence. It is very worrying that they claim to have a controlling influence in the majority of Scotland’s local authority education committees.

Colin Emerson Edinburgh Secular Society
link

My understanding is that the situation is to do with the number of education committees that are made up of coalitions because no single political party has power, so the churches’ representatives hold the balance because they are not affiliated to a political party.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

Convener, that is what I am trying to get from the petitioners who are before us today. On the “balance of power” argument, I know that you have selectively quoted from the Church of Scotland’s document to identify that “balance of power” and how it is used to influence the decisions of local authorities. I know that in some local authorities the churches have certainly exerted undue influence over the local authority’s decisions—in particular, local authorities in which joint-campus education provision has been proposed and church representatives have, in effect, vetoed moves in that direction.I was interested in the earlier argument that used the example of Glasgow. You said that there were representatives from the “Church of Rome”, as the document described it, and the Church of Scotland; and I think that Mr Bonney said that, given some schools’ rolls, the third representative may be a Muslim representative. However, as recorded in the 2011 census results, the Muslim population of Scotland makes up only 1 per cent of the total population. Would it be fair to appoint to represent a particular religious group on an education committee someone who represents 1 per cent of the population?

Norman Bonney Edinburgh Secular Society
link

I cannot give you a precise figure for the proportion of Muslims in the Glasgow population, but the figure for Scotland as a whole is 4 per cent, if I remember correctly. The figure would be much higher in Glasgow.In some local authority areas the Roman Catholic population is only a few per cent, but they get representation on local authority education committees. That principle suggests, therefore, that if religious diversity is wanted on the education committee in Glasgow, the vacancy there ought to be filled by a Muslim representative. The question why a big city such as Glasgow should still have a vacancy for the third religious representative raises all sorts of issues.I hope that our comments have demonstrated to you that there are a number of difficulties in how the current system operates. I think that our solution is the cleanest by far.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I have every sympathy with your petition in terms of the way it has been presented, the arguments that have been presented here today and the supplementary paper. The situation is that in the 21st century we are using legislation that was drawn up in the 19th century that continues to influence decisions that local authorities make.How would you like to see the petition being taken forward? What is your ultimate goal? Is it to remove all religious representation from local authority education committees?

Norman Bonney Edinburgh Secular Society
link

Our petition is very clear. We are asking the Scottish Parliament to resolve to urge the Scottish Government to draw up legislative proposals that would, in effect, remove the current form of religious representation on education committees. The consequence would be that other laws would leave it open to local authorities to appoint religious representatives to education committees, if they wish to do so. The proposal would therefore give back power to local authorities.11:00

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

For clarification, is it the case that you and the Edinburgh Secular Society have no objection to the appointment of religious representatives to education committees of local authorities, if the authorities want that, and that you seek only repeal of the current legislation, in which there is a statutory obligation on local authorities to appoint religious representatives to education committees? Would you therefore be quite happy for local authorities to continue to appoint religious representatives if they deemed it to be necessary?

Norman Bonney Edinburgh Secular Society
link

That would be the effect of Parliament’s approving our petition and urging the Scottish Government to introduce legislation to do away with the requirement to have three religious representatives on education committees. As a result of other laws, each local authority could appoint external members to its education committee and could choose, if it so wished, to appoint religious representatives. They cannot do that at present.

Colin Emerson Edinburgh Secular Society
link

Those representatives should be without voting rights; we would be quite strong about that. It would be up to councils to justify—it would be in their gift to do so—how they selected and why they gave representation to some religious groups and not to other groups, whether they be humanists, pagans or whatever.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I am sorry to prolong the discussion, but I am simply seeking clarification about what you are trying to achieve. My understanding is that the petition seeks to remove the appointment of religious representatives to education committees and to change legislation that it is in the gift of the Scottish Government and the Scottish Parliament to change. However, what you are saying—what I am picking up; I will check the Official Report—is that you would be quite happy for local authorities to continue to appoint religious representatives to education committees if we were to change the legislation. Would that extend to local authority education committees being able to appoint more than three religious representatives? In Glasgow, for example, could religious representatives be appointed to the education committee to cover the wide spectrum of religious communities that operate and have members in Glasgow?

Colin Emerson Edinburgh Secular Society
link

The current legislation says that local authority committees can appoint external members in number only up to a third of the membership of committees. The exception is education committees, which can currently appoint up to 50 per cent external members, which is the part of the legislation that we are seeking to repeal. Education committees would then be in line with all other local authority committees on the one third to two thirds rule. There would be a limit to the extent to which councils could appoint religious nominees. That would also be up for debate and would shift the debate to local councils, because they would have to justify offering X external memberships. They currently must justify giving external membership to parents. Only 50 per cent of local authority education committees grant external membership to parents, I think, according to our analysis from last year. Of that 50 per cent, only 12 councils give those representatives voting rights, so there is already in-built flexibility and representation has to be justified council by council. The proposal would merely bring external membership on education committees into line with all other council committees.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

The petition raises a number of questions, but they are for a later date.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

We are a bit short of time, but there is still time for a very quick question from Chic Brodie and a quick response from the petitioners.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

I think that we are agreed that it is a nonsense that 85 years on from the original legislation this petition is before the committee today. Had the churches moved with the times and spread their message, their representation might have had more substance, but that is clearly not the case. If that is a message for the churches, so be it.I am concerned about legislation of this sort because our objective should always be to ensure that no rancour, criticism or critiquing continues after legislation is passed. This might seem like a silly question, but I am going to ask it anyway. Have you had any discussion with the two main churches about the lack of democracy in the current situation?

Colin Emerson Edinburgh Secular Society
link

Yes—I have had informal discussions with both.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

Will you share their reaction with us?

Colin Emerson Edinburgh Secular Society
link

One was quite adamant that the system should stay. The position that it presented was that instead of the situation being reversed, the statutory obligation being removed and the religious representatives lost, the number of religious representatives could be extended through, for example, seats being offered to humanists or A N Others. I should stress, however, that those discussions were private and informal.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

I understand and appreciate your sharing that information with us.

Norman Bonney Edinburgh Secular Society
link

Under the committee’s auspices, we are requesting that the churches consider supporting our petition and voluntarily relinquish religious posts in education committees.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you very much, gentlemen. I apologise for our having run out of time. Please stay where you are for a second. There will be no more questions, but we will have a summation of the situation and the whole committee will consider the next steps for the petition.My view is that we should continue the petition and seek further advice. As members know, the clerk has suggested that we seek advice from the Scottish Government, the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities and others. Clearly, it would be sensible to write to the churches that the petitioners have mentioned, so I suggest that we contact the Church of Scotland education committee and the Scottish Catholic education service. I seek members’ views on the matter.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

To achieve some equity and fairness, we should not only write to the Church of Scotland education committee and the Scottish Catholic education service but enjoin other faiths and organisations such as humanist organisations and what have you to provide us with their views.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

We should also seek the views of the Educational Institute of Scotland, given that it is directly involved in education. It is important that we gather the widest possible range of views on the petition and, following what Mr Brodie said, I suggest that we seek the views of the Scottish Interfaith Council and, particularly given the petitioners’ comments, the Muslim Council of Scotland.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you for that. Does the committee agree with the suggested course of action?Members indicated agreement.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

As the petitioners will have heard, the committee will go away and do some homework with these organisations. We will continue the petition, the clerks will keep you up to date with developments and we will discuss the matter at a future date when we have got all the information back.

Norman Bonney Edinburgh Secular Society
link

Can I suggest that the Equality and Human Rights Commission be consulted, as well?

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Do members agree with that suggestion?Members indicated agreement.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

With that, I thank Norman Bonney and Colin Emerson for coming along and giving evidence.11:09 Meeting suspended.

11:10 On resuming—

  1. 10:30 New Petitions Petitions · 60
  2. 10:30 New Petitions Petitions · 66
  3. 10:30 New Petitions Petitions · 13
  4. 10:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  5. 10:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 23

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.