The second petition is PE1498, which was lodged by Colin Emerson on behalf of Edinburgh Secular Society. It calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to bring forward legislative proposals to repeal section 124 of the Local Government (Scotland) Act 1973, as amended by section 31 of the Local Government etc (Scotland) Act 1994.Members will note the Scottish Government’s view, which is that it supports the involvement of religious representatives in councils’ decision-making process on education and does not have any plans to change the existing provisions.I am sure that members are aware of this, but I highlight for the record that a member’s bill proposal on the subject of the petition has been lodged by John Finnie MSP. Do members have views on what, if any, further action we wish to take on PE1498?
Official Report · Committee
Public Petitions
Local Authority Education Committees (Religious Representation) (PE1498)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Stewart Maxwell SNP 4
- Mary Scanlon Con 2
- Liam McArthur LD 1
- Colin Beattie SNP 1
The record
8 contributions
link
You have pointed in your introduction to the issue that I will raise. John Finnie has a member’s bill proposal under consultation and consideration. That seems to be the logical vehicle through which members across the parties can contribute to the debate and, ultimately, take a view on the matter. I am not sure what the committee could add, given that the petition urges the Scottish Government to bring forward a legislative proposal and there is a mechanism for doing that through John Finnie’s proposed member’s bill.
I feel that the information that I have in the committee papers is probably insufficient to make a decision. I have not had the opportunity to discuss the issue with my party group. I think that there would be a wide range of views within my party group; to be fair, in all parties there will be a wide range of views on the issue. The situation is historical—the provision is more than 100 years old.I would welcome the wider consultation that would be carried out for John Finnie’s proposed member’s bill and I would be very interested to hear a wider range of views. Rather than the committee jumping to a decision today on the back of what is, in my view, a lack of consultation and information, I would prefer to examine more thoroughly the evidence that comes from John Finnie. Should the proposals come forward in a member’s bill, there could be a free vote in my party, although I do not know whether that would be the case. These are the important issues that we have not had an opportunity to discuss.
link
For the second time, I agree with Mary Scanlon.
It is a strange day.
I am very grateful.
From my point of view, the proposal in the petition is an interesting one. Clearly, religious groups have a—I hesitate to use the word “privileged”—position on education committees in local government that is different from that of other groups. There are historical reasons why that is the case and we all understand that process.I tend to agree that if the member’s bill proposal by John Finnie progresses, it will provide a wide platform for detailed discussion and debate on the evidence for and against such a proposal. I think that that would be the best place to have the debate, rather than have the committee repeat what the Public Petitions Committee has already done. To urge the Scottish Government would achieve nothing, given that it has already expressed its view on the matter.I think that I have a feeling for members’ views. Are members content that we close the petition on the basis that we have just discussed, and that we write to the petitioners? I am sure that they are already aware of John Finnie’s member’s bill proposal. We can write to them and state that our belief is that that is the best place to have the debate and discussion on the proposal, and that that is why we have taken this decision. Are members agreed?Members indicated agreement.
Thank you. That concludes our business today.Meeting closed at 11:51.
In this meeting
Everything on 6 May 2014 →- 10:00 Historic Environment Scotland Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 123
- 10:00 Public Petitions Petitions · 20
- 10:00 Public Petitions Petitions · 8
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.