Petition · PE01491 · Session 4
Secret society membership declaration by decision makers.
Signatures
0
Comments
181
Considered
2 meetings
What it asks
Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to amend the law or codes of practice to make it compulsory for decision makers such as sheriffs, judges, and juries at their courts, arbiters, and all panel members of tribunals that are convened and held in Scotland and governed by devolved legislation, custom and practice, to declare if they have ever been members of organisations, such as the Masons, that demand fraternal preference to their brethren over non-brethren, or organisations which have constitutions or aims that are biased against any particular sect, religion or race.
That a register of such membership is held by the various bodies that supervise such judicial and quasi-judicial tribunals and that access to these registers is given on demand to the defendant, litigant, or plaintiff wishing to exercise their rights to a fair hearing in accordance with Article 6 of the ECHR.
That a register of such membership is held by the various bodies that supervise such judicial and quasi-judicial tribunals and that access to these registers is given on demand to the defendant, litigant, or plaintiff wishing to exercise their rights to a fair hearing in accordance with Article 6 of the ECHR.
What the petitioner did first
In 2000 I petitioned the Scottish Parliament with PE 306 which was in a similar vein to this petition. Then, after having been under consideration for over three years with the parliament the petition was dismissed without reason.
The Public Petitions Committee summary of the petition showed that the committee had closed the petition in December 2002 when in fact the terms of the petition were considered by the Justice 2 Committee on 04 March and the Public Petitions Committee on 18 March 2003. The latter anomaly has recently been corrected and the meeting of 04 March can be found here: http://archive.scottish.parliament.uk/business/committees/historic/justice1/mop-03/j2mop0304.htm
The meeting of the Justice 2 Committee, of 4th March, was not insignificant. The Justice Minister Jim Wallace was questioned by the committee on my submissions regarding membership of the Speculative Society of Edinburgh and the Masons among the judiciary. The Minister said he had not had time to read my submissions but he would do and revert to the committee. There is no record of this having happened.
Furthermore despite the fact that the committee had asked me to provide examples of cases where there was a perception that freemasonry had influenced a court or tribunal the committee did not publish the submissions I made in this regard.
I believe that this censorship was draconian given that details of own case, Stott v Minogue 2000 SLT (Sh Ct) 25, & GWD 36-1386,
- which spawned the petition – and the decision by the Social Security Commissioner, Ref: CS1/136/02. are in part matters of public record, or have been reported widely in the press and legal journals and are the two most important Scottish cases that deal with the influence of freemasonry in the justice system.
Having sought to determine my rights to challenge the existing law which allows non-disclosure of (secret) membership of fraternal organisations by decision makers by the courts, my elected representatives, and the previous government (which subverted the public petitions process), I am now attempting to resolve this anomaly with a new government, which claims to be open and accountable to the people of Scotland.
The Public Petitions Committee summary of the petition showed that the committee had closed the petition in December 2002 when in fact the terms of the petition were considered by the Justice 2 Committee on 04 March and the Public Petitions Committee on 18 March 2003. The latter anomaly has recently been corrected and the meeting of 04 March can be found here: http://archive.scottish.parliament.uk/business/committees/historic/justice1/mop-03/j2mop0304.htm
The meeting of the Justice 2 Committee, of 4th March, was not insignificant. The Justice Minister Jim Wallace was questioned by the committee on my submissions regarding membership of the Speculative Society of Edinburgh and the Masons among the judiciary. The Minister said he had not had time to read my submissions but he would do and revert to the committee. There is no record of this having happened.
Furthermore despite the fact that the committee had asked me to provide examples of cases where there was a perception that freemasonry had influenced a court or tribunal the committee did not publish the submissions I made in this regard.
I believe that this censorship was draconian given that details of own case, Stott v Minogue 2000 SLT (Sh Ct) 25, & GWD 36-1386,
- which spawned the petition – and the decision by the Social Security Commissioner, Ref: CS1/136/02. are in part matters of public record, or have been reported widely in the press and legal journals and are the two most important Scottish cases that deal with the influence of freemasonry in the justice system.
Having sought to determine my rights to challenge the existing law which allows non-disclosure of (secret) membership of fraternal organisations by decision makers by the courts, my elected representatives, and the previous government (which subverted the public petitions process), I am now attempting to resolve this anomaly with a new government, which claims to be open and accountable to the people of Scotland.
Where it was considered
Official Report-
12 Nov 20131 mention
-
28 Jan 20141 mention
Signatures by country
3,116 online signaturesComments
181 comments, oldest first181 comments · showing 151–181
-
Tom Minogue 18 Oct 2013Ken Wood, Wilhelm Anderson, Tony Bently, suggest you read the petition terms again or for the first time. Petition refers to societies such as the freemasons and have . SUCH AS. If other societies that you mention meet in secret, swear oaths in secret and demand fraternal preference to their brethren over non-brethren, or are organisations which have constitutions or aims that are biased against any particular sect, religion or race then of course they are included in the terms of this petition. Do the ones you name have these characteristics?
-
Anthony Brannan 18 Oct 2013Masons owe allegiance to their Order and fellow masons before anything else, so it's hardly surprising that people in positions of power and influence such as judges and police could be seriously conflicted and compromised when dealing with other masons in a professional capacity.
If they have nothing to hide then they have nothing to fear.
On the other hand.............. -
William curran 19 Oct 2013Long overdue. Well done.
-
Frank Boyd 19 Oct 2013I agree with the above petition and support it.
-
Marcus Mac Veigh 21 Oct 2013about time.
-
donny 21 Oct 2013Should have a compass and dividers tattoo on their foreheads
-
Tom Minogue 21 Oct 2013Donny, the sign is a compass and square and I don't think your comment adds anything to the reasonable tone of debate so far. Why the clerks have allowed it I do not know.
-
paul reynolds 21 Oct 2013Long overdue in my opinion, the obligtion to the society may have confliction in the duty obliged in this part of the justice system.
-
laurence reid 21 Oct 2013I would feel much more comfortable about voting for an independent Scotland if matters like this were more transparent.
-
Gerry McGhee 23 Oct 2013Why would they possibly want to hide anything , aye right .
-
R. Omozik 24 Oct 2013No one should benefit from secret societies
-
David Conway 24 Oct 2013If you have nothing to hide, then why hide?
-
Brian Williams 25 Oct 2013Secret societies should not operate within the judiciary
-
stephen higgins 25 Oct 2013if a judge had a personal interest in fox hunting, would they be assigned a case involving such a thing.
-
Ian Golden 25 Oct 2013All in the spirit of "Transparency" as they say in the establishment!
-
Dave Owen 26 Oct 2013Freemasons shoud be banned from any position in Public Office.
-
James Flynn 28 Oct 2013No Comment
-
P McKenna 28 Oct 2013My grandparents explained to me how if you were of a particular religion in Scotland it was harder or simply impossible to get particular jobs. Preference was given to people of other religions for no good reason. Many of the people responsible for this were members of secret or biased societies. I am certain, sadly, some of this still goes on today. Anything which can therefore make people in positions of power
- especially justice
- more transparent should be welcomed. -
Liam Welsh 28 Oct 2013No room for secret societies in this day and age. What good has come out of any secret?
-
Paul Cochrane 28 Oct 2013Any secret society should be declared.
-
Billy 28 Oct 2013No ban, just a declaration of conflict of interest
-
Robbie Pennington 28 Oct 2013Secret organisations have no place in the official mechanisms of a democracy.
-
Gavin Alexander 28 Oct 2013I don't know if members of any secret society are any worse than any other members of public office. However, in the interests of transparency, and to allow the population to have faith in these people, this is a good idea.
-
davie Hutchison 29 Oct 2013its about time something like this has come up,
-
alex laird 29 Oct 2013Clear and transparent
-
Alfred Nobile 29 Oct 2013All public figures should be seen to have no bias towards any particular grouping.
-
John Fitzpatrick 29 Oct 2013Transparency please
-
John Macfarlane 29 Oct 2013When someone has the power to take away someone liberty for a possible lifetime then we should be completely confident that everything is 100% above board. Nobody should be hiding anything. Ever.
-
Geordie Reid 29 Oct 2013This make the men in power sweat a little, wonder what the percentage is? No more discrimination!
-
Ryan Muldowney 29 Oct 2013Common Sense must prevail
-
Stuart Kennedy 29 Oct 2013Couldn't agree more! The men with such power should disclose any information that's deemed in the publics interest.