Petition · PE01491 · Session 4
Secret society membership declaration by decision makers.
Signatures
0
Comments
181
Considered
2 meetings
What it asks
Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to amend the law or codes of practice to make it compulsory for decision makers such as sheriffs, judges, and juries at their courts, arbiters, and all panel members of tribunals that are convened and held in Scotland and governed by devolved legislation, custom and practice, to declare if they have ever been members of organisations, such as the Masons, that demand fraternal preference to their brethren over non-brethren, or organisations which have constitutions or aims that are biased against any particular sect, religion or race.
That a register of such membership is held by the various bodies that supervise such judicial and quasi-judicial tribunals and that access to these registers is given on demand to the defendant, litigant, or plaintiff wishing to exercise their rights to a fair hearing in accordance with Article 6 of the ECHR.
That a register of such membership is held by the various bodies that supervise such judicial and quasi-judicial tribunals and that access to these registers is given on demand to the defendant, litigant, or plaintiff wishing to exercise their rights to a fair hearing in accordance with Article 6 of the ECHR.
What the petitioner did first
In 2000 I petitioned the Scottish Parliament with PE 306 which was in a similar vein to this petition. Then, after having been under consideration for over three years with the parliament the petition was dismissed without reason.
The Public Petitions Committee summary of the petition showed that the committee had closed the petition in December 2002 when in fact the terms of the petition were considered by the Justice 2 Committee on 04 March and the Public Petitions Committee on 18 March 2003. The latter anomaly has recently been corrected and the meeting of 04 March can be found here: http://archive.scottish.parliament.uk/business/committees/historic/justice1/mop-03/j2mop0304.htm
The meeting of the Justice 2 Committee, of 4th March, was not insignificant. The Justice Minister Jim Wallace was questioned by the committee on my submissions regarding membership of the Speculative Society of Edinburgh and the Masons among the judiciary. The Minister said he had not had time to read my submissions but he would do and revert to the committee. There is no record of this having happened.
Furthermore despite the fact that the committee had asked me to provide examples of cases where there was a perception that freemasonry had influenced a court or tribunal the committee did not publish the submissions I made in this regard.
I believe that this censorship was draconian given that details of own case, Stott v Minogue 2000 SLT (Sh Ct) 25, & GWD 36-1386,
- which spawned the petition – and the decision by the Social Security Commissioner, Ref: CS1/136/02. are in part matters of public record, or have been reported widely in the press and legal journals and are the two most important Scottish cases that deal with the influence of freemasonry in the justice system.
Having sought to determine my rights to challenge the existing law which allows non-disclosure of (secret) membership of fraternal organisations by decision makers by the courts, my elected representatives, and the previous government (which subverted the public petitions process), I am now attempting to resolve this anomaly with a new government, which claims to be open and accountable to the people of Scotland.
The Public Petitions Committee summary of the petition showed that the committee had closed the petition in December 2002 when in fact the terms of the petition were considered by the Justice 2 Committee on 04 March and the Public Petitions Committee on 18 March 2003. The latter anomaly has recently been corrected and the meeting of 04 March can be found here: http://archive.scottish.parliament.uk/business/committees/historic/justice1/mop-03/j2mop0304.htm
The meeting of the Justice 2 Committee, of 4th March, was not insignificant. The Justice Minister Jim Wallace was questioned by the committee on my submissions regarding membership of the Speculative Society of Edinburgh and the Masons among the judiciary. The Minister said he had not had time to read my submissions but he would do and revert to the committee. There is no record of this having happened.
Furthermore despite the fact that the committee had asked me to provide examples of cases where there was a perception that freemasonry had influenced a court or tribunal the committee did not publish the submissions I made in this regard.
I believe that this censorship was draconian given that details of own case, Stott v Minogue 2000 SLT (Sh Ct) 25, & GWD 36-1386,
- which spawned the petition – and the decision by the Social Security Commissioner, Ref: CS1/136/02. are in part matters of public record, or have been reported widely in the press and legal journals and are the two most important Scottish cases that deal with the influence of freemasonry in the justice system.
Having sought to determine my rights to challenge the existing law which allows non-disclosure of (secret) membership of fraternal organisations by decision makers by the courts, my elected representatives, and the previous government (which subverted the public petitions process), I am now attempting to resolve this anomaly with a new government, which claims to be open and accountable to the people of Scotland.
Where it was considered
Official Report-
12 Nov 20131 mention
-
28 Jan 20141 mention
Signatures by country
3,116 online signaturesComments
181 comments, oldest first181 comments · showing 51–100
-
John 7 Sep 2013Theyve nothing to hide Martin except the old shifty handshake Cover your work
-
Andrew 7 Sep 2013This is an extremely pertinent question that should be foremost prior to next years vote on independence. All candidates should be made to state their position on this very clearly , and very soon.
-
Sidney McKechnie Gallagher 9 Sep 2013I fully support Tom Minogue in his petition.
-
Craig 9 Sep 2013An idea whose time has come. Let the cleansing sunlight shine into the dark secret places.
-
James Shortt 10 Sep 2013We are forever being told by the Establishment that if we have nothing to hide we have nothing to fear, Practice what you preach, LONG OVERDUE
-
kevin budge 10 Sep 2013declare yourselves.this is not the dark ages anymore
-
Tom Minogue 10 Sep 2013Good enough for Norwegian judges, so why not their Scottish counterparts to register extra-judicial activities such as the freemasons?
See freemasonry page on Tom Minogue blog for details. -
James A Barr 10 Sep 2013The Freemasons, I believe, do a lot of good work . This being so, anyone in a position of power should be happy to let their membership be known. Unless, of course, said membership compels one to be biased in favour of fellow members.
-
gerry white 10 Sep 2013can you not be proud of your membership of your organisation?
-
A Martin 10 Sep 2013Does this include such secret society's as Opus Dei ?
-
Craig Gallagher 11 Sep 2013The British justice system will always be viewed with suspicion as long as the allegiances off the people within it remain secret.
-
Kevin McQuade 11 Sep 2013Folk who operate within 'secret societies' do so because they've something to hide.
Sinister ?
I believe so. -
Tony Hughes 11 Sep 2013Transparency required for all!
-
Gerry Doyle 11 Sep 2013Sack them....end of story!
-
Nigel Ross 12 Sep 2013Too many miscarrages of justice and establishment cover-ups have the suspicion of masonic involvment
-
Paddy Turner 12 Sep 2013They say it's a Society of Secrets & not a Secret Society........WHY the Secrecy......WHAT are they afraid of?
-
Gingernut 13 Sep 2013Maybe they are aliens trying to infultrate the Scottish legal system in order to take over the world.
-
Brian McAuley 13 Sep 2013Good Luck!
-
lord sealand 13 Sep 2013ALL secret societies have something to hid thats why there members want to hid there involvment
-
rh 13 Sep 2013The British Justice System needs to be neutral and fair.
-
John Duffy 14 Sep 2013JFK said once just before his death "the very word secrecy is repugnant in a free and open society"
-
Mary Catterson 14 Sep 2013LONG OVERDUE!
-
B Mc 14 Sep 2013The reason they are secret is because they have something to hide. There should be no place in a democracy for these medieval societies.
-
Peter Broughan 15 Sep 2013It is howlingly clear that justice has been mocked over the decades because of masonic (and other) baleful influences in the police, judiciary and othe professions.
The "society with secrets" nonsense should be outlawed immediately. Transparency and justice. We all know it makes sense. -
AR 15 Sep 2013A member of a group people who cannot survive by
their own singular endeavor. Name them! -
ChRiS SMITH 15 Sep 2013People must get more involved, governments even employ "ombudsmen" that are a s bent as the "officiaLS"
-
Jim McGrane 16 Sep 2013The same bill should include serving police officers
-
sheva burton 17 Sep 2013I believe the House of Lords changed the statute of limitations in 1993, to prevent more child sexual abuse cases being brought out into the open.
-
James Reynolds 17 Sep 2013why does the bill not include the Police ?
-
f.green 17 Sep 2013Transparency please.
-
robert roger 18 Sep 2013bigitory is indemic in scotland imo as i have exp first hand
-
Allan Mcleod 18 Sep 2013I agree with James and Jim.. Why does the bill not include serving police officers ?
-
Tom Minogue-Petitioner 18 Sep 2013Regarding police officers being obliged to declare, if the PPC see these comments they may agree particularly when giving evidence in court. I agree.
-
Derek 18 Sep 2013My comments keep getting deleted by the moderator for no good reason.
I stated I had encountered Masonic workings in a Court and they will not allow it to be added.
Has anyone else experienced this? -
Tom Minogue, petitioner 19 Sep 2013Yes Derek one of my comments was not posted and I was told that there was no record of it.
-
william wood 21 Sep 2013this petition is long long overdue.Best of Tom.
-
John Mullan 21 Sep 2013If you need to be secret, you can't be impartial.
-
Mark McQuade 22 Sep 2013no room for secrets in Modern Scotland
-
John Kerr 22 Sep 2013Surely the trial of the guy who attacked Neil Lennon says it all. He pled guilty to the assault charge but the jury came back with a not guilty. The judge failed to instruct them that they had no need to discuss this as he had already pled guilty. Shocking!!!!
-
Jacqui Collins 22 Sep 2013Our so called judicial system is corrupt to the core! The people who are supposed to uphold the LAW are in fact at the core of the corruption!!!
-
Patrick Mc Grory 24 Sep 2013All anyone can expect is honesty and fairness in this wee country of ours? Nope I don't think so, it stinks of corruption and injustice.
-
Hamish Park 24 Sep 2013Lets have an open and transparent society
-
Michael Jobson 24 Sep 2013It's only right that we know who you are !!
-
J R 25 Sep 2013Had doubts about incoming e-mail about request to visit petition. Billy Burns needs to include more references about who he is and where the e-mail came from. People are wary of unsolicited but convincing e-mail requests. Many people will delete and pass it over because of this.
-
amy wood 26 Sep 2013get rid of secrecy like the masons
-
James Burns 29 Sep 2013It's only right that we know who you are.
Get rid of secrecy like the masons,if they have nothing to hide they won't mind. -
Mark Gillespie 30 Sep 2013The very word 'secrecy' is repugnant in a free and open society.......
-
Tom Daly 1 Oct 2013in todays society the very thought of people belonging to secret organisations is troublesome. Someone has to ask the question: Why do these people want to hide behind the shadows what are they shielding the rest of society from?
-
Rose Rivendale 3 Oct 2013Corrupt Masons are destroying what is meant to be humanitarian organisation
-
Jan Ooms 3 Oct 2013Where secrecy or mystery begins, vice or roguery is not far off.
- Johnson, Dr Samuel