Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01491 · Session 4

Secret society membership declaration by decision makers.

Closed Submitted 26 Nov 2012
Signatures
0
3,116 online signatures with a country
Comments
181
Considered
2 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to amend the law or codes of practice to make it compulsory for decision makers such as sheriffs, judges, and juries at their courts, arbiters, and all panel members of tribunals that are convened and held in Scotland and governed by devolved legislation, custom and practice, to declare if they have ever been members of organisations, such as the Masons, that demand fraternal preference to their brethren over non-brethren, or organisations which have constitutions or aims that are biased against any particular sect, religion or race.
That a register of such membership is held by the various bodies that supervise such judicial and quasi-judicial tribunals and that access to these registers is given on demand to the defendant, litigant, or plaintiff wishing to exercise their rights to a fair hearing in accordance with Article 6 of the ECHR.

What the petitioner did first

In 2000 I petitioned the Scottish Parliament with PE 306 which was in a similar vein to this petition. Then, after having been under consideration for over three years with the parliament the petition was dismissed without reason.
The Public Petitions Committee summary of the petition showed that the committee had closed the petition in December 2002 when in fact the terms of the petition were considered by the Justice 2 Committee on 04 March and the Public Petitions Committee on 18 March 2003. The latter anomaly has recently been corrected and the meeting of 04 March can be found here: http://archive.scottish.parliament.uk/business/committees/historic/justice1/mop-03/j2mop0304.htm
The meeting of the Justice 2 Committee, of 4th March, was not insignificant. The Justice Minister Jim Wallace was questioned by the committee on my submissions regarding membership of the Speculative Society of Edinburgh and the Masons among the judiciary. The Minister said he had not had time to read my submissions but he would do and revert to the committee. There is no record of this having happened.
Furthermore despite the fact that the committee had asked me to provide examples of cases where there was a perception that freemasonry had influenced a court or tribunal the committee did not publish the submissions I made in this regard.
I believe that this censorship was draconian given that details of own case, Stott v Minogue 2000 SLT (Sh Ct) 25, & GWD 36-1386,
- which spawned the petition – and the decision by the Social Security Commissioner, Ref: CS1/136/02. are in part matters of public record, or have been reported widely in the press and legal journals and are the two most important Scottish cases that deal with the influence of freemasonry in the justice system.
Having sought to determine my rights to challenge the existing law which allows non-disclosure of (secret) membership of fraternal organisations by decision makers by the courts, my elected representatives, and the previous government (which subverted the public petitions process), I am now attempting to resolve this anomaly with a new government, which claims to be open and accountable to the people of Scotland.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 12 Nov 2013
    1 mention
  2. 28 Jan 2014
    Public Petitions Committee
    Current Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

3,116 online signatures
  1. Scotland2,291 73.5%
  2. United Kingdom364 11.7%
  3. England210 6.7%
  4. Canada36 1.2%
  5. Australia34 1.1%
  6. United States29 0.9%
  7. Northern Ireland25 0.8%
  8. Ireland24 0.8%
  9. Wales12 0.4%
  10. Sweden9 0.3%
  11. 29 other countries82 2.6%

Comments

181 comments, oldest first
181 comments · showing 101–150
  1. Gary Pearson 3 Oct 2013
    What happened to Transparency or declaring an intrest.
  2. Derek 5 Oct 2013
    How can they be allowed to not allow comments without keeping a record of them and a reason for deletion?

    Yes Derek one of my comments was not posted and I was told that there was no record of it.

    Tom Minogue, petitioner

    12:37 on 19 Sep 2013

    My comments keep getting deleted by the moderator for no good reason. I stated I had encountered Masonic workings in a Court and they will not allow it to be added. Has anyone else experienced this?

    Derek

    11:48 on 18 Sep 2013
  3. david wilson 5 Oct 2013
    I believe local authority members, directors & staff should also declare membership of Round Table & Rotary Club as well as Masonic Orders on an public accessible register
  4. John McDonnell 7 Oct 2013
    Behind the scenes or under the table funny handshakes have no place in a democracy or a court of law, and should in themselves be a criminal offence
  5. Stewart 7 Oct 2013
    No place for secret organisations in 2013 got to wonder why people would want to join these pathetic schoolboy cabals
  6. Thomas lamb 7 Oct 2013
    The fact that this is secretive makes me suspicious of it if it does any good in society why the need to hide the fact folk are in it what are they hiding ?
  7. David Forbes 7 Oct 2013
    Time to have a fairer sytem in scotland
  8. Jim McLaughlin 7 Oct 2013
    Secret societies are the scourge of Scottish democracy.
  9. Martin McKerry 7 Oct 2013
    This is vital in ensuring equality to all and protecting a democratic society.
  10. Neil 7 Oct 2013
    This is Scotland 2013, no more secrets, everyone is equal.
  11. Billy Coyle 7 Oct 2013
    Its about time these people were called to boot,they think theyr above the law.
  12. Michelle Smith 7 Oct 2013
    Stop now!
  13. pat hynes 7 Oct 2013
    well done.
  14. Frankie 7 Oct 2013
    Anyone in public service should ne subject to this bill.
  15. Ian Fitzpatrick 7 Oct 2013
    Disgraceful this has not been legislated on before now.
  16. Ian Fitzpatrick 7 Oct 2013
    It's 2013!!!
  17. Mark Brennan 7 Oct 2013
    No place for secret societies in this day and age. Tell the truth and shame the devil.
  18. stephen martin 7 Oct 2013
    Its time for transparency, we deserve to know if those sitting in positions of power are freemasons.No place in our society
  19. father 7 Oct 2013
    I would like to know if I say YES to an independent Scotland. Will I be living in a secular country, governed my masons? They already are in positions of authority. We know this. So if Scotland becomes independent what will we have? I would like to see this investigated, and to what degree will we be governed by a masonic power.
  20. Joe 7 Oct 2013
    Out the masons .No need for secret societies in a free and democratic society
  21. Kirstin Williams 7 Oct 2013
    Its all secrets and lies!!!!!!
  22. Philip hodge 7 Oct 2013
    I wish to be told of this information without request
  23. Colin 7 Oct 2013
    We need full visibility in all of our Govt
    - after all, we pay the wages through our taxes, so we should understand fully any conflicts of interests.
  24. mike ivory 8 Oct 2013
    People employed by the nation to take care(uphold the laws) of it's inhabitants equally and fairly shouldn't belong to secret societies who help and protect each other, declaring their involvement should be the minimal requirement and the public should have the right to know and choose an alternative to mediate!
  25. Philip McSherry 8 Oct 2013
    Disgusting systematic abuse if position has been rife for too long, time to end the flagrant disregard for moral, ethical correctness
  26. Marie Christie 8 Oct 2013
    We need a to know that the scales are even, not tipped to one side in favour of someone on the basis of membership of certain groups.
  27. Marcello Mega 8 Oct 2013
    We are asked to believe that judges and sheriffs are somehow superior beings, immune to bias or petty discrimination of any kind. That is preposterous. Take a group of 200 professionals from a single body: lawyers, doctors, accountants, teachers, journalists, politicians, clergy, academics, etc, and ask the public to accept that every single one of that group of 200 is equally fair, impartial and open-minded and of course no one would believe it. But we are asked to accept that, without question, of our judges and sheriffs. The system is out of date and does not meet the standard test that all tribunals must not only be fair impartial, they must also be seen to be such by a relatively informed onlooker. If a judge can preside over the trial of a fellow Mason or a fellow Orangeman, having sworn the same oath to the same cause, and to the brotherhood that exists between them, without declaring it, how can that be seen to be fair?
  28. Michael Houston 9 Oct 2013
    lets got all citizens of this country on an equal footing no unfair privileges and no crony-ism for a select minority
  29. Amberly 9 Oct 2013
    Good luck
  30. Linda Wallace 10 Oct 2013
    Where there is doubt, there is no doubt !! Wake Up Scotland
  31. Clare Cameron 10 Oct 2013
    Absolutely no place for secret societites in any walk of public life
  32. Tom Minogue, Petitioner 10 Oct 2013
    JFK said: 'The very word 'secrecy' is repugnant in a free and open society and we are, as a people, inherently and historically opposed to secret societies, to secret oaths and secret proceedings. We decided long ago that the dangers of excessive and unwarranted concealment of pertinent facts far outweighed the dangers which are cited to justify it.'
  33. Jim Wood 10 Oct 2013
    Pushing for an open and transparent society is the only way we can combat prejudice.
  34. Michael Belton 10 Oct 2013
    No room for this in modern society
  35. John McFadyen 12 Oct 2013
    No place for this in a modern Scotland!!
  36. Anne Maria Rennie 13 Oct 2013
    Freemasons are a secritive society that are duty bound to help if help is asked of them. Seceret hand shakes and practices they can determine the outcome of a trial. In the Scottish Borders, if the man in the dock is reffered to as a Border gentleman, he gets a more lenient sentence, if convicted at all. record will expose this.
  37. KM 13 Oct 2013
    If we truly are a modern and inclusive society, this sort of transparency should come easily and naturally.
  38. Fiona Kennedy 15 Oct 2013
    Our judiciary get aware with being unfair and unjust displayed in their judgements on a daily basis, this is just another means for them to be above the law by not answering to those they apparently represent!
  39. Eilidh Smith 16 Oct 2013
    Right to a fair trial is a human right. In a country that prides itself on our enforcement of human rights, we should have no such possible barriers to justice.
  40. OOMS 16 Oct 2013
    Where secrecy or mystery begins, vice or roguery is not far off.
    - Johnson, Dr Samuel
  41. Paul Hendry 17 Oct 2013
    I agree there should be no doubt that cronyism is wholly unwelcome. Scotland's lack of awareness about the presence of secret Masonic membership is something we should all be concerned about. I observed such at a tribunal and was unable to understand its influence on the outcome.
  42. Michael 17 Oct 2013
    Why should anyone have to be a member of any secret organisation just to get on in life.
  43. Pat McLinden 17 Oct 2013
    As a proud member of the Masonic Lodge I feel with the years I have been in it that it is other people who are non members who make a big issue of this organisation. I feel it is no secret to declare your membership of such a charitable organisation if asked, it is not asked it is not required for you to mention it. It is the same as your religious practice unless asked it is no one else's business. These things are your own business but if it is required for you to answer it on a document does that mean you will be favoured or not favoured???
  44. Tom Minogue 17 Oct 2013
    Pat McLinden, I know of no religion that demands preferment by thier members of fellow brethren over non-brethren. Nor do I know of any religion that demands that their members must help a fellow member in trouble or keep the secrets of their church under pain of the most hideous torture, such as Quote. having my throat cut across, my tongue torn out by its roots, and my body buried in the rough sands of the sea, etc. Of course if religions did demand this from their flock I would agree with you. As for charity of course there is that side of freemasonry but police officers in the Craft have been banned from the Hillsborough cover up inquiry for non charitable reasons I suspect. But I note you are in favour of declaring membership if asked and hope you are a judge.
  45. Joe Cannon 17 Oct 2013
    There is no place in a modern Scotland for this secret society nonsense anyone in public office the judiciary or decision making process should be banned from holding such positions if they are part of ANY secret society simply because they cannot be trusted to be impartial if it comes to a choice between their brethren or the ordinary guy in the street
  46. John 17 Oct 2013
    Truth, honesty and integrity, not secret handshakes and winks.
    I am fully aware of the good works done by the vast majority of Masons but there are a few bad apples which tarnish the rest i'm afraid.
  47. Derek T 17 Oct 2013
    Ban Secret Society Membership it is 2013 for gods sake
  48. Willhelm Anderson 17 Oct 2013
    I agree. Anyone in a position of power and belonging to sectarian groups such as the Knights of St Columbus or AOH should be forced to reveal their involvement. For too long, these hate mongers have got away with remaining secret.
  49. Ken Wood 17 Oct 2013
    People do not need to be members of secret societies to collude and promote their own aims above others. That freemasonry has been singled out in this petition displays ignorance of this society and its principles. Anyone who is a member of any society should not be afraid to disclose this. However, the ignorance displayed here shows why many will not do so. There is a prejudice against member of secret societies particularly Freemasonary. The Freemasonary I know has moved with society (so sorry to disappoint, but nobody is threatened with any physical violence) and it's brethren are asked to pledge allegiance to their state and uphold its laws. My experience is that it is a social club, predominantly for older gentlemen, where the ceremonies are the centre of attention. These ceremonies are symbolic as are any penalties mentioned (that those who like to imagine they know something make a point of saying mean we have something sinister to hide). Anyone who would take these literally is an idiot and probably unfit to be a member. The circumstances which prompted the petition are regrettable but hardly representative. I have met no one who could be described as holding position of power in my 20+ year in the craft, nor have I heard of any inappropriate actions of this sort. Is this Scotland or Stalinist Russia? Should the state listen in on all meetings of more than 2 people?
  50. Tony bentley 17 Oct 2013
    If gets the go ahead it must include all secret societies not just the masons. This will upset most politicians in Scotland because of there religious beliefs, also the BBC.