Petition · PE01487 · Session 4
Religious observance in schools
Signatures
20
Comments
96
Considered
5 meetings
What it asks
Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to amend the Education (Scotland) Act 1980 by making Religious Observance (RO) in public schools an “Opt-In” activity rather than an “Opt-Out” one.
What the petitioner did first
The provision of Religious Observance (RO) in schools is a national issue, not a local or a personal one. I have complained to the school after my daughter was incorrectly sent to a church service. The school explained that this error arose because a temporary teacher was on duty; however, this merely emphasises that such errors are implicit in the present system.
I have consulted numerous school handbooks and discovered that they often do not even mention the right to opt out. This is a systematic; not an individual, failing.
I have researched the issue, and find that only 20% of parents say the school informed them of their opt-out rights. These are among the reasons why I am forced to conclude that the opt-out system is systematically defective, and since 'opt in' vs 'opt out' is specified by the Scottish Government, I feel it is a matter for the Scottish Parliament.
I have spoken to my MSP who has advised that this was a legitimate topic for petition.
Additionally, Secular Scotland with over 500 members is raising this issue on Facebook and Twitter with the support of the Humanist Society of Scotland and various figures within Scottish churches.
I have consulted numerous school handbooks and discovered that they often do not even mention the right to opt out. This is a systematic; not an individual, failing.
I have researched the issue, and find that only 20% of parents say the school informed them of their opt-out rights. These are among the reasons why I am forced to conclude that the opt-out system is systematically defective, and since 'opt in' vs 'opt out' is specified by the Scottish Government, I feel it is a matter for the Scottish Parliament.
I have spoken to my MSP who has advised that this was a legitimate topic for petition.
Additionally, Secular Scotland with over 500 members is raising this issue on Facebook and Twitter with the support of the Humanist Society of Scotland and various figures within Scottish churches.
Where it was considered
Official Report-
3 Sep 20131 mention
-
12 Nov 20131 mention
-
28 Jan 20141 mention
-
18 Mar 20142 mentions
-
6 May 20141 mention
Signatures by country
1,496 online signaturesComments
96 comments, oldest first96 comments · showing 51–96
-
Martin MacInnes 4 Jun 2013excellent idea
-
Alan Rogers 5 Jun 2013When I have succeed in making organised religion fund religious care in NHS Wales hospitals (£1.3 million p.a.) I will begin a campagn in Wales like yours. Good luck.
-
Barry Keylock 5 Jun 2013Education is about knowledge, not belief or opinion. Schools should be built on a secular foundation. Religion should be a personal thing, for the home and church.
-
Stewart Coe 5 Jun 2013More than happy to have religion feature as an element of history, modern studies, social science but the place for observance is church and the choice should be entirely personal.
-
James Clark 5 Jun 2013Should have been done a long time ago.
-
gerry gallacher 5 Jun 2013onward forward to a free thinking society
-
G. Petrie 5 Jun 2013I was not aware of this possible change.
I'm not against my kids going to RO in principle, but I think that you should have to choose to go to a religious event, rather it just assumed that you will. -
Duncan Cuthill 5 Jun 2013Seems like an ironic law, my reading of the gospels is that Jesus didn't make anyone do anything. On the contrary, he welcomed children and encouraged personal choice and responsibility. Also, church tends to flourish when it is on the margins of and serving society so ending this law might be good for Christianity too? The discussion is particularly interesting in a Scottish context since an emphasis on education was a distinctive of the Scottish reformation, again, it seems odd that Christianity has now become entangled in the education system in this way. If there is to be RO in schools in a predominantly non church attending country, opt-in sounds fair to me.
-
William Twycross 5 Jun 2013Faith develops within the individual and is personal. Like wise the choice of where and when it is expanded and re-enforced is also a personal choice.
-
Stewart 5 Jun 2013Very happy to support this
- and I'm a Catholic. -
Theresa Ritchie 5 Jun 2013I walked into a local school one afternoon on business and found 100 young dancing, singing and clapping to a Kidz Club Evangelical Church group who I discovered go into every primary school in town once a week and perform a cutesie style encouraging kids to be 'saved'. Scary. I know their background
- they are fundamentalist, miracle believing, signs and wonders woshipping church who encourage children to come to their 'Kidz Club' after school. Parents just don't know the depth of the belief of these people and it's hard to say no to their children. This has no place in school. -
David 6 Jun 2013Why should children be made to subjected to the ramblings of the deranged?
-
Mark Dale 6 Jun 2013Scotland should follow the lead of its auld alliance partners France, and adopt this policy.
-
Kevin Edward 6 Jun 2013It is absurd that schools still have this, often opt out is not mentioned almost like a not asked don't tell situation, children that are removed from observance are made to feel outcast by the school and made fools off. Parents I know don't want the observance, however don't opt out as it is less stressful for the child who would otherwise be made to feel excluded. Enough is enough
-
Archie Macbeth 6 Jun 2013I survived a Plymouth Brethren upbringing and would hope to shield future kids from that.
-
Linda Sime 6 Jun 2013Wish we had the right to 'opt out' when I was at school. Even as a primary school student, I knew I was being taught a lot of nonsense under the guise that these fairy stories were FACTUAL!
-
Robert Howitt 7 Jun 2013Religion should be taught in your place of worship NOT in a school.
-
Shaomin lee-murray 7 Jun 2013Keep education secular.
-
robbie 7 Jun 2013over 20 years ago my parents supported me in opting out of religious observance. i was the only one at the school to do so and had to sit outside the headmaster's office, in the place where kids due to be disciplined normally sat. attendance at any religious ceremonies in a secular society should only ever be by a positive choice
- ie opt in. -
Gordon Barrie 8 Jun 2013RO shouldn't even be a part of schools IMO
-
eirinn 8 Jun 2013Religion should be a choice, and not forced on children.
-
Alison Perry 9 Jun 2013Religion has no place in schools anymore as it is not the majority anymore
-
Robin Raybould 9 Jun 2013We have the means to teach our children without influencing them with religion.
-
Keith Bromley 9 Jun 2013End all privileges and benefits for non-secular activity
-
Billy Sands 10 Jun 2013How absurd that the default position is opt out. World views should not be forced on anyone
- by stealth or otherise -
Brent Cheetham 10 Jun 2013to be fair to all- it is only right that folks should have to opt-in if they require their children to have "RE" !
-
Jez Kempston 11 Jun 2013Religion is on the way out.... quite rightly
-
Allison Stevenson 11 Jun 2013Religion should be practiced in any place of worship but not made compulsory in education. The time in school should be given to more productive topics.
-
Philip Allan 11 Jun 2013I respect others' religious views, but religion should be restricted to the home, and the chosen church of that home.
-
Patricia Caird 12 Jun 2013I see absolutely no need nor requirement for religion to be part of a secular education except as an embedded within such Social Science subjects as History, Politics, Languages etc. where the historical and current role of different religions could be accurately recounted within the context of the individual subject. Religious Observance classes should be replaced with Critical Thinking and Philosophy classes and religious instruction should be treated as a private matter for individual parents and not given undue status within Public Sector Education.
-
Graeme McKiggan 12 Jun 2013My kids have been bullied because we did opt out. Education should be about facts.
-
Tim Abernethy 12 Jun 2013Schools are there to educate, not to be proselytized Pupils should have the option to decide to go to services, but not be expected to go by default. The worrying and shocking emergence of Creationism and science-deniers in our education system is a source of great concern and should be redressed sharply.
-
James Yule 12 Jun 2013Opt in offends no one
-
Helen 13 Jun 2013I didn't realise I could opt out of religious observance in High School. I sat through hours of services (at a non-denominational school), some of which implied that I as an atheist had a defective moral compass due to my lack of belief in someone's god, because I thought it compulsory to everyone save for those who were of different religions. Frankly I would have preferred to spend an hour in supported study.
-
Michael Richardson 13 Jun 2013When I was at school, Religious Education class was always considered a "free" period because there was no exams to take and therefore no need to study or even really to show up at class. If schools have to teach religion, they should offer all belief systems equally or none at all.
-
Angus Brown 14 Jun 2013This proposed change is a logical and fairer
method for both believers and non-believers
and offers parents a wider choice of their personal wishes. -
Ian Cobb 14 Jun 2013I think religious observance should be banned from all schools. That's not going to happen, so as a minimum the pupils should be allowed to opt-in to any religious service. OK, if that's still a bit too strong, at least allow 16 year-olds to opt-out especially as the Scottish Government considers them capable of voting on Scottish "independence".
-
Magister iratus 15 Jun 2013I believe children should not be forced into a particular religion and to let themselves decide when they are old enough to make an informed decision.
-
John Wiltshire 15 Jun 2013The primary spiritual virtue of science is honesty. Those who claim to know outrageously unlikely facts about the Universe that are not underwritten by science should not be allowed to impose their views on the young by default. They should be challenged to explain, in all honesty, how they can know what science doesn't know. It is dishonest to claim that religious belief is a reliable source of truth about the Universe. It is not. Ask Galileo. We must look to science for that truth and the honesty of science should be the default and parents should be encouraged to think very carefully before opting their children into the dishonesty of religion and its claim to know what cannot be known.
-
Steve 18 Jun 2013No one should be forced to pray.
-
Allen Kerr 18 Jun 2013Religious indoctrination has no place in education. Children should not be frog-marched into assembly and forced to pray to a certain god of a certain religion. I'm employed to teach, not to convert.
-
Andrew C 18 Jun 2013I don't think it should be "opt in" either! If you want your child to learn that load of twaddle then teach them it yourself. Schools will still be able to teach good morals etc without the "Christian" label attached. In fact if they were true Christian schools they'd be teaching homophobia, racism, sexism etc.
-
Harris 19 Jun 2013Beliefs and ideologies should not be enforced on children in any way, shape or form! Let them make up their own minds through their innate curiosity!
-
Julian Adkins 19 Jun 2013Children should be taught about religions in the diversity in a balanced and factual way so they can decide for themselves how they wish to interact with these traditions. It is not the job of the state to promote religious observance of any kind.
-
Keith Gilmour 19 Jun 2013I have taught RME-RMPS (secondary) for over ten years. For the first few years, I taught in six different schools in three different authorities. In my experience, RME-RMPS teachers avoid RO involvement like the plague, fearing this might compromise their neutrality. Christmas and Easter services are held on the last day of term when attendance is low anyway but Muslim, Hindu, Atheist, etc pupils do still turn up and would really have to make quite a fuss to get out of going. Ditto staff! I have known several school chaplains (all Christian) and found most to be friendly and fairly sensible. Services are less religious than they used to be (e.g. pupils listening to the school's gospel choir but not being expected to sing along, reference to a moment of "silent reflection" rather than "prayer", etc). The emphasis is invariably on shared values and a shared sense of wonder. Chaplain assemblies are basically 'Thought for the Day' and are, in my experience (which may not be typical), pretty uncontroversial. I have two tentative reservations about this petition. The first is the language and principle of 'opt-out' and 'opt-in.' (Are any of us pleased to see the children of fundamentalists removed from RME classes, PSE sexual health lessons, LGBT talks, PE dancing, etc? Would we be happy for the children of creationists to 'opt out' of -- or opt not to 'opt in' to -- science lessons on evolution?). Secondly, I worry that religious parents might 'opt-out' of non-denominational schools altogether, if they begin to view them as atheistic. Those reservations aside, I can't see how anyone could object to 'an instruction to attend a religious service' being replaced with 'an invitation to attend a religious service.'
-
Ian Armstrong 19 Jun 2013Young children will believe anything you tell them and older children just get demotivated by having to sit through boring lectures by the minister. Not to mention the fairly obvious fact that opt out RO is completely outdated. Teaching about religions is important but give the Christian sales pitch a rest.