Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Schools (Religious Observance) (PE1487)

Tuesday 3 September 2013 Public Petitions Committee About 10:00 Petitions 31 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

31 contributions
David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

The second new petition is PE1487 by Mark Gordon and Secular Scotland, on religious observance in schools. Members have a note from the clerk and a SPICe briefing. We have also received a written submission from the Church of Scotland. I welcome Mark Gordon and Caroline Lynch, the secretary of Secular Scotland. I understand that you wish to make a joint presentation. We are a bit behind time, for which I apologise. If you can keep your presentation to around three minutes, that will be very useful.

Caroline Lynch Secular Scotland
link

We will be as brief as possible. Our petition seeks to change the Education (Scotland) Act 1980, which sets the default position as being that every child is opted in to religious observance in schools and that parents have a statutory right to withdraw their child should they wish to do so. We want parents to have an active and meaningful choice as to whether they want their child to participate in religious observance or whether they want to send their child to a suitable and meaningful alternative activity. In essence, we want parents to be asked first.Our petition seeks a simple solution to a serious problem that is caused by the law not working as intended. Today, we will give you the testimony that we have received from parents telling us what is really happening on the ground. Mark Gordon started the ball rolling with his personal experiences, which he will tell you about.

Mark Gordon Secular Scotland
link

Ladies and gentlemen of the committee, my personal experience of opting my daughter out of religious observance was the trigger for raising the petition. It became abundantly clear from discussions with the school, analysis of legislation and discussions with others of the prevalence of belief in the population that many parents would not want to take the stand that I took. Having decided to act, however, we sought the experiences of other parents, some of which we hope to present to you in an additional submission afterwards. If you will permit me, I will give you a small sample of what we found.We have testimony from parents of children who have been opted out that their children have been left unattended in corridors with little that is meaningful to do. We have testimony of children being, in effect, chastised for their parents’ decision, children being told to carry out menial tasks—including, believe it or not, sharpening pencils and cleaning a library—and parents being considered difficult because they dared to question a headteacher’s wisdom. Parents have been told that there is no right to withdraw, have had to seek legal advice because a school could not or would not provide acceptable alternative activities and have been told that alternative activities such as humanist material would categorically not be allowed. A teenage pupil who had a right to withdraw himself was forcibly prevented from leaving religious observance that he objected to. Crucially, there is evidence that, despite very recent regulations—the Education (School and Placing Information) (Scotland) Regulations 2012—that outline the requirement for school handbooks to lay out in writing the parental right to withdraw, a large percentage of school handbooks do not, as yet, contain that information.My daughter is well treated and, in my opinion, attends a very good school. However, she has reported—as others have—that she has sat in the school office with the school secretary during religious assemblies. More recently, she was taken to a church service against my written instructions. Maybe not every parent is as confident as I am in making a stand for the right thing to do. Perhaps most parents do not want their children to be exposed to some aspects of Christian religious observance but they do not feel able to opt out and address the issue by facing up to the authority of the school or to risk their child being ostracised for non-conformity. Perhaps they just fear damaging an otherwise healthy parent-teacher relationship.My conclusion is that the law is no longer in accordance with the demographic of Scotland, which has changed significantly since the last review. There is also a built-in unfairness. Despite the religious observance review group stating that religious observance should not be of a confessional nature, we know from testimony that it is. The existing legislation makes the removal of religious observance even from a single school extremely difficult, as it requires a poll of the local authority electorate. In any case, that is not what we seek, as it would only end up in patchy provision throughout the country. Indeed, if our petition were successful, it might well strengthen religious observance through discussion.Because of all that, we are here today to present our petition.12:15

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you very much for that joint presentation. You have touched on evidence and have provided some very useful examples, but do you have comprehensive Scotland-wide evidence of the views of pupils, parents or staff?

Caroline Lynch Secular Scotland
link

Yes. We have brought with us testimony from parents, teachers, course designers and students about their experiences. Those experiences vary widely; we are not saying that every single school is failing. What we are saying is that, on this issue, failure is endemic throughout the school system.The law makes five provisions. First, it provides a minimum of six opportunities for religious observance throughout the year; secondly, every parent has a statutory right to withdraw; thirdly, every parent must be informed of that right and given sufficient information on which to base their decision; fourthly, if the statutory right to withdraw is taken up, a suitable meaningful alternative activity must be in place for the child to ensure that they are not penalised; and, finally, no child should be disadvantaged by choosing to withdraw from religious observance. There are failures across the board in all those areas. Because that failure is endemic and happening everywhere, the law—in our opinion—is in need of urgent reform.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Perhaps you can give us that evidence to look at, if you have not done so already.

Caroline Lynch Secular Scotland
link

Absolutely.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

Good afternoon. I am intrigued by—indeed, I might somewhat agree with—Mr Gordon’s comment that such a change might strengthen religious observance. How have you come to that conclusion?

Mark Gordon Secular Scotland
link

We think that the change would make the process more inclusive, because parents and children would positively opt to get involved in it. After all, there are possibly a lot of kids who do not want to be there.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

Good afternoon. I suppose that all I can do is play devil’s advocate with this petition—if you do not mind the contradiction in the sentiment underpinning that statement.I have no religious convictions myself, but I think that you have made a very good case this morning for ending the opt-out provision. You clearly feel that no alternative meaningful activity is taking place. I went to a school where I had to attend religious education or observance. My parents very much encouraged in me an independent attitude not just to that but to subjects such as politics and history—whatever we were taught in school we would challenge in the home. As a result, I ultimately came to an independent view on matters that are subjective or of faith. Imposing a view that no one should be exposed to any kind of religious education is itself a rather doctrinaire approach, when surely it is perfectly open to parents to encourage a degree of independent thinking by challenging whatever their children have been exposed to. I do not necessarily equate participation, attendance and conviction as being one and the same thing and ultimately and fundamentally I am not terribly sure what great damage is being done here unless children are not being encouraged by their parents or schools to evolve any ability to assess, judge and evaluate information on an independent basis.

Caroline Lynch Secular Scotland
link

There are several points to note in response to that. First of all, our religious education is split into religious and moral education and religious observance. In religious and moral education, children are taught what religion is and what the beliefs of the different groups are. We have absolutely no issue with that, because everyone needs at least a basic understanding of that information in order to function in our world.Religious observance, on the other hand, is active participation in religion. Although there is guidance in place that sets out what such observance should be—it should, for example, be non-denominational and inclusive and should not contravene anyone’s personal faith stance—the reality on the ground is that in most cases we are talking about Christian worship. Indeed, we can give you dozens and dozens of examples of that.Just yesterday I got a phone call from a parent who was very angry and distressed because his five-year-old son had brought home two young earth creationist books that had been given to him during religious observance. Those books directly state that their aim is to debunk Scottish education and scientific education in general, and they talk about exposing the myth of evolution. That is the type of material that is making its way into schools under the auspices of religious observance.We also have evidence of prayer spaces being used for the faith healing of incurable conditions. That is being done without parental knowledge and consent, and it is among the reasons why we are so concerned.My five-year-old son had nightmares for months because he was told that Jesus had nails hammered through his flesh to save him. Teachers tell us that children are being told that they are sinners and that, unless they accept God, they are going to go to hell. We have heard from Muslims who, along with Jews and Buddhists, are being asked to participate in praying to God. All sorts of people are being asked to pray to a Christian god, which is an anathema to their own personal stance.Parents are not being informed that they can opt out, and some are being prevented from exercising their right to do so. We have a lady whose daughter has been threatened with expulsion from school if she exercises the right to opt out. Those are the type of things that are going on, and at present there is very little protection for parents because the abuse of religious observance is so endemic. It is happening across the system, and all over the place.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

I follow a lot of what you have said; you are talking about a certain evangelical fanaticism that would be of concern not just to the pupils who opt out but to the pupils who remain in that environment. However, I maintain that there is a difference between attending a religious observance event and participating in it. I have to say that I have done plenty of the former: I have attended but not participated—

Mark Gordon Secular Scotland
link

It behoves us to offer the children protection rather than just saying, “Well, it is up to the child to figure this out.” We are talking about five-year-olds.

Caroline Lynch Secular Scotland
link

In addition—

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

Well, I was not protected—I was encouraged to think independently and to challenge the views that were expressed to me. That is what I did, and in so doing I came to a rational judgment that I am comfortable with, and that I can live with and understand. I am not quite sure how protecting people—as you put it—from hearing any alternative point of view is to do them any service at all.

Caroline Lynch Secular Scotland
link

It is not about protecting them from hearing an alternative point of view—they will hear alternative points of view throughout their education, in religious and moral education. It is about participation: the freedom to choose what your faith is and to participate in it freely. That is about human rights.We raise the point that, in not allowing parents to choose freely how their children participate in religious observance or to exercise that judgment as they should do, we are directly contravening human rights law. Article 18.4 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, which we have opted in to and ratified, states that parents have the right to raise their children and have them educated in accordance with their beliefs, and we are breaching that.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I am sorry, but we are really short of time now. Do members have any other points?

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I have a brief question for Ms Lynch and Mr Gordon. I am assuming that, if you wanted us to go ahead, the change would apply only to non-denominational schools in Scotland.

Caroline Lynch Secular Scotland
link

Not at all—it would apply to all state schools. Although the majority of parents who send their children to a denominational faith school perhaps have accepted the faith stance of that school, there are parents who send their child to an inter-denominational school for non-faith reasons: perhaps because of the educational standard of achievement, or perhaps because the child has not been able to get a place in a non-denominational school. I mentioned a parent whose daughter has been threatened with exclusion. She sent her child to that school because her child’s friends went there.People send their children to certain schools for a range of reasons. Ultimately, the schools are state funded and are open to everybody under the law—that is the requirement. Parents who send their children to such schools should not have fewer rights or protections for their children than there are for any other children in the state system.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

On that basis, I assume that you are talking about amending the Education (Scotland) Act 1918.

Caroline Lynch Secular Scotland
link

Our petition is based on the Education (Scotland) Act 1980.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I understand that denominational schools were created under the 1918 act; the majority of them have been established under that act.

Caroline Lynch Secular Scotland
link

The 1980 act covers religious observance and rights in relation to that; it specifies the requirements. We would amend that act to reverse the situation, so that parents who want their children to take part in religious observance would choose that.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

As members have no more points, the next step is to consider how we will deal with the petition. My view is that we should continue it and seek the views of the Scottish Government, Education Scotland and the Scottish Parent Teacher Council. As always, I am open to committee members’ views.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I suggest that we write to ask Interfaith Scotland for its views. I am interested in seeking the views of a range of organisations on that body and particularly of some of its associate members, including organisations such as the Pagan Federation, which has raised issues with the teaching of religious and moral values in schools.I know that an exchange has taken place between the clerk and Edinburgh Secular Society about making a submission. If any other organisations feel that it would be relevant for them to respond to the petition, their submissions would be welcome, too. We can name organisations, but we might not cover them all. I am sure that a number of organisations out there would wish to comment and they are welcome to do so.

Anne McTaggart Lab Glasgow
link

It is important to ask the Scottish Parent Teacher Council for its views.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

I am interested in exploring with local authorities the provision of alternatives in the opt-out process, which struck me as not quite fulfilling the aim of being suitable and worthwhile activities. I am also interested in knowing the number of people who opt out, how suitable alternative activities are provided and conducted and whether suitable alternatives are not being provided because they are difficult to finance and sustain. That raises quite interesting issues. I am slightly uncomfortable with the idea that resources are being diverted or that individuals who opt out are in no way benefiting from that.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

That is a good point. We could write to, say, six local authorities covering rural, island and busy city centre areas.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I suggest that we also write to the Educational Institute of Scotland and the Scottish association for senior teachers and headteachers—I am not sure of its name—for their views. There is an educational issue, particularly as the petitioners have raised the question of local choice for headteachers and teaching staff about the religious and moral education that they deliver and about religious observance.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

As members have no more points, are we happy to continue the petition and seek the views of the organisations that we have identified?Members indicated agreement.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I thank both petitioners for coming along. We will keep you up to date with developments. I apologise that you were delayed because we were held up by lengthy consideration of earlier petitions.I allow the petitioners to leave but, because of time constraints, I will not suspend the meeting.

  1. 10:00 Interests Procedure · 3
  2. 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 91
  3. 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 84
  4. 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 72
  5. 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 31
  6. 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 3
  7. 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  8. 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  9. 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  10. 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 12
  11. 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  12. 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  13. 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  14. 10:00 Correspondence Committee business · 1

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.