Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Current Petitions

CalMac Ferries (Wi-fi) (PE1473)

Tuesday 3 September 2013 Public Petitions Committee About 10:00 Petitions 84 contributions · 11 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

84 contributions
David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

The committee will now take evidence from CalMac Ferries Ltd and NorthLink Ferries Ltd on PE1473 by Frances Anne Gillies, on behalf of Barra Youth Council, on wi-fi on CalMac ferries. Members have a note by the clerk, which is paper 4.I welcome the panel. I am sorry for delaying you, gentlemen—as you probably picked up, we were having quite an intensive debate. I am sorry that we have overrun on time.From CalMac, I welcome Roger Willison-Gray, who is the information services director, and Robbie Drummond, who is the group finance director; and, from NorthLink Ferries, I welcome Stuart Garrett, who is the managing director, and Steve Moreton, who is the information technology manager.There is no opening statement. For ease, I intend to divide up the questions between CalMac and Serco. The first set of questions will be for our CalMac witnesses. When will passengers on CalMac services get wi-fi?

Robbie Drummond CalMac Ferries Ltd
link

As we set out in April, we are in the middle of the process. We have tendered for extending wi-fi across the network. We think that the contract will be awarded some time in August and that the roll-out will take place at the back end of this year and into January or February of next year.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I take it from the nature of the geography on the routes on which your 29 vessels operate that you are looking at satellite services. You mention some other means, but I presume that, on many occasions, 3G will not reach across the Minch.

Roger Willison-Gray CalMac Ferries Ltd
link

Satellite is not feasible on all of our vessels because of their size. In addition, there would be substantial operating costs associated with satellite for what are relatively small passenger numbers. The larger vessels on the longer routes will have satellite. We have a pilot for the new satellite technology under way on the Lord of the Isles and we will shortly have one on the Clansman. The remaining vessels will use a variety of technologies; mostly, they will use high-speed meshed wi-fi, so there will be ship-to-shore communications and wireless access points on the vessels. The backhaul will be through the fixed line network at each of the locations.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

So what is the reality for passengers who use a 40-minute service, such as the one to Tarbert that I used a few weeks ago? Will members of the business community and tourists get wi-fi once the pilot is up and running next year?

Roger Willison-Gray CalMac Ferries Ltd
link

I should point out that this is a multi-million pound investment, involving 29 vessels, 26 routes and 54 locations. It is a complex network that will take time to roll out. However, once everything is in place, we will use the network to provide services such as ticketing to our vessels and, as a result, all the passengers on the vessels will have access to wi-fi. Currently, we have no plans to charge for that.11:15

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

To be clear: will all passengers on all vessels on all your routes have wi-fi once the system is up and running next year?

Robbie Drummond CalMac Ferries Ltd
link

That is absolutely the intention, and ports will have it as well.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you for that. I throw open the discussion to my colleagues.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

I travel regularly to Norway, and it has been the case for a while in Norway that wi-fi has been available on most ships, even small local ships or ferries. As we know, NorthLink has already introduced wi-fi on the services to the northern isles. I am glad that CalMac is getting there, but it is unfortunate that you are a wee bit behind.Your statement on 8 March indicated that the roll-out of on-board wi-fi involves“significant technological challenges and costs”.Can you outline what those challenges include and how much the installation of the new communication system might cost? You mentioned a multi-million pound cost, but I presume that it is not too high.

Roger Willison-Gray CalMac Ferries Ltd
link

It is a competitive procurement. It is an outcome-based tender—a full Official Journal of the European Union tender—and therefore I cannot give you a price, because it will depend on the bids that we receive from the six qualified bidders. Obviously, I cannot comment on the procurement process until it is complete.In terms of technology, all I would say is that it is unfortunate that BT and other providers of infrastructure to the Western Isles are unable to offer the same level of service that is offered in Norway. The limitation for us is not the technology on our vessels but the inability to communicate from places such as Barra, where, as I am sure you are aware, there is no mobile signal.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

There is, but it depends.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

Even in Lewis there can be the lack of a signal, as we found out to our cost in the past few weeks. The Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee has very much taken that issue on board and is looking at it in depth.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

Good morning, gentlemen. My question is to NorthLink Ferries. What was the cost of installing on-board wi-fi on your ships? Did it make economic sense to charge passengers for the service?

Stuart Garrett NorthLink Ferries Ltd
link

The total cost was less than £100,000. It was part of a large refurbishment programme, so it was a programme of works. There is no charge for wi-fi on our services.

Anne McTaggart Lab Glasgow
link

I have another question for Serco NorthLink Ferries. By what means do you monitor passenger satisfaction with the on-board wi-fi service?

Stuart Garrett NorthLink Ferries Ltd
link

We introduced individual servers on each of the vessels and in each port location in addition to introducing wi-fi and expanding the local area network—LAN—in each of the ships. We are able to capture individual log-ins and upload and download through the servers. We have separate customer satisfaction surveys available on board. To date, while there are, as ever, intermittent issues with wi-fi, there has been no issue of significant or even limited concern about the wi-fi provision.

Anne McTaggart Lab Glasgow
link

Can you outline some of the key comments and concerns about the service from passengers who have perhaps filled out some of the customer service forms?

Stuart Garrett NorthLink Ferries Ltd
link

When there is a satellite-related issue and there is no service—or when the down-station, as it is referred to, has loss of productivity—that is entirely outwith our control. What we do find, though, is that issues in relation to wi-fi connectivity are often down to the user and the individual device that they use. There are certain proprietary brands of wi-fi and hand-held equipment in particular that perhaps do not connect as well to external wi-fi systems as some other types of equipment.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I will bring in Steve Moreton—he is the IT whiz kid here, so he can perhaps take the scales from our eyes. Am I right in thinking, in my amateur view, that satellite is the main solution to the problems with providing wi-fi on vessels?

Steve Moreton Northlink Ferries Ltd
link

Yes. Because of the routes that the ferries take, they are significantly out of the line of sight of the shore. That produces the same issues that CalMac has discovered: there are certain routes on which we just cannot afford to rely on shore-based connectivity. Most ferry companies do indeed use satellite.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I had a quick look before I came out today, and I saw that there are a number of companies that would provide you with satellite fairly quickly. If the committee was visiting Antarctica tomorrow, they tell me that I could get fast broadband speed using satellite and modems. I am obviously taking a very amateur view, and it is much more complicated when you are running a fleet, but it is technically possible. How long have you been providing wi-fi on your three vessels?

Steve Moreton Northlink Ferries Ltd
link

We have been doing so since the beginning of the year—since the reboot. There was already a limited wi-fi system in the ships from the previous NorthLink company, which also used satellite communication. I am not sure how long that had been on board.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Perhaps Jackson Carlaw can direct his question to both groups of witnesses.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

Serco already blocks access to sites such as BBC iPlayer simply because of the potential scale of bandwidth usage. Is that likely always to be the case? Is it a permanent position? Does CalMac expect that to be the case? Would you also not give people access to things such as iPlayer because it would be very expensive or because it would overutilise your service availability?

Steve Moreton Northlink Ferries Ltd
link

The data rates that are associated with videostream exceed the capability of the satellite.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

Can you identify the commercial cost of providing that service, if only to illustrate how unfeasible it would be?

Steve Moreton Northlink Ferries Ltd
link

If we went for the satellite equivalent of a leased line, we would be talking about tens of thousands of pounds a month.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

And that whole cost would have to be borne by somebody, so the investment would simply not be justified.

Steve Moreton Northlink Ferries Ltd
link

Correct.

Roger Willison-Gray CalMac Ferries Ltd
link

We have the same view. There is a question around providing reasonable access, which has to be managed.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

There will be so many other wonderful things that people can do on board anyway that they would not need to sit and look at BBC iPlayer, I assume you will assure us.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

They could go for a coffee.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

Good morning, gentlemen. Mr Drummond, you said in answer to a question from the convener that installing wi-fi is your “intention” rather than saying, “Yes, we are going to do it.” Is that intention inhibited by your contractual arrangement with the Government?

Robbie Drummond CalMac Ferries Ltd
link

We are going to do it.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

Okay. I know from my business experience that one sometimes has to take a risk and invest in projects to attract customers.In your press release of 8 March, you state:“Where there is sufficient capacity and network coverage this will allow us to deliver ‘Wi-fi’ services to passengers.”Given that the Government has a large focus on tourism, how far are we being constrained by not providing such a service to tourists?

Robbie Drummond CalMac Ferries Ltd
link

I am not sure that I am qualified to comment on that. We are installing wi-fi primarily for the safe and effective operation of vessels and to manage our processes better. As an outflow from that, we will be able to give passengers access, which would clearly improve their experience. We would hope to gain additional revenue from that, but that is hard to quantify.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

Perhaps I can help by asking NorthLink a question. Having successfully introduced wi-fi, do you monitor passenger satisfaction with the on-board service? If so, can you comment on or highlight any concerns that passengers have raised in that respect?

Stuart Garrett NorthLink Ferries Ltd
link

Looking at individual ships and ports, we track the number of log-ins on a monthly basis. On the MV Hrossey, for example, the log-ins numbered 2,712 in May, 3,064 in June, 3,297 in July and 3,644 in July. Those figures show an incremental use of the facilities that tallies with the increase in traffic during the summer months.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

Which would indicate customer satisfaction.

Stuart Garrett NorthLink Ferries Ltd
link

One would hope so, yes.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I have some questions for our CalMac colleagues. Did I hear you correctly when you said that the contract had to be advertised in the Official Journal of the European Union? Is the contract of that scale? In my experience, such contracts are normally over £4 million.

Roger Willison-Gray CalMac Ferries Ltd
link

No. The threshold is £195,000 but, as I am sure that you are aware, there are complexities around what you can and cannot do. Part of the reason for advertising the contract is that our existing network supplier has been in place for 10 years; in such cases, it is good practice to go to market, so we would have done this anyway.We also want to ensure that we attract the best potential suppliers. As I have said, the issue is technically complex and we have attracted a number of potential suppliers who are able to work in very challenging environments.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I realise that you do not yet have the tender prices but, whatever the final cost is, will the funding come out of the CalMac group’s current capital programme, or are you getting any extra money from the Scottish Government?

Robbie Drummond CalMac Ferries Ltd
link

It is coming out of resources from the Scottish Government.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Right. If for the sake of argument it costs £4 million to provide the contract, all those funds will come directly from the Scottish Government and not from your existing budget.

Robbie Drummond CalMac Ferries Ltd
link

It is part of our existing budget. It will not come out of capital budgets; it will be revenue spend.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

So what percentage of the project will be funded by the Scottish Government and what percentage by CalMac?

Robbie Drummond CalMac Ferries Ltd
link

It is being funded out of the resources that we are getting from the Scottish Government. It is not ring-fenced funding; it is funded from our block grant.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Okay. Is it additional funding? Do you want to write to us about this?

Robbie Drummond CalMac Ferries Ltd
link

It is part of the funding package that has been agreed.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I will bring in Chic Brodie in a second.If I understand it correctly, the current arrangements to cover your various routes across the Highlands and Islands and the rest of Scotland were extended by three years. Is wi-fi provision going to be a condition of future tenders, or is it a condition of the current arrangements to provide the service?

Robbie Drummond CalMac Ferries Ltd
link

It is not conditional on the current contract, and any future contract is clearly a matter for Transport Scotland.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

So that is a question for Transport Scotland. I imagine, however, that it would be quite sensible to make it a condition of future service provision, not least because you have already provided the services.I believe that you wanted to come in, Mr Brodie.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

If I may, convener.I have to say that I am astounded: not five minutes ago you said that you would deliver a capital programme, but now we hear that you do not know how it is going to be funded.

Robbie Drummond CalMac Ferries Ltd
link

It is fully funded. In any case, as my colleague has explained, it is not a capital programme; it is a service-based contract—

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

So how much are you going to spend, Mr Drummond, given that your contract lasts for another two and a half or three years? You must know what the cost of the investment is likely to be and which budget it is going to be sourced from.

Robbie Drummond CalMac Ferries Ltd
link

As this is not investment but service-based provision, we are talking about the amount that we will pay each year to the service provider, which will replace the amount that we are already paying for our full technology platform. This is not just a case of putting wireless on to the vessels; this is a full technology programme right across the group from our head office to our ports and vessels, part of the aim of which is to increase efficiency in executing and managing our business. One of the added benefits is that we can offer this additional facility to customers.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

What is your budget figure? What have you estimated it will cost you?

Robbie Drummond CalMac Ferries Ltd
link

It is well into seven figures, but we will not have that information until we get the responses back from providers. I do not think that it would be right to put that out.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

From wearing other hats, I know that even though the tender process is not complete the custom and practice are that finance directors will have given you a figure for what they expect the cost to be. What do you expect the cost to be?

Roger Willison-Gray CalMac Ferries Ltd
link

If we were outside procurement, we would be willing to answer that question. I have no desire for the people who are bidding for the contract to know what our budget is at this stage.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

You raised your eyebrows, Mr Carlaw. I do not know whether that means you want to ask a question.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

I am sorry, convener—I was merely indicating that I was in full sympathy with you there.11:30

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

I have what might be seen as an operational question for CalMac. Can the installation be completed only when the ships are in for refurbishment or refit or can it be done at any time?

Roger Willison-Gray CalMac Ferries Ltd
link

That is an interesting question. The short answer is that it will depend on the supplier’s bid. Our desire would be to have all the vessels fitted during the dry dock period, and therefore to be fully tested and go into service following their annual overhaul. The complexity is that the annual overhaul programme begins in September and completes in March, and it is likely to be November by the time the contract award is mobilised. We are targeting March for the roll-out, but the feedback from suppliers is that doing 29 vessels in less than three months is optimistic. It is likely that the core network—the central switch part of the network—will be installed by the beginning of next year. We expect the port offices and slipways, including wi-fi, to be operational around March or April. As for the vessels themselves, some will be operational in the first quarter and some may get delayed until the second quarter—particularly those that have to be done while in transit. During that period, some of our vessels will be operating 24 hours a day, with two crews on board, which presents particular operational challenges in putting access points in passenger areas and crew quarters. I expect that we will have fully completed the roll-out by June of next year, and we will endeavour to do it as quickly as possible, but it will depend on the suppliers and there is obviously a price sensitivity. If somebody says, “Yes, we can do it by March, but it’ll be three times the price,” we will clearly have to take a commercial decision on whether that is appropriate.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

I am a bit confused. I understood from the initial statements that it would be done in January or February.

Robbie Drummond CalMac Ferries Ltd
link

That will be the start of the roll-out programme, but it depends on what the suppliers come back to us with. It will be delivered not all at once but as a series of rolled-through deliveries.

Roger Willison-Gray CalMac Ferries Ltd
link

We can set an aggressive programme, but the bottom line will be whether the contractors can deliver to it and achieve best value for the Government. It would not be prudent for us to accept a ridiculous price point to get it in by March.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

The sooner the better. As someone who travels on the Isle of Lewis vessel, I know that it is quite frustrating not being able to get on with work when you are travelling between Ullapool and Stornoway.

Robbie Drummond CalMac Ferries Ltd
link

We accept that.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Will some vessels not be available for certain periods because of the wi-fi work that is being carried out, or can that work be done when they are in transit?

Roger Willison-Gray CalMac Ferries Ltd
link

It depends on the vessels. Not only do we have 26 vessels, but no more than two of them are of the same type and configuration, so we have 13 pairs of different vessels with different layouts. Some can be done in transit and some cannot. The majority of the smaller vessels do not operate after about 10 o’clock at night and there is no resident crew, so they are relatively easy to do. Where there are resident crew on board, it can be much more complex to work around legal rest periods and other interruptions. We will put in the best optimised programme that we can at the price point that we think is acceptable and represents good value for the Government.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Is there a likelihood of any interruption for customers? That is the point that I was trying to make.

Roger Willison-Gray CalMac Ferries Ltd
link

No, we will not be taking vessels out of service to fit wi-fi.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

For clarification, are you saying that all vessels, including the three reserve vessels, will be fitted with wi-fi by June 2014?

Roger Willison-Gray CalMac Ferries Ltd
link

As I said, there is a caveat: it depends on the award of contract and on the schedule that the suppliers provide, but we believe that there is no reason why we cannot achieve it by June of next year.

Robbie Drummond CalMac Ferries Ltd
link

Yes, for all vessels. The only caveat is around the timing and the practicality of getting the programme completed.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

A thought has occurred to me while listening to Mr Drummond—perhaps he can clarify whether it is an uncharitable thought on my part. From what I have gleaned so far, my understanding is that you entered into the programme because wi-fi is a service that you want to provide in its own right. Given your response, is the programme in fact an incidental benefit that arises from the much wider solution that you are seeking to implement across the entire business, including the head office and other facilities, and a part of the wider look at your provision, rather than because providing a wi-fi service in isolation emerged as an objective that you particularly sought out? Was it conditional on the wider service solution that you were trying to provide that wi-fi had to be a feature of that work or, had that not been the case, would wi-fi still be something that we would hope that you would do rather than something that you were committed to doing?

Robbie Drummond CalMac Ferries Ltd
link

Absolutely—it is an element of the wider solution that we are putting in place. We are renewing the network right across our business, which will allow us to operate more effectively. We will also give access to our workforce and our customers. The difficulty does not relate to the system being wireless; the difficulty relates to the network that sits behind it. Our approach is the most sensible way of providing the service as part of a much wider programme.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

We are a bit behind time. As colleagues have no final questions, I again thank Barra Youth Council for its excellent petition. The members who visited Stornoway will recall that the three women gave a first-class presentation on the petition. They showed great initiative.I do not know at what stage CalMac’s plans were or whether the petition helped develop its ideas or whether it was planning to introduce wi-fi anyway. Nevertheless, I will be charitable and say that I am glad that CalMac is going ahead with the service.It seems sensible to close the petition, under rule 15.7, on the basis that CalMac has initiated a networks project and that it will conclude that process as soon as possible. Do members agree?Members indicated agreement.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I thank our four guests for coming along. I am sorry that we have delayed you. Some of the questions were technical, and others were financial. Your responses helped the committee to understand what Serco NorthLink is doing and what CalMac is pursuing. Both are very important companies in relation to the development of ferry services in Scotland.I briefly suspend the meeting to allow a changeover of witnesses.11:37 Meeting suspended.

11:38 On resuming—

  1. 10:00 Interests Procedure · 3
  2. 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 91
  3. 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 84
  4. 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 72
  5. 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 31
  6. 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 3
  7. 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  8. 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  9. 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  10. 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 12
  11. 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  12. 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  13. 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  14. 10:00 Correspondence Committee business · 1

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.