Our next item is consideration of two petitions. We will deal with them one at a time. The first petition, PE1487, was lodged by Mark Gordon and the Scottish Secular Society. It calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to amend the Education (Scotland) Act 1980 by making religious observance in public schools an opt-in rather than opt-out activity.Committee members will note the Scottish Government’s view on the petition, which it submitted to the Public Petitions Committee. The Government believes that the current legislation and guidance on religious observance are relevant and up to date, and it is not persuaded that a move to an opt-in system would be helpful to young learners. In addition, we have received a number of submissions for committee members’ consideration.I throw it open to members to express views, make comments or suggest actions that they wish to take in relation to the petition.
Official Report · Committee
Public Petitions
Schools (Religious Observance) (PE1487)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Stewart Maxwell SNP 10
- Mary Scanlon Con 4
- Liam McArthur LD 3
- Colin Beattie SNP 1
- Gordon MacDonald SNP 1
- Jayne Baxter Lab 1
The record
20 contributionsI would like to make a public announcement: I support the Government. Laughter. You will not hear that very often, but there you are. I have read the papers through; the Government’s approach to the petition is reasonable.I am not entirely sure that every parent is fully aware of the guidance. According to the briefing that we have received, the guidance states:“This right should always be made known to parents and their wishes respected. Parents should be provided with sufficient information on which to base a decision.”I am not sure that every parent is given that advice on the right to opt out when their child starts school. The Scottish Government may wish to remind local authorities that that should be included in the guidance that is given to every parent who has a child at a school.
link
I agree with Mary Scanlon’s suggestion and her comments about the availability of information. However, even if they are armed with that information, parents in different parts of the country can have experiences that vary significantly. The steps that the Public Petitions Committee has taken are the steps that we would, under normal circumstances, have recommended. I am not sure how we can take the matter further.
I agree with both members. The Public Petitions Committee has taken oral and written evidence and it has written to the Government, which has written back, laying out its position. Those are measures that we would have undertaken, had they not already been undertaken.For me, it comes down to parents’ knowledge about their rights. As has been said, parents and young people may not be aware of their rights on the issue. Mary Scanlon has suggested that we write to the Government, asking it to encourage local authorities to ensure that parents are made aware of their rights.
Yes—local authorities should give parents the information and make sure that they are armed with it.
At the moment, there is a legal requirement to include information about the right to withdraw from religious observance in the school handbook, and I am sure that local authorities do that. The issue that we are discussing is whether parents are aware of that right or whether there should be more proactive provision of the information, which may be a little bit hidden from parents and young people.
link
I referred earlier to the implications if a parent elects to withdraw their child—or if a child elects to withdraw—from that aspect of school activity. The implications may be clear in some instances but not in others. I am not sure whether that is covered in the code that schools are required to observe, but it would be helpful to know the implications. Knowing one’s right is one thing, but knowing the implications of exercising that right is equally important.
Are you talking about the meaningful activity that the individual pupil would undertake?
link
I am talking about how a school might be expected to respect the right. For example, rather than exclude an individual child, certain schools that I have had direct personal involvement with will find a different way of delivering a particular activity. I suspect that it would be more illustrative than didactic, but it would be useful information for parents or children on how they might go about exercising their right.
A couple of points have been made. I will try to break this down a bit. Are members content that—in the first instance, at least—we write to the Government, asking it to encourage local authorities to make sure that parents are aware of the right? That is Mary Scanlon’s suggestion.Members indicated agreement.
Should we include in that letter Liam McArthur’s suggestion that local authorities go beyond that and provide information on the implications of withdrawing and on the meaningful activity that individual pupils would undertake?Members indicated agreement.
It now comes down to what we do with the petition. We have a number of options. We could take further evidence, we could write out, we could consult, we could ask the Government for a further response or we could close the petition. What are members’ views?11:45
As Liam McArthur said, a considerable amount of work has been done on the petition. The weakness—if there is a weakness—is in the guidance and ensuring that people are fully informed. I do not see any benefit in taking further evidence, which would only duplicate the excellent work that the Public Petitions Committee has done. I suppose that I am therefore suggesting that the petition be closed.
link
I agree with Mary Scanlon.
I also agree with Mary Scanlon.
And I agree with the Government.
That is twice that Mary Scanlon has agreed with the Government.
I do not see what we could add to the work that has already been done, so I think that it is reasonable to close the petition.
The only other thing that I will say, from a personal point of view, is that most parents are probably unaware that they have the right to opt out. I am sure that young people are also unaware of the right. For me, it is a matter of free choice that the individual can decide whether or not to attend. I therefore emphasise that it is important that individual families be aware of their legal right. I am less concerned about the law, as long as it is available to families and individuals to choose whether or not to attend. Their being made aware of that right would be my priority.I agree that the Public Petitions Committee has taken all the steps that we would have taken, so I am not sure what else we could add. I therefore agree with Mary Scanlon and others that we write to the petitioners saying that we are closing the petition. I suppose that, in addition to the committee writing to the Government to urge it to ensure that parents are aware of the right, the petitioners could urge COSLA and individual local authorities to ensure that parents are aware of it. Are members content with that proposal?Members indicated agreement.
Thank you. We will close the petition and write to the Government on that basis.
In this meeting
Everything on 6 May 2014 →- 10:00 Historic Environment Scotland Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 123
- 10:00 Public Petitions Petitions · 20
- 10:00 Public Petitions Petitions · 8
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.