MSP
Tim Eagle
Distinctive phrases: lotting · deer · lotting decision · naturescot · rural support · deer management · land management · muirburn · support plan · small farmer
-
17 Nov 2026NHS Grampian
There has been a lot of chat about governance and oversight, and there is no doubt that there have been failures at chief executive and board level. However, to get real for a second: NHS Grampian has been monitored by the Scottish Government at stage 2 since…
-
12 Nov 2026Scottish Local Government Elections (Candidacy Rights of Commonwealth Citizens) Bill: Stage 1
I am really sorry, but I am out of time. What I seek, if the bill does pass at stage 1 today, is the right for a full debate in the Parliament, and I seek that debate through the new right to stand bill.15:22
-
12 Nov 2026Scottish Local Government Elections (Candidacy Rights of Commonwealth Citizens) Bill: Stage 1
I will make a little bit of progress before I come back. I do try to take as many interventions as I can.As has been pointed out, 77 per cent of respondents to the Government’s 2023 consultation opposed the extension of the rights. After the committee’s decis…
-
12 Nov 2026Scottish Local Government Elections (Candidacy Rights of Commonwealth Citizens) Bill: Stage 1
I just do not buy the argument that this is a far-right campaign. I point out that, at committee, we heard evidence from a wide range of different people. To suggest that this is from the far right is just dangerously wrong.Scotland is an outlier in this area…
-
12 Nov 2026Scottish Local Government Elections (Candidacy Rights of Commonwealth Citizens) Bill: Stage 1
I do not know who was first. I will take Emma Roddick’s intervention.
-
12 Nov 2026Scottish Local Government Elections (Candidacy Rights of Commonwealth Citizens) Bill: Stage 1
I will make a tiny bit of progress, then I might come back to the members.Let me be clear that that does not make someone on a temporary visa a security threat, that foreign interference can involve people of any nationality and that the Government has not re…
-
12 Nov 2026Scottish Local Government Elections (Candidacy Rights of Commonwealth Citizens) Bill: Stage 1
Of course, I do not think that hostile states will put all their—what was it—evil-aligned hopes on to the back of people with limited leave to remain. However, foreign states are interfering in this country’s election process—we heard that from the Electoral …
-
12 Nov 2026Scottish Local Government Elections (Candidacy Rights of Commonwealth Citizens) Bill: Stage 1
The convener of the committee—I will correct the record if I am wrong, but I think that I am right in saying that it was the convener—noted that. That point was widely debated in committee and, although I cannot speak for the latter, my view was that our doin…
-
12 Nov 2026Scottish Local Government Elections (Candidacy Rights of Commonwealth Citizens) Bill: Stage 1
You know, I think that I will actually live quite happily with Lorna Slater’s shame and disappointment. I do not need to be told in this chamber that I cannot think for myself. However, that was the usual type of personalised comment that I would expect from …
-
12 Nov 2026Electoral Commission
If it is a communications problem, we need to learn from that and improve it.The geography issue is slightly redundant—that argument could be made if the count was done overnight, but all the boxes came in overnight and were there and ready to go the next mor…
-
12 Nov 2026Electoral Commission
Good luck with that. It is a challenge, because there are grey areas. We want to enable debate while at the same time ensuring that the debate is as fair as possible.I have one other question. Long after most of the candidates who were successful in May were …
-
12 Nov 2026Electoral Commission
Are you resourced for that? You are right to say that the situation will potentially get worse before it gets better. We will hopefully reach a point where, as you mentioned earlier, technology will defeat technology, to some extent, but do you need more reso…
-
12 Nov 2026Electoral Commission
I strongly support the points that have just been made about young people. Some of the toughest conversations that I have ever had were in a primary 7 classroom. Last week, I got completely grilled over the closure of the slides in Inverness swimming pool, an…
-
11 Nov 2026Portfolio Question Time
I am not sure that the Scottish National Party truly understands the implications for the private rented sector and its vitalness in supporting our economy. I know of young people, doctors, dentists and businesses all seeking private rented accommodation—home…
-
10 Nov 2026Winter Resilience
I do not think that the Scottish National Party has yet twigged the connection between the summer wildfires and the recent flooding. How can the cabinet secretary come to the chamber and say that he regularly assesses plans if, for both incidents, the respons…
-
10 Nov 2026General Question Time
This is a bit of a mess. The site is a palliative care centre on the outskirts of Elgin. It has no direct bus service, it is open for only four hours on a Friday afternoon, there are very serious concerns about infection control and it will likely rely on loc…
-
10 Nov 2026General Question Time
I voluntarily remind members of an interest: my wife is a GP partner.To ask the Scottish Government what evidence informed its view that a four-hour walk-in general practitioner centre operating on Friday afternoons in Elgin will be sufficient to meet local h…
-
5 Nov 2026World Diabetes Day 2026
That is exactly the right point to make. As I say, I am not coming to this from the perspective of knowing a lot, which is why I would like to meet representatives of the Diabetes Safety Organisation again. The lady I was speaking to yesterday was making the …
-
5 Nov 2026World Diabetes Day 2026
I congratulate Colm Merrick on securing the debate. I also congratulate Diabetes Scotland on all the very effective work that it does in supporting and advocating for people who live with diabetes. I am not one of those, although I recognise that, as I get ol…
-
5 Nov 2026Strengthening Scotland’s Bus Network
I think that most people in the chamber agree that we want better buses, but what we need is for you to deliver them. At the moment—and since 2019—your party has not done that.
-
5 Nov 2026Strengthening Scotland’s Bus Network
Thank you for allowing the intervention. I was just hoping that, at some point, you would stop banging on and moaning about other parties and talk about the delivery of what we have been discussing—
-
5 Nov 2026Strengthening Scotland’s Bus Network
Will the cabinet secretary take an intervention?
-
5 Nov 2026Strengthening Scotland’s Bus Network
I think that Willie Rennie missed the Highlands and Islands off his list.I will be quick, because I know that we are pushed for time. Stephen Flynn mentioned lifeline services, and public transport in the Western Isles genuinely is a lifeline service. I hope …
-
5 Nov 2026Strengthening Scotland’s Bus Network
To some extent, here we go again, with Stephen Flynn, along with the SNP, announcing more plans, some parts of which I admit that I agree with and some I do not. However, for members who have been in the chamber for a little more than a few hours, it becomes …
-
5 Nov 2026General Question Time
I am immensely proud of the campaigners who have worked tirelessly to show that the Moray FLOW-Park is not required in the area. They have told me that the exclusivity agreement with Crown Estate Scotland runs out in March 2027. Will the minister give a cast-…
-
5 Nov 2026General Question Time
To ask the Scottish Government whether it will provide an update on its position on the proposed Moray FLOW-Park development. (S7O-00453)
-
5 Nov 2026Scottish Information Commissioner
Grand. Those are all my questions.
-
5 Nov 2026Scottish Information Commissioner
That is good to hear. Fundamentally, the message that I would send to organisations is that, if they do not want a huge amount of AI requests to come in, they should put the information out there. In an information age—which is becoming more and more apparent…
-
5 Nov 2026Scottish Information Commissioner
It does, and that is the interesting thing. It would be far better to admit those mistakes early on, because they come out and, ultimately, cause problems.Please tell me if I am pressing on the wrong point, but your organisation is also under significant budg…
-
5 Nov 2026Scottish Information Commissioner
My confusion arises from the fact that we have had FOI for quite a long time now, yet we still have a culture of protectionism around our own little spaces. I get that, to some extent, because things go wrong and mistakes happen when service organisations suc…
-
5 Nov 2026Scottish Information Commissioner
Good morning. That was a useful segue at the end. So far this morning, we have looked at the issue from the user perspective and at whether it is fair or right that users can chuck in 600 requests. To flip that around, do you think that it is fair to ask abou…
-
4 Nov 2026Business Motion
I think that the ability to challenge a business motion is a Ken Macintosh legacy, is it not? Although, as the business manager for the Scottish Conservatives, I have made a request for a statement in the appropriate way, by taking it to the Minister for Parl…
-
4 Nov 2026Business Motion
Will the minister take an intervention?
-
29 Oct 2026Transport Connectivity (Rural Scotland)
Does the member agree that the Borders railway is a brilliant example? Although I do not know much about it, my understanding is that the passenger numbers and economic benefit resulting from the railway far exceed the initial expectations, so, if there is th…
-
29 Oct 2026Transport Connectivity (Rural Scotland)
It is not the landowner who is causing the problem in that instance. I am not aware of any landowners in my own patch who are causing such problems, but where there is community support, and where we can get landowners on side, we should. My point is that if …
-
29 Oct 2026Transport Connectivity (Rural Scotland)
I absolutely agree. It is a very well-made point. I have stood on Baleshare causeway in the pouring rain. There is a nurse who lives on that island who struggles to get to work some days. It is a vital part of the local community. I absolutely agree that such…
-
29 Oct 2026Transport Connectivity (Rural Scotland)
I say a massive thank you in advance to all those who will speak this evening. When I came into Parliament in 2024, I remember thinking about what the one issue that I would constantly come back to would be. Ultimately, I decided that that it would be rural d…
-
28 Oct 2026Portfolio Question Time
I have always understood that the primary aim is to treat people in a hospital-at-home setting as much as possible. Most people agree that they want that. However, in large parts of rural Scotland, and particularly the Highlands and Islands, that is unachieva…
-
28 Oct 2026Pre-budget Scrutiny 2027-28
There is no doubt in your mind that the dualling of those roads could fundamentally change and benefit rural communities in the future.
-
28 Oct 2026Pre-budget Scrutiny 2027-28
Exactly.
-
28 Oct 2026Pre-budget Scrutiny 2027-28
On a wider point, Shan Saba, you mentioned a fiscal problem, meaning the money. A lot of you are very positive about your engagement with Transport Scotland. The interesting issue is that, although such engagement can be quite positive at the beginning, what …
-
28 Oct 2026Pre-budget Scrutiny 2027-28
It was highlighted earlier that there is some debate about the option that has been put forward. Does it frustrate you and the group that you did not feel completely listened to in the making of Transport Scotland’s ultimate decision for a sort of half tunnel…
-
28 Oct 2026Pre-budget Scrutiny 2027-28
I have two quick questions. Thank you, John, for those answers. To an extent, most of the questions have been answered and you have explained very well the problems at the Rest and Be Thankful.I live next to the A96, which Shan Saba talked about. Despite all …
-
1 Oct 2026Highlands and Islands Regional Air Strategy
I completely agree with that. I have not been on that Benbecula flight—I do not know whether Donald MacKinnon has. One of the cancer patients whom I spoke to in Benbecula said that they almost had to crawl over seats in order to get to the back of the plane, …
-
1 Oct 2026Highlands and Islands Regional Air Strategy
I thank Liam McArthur for bringing this incredibly important debate to the chamber. I also congratulate his son Tom, who I think won a bronze medal, if I have read the member’s Instagram posts right. We should always celebrate young people across Scotland and…
-
1 Oct 2026Representation of the People Bill
Professor James, do you have anything to add on that? It is always helpful to learn whether something has worked well and whether we could do more. On the practical side, are there any administrative inconsistencies between what we do in Scotland and what wou…
-
1 Oct 2026Representation of the People Bill
I thank the witnesses for their answers.I want to look specifically at young people. It has been 10 or 11 years since Scotland introduced the right to vote for 16 and 17-year-olds, and the UK bill seeks to introduce the same thing for UK elections. What have …
-
1 Oct 2026Scottish Local Government Elections (Candidacy Rights of Commonwealth Citizens) Bill: Stage 1
So there is nothing. Because you are not doing the research, we do not have any of that data.
-
1 Oct 2026Scottish Local Government Elections (Candidacy Rights of Commonwealth Citizens) Bill: Stage 1
Okay. We can come on to that in future.Did we learn anything from the recent Scottish Parliament election about how many people with limited leave to remain chose to stand?
-
1 Oct 2026Scottish Local Government Elections (Candidacy Rights of Commonwealth Citizens) Bill: Stage 1
So why do you think that that was not picked up—or can you not say?
Search matches debate headings only. For the words spoken, use the Official Report search filtered to this MSP.