Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

“Renewable energy”

Wednesday 2 October 2013 Public Audit Committee About 10:00 Committee business 45 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

45 contributions
Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

The next item on the agenda is a section 23 report on renewable energy. I invite Caroline Gardner to brief the committee.

Caroline Gardner
link

The Scottish Government estimates that renewable energy could deliver up to £30 billion of investment and 14,000 jobs in Scotland by 2020. In addition, renewable energy could contribute to reducing emissions and providing a more secure energy supply.The Government wants renewable sources to meet 30 per cent of Scotland’s energy use by 2020. Realising the potential of renewable energy is central to the Government’s economic strategy and its goal of sustainable economic growth.Members will be aware that the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee conducted a wide-ranging inquiry into the renewable energy targets last year. Our report complements that inquiry by examining what the public sector has done to develop renewable energy, what investment it has made and what has been delivered to date. We focused on activity and investment by the Scottish Government, Scottish Enterprise and Highlands and Islands Enterprise. It is worth noting that we did not examine the role of the planning system or the consents process in assessing applications for renewable energy projects.Overall, we found that the Scottish Government is providing clear leadership, direction and ambition for the development of renewable energy. It has a clear strategy to 2020 that is well linked to other policy areas such as housing and planning and to the strategic priorities of other public bodies. The Government’s renewable energy targets demonstrate considerable ambition for the sector, and particularly for renewable electricity, for which the 100 per cent target is much higher than the UK Government’s 30 per cent target. The Scottish Government has made steady progress towards its targets, but achieving them will be challenging and will rely on significant activity and investment over the next seven years.The development of renewable energy relies largely on investment from the private sector. Attracting, encouraging and enabling that investment is the focus of activity and funding by the Scottish Government, Scottish Enterprise and Highlands and Islands Enterprise. For example, the two enterprise agencies have together invested £43 million in specific ports and harbours around Scotland to make them suitable for use by the offshore wind and marine energy industries. Collectively, the Government and the two enterprise agencies spent more than £209 million on delivering renewable energy over the 11 years to March 2013. More than 90 per cent of that—£193 million—was spent in the past six years, since March 2007, and funding is increasing. Exhibit 6 on page 19 of the report illustrates the scale of the increase.The budgets for the next two years—2013-14 and 2014-15—total £264 million, which is intended to lever in billions of pounds-worth of private sector investment. However, the current financial climate is making potential investors more cautious. Uncertainties about reforms to UK energy policy, the cost and reliability of new technologies and access to the national grid are also delaying investment decisions. Those issues are not exclusive to Scotland, and the Government is working with the UK Government to try to address them. We recommend that the Scottish Government and the two enterprise agencies identify what specific additional steps they can take to accelerate progress, especially in relation to offshore wind.The uncertainty means that projects that are eligible for public sector funding are not progressing as quickly as anticipated, and public bodies are experiencing delays in spending some of the money that is available to them. When the finance secretary presented his draft budget for 2014-15 to the Parliament last month, he proposed that the £101 million budget for the Scottish Government’s renewable energy investment fund should be extended over an extra year to 2015-16 to reflect the lower-than-expected progress.The report is positive overall, but we make three specific recommendations to build on the progress that has been achieved so far. First, total investment in the Scottish economy by the renewable energy industry is not monitored, although Scottish Enterprise and Highlands and Islands Enterprise individually monitor private sector investment in the projects that they fund. We think that the Scottish Government should collate that information and report at a national level how much the private sector has invested in renewable energy projects that have received public funding.Secondly, as I mentioned earlier, the Government estimates that renewable energy could deliver up to 40,000 jobs by 2020. However, we found that the assumptions that were used to reach that estimate are based on optimistic scenarios. For example, 28,000 of the estimated 40,000 jobs are in the offshore wind sector, but this assumes that there will be twice as much offshore wind capacity in 2020 than current industry estimates suggest. We therefore recommend that the Scottish Government works with its partners to ensure that revised employment projections, which are due by the end of the year, are realistic.Finally, I highlight our recommendation that the Scottish Government should set out how it aims to develop renewable energy beyond 2020 and should develop targets to reflect that. That will be important in demonstrating to potential investors the Government’s long-term commitment to developing renewable energy.As ever, convener, we will be happy to try to answer the committee’s questions.12:30

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

I know that it is not Audit Scotland’s responsibility to recommend changes in policy, practice or priorities, but given the discussion that we have just had on housing, was any work done to estimate the financial benefit to individual households and, more significantly, to the public purse of implementing a change to housing and planning policy to require new-build properties to have certain minimum standards of insulation and/or solar panels installed?

Caroline Gardner
link

I ask Mark Roberts to pick up on that, based on what we know about the interrelationship between those two policy areas in the Government.

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

In the context of this audit, we did not look at policies to encourage take-up of insulation or the use of solar panels at the individual level. Obviously, those are important in the Government’s wider low-carbon strategy but not within the context of this audit or the work of the two enterprise agencies, which was the primary focus.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

I was not asking about steps to encourage take-up; I was asking whether any consideration was given to the financial benefit to the public purse of investing in higher insulation standards and, perhaps more significantly, solar panels at the new-build stage. For example, rather than encourage individual householders to apply for grants, there might be a requirement for solar panels to be installed as a matter of course in new-build properties. What would be the costs and long-term benefits of that and what is the cost benefit ratio? Is there any value to the management of public finances of doing that at the planning and construction stage rather than have to react and to encourage individual households to do it at a later stage?

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

There is an interesting potential piece of work to look at what the longer-term benefits might be if building standards were changed to require higher insulation standards or renewable energy technologies. However, within this piece of work, we did not do any of those calculations or look at those potential changes, so I could not comment further on that.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

The convener makes an interesting point, because the report is excellent and we are looking at next steps as much as at the content of the report, so that was a fair question.I will tread delicately with my question. The convener said that we might have an incentive to put solar panels on new-build houses, which might be like reducing VAT to incentivise that kind of thing. I do not want to blur devolved and reserved issues—that is not my reason for asking this question. I have a constituency interest in relation to a company called Gaia Wind, which makes small-scale wind turbines for farmers and individuals. The business model is very much based on UK Government feed-in tariffs to subsidise the turbines and bring them on line. Recent changes in feed-in tariffs mean that those microrenewables will pay for themselves after five years whereas, under the previous regime, it was three years. I will not drag in the details of feed-in tariffs, but in auditing what the Scottish Government is doing to achieve its ambitions on renewable energy, did you do any work on how that interacts with policy decisions elsewhere? I do not want to drag you into constitutional issues, because the question is not about that. It is about how we boost renewables in Scotland.

Caroline Gardner
link

I take the question in exactly the spirit that is intended. This area is a good example of a complex area that is made more complex by the current mix of devolved and reserved powers. We say in the report that the Scottish Government has ambitious targets that are well linked to its wider policy agenda and that it is doing a lot to make progress on meeting them. We are also clear about the parts of the UK energy policy that can make that harder. The first is to do with access to the national grid and the way in which that works. The second is to do with transmission charges for more remote parts of the UK. Mark Roberts might want to expand on that but, in broad terms, because of the limits of my responsibility in auditing the Scottish Government’s expenditure and the Scottish Parliament’s budget, we have focused on the existing boundaries of what is devolved while recognising that the issue has to be examined in the context of wider UK policy and wider economic factors, such as the current uncertainty about large financial investments.

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

To pick up on the points about the feed-in tariffs, one of the problems that the sector as a whole faces is uncertainty as to what happens in the future with feed-in tariffs and their potential replacement. That is tied in with the wider issue of the electricity market reform that is taking place at the UK level. As we say in the report, that has had an impact on the pace at which public bodies have been able to spend some of the money that the Government has made available to them because that uncertainty is slowing down the rate at which projects are coming on stream. People are waiting to see what happens and how the energy market reform is resolved before they commit to projects.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

I suspect that the detail of that will be for another committee but, given my constituency interest, I wanted to put some of it on the record.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I want to get a bit more clarity about jobs. My son is a civil engineer and a project manager for wind farms. However, when a wind farm is finished, the job is finished, so I appreciate that it is difficult to get a snapshot.In March last year, there were just over 11,000 jobs in renewable energy. That included 1,000 jobs in colleges, universities and the public sector, so we are talking about just over 10,000 jobs. The Auditor General mentioned jobs in her opening statement. Paragraph 74 of the report says that“the most optimistic scenario of 40,000 jobs”has been used in forecasts. That is apparently twice as many as the industry is suggesting for offshore jobs. The least optimistic scenario is around 13,000 jobs.Can we get a little bit of honesty? It will not be 40,000 jobs—it is not 40,000 jobs at the moment. There is a big difference between 13,000 and 40,000—one is three times the other. Are we looking at nearer 13,000 jobs? Is 40,000, in your own words, an “optimistic scenario”?

Caroline Gardner
link

The 40,000 certainly is an optimistic scenario. That is why I recommend that the revised forecasts that are due by the end of this year should be more realistic.Three things are going on. First, the current forecasts include a number of scenarios, which is good practice. When we are forecasting, by definition we do not know what will happen, so having and testing different assumptions is a good thing. Using the most optimistic one does not do justice to the complexity of that planning.Secondly, as we say, there has been a delay in some of the expected investment because of the wider uncertainty about the investment required, much of which it is outside the Government’s control and reflects market conditions or UK energy policy.Thirdly, what is a renewables job is not always clear.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I was just about to come to that. Is it fair to include almost 1,000 jobs in colleges, universities and the public sector? Would those people lose their jobs if we stopped building wind farms?

Caroline Gardner
link

I ask Mark Roberts to take you through that. He has focused a lot of attention on that question and can give you a better answer than I can.

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

The figure of 11,000 is based on a survey carried out by Scottish Renewables, the organisation that represents the renewables industry in Scotland. It is in the process of trying to revise that figure for 2013, and I expect to see the revised figure in the next few weeks.As the Auditor General said, it is hard to understand exactly what a renewables job is. It is difficult to define. People who work for engineering consultancies, divers and maintenance crews may well work in the oil and gas industry as well as in marine renewables environments. That is why, when we spoke to the enterprise agencies, they said that it was hard even to get a firm handle on exactly what an energy job—in the widest sense—is, let alone a renewables job, because many of the skills are transferable between sectors.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

The temporary nature of the jobs must also be taken into account.

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

We do not have any information on whether they are permanent or temporary roles.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

My second question concerns exhibit 7 on page 23, which is on public and private sector investment in ports and harbours. Orkney and Shetland were left out of “Scotland’s colleges 2013”. I did not want to ask about that when we discussed that report under item 2, but they are also left out of the information in exhibit 7. The Western Isles are mentioned, but not Orkney and Shetland. Have they not been investing in their ports and harbours?

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

The various dots on the map in exhibit 7 show the 11 ports and harbours that were identified in the national renewables infrastructure plan back in 2010. There was one site on Lewis and there were no sites on Orkney and Shetland in that plan, but that is not to say that there has not been investment in ports and harbours on Orkney and Shetland, supported in part by HIE. However, that was outside the scope of the national renewables infrastructure plan.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I am slightly surprised by that, but never mind.An estimated total of £253 million is needed. I think that the largest investment that is being sought—£36 million—is at Ardersier, which is just outside Inverness. Where will that money come from?

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

It is expected that the vast majority of it will come from private sector investments in building facilities at ports and harbours to allow the development of predominantly offshore wind facilities but also the wider marine technologies and wave and tidal facilities that the Government hopes for.The six sites for which Scottish Enterprise has responsibility are illustrated with purplish dots on the map. The initial estimates were that they required £164 million-worth of investments to upgrade them to the necessary level. Scottish Enterprise put aside £70 million to try to support that investment, leaving the balance to come from the private sector.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Given that the figure for Hunterston is £65 million, that is quite a significant amount from the private sector.

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

Yes.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Would the amount for the Highlands also be met by the private sector?

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

Yes.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

That is quite a significant amount.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

The Government and many of the rest of us support greater community ownership of renewables, but that does not seem to have been a phenomenal success so far. There is a section on that on page 20 of the report.

Caroline Gardner
link

I will ask Mark Roberts to come in with more detail on that. That is one of the issues that we highlight in the report as having been made more difficult by the current economic climate in which people are working. The Government has two schemes: the community and renewable energy scheme—CARES—and the renewable energy investment fund. The schemes are intended to help communities to take advantage of the opportunity to invest in renewables schemes in their areas, if I can put it in that way, but both have been slower to take off than the Government expected. I ask Mark Roberts to talk through why that has been the case.

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

One of the challenges that projects face is their financing. CARES, to which the Auditor General referred, is controlled to a certain extent by European regulations, which broadly specify the interest rates that have to be charged. The rates are relatively high, which reflects the perceived risks of some of the projects. Perhaps communities are less willing to take on those risks and attract the high interest payments. Formerly, many of those projects were financed by grant funding and no risk was associated with them, whereas now community groups and perhaps individuals are finding it harder to take on the risks, as they have to raise money from the market.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

You do not seem to have made any recommendations about that. Do you have any recommendations on how community ownership could be improved?

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

We have not made recommendations about that. The Government evaluated CARES fairly recently, and responsibility for the organisation that runs and delivers the scheme has changed. Having taken that on in August this year, it is looking at evaluating whether it can find ways to improve accessibility for community groups, for example. I expect it to report on that in the relatively near future so that we can see what the best way forward might be to address exactly the issue that you have raised.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Do you make an overall assessment of the main beneficiaries of the renewables expansion and who they are? Do you assess who owns the companies that make the turbines and wind farms and who owns the energy that is produced?12:45

Caroline Gardner
link

We have not made that analysis so far, as it is not necessary to do so in looking at progress against the Government’s targets and the investment that it has made. Those are all relevant considerations in evaluating the wider economic benefit, although we have not looked at them as part of this work. That evaluation would need to take account of the wider constraints that come from global trade obligations and our membership of the European Union.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I have a final question. According to your recommendations, the Government does not appear to have“a methodology to monitor its target for overall energy demand”.Do you think that that is a gap?

Caroline Gardner
link

Not necessarily, but I ask Mark Roberts to tell you about that.

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

The overall energy demand target of 30 per cent of energy demand being met from renewable sources by 2020 is made up of the heat, transport and electricity targets. To put it crudely, if you add those three together you will get an indication of the overall energy demand. The Government is working on refining the method behind that, and our recommendation encourages it to ensure that it does that. By chance, because of those three targets, it is currently about a third of the way towards meeting the overall energy demand target.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Auditor General, there were three main messages in your summary. One was about monitoring private sector investment and another was on the issue of the 40,000 jobs. I want to focus on the third one: the implications for all of us—for the Scottish Government and the Scottish population—post 2020. My attention is drawn to the chart on page 13 of your report, which contrasts starkly the renewables revolution in Scotland and what is happening in the UK. I draw your attention to the electricity generation circle, which shows that we expect 100 per cent of electricity in Scotland to be generated from renewables by 2020 compared to a UK figure of 30 per cent. Going back to your third message about the situation post 2020, is there an opportunity for Scotland and the Scottish Government to develop the renewables revolution here further to capture some of the UK market and help our neighbours down south to keep their lights on?

Caroline Gardner
link

I am not sure that I can answer that question directly. The reason why we made our recommendation is that—this is, in some ways, similar to the situation with housing—the up-front investment that is needed is significant and needs to be made over a long period. In any circumstances, but particularly in the current economic climate, it is important that any Government gives potential investors as much certainty as possible about its commitment over a long period of time to a particular policy area and the targets that underpin it.The question of how we see our energy supply policy and how it links to energy security and economic revenue streams is a wider policy question for the Government that I do not think we are equipped to answer.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Willie Coffey asked about sales. Have you looked at how much it costs to generate renewable energy and what the subsidies are?

Caroline Gardner
link

You will see from our report that that is not a major part of what we have done, but I ask Mark Roberts to talk you through our thinking in that area.

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

The cost of renewable energy is very much dependent on the maturity of the technology. Big efforts are being made to reduce to a certain level the cost per megawatt in, for example, offshore wind. The technology, engineering and infrastructure are not there yet, so electricity that is generated in that way will be more expensive. With technologies that are at an even earlier stage in their development—for example, wave and tidal—the cost per unit of electricity is higher still. Part of the economic prize that is being sought is a reduction in that cost to enable Scotland to market and sell the expertise more widely.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Our aspiration to sell on significant amounts of renewable energy by 2020 will depend on how much it costs us to produce it and how much the market is able to sustain.

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

That is absolutely the case, yes.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Okay. Thank you for that. It is a very interesting report that throws up a number of challenges for the future.12:49 Meeting continued in private until 13:25.

  1. 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 180
  3. 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 145
  4. 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 45

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.