Agenda item 2 is consideration of the section 23 report “Scotland’s colleges 2013”. Obviously, this issue has been of considerable interest over the past year and more, so the report is timeous. I invite the Auditor General to brief the committee on her report.
Official Report · Committee
Section 23 Reports
“Scotland’s colleges 2013”
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland 64
- Hugh Henry Lab 26
- Ken Macintosh Lab 20
- Tavish Scott LD 15
- Graeme Greenhill Audit Scotland 11
- Mary Scanlon Con 11
- Colin Beattie SNP 10
- Phil Grigor Audit Scotland 8
- Ronnie Nicol Audit Scotland 5
- Bob Doris SNP 4
- Willie Coffey SNP 3
- James Dornan SNP 3
The record
180 contributionsAs the committee is aware, we published a report in October last year that assessed the financial standing of Scotland’s colleges immediately before the structural reforms and planned public sector spending reductions took effect. That report also summarised progress towards the establishment of 13 new college regions, with the intention of establishing a position against which the progress of the reforms could be measured later.In August this year, we published an update report, which covers colleges’ financial standing in the academic year 2011-12 and how much learning they delivered. The report also summarises the college sector’s recent progress towards regionalisation and examines some of the key issues that colleges are likely to face in the coming years.We found that the overall financial standing of the college sector continued to be generally sound. Colleges reported an overall operating surplus of £2 million compared with an overall deficit of £29 million in 2010-11, but most colleges continued to operate to tight financial margins, with the amount of the surplus or deficit rarely being more than 3 per cent of their income. Some colleges appear more financially sustainable than others, but there is often no discernible pattern in their ability to achieve a surplus from one year to the next.Colleges’ income has fallen in recent years, and that will continue for the foreseeable future. A £56 million real-terms reduction in grant funding from the Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council contributed to colleges’ overall income falling by 9 per cent between 2010-11 and 2011-12. The Scottish Government has announced budget increases for colleges totalling around £130 million since 2011, but colleges still face an 11 per cent real-terms cut in revenue funding between 2011-12 and the end of the current spending review period in 2014-15. Some college regions will face larger reductions in funding than others and will therefore need to reduce their costs more.Colleges achieved their sound overall financial position by reducing spending, mainly on staff. Between 2010-11 and 2011-12, there was a net reduction of around 1,200 full-time equivalent staff, with most reductions in teaching staff. Colleges reduced their recurring staff costs by £56 million in real terms. Staff costs form about 60 per cent of a typical college’s spending, so it is understandable that reducing staff numbers is the key way in which colleges have made savings. However, that creates risks, and it is important that colleges retain the right skills and experience that they need to maintain the quality of education that they deliver.On the issue of regionalisation and reform, most colleges are currently either merging or forming federations with other colleges to create the 13 new college regions. The structural reforms are aimed at helping colleges better to meet local needs for further education and to make savings through increased efficiency. The restructuring represents a major change for the sector. Colleges aim to complete the process as planned by the end of 2013. The total number of colleges will reduce from 37 in 2011-12 to just 21 by the end of this year.The funding council is providing around £54 million to help to fund regionalisation. Colleges are expected to meet up to half the total cost of individual mergers, but the amount that each college will contribute varies widely. The costs of recent and current mergers have still to be finalised, but the funding council expects the reforms to generate around £50 million in savings each year from 2015-16 onwards. We will monitor colleges’ progress on achieving those efficiencies and the other benefits that are planned from the reforms. We will also continue to monitor the sector’s progress towards other aspects of structural reform, including the further development of the outcome agreements that set out what colleges are expected to do in return for funding council funding.Colleges continue to meet their annual targets for providing education, but an increased emphasis on longer courses has led to a reduction in the total number of students who attend college. In line with Government policy, colleges are increasing the emphasis on full-time courses and prioritising education for younger students. That might limit learning opportunities for older people and other groups who prefer to study part time. It is therefore important that colleges monitor the demand for places to help to meet national priorities and local needs for further education.Finally, following a decision by the Office for National Statistics, all colleges in the United Kingdom will be reclassified as public bodies from 2014. That will require Scotland’s colleges to operate within the same system of annual budget limits as other Scottish Government bodies. In turn, that will restrict colleges’ ability to build up financial reserves. The Scottish Government and the funding council are currently engaging with the college sector to investigate ways of minimising the impact of reclassification on college finances.The report makes a number of recommendations to the Scottish Government, to the Scottish funding council and to colleges about what needs to happen to help the sector to address the future challenges. That includes: monitoring progress in achieving savings and the other benefits from mergers to help with financial planning; assessing and managing the impact of reclassification on the financial standing of colleges; identifying risks to future capacity, such as colleges’ ability to meet learning needs in the context of reduced staff numbers, and mitigating those risks when necessary; and monitoring the impact of prioritising younger students and full-time courses on the opportunities for older people and other groups and taking appropriate steps to address those needs when necessary.I intend to produce future reports on progress with reform to allow the committee to keep oversight of how this important policy initiative from the Government is progressing. For now, my colleagues and I will be happy to answer any questions that the committee might have.
Thank you. That is helpful. It is also helpful to know that there will a regular look at such a significant issue.Could you clarify a couple of figures? You said that, in 2010-11, there had been a reduction in income of 9 per cent and that, for the period 2011-12 and 2014-15, there would be a reduction of 11 per cent. Is that 11 per cent real-terms reduction on top of the 9 per cent real-terms reduction?
I will ask my colleagues to clarify that for you, convener. You are right; the picture is complex and there have been a number of shifts in the past couple of years. I ask Phil Grigor to respond to that question on my behalf.
The 9 per cent is the one-year difference between the 2010-11 and 2011-12 figures. The 11 per cent reduction is the difference between 2009-10 and 2011-12. The longer period of time explains the larger reduction.
Paragraph 25 of the report says:“A lack of cash can be an indicator that an organisation has financial problems. We therefore asked the auditors of Reid Kerr and Barony Colleges for their views on the colleges’ cash position. The auditors told us that these colleges normally operate to tight cash margins and they had no significant concerns over the colleges’ financial sustainability.”There are two parts to my question. First, have you had any expressions of concern about the funding position of any colleges in Scotland during the past year or 18 months?
I will ask Graeme Greenhill to pick up on the specific of the question, but it is important to be clear what the cash equivalents figure means. It is only a snapshot of a particular point in time: the final day of the financial year. The auditors of all the bodies for which I have responsibility are asked specifically to make a judgment about whether they think that the body involved is a going concern. There are therefore two tests being done. Graeme Greenhill will pick up on the question about financial pressures.
I do not think that we have had any indication that any one college is in significant financial trouble.
My question was not about significant trouble. I asked whether you had received any expressions of concern at all from any colleges.
No.
On the same page of the report, paragraph 24 talks about“the SFC’s ‘good practice’ minimum of 60 days’ cash”and Reid Kerr and Barony colleges are again mentioned as having less than one day in reserves. If that is not a concern, why does the Scottish funding council have that standard for good practice?
The 60 days’ cash minimum is intended to give colleges a certain amount of leeway in managing their cash and in the timing for income and paying their bills. Because Reid Kerr, Barony and Carnegie colleges had so little cash at the end of the financial year, we went back to the auditors specifically to ask about how those colleges operated. In the case of Carnegie, it was fairly clear from the accounts why the college did not have a lot of cash. It was less obvious in the cases of Reid Kerr and Barony, and those colleges had a history of not having a lot of cash at the end of the year. According to the auditors, that is basically the way that they operate, and the auditors did not express any concerns about it.There are potentially some questions about how the colleges manage their cash position. Under the circumstances in which the colleges find themselves, they have to pay close attention to their cash flows and the timing of when they receive money and pay their bills. Generally speaking, that is all manageable. There is a risk if there is a mismatch such that, at any one time, timing differences mean that the college runs out of cash; in that case, it would probably need to have recourse to its overdraft facilities. That borrowing can be expensive, although it is manageable if it is only for two or three days. If that was a routine approach—if the college had to borrow to support its day-to-day activities—we would not encourage it. In general, borrowing to support capital investment is often a good thing but borrowing to support day-to-day operational activities is rarely a good thing. However, neither Reid Kerr College nor Barony College is in that situation. We are fairly comfortable with the way in which they are operating.
We can ask the Scottish funding council why it has a 60 days’ cash minimum good practice standard. From your perspective, given that the standard has clearly not been adhered to, is it of any value to have a 60-day minimum standard if it really does not matter that much? Is there a point to it?
It is guidance. Some colleges, because of the way that they operate, are unable to generate cash.
I know that it is guidance, but I am asking you whether there is any point to it.
As accountants and auditors, we all feel that any public body needs to manage its liquidity—the amount of cash that it has available to meet outgoings as they fall due, in the way that Graeme Greenhill has ably described. Guidance is really the only way to put forward what good practice looks like. Everybody’s circumstances are different, and the risks that bodies run are different, depending on their ability to borrow. The funding council’s rule of thumb is 60 days, but it can be no more than that. The same is true of the liquidity ratios that are often used in the private sector to consider how liquid a company is.
I have a supplementary question on the point that the convener made about the 11 per cent fall in funding between 2010 and 2012. I am looking at exhibit 8 and paragraph 31 on page 18 of the report. The fall in teaching in those two years—the ability to offer courses and to deliver education and training—is £69 million, which, as I understand it, is referred to in the statement:“costs of teaching staff reduced by about 16 per cent”.The figure that you gave to the convener was 11 per cent. Was that for overall college funding, taking into account administration, catering and residential costs? It is the actual teaching that is critical. Can you confirm that the fall in teaching was £69 million over two years—a fall of 16 per cent in colleges’ ability in that regard? Is that correct?
We say in paragraph 31, which is above the exhibit that you referred to, that the teaching staff costs reduced by 16 per cent. I do not have the figure to hand, but 16 per cent is certainly the correct percentage reduction.10:15
That is significant compared with 11 per cent.I have some further short questions. Before I became a member of Parliament, I was a lecturer in further and higher education and I still see many colleagues in the Highlands. They have been asking me about national pay bargaining, which I understand is due to come in this year. As Tavish Scott will know, the colleges in the University of the Highlands and Islands tend to languish fairly near the bottom on pay, whereas Reid Kerr College is at the top. People are asking me whether all staff will be moved up to the level of those at Reid Kerr, which would mean that lecturers and staff there would have to go without pay rises for some time. How will national pay bargaining work? Will it mean equal pay for equal work as a lecturer, information technology expert or whatever throughout Scotland?
I am afraid that we cannot help you with that. The focus of the report is on the colleges’ annual accounts as they stand and progress on the reform and regionalisation agenda. The committee would need to direct those questions towards either the Scottish funding council or Colleges Scotland.
I understand that lecturers in UHI colleges are paid £5,000 less than those at Reid Kerr College, and many people are concerned about that. I am not a trade unionist, so perhaps you can help me on this, convener. What is your understanding of national pay bargaining?
To be fair, I do not think that that is a question for Audit Scotland, although it is clear that implementing national pay bargaining will have financial implications.
Yes, that is my point.
I do not know whether the Scottish Government has a role in that or whether it is the funding council’s responsibility. We can perhaps find out exactly who is responsible and the financial implications and consequences for each individual college. To be fair, though, it is not a question for Audit Scotland.
Okay. You will understand that people are concerned about the issue.It feels like only yesterday since we looked at the previous Audit Scotland report on colleges, although I notice that it was in October last year. At that time, I highlighted some points that I do not see covered in the current report, although that is perhaps because I have not read every word. One issue that I raised as a concern last year and which is not covered in the current report—I hope that this is appropriate—is that the pension deficit in the college sector had increased sixfold since 2007. In 2007, it was £10.8 million and, last year, it stood at £60 million. I would have thought that it is appropriate to raise that issue as we move towards merging colleges. Am I right that the issue is not mentioned in the current report? Is it still a concern, or has it been addressed?
It is still a concern and we have addressed it in the current report. It is a long and complex report, so do not worry that you missed it. In paragraph 19 and the following paragraphs, the report talks about the pension deficits. We show that, broadly, between 2010-11 and 2011-12, the deficit on the pension reserves almost doubled to £115 million.
Oh gosh—it is even worse than I anticipated.
I can talk you through what is behind that. Two things that have affected the valuation are, in effect, prudent accounting adjustments that reflect the current state of the financial world. First, we have seen a reduction in the assumed rate of return on the funds that are invested, which is no surprise, and, secondly, there is a reduction in the discount rate, which has the effect of increasing the valuation. A third factor is that more further education staff have been taking early retirement, which causes a real increase in the deficit in the pension reserve. Three things are going on that all have the impact of increasing the deficit.We would make the same point that we made last year, which is that these are long-term liabilities that certainly need to be managed but which will not have an immediate impact on any individual college or on the sector as a whole.
Okay. Sorry that I missed that one.My final—
Sorry, but before we move on from pensions, I ask the Auditor General to clarify something. Paragraph 19 states that teaching staff are usually members of the Scottish teachers superannuation scheme and that some others will be in the local government pension scheme. Those are both national schemes. Why does each college have either a surplus or deficit in its pension scheme if staff participate in a national scheme? Is the national scheme divided up between colleges?
In effect, the schemes are divided into separate pots for each of the main employers that are part of them. I ask Graeme Greenhill to talk you through how that works in more detail.
As you say, convener, there are two main pension schemes that college employees are members of. The Scottish teachers superannuation scheme is an unfunded scheme, so colleges basically make contributions to the scheme to cover the future cost of their pensions. In respect of the local government pension scheme, there are actually several local government pension schemes across the country, and the local college tends to belong to the local scheme in respect of its non-teaching staff.The local government pension scheme is a funded scheme—that is, the money that it collects is invested in stocks and shares and so forth. Under the accounting rules, colleges account for their share of the scheme in their own accounts in exactly the same way as, for example, the local authority will account for its pension costs. A college’s accounts will show both its share of the assets of the overall pension scheme and its liabilities.
So with neither scheme is there the possibility that a particular college pension fund will go bust or there will be a problem. They are all part of a bigger scheme and they are merely accounting for it. You state the figure of £9.6 million for James Watt College, but in terms of the pension fund, that is neither here nor there. The impact is on the college accounts.
If the pension scheme went bust, as you put it, it would not just be the particular college that would lose its share of the assets and liabilities, but every other member of the scheme as well.
Equally, in terms of meeting future liabilities, there is no greater financial burden on James Watt College given the health of the pension scheme. All the colleges would share in the contributions to the pension scheme.
That is correct. That is the kind of thing that actuaries routinely look at, and depending on how the pension scheme is performing, they might require members of it to increase their contributions to the scheme to address any liabilities.
Mary, do you have another question before I bring Bob Doris in?
Yes—just a brief one. Again, I raised it last year. The first set of outcomes last year was about the amount of learning and structural change. It included:“a greater focus on colleges’ contribution to the development of a highly educated and skilled workforce.”I was slightly disappointed when I saw that one of the five outcomes in paragraph 54 of the 2013 report is:“improve the quality of education so that 1,000 more full-time students successfully complete their courses”.I would not see 1,000 students finishing their courses as an indication that the quality of education had increased across the board. Is there sufficient emphasis on the quality as well as on the finances?
I ask Ronnie Nicol to talk you through what we know about the development of outcome agreements.
We recognise that the development of outcome agreements is a bit of a journey for all the public bodies that are involved in that across the public sector. When we looked at the initial ones last year, we felt that they were fairly basic. They were focused on the planning and structural reform aspects. We have seen some movement this year, and that is particularly supported by some work that was done by Education Scotland for the Scottish funding council. We are seeing more focus on what we might call outputs rather than outcomes. We see that as at least some progress towards where we want to be in seeing those agreements managing longer-term benefits as a result of the education process in colleges.
Do you understand that, to anyone who reads that outcome, there is not a lot of focus on quality? It focuses more on the finances.
That is why we have recommended that attention needs to be paid to continue to develop the outcome agreements.
link
I was looking at the part of the report about outcome agreements while Ms Scanlon was talking about quality. One of the targets is:“improve the quality of education so that 1,000 more full-time students successfully complete their courses”.Quality is therefore an inherent part of the outcome agreement. I happened to be looking at that page as Ms Scanlon was making her comment about quality.I am interested in outcome agreements and community planning, but I have another question first.On page 34 of your report, in paragraph 74, you mention colleges’ application processes, and the recommendation on page 35 states that colleges should“implement the Scottish Government’s recommendations to improve the application process to help monitor the demand for college places.”Some more information on that would be welcome. If a student decides to undertake a course in construction—be it in bricklaying, joinery or whatever—and applies for a place at North Glasgow College, City of Glasgow College and another college, that may show up in the figures as a demand for three college places, although it is just one student exercising a range of choices. How is that audited? The current process may capture the range of desires that students have, but it does not reflect the demand for college places. As we try to identify the number of college places that are needed, would it not be better to have a more sophisticated system that could track the demand from students? I hope that your recommendation is partly to do with that. Politicians of all parties sometimes talk about unmet demand in the sector, but we are not necessarily reflecting the number of students who are seeking courses at colleges, as students may apply for several courses. Some more information on that would be welcome.
You are right. That issue has received a lot of attention over the past year and the Government has recognised that we need better information about the real level of need and demand rather than about the level of applications, which may not reflect either. I think that the question about the progress that has been made is for the Scottish funding council and the Government, but Phil Grigor will update you on what we know about the progress that has been made to date.
Paragraph 74 was written on the back of two separate surveys that produced widely differing results in terms of the demand for college courses. The report that the Government published in March made several recommendations for working with the likes of the funding council, colleges and Colleges Scotland to monitor and manage the demand for places so that multiple applications from a single student are not double counted, giving the false impression of unmet demand. That is why, in our report, we made the recommendation for colleges to work with the Government and the funding council to establish a more robust measure of the demand for college places.
link
I see the importance of that. Could the Government and the funding council have based the range of college courses that they wanted to be developed—be they part time or full time—on false assumptions based on the number of applications rather than the number of students seeking college places? Was there poor practice previously, and do you see this as a necessary step towards better planning of the college sector?
We would certainly say that it is a necessary step to take, particularly given the importance that FE has in the Government’s employability agenda, which is central in the current economic climate, and the regionalisation and reform agenda, which means that we should be planning on a much more regional basis. I cannot go as far as to say that planning was, in the past, based on poor information. The applications were part of the information that was used by individual colleges and the funding council, but they were only part of it. We know from the two studies that Phil Grigor referred to that different sets of assumptions were at work. It is not the subject of this audit, but it may be an issue that you would like to explore further with the funding council and the Government.
link
That is helpful. I have a final question. I started by talking about community planning and agreed outcomes. How does the recommendation on page 35, about properly gauging the demand for a college or region, feed into or link with community planning? Is there a link, or is there work in progress to ensure that there is alignment between college provision and community plans within a region?10:30
That is still very much work in progress. In May, I published a report jointly with the Accounts Commission on progress with community planning. One of our findings was that FE reform and other parts of the public service reform agenda are not always closely aligned with community planning.Given the refreshed approach to community planning and the single outcome agreements, we expect a much clearer line of sight from the priorities for an area through to the targets and outcomes that are agreed for an individual college or college region, so that we can see how action that is taken in the FE sector contributes to local community planning priorities and to the national priorities that the Government has set. That is still work in progress.
link
If I am lucky enough to be a member of the Public Audit Committee in three years’ time—I say that with some irony—should I expect to see much closer correlation between community planning and how colleges design and promote courses for communities in their areas?
The short answer is yes. We will be able to give you evidence on that from two ends of the telescope: the reports on community planning, which we will continue to produce; and the reports on further education and employability. We should start to see things joining up much more clearly than they do at the moment.
link
On page 9, under the heading, “Key messages”, you said in paragraph 2:“there is often no discernible pattern in colleges’ ability to achieve a surplus”.I am having a bit of trouble with that. A college will have a business plan and a budget, and to a large extent its cash flows in and out will be predictable, but it seems that whether it has a surplus or a deficit is almost random.
I think that what we said reflects the comment that we made in the same paragraph about the tight margins within which most colleges operate. That means that although colleges have plans, financial controls and all the things to which you referred, they are quite vulnerable to short-term changes. Whether such changes could have been foreseen or not is always difficult to know, but an upturn or downturn in student numbers or funding, or an unexpected charge coming through, can have a marked impact on colleges’ ability to make a surplus or a deficit.
link
We are talking about very small changes having such an impact.
Exactly. Most surpluses or deficits were within 3 per cent of income—Phil Grigor will tell me if that is not correct—so it does not take much of a shift in income or expenditure to switch from a surplus to a deficit.
link
Given your comments in paragraphs 17 and 25 on page 13, will you confirm that there are currently no concerns about the financial position of the colleges that are listed?
The auditors who audit colleges are required to give an assurance about going concern, and they have done so in each case as part of their audit for the 2011-12 financial year. At the same time, we say in the report that there are significant challenges for the sector as a whole, which need to be carefully managed. In strict accounting terms, there are no concerns about going concern, but, as the report says, there are challenges that will need careful management by the colleges, the funding council and Government.
link
There is a pension deficit of £115.3 million, which is an awful lot of money. In paragraphs 20 and 21 you seem to say that the deficit is sustainable in the short term. When does it become a problem? At what point do the colleges get a gun put to their heads and told to put money in?
I do not think that there is a particular date at which that will happen. The benefit of valuing pension assets and liabilities in a transparent way, as the financial reporting standards now require, means that the scale of the problem that needs to be managed over a long period becomes more apparent.There are two things to say. First, the position is sensitive to small changes in the assumptions for the discount rate and the rate of return on investments, where that is applicable. Secondly, a range of responses can be made. In paragraph 21 we highlighted some of the changes to pension schemes that the UK Government is proposing, to bring assets and liabilities back into balance. As Graeme Greenhill said, there is also a process by which the actuaries for each scheme make recommendations to the scheme as a whole and to individual scheme members—individual colleges—about the contributions that they should make. We are keen that this committee, the Government, the funding council and colleges keep an eye on the liabilities and ensure that over time things move in the right direction.
I just want to clarify this. If colleges are asked to pay, for whatever reason, extra into the pension funds in the future, would that be at the same time that all local authorities would also have to make additional contributions for the members who would make up the vast bulk of contributors?
I will ask Graeme Greenhill to keep me straight here, because pension accounting is very complex and I am not an expert in it. I think it operates at two levels. For the scheme as a whole there is a triennial review of the level of contributions made by members, rather than by the public bodies, to make sure that they are keeping pace. For individual colleges and other members of the local government pension schemes, there can be a requirement to make additional payments to reduce the scale of their deficit over time.
Would there be a different payment for each individual body?
That is certainly the case for some members of the local government pension scheme. It is the case for Audit Scotland in respect of our staff who are members of the scheme. Graeme, do you want to add to that?
Caroline Gardner’s analysis is spot on. One of the reasons why the pension scheme administrators try to identify each member’s share of the assets and liabilities of the pension scheme is so that any difference in liabilities can be addressed through changes to the contribution rates.
That takes me back to a question that I asked earlier. James Watt College, which is now part of West College, was mentioned. For argument’s sake, if there was a concern about the pension pot at James Watt College, or indeed West Lothian College or any of the colleges, could it be asked to pay over and above what other contributors are having to pay?
I will caveat this by saying that we will need to confirm it with you afterwards, convener. Our understanding is that in relation to the historical deficits for an individual member, for the liabilities that are already built up, as opposed to those that are forecast to build up in future, the local government scheme allows for a specific additional payment to reduce the deficit from the contributing body—the individual college, or, in future, the new merged college, to which you referred. We do not know whether that is actually the case for any of the colleges across Scotland, such as the one to which you referred, but it is a possibility and it happens in relation to current members of the local government scheme.
Concerns have been expressed about college management over the years, such as that generous remuneration packages were offered with significant pension pots on offer and enhanced payments were made for early retirement, which would have a specific burden on an individual college, which it or its successors could have to pay. In other words, the managers who were party to encouraging those responsible in their colleges to look at enhanced pension provision for the senior staff could well benefit from it but leave with a package and not have to worry about who would have to pay for it in the future.
I cannot comment on the specifics that you are referring to, but it is obviously the case that for any member of one of the public sector pension schemes, past decisions about retirements and early retirements will have an impact on future liabilities. Our understanding is that that can affect both the overall levels of scheme contributions and the levels for individual members. One of the reasons for the Accounts Commission’s reports on managing the local government pension scheme in particular is to make sure that early retirement decisions are made in full knowledge of the likely impact of those costs.
I remember hearing complaints about what was going on at James Watt College prior to the merger, when the salaries and pension packages of senior staff were enhanced considerably. Indeed, just before the merger I think, the principal of James Watt College was on what was termed gardening leave for between six months and a year before leaving with a very generous package. Is it the case that the successors would have to bear the burden of the generous provision made by those in James Watt College at the time?
Again, I cannot comment on the specifics. It is not what we have audited in the report. I reiterate the point that past decisions made about early retirement will have an impact on the future costs of the pension schemes and the future liabilities.
Perhaps that is something that we could inquire about.
link
Turning to exhibit 7 on page 17, I notice that, between 2010-11 and 2011-12, administration costs increased. Does the figure include an element of the cost of the mergers or is it that the administration costs have, in fact, gone up, which would not be right?
I will ask Phil Grigor to talk you through what more we know about those figures, which are taken from the annual accounts.
We do not have the details of what the administration costs involved, but a large part of the merger costs were spent on staff severance packages and that is one of the ways—in fact, it is the main one—in which colleges are achieving their savings from one year to the next.
link
So we do not actually know what is contained within that figure.
No, we have not drilled down to that level of detail from the accounts.
link
It just stands out.
As does the other figure, which is “Other inc. exceptional costs”.
The exceptional costs could include staff severance packages. It is unlikely that the administration costs include that.
link
Unfortunately, it seems to be speculation as to what those costs comprise.
Is there a way of finding out?
It is not speculation, convener. As the report tries to make clear, it pulls together the accounts of all the colleges throughout Scotland as an exercise in demonstrating what is changing.It is possible for us to explore the matter further for next year’s report if you have an interest in it and, if the committee wishes, to explore further with the funding council what it knows about the costs of mergers and how they are being funded.
Is there a way to find out how much colleges cumulatively paid on packages between 2010-11 and 2011-12?
I ask Graeme Greenhill to pick that question up.
If the committee is interested in pursuing the matter, we could probably do a little more analysis, break down exhibit 7 into a little bit more detail and explore some of the issues that have been raised.
Yes, that would be helpful. Thank you.
link
How will the change in college status that is coming up affect the borrowing powers of colleges?
Graeme Greenhill is keeping a close eye on that for us, so it is back to him again.
The consequences of college reclassification largely fall into two camps. One is the consequences of the change in the colleges’ accounting year. That is largely procedural and manageable. Perhaps more challenging are the consequences of colleges becoming part of the Scottish Government’s overall budgetary control regime. Under the current system, what counts as college expenditure is basically what the funding council gives colleges in the way of grant. From April 2014, all college expenditure, regardless of how it is funded, will count as expenditure within the Scottish Government’s budgetary control regime.To cut to the chase, the Scottish Government has an annual budget limit and the change means that that limit will also apply to colleges. Therefore, in future, if colleges incur a deficit, they will require annual budget cover. Basically, that means that the Scottish Government will have to find savings from elsewhere within its budget to support them. If they make a surplus in any one year with the intention of using it in future years, the surplus will count as an underspend in the year in which it is made, but the future spend will require budget cover. If they wish to use their current cash reserves to support their activities in the future, that will require budget cover. Equally, if they borrow to support capital investment, for example, that expenditure will require budget cover.Those are quite significant changes. The sector, colleges, funding council and the Government are looking at how best to mitigate the effects of the ONS’s decision to ensure that colleges still have that flexibility to manage their reserves and annual surpluses. They are considering various options for how best to do that. It is still early days and no college has come out with any firm proposals for how it intends to do that, but we will keep an eye on the situation as the months pass. It is the sort of thing that we will be expected to say more about when we produce subsequent college reports.10:45
link
Your answer alarms me more than the original question did. Colleges obviously have facilities that enable them to manage their cash flow. Will they be able to continue with that? It will be quite awkward if they cannot.
Colleges will still be able to manage their cashflow. The main challenge for the colleges is how they retain access to their current level of reserves and how they will be able to use any surplus that they make from year to year.
One of the figures that jump out at me is the one that shows that in 2011-12, 48,000 fewer Scots went to college. During the three years up to then, about 100,000 fewer Scots went to college. Is that correct?
The figure for the current year is certainly in the report. I am not sure whether we have the three-year figure to hand.
I am just looking for the page.
Could you give me the page reference please, Mr Macintosh?
Pages 18 and 19. I think that paragraph 32 suggests that 48,000 fewer Scots went to college in that one year. The chart makes it look as though 100,000 is roughly right.
We would have to confirm the three-year figure. It is important to say that that change reflects a specific Government policy choice to focus on 16 to 19-year-old students and full-time courses rather than shorter or part-time courses. That is linked to the Government’s policy objectives for employability and it clearly has consequences for other groups, as I said in my introduction. It is important that the impact on those other groups is monitored and action is taken where necessary.
The figures for the number of people going to college that I am quoting are quite dramatic, are they not?
As I say, the natural consequence of the Government’s policy choices is more younger and full-time students, and fewer older and part-time students. When you convert that into a head count, it reflects a reduction in the number of people who are at college but, within that, there is a retargeting of younger and full-time students rather than other groups.
There was a cut of £56 million in that one year, which led to the drop of 48,000 students. That was a 9 per cent cut and you suggest that there is an 11 per cent cut to come. Are you suggesting that there will be a further fall in the number of Scots going to college because of that?
That is a question that you will need to take up with the Government and the funding council. What we have set out in the report is the figures for further education funding that we have from the Scottish draft budget for the two years ahead. We know that the Government’s current policy is to focus on 16 to 19-year-olds on full-time courses. It is not possible for us to draw a clear line of sight between the two, but you might want to explore that with the Government or the funding council.
Just over 1,000 full-time equivalent staff, which is probably more than 1,000 people, have lost their jobs.
It is 1,200.
Yes, 1,200 people have lost their jobs. You point out that colleges have dealt with the majority of the cuts by getting rid of staff, and you suggest that another 11 per cent cut will follow. Can you see any way of not laying off more lecturers?
How individual colleges respond to the reduction in funding that is available for further education is a matter for them in discussion with the funding council. Obviously, the other bit of the jigsaw is the outcome agreements that colleges have and the targets that they sign up to on, to use the jargon, weighted student units of measurement—that is a horrible phrase, but the aim is to standardise and take account of different types of students doing different courses. The committee would need to explore that with the funding council and the Government if it wants to know more about the issue. It is clear that the Government is operating within a UK-wide climate of financial austerity, which requires choices to be made in the budget that are outside my remit. The focus of the report is on making transparent the figures for the further education sector, as we do for the health service and other sectors, as a basis for holding the Government to account.
Indeed. Bear with me, because I am trying to work this out. Given that there has been a 9 per cent cut and we have lost 48,000 students and 1,200 staff, and that we are going to get an 11 per cent cut, how can colleges do that without cutting staff or the number of students or both? Do they have anything else at their disposal that they can do?
I have two things to say, without answering the question on how they will and should do that. First, we know that staffing accounts for about 60 per cent of the colleges’ costs, so it is clear that they will have to look at that as part of managing the reduction that they face. Secondly, the Government and the funding council see the reform agenda not just as a way of increasing the quality of education but as a way of generating efficiencies that can help to balance the available funding with the objectives for education. Obviously, a range of things within that mix are unknown, but you might want to explore with the Government and the funding council their plans for how that circle will be squared.
I am just trying to think what it could be. Could it be more students in the classroom or fewer hours per student?
You really have to explore that question with the funding council. There is a range of questions on the efficiencies that could be generated from the reform agenda. They will be different in different parts of the country and in different circumstances.
You have given us a good analysis of the figures, but do you make any analysis of the impact on the quality of education? Given that staffing accounts for 60 per cent of the running costs, it looks as though the staff have borne the brunt of the cuts so far. You say that colleges as institutions are efficiently run on a financial basis, but do you make any comment on the capacity of colleges to absorb the level of cuts without that affecting the quality of education or the number of students who are taught?
We are clear in the report that it is a work in progress and a review of how the reform agenda is being taken forward and the impact that it is having on expenditure, student numbers and other indicators. We will keep that under review. In due course, it might be appropriate to do a full assessment of the reform and how it has worked out. I am not making a commitment to do that, but we will certainly keep the issue under review as part of the updating of our work programme. The funding council and the Government are and should be monitoring the impact of the reform agenda and comparing it to the plans that they made. The committee might want to explore that with them while it is still a work in progress to get more information from them about the impact that they expect and how they are monitoring the effects on quality as well as on costs.
While we are on that, are you aware of any forecasts that the Government and the funding council are using on student numbers or staff numbers?
That is very much a question that you would have to ask of the funding council and the Government.
I want to go back to the issue of reserves, which colleagues have touched on. On page 12, you say that the colleges currently have about £214 million in reserves. A couple of colleges have had trouble. For example, Forth Valley College’s deficit has increased substantially. At paragraph 13, you state that“staff severance costs associated with planned restructuring”amounted to £1.1 million. It strikes me that the restructuring and regionalisation programme has been paid for out of reserves. Is that right?
For some colleges, that certainly is the case. It was the plan that some colleges would contribute from the reserves towards the cost of restructuring. Others are receiving direct support from the funding council. In paragraph 17, we provide a bit more information on the three colleges with deficits in their income and expenditure reserves.
Again, you might not know the answer to this, but I thought that the Griggs report specifically recommended that colleges should not use reserves for restructuring.
I am not aware of that recommendation, but in the report we talk about the differences in the extent to which colleges and college regions are expected to contribute towards the cost of the reforms. That reflects local circumstances and the level of reserves that are available to them.
From next April, when colleges become public bodies again under the ONS recommendations, will the Government be able to access the college reserves? I ask because, last year, after the police forces were restructured, the Government basically took what was in the police reserves and used it as Government money. I take it that the Government can and probably will do that again. Do you expect it to do so?
Graeme Greenhill has outlined some of the potential impacts on colleges’ finances of their reclassification as public bodies. One is that surpluses that colleges generate count against the overall Government spending limits. A lot of work is going on to manage the impact of that and to consider the available options. We cannot second-guess what the outcome of that work will be.
Do you expect the Government to take the money—the £214 million—now that it can get its hands on it?
I am not sure that I would frame the question in that way. It is public money in any case and there are important decisions to be made about the way in which it should be used in relation to the FE sector, individual colleges and wider priorities. Those decisions are well outside my remit. In the report, we have highlighted the potential impact that the change in classification will have on the overall financial framework for colleges.
On good financial planning, we recently had a debate about trying to move to three-year funding more generally for the voluntary sector. However, colleges are moving away from advance planning to annual budgets. If the Government takes away their £200 million of reserves, will that help their ability to plan for the future?
Again, I would come at the issue slightly differently. My report last year on national health service finances made the specific point that the annual targets for individual health boards make it harder for them to take a longer-term approach to financial planning. That issue affects not only health boards but all the bodies that are part of the public sector financial framework. There are good reasons for it, but my recommendation was that the Government should consider ways of encouraging and supporting longer-term financial planning. The same issue potentially applies to FE colleges on the back of the ONS reclassification.
I have two brief further points, convener.
They will need to be very brief, because we are starting to run out of time.
On staff severance payments, I notice that, over the past years, there has been continuing use of compulsory redundancies in the college sector, despite there supposedly being a Government policy against that. There has also been increasing use of compromise agreements. To give you the figures, which come from my freedom of information requests rather than your report—if I may say so, the figures in your report are higher than those that I got from my FOI requests—there were nine compromise agreements in 2007-08, 24 the next year, then 73, 117 and 146 in following years and 411 last year at a cost of more than £1 million. That strikes me as a worrying trend. Have you picked up on that and would you caution against it? Do you expect colleges to be wary of that?
In paragraph 30, on page 17, we talk about the amount that was spent on staff severance payments in 2011-12 as we have taken it from the accounts. That was £21 million. I do not recognise the figures that you have and I am not surprised by that, given the different sources and the potentially different ways in which colleges are managing the reduction in staff and the broader reform agenda.It is important to say that, if the reform agenda is to generate efficiencies in the way that is proposed, it is likely that there will be either reductions in staff numbers or changes in the balance of staffing to ensure that future needs can be met. It is important to me that those changes are transparent to the Parliament and to others with an interest. The report is a contribution to that but, as we say clearly, it is not the whole story, because it is a work in progress. We are keeping a close eye on the issue and, in future, I will consider whether there is value in bringing a further report back to the committee. For now, we have the information from the colleges’ accounts for 2011-12. The broader question of the way in which colleges are managing the balance between efficiency and quality is one to explore with the funding council and the Government.
You have produced a report that highlights the use of compromise agreements and warns against their misuse. Their use is clearly on the increase. I made FOI requests to all the colleges about compromise agreements and found that there has been a quite dramatic increase from nine to 24 to 73 to 117 to 146 to 411. That is not just a dramatic trend but a worrying trend that is going in the wrong direction. Does that flag up any warnings to you at all?11:00
We were very clear in the report that, in reducing the size of the workforce through early departures from the public sector, there can be a role for compromise agreements. They can be used to protect both parties to an agreement from future legal action, for example. We are also very clear that compromise agreements should not be used to gag whistleblowers or to hide concerns about how public bodies have managed particular situations. The trend in itself does not concern me, but the way in which compromise agreements are used is obviously very important and is a matter of public interest. It is something that you may wish to explore with the funding council.
A constituent wrote to me because they were concerned about the cost of the City of Glasgow College’s capital programme in particular. They suggested that it will have an impact on the capacity of the overall college sector in Glasgow. Is it within your remit to look at such an issue and, if so, have you done so?
I have also had a query about that particular investment project. As part of our general responsibility to understand how public money is being spent and to be aware of issues that may be of concern, the auditor is looking at that for me at the moment. However, I do not have any further findings to report back at this stage, I am afraid.
My apologies for being late, convener. If Caroline Gardner covered this point in her opening remarks, please let me know.I want to try to understand the financial governance landscape in the college sector so if I get this right, tell me. We have the funding council, then we have regional boards and then we have college boards. What is the relationship between those three bodies and who drives the process?
I will ask Ronnie Nicol to answer that. It is still very much a work in progress, but I think that we can give you an outline picture of it.
The Scottish Government expects the funding council to manage overall the money that is given to individual colleges. Those colleges are now being directed through the regions. It is a work in progress. The links between the funding given and what is delivered from the college sector is being managed by the outcome agreements which, as we said earlier, are in their early stages and need to be developed and improved. That is the basic outline.
Who sets the outcome agreements?
The funding council requires college regions to produce the outcome agreements for their areas. They have to respond to specific things that the funding council asks them to include.
Where does an individual college fit into that—or does it not fit into that at all?
Individual colleges would be represented on the regional boards.
By whom?
The arrangements for establishing the regional boards are in progress just now and there has been correspondence from the Scottish Government to the regional boards to outline some transitional arrangements before things are finally in place next spring.
So this is all meant to be in place by spring 2014.
Yes. The aim is to have the regional chairs and the regional boards in place by May next year.
Does that mean that regional boards will then divvy up the money that is allocated to a region for the purposes of providing college places across that region? Sorry, I appreciate that “divvy up” is not a very good accounting phrase.
“Divvy up” is not the phrase that we would use, but the aim is that the regional board will pull together each of the colleges in the region, agree a picture of what the needs and demand are in that area and then agree how between them the colleges will meet those needs or demands with the funding that is available from the funding council.
How are you going to audit that? I am sorry, as this is all about the future, but will Audit Scotland therefore be auditing the regional boards rather than individual colleges?
We will be auditing the groupings that make up the accounting entities, if I can put it that way. In most cases, that will be the new colleges—the merged colleges. The regional boards are a planning and resource allocation mechanism between those colleges and the funding council.
Audit Scotland previously audited the relationship between the funding council and colleges; now there is another structure in the middle of that, which will, in effect, be where all the decisions are taken once the regions have received their allocation from the funding council. Is that a fair summary?
The regional boards will have a role between the colleges and the funding council in agreeing the resource allocation. We track the money, so we can audit the system as a whole, we can audit the funding council and, in most cases, we can audit the new merged colleges that are spending the money. However, because I have the section 23 powers that let me carry out reports like this one, we will still have oversight of the whole system if we think that there is an issue there that is worth investigating.
If an individual college, wherever it might be in Scotland, ultimately feels that it did not win, or simply was unsuccessful, in its application for funds to the regional board, would you still be able to look into that in order to assess why that college had failed on student numbers, or other Government targets—which of course are set at the centre—and so forth?
Yes. One of the benefits of the public audit model in Scotland is that it is joined up and we can look at a situation at whatever level of aggregation is most useful.
Right. That is very helpful. As regards Ken Mackintosh’s point about the Griggs review, you covered that in paragraph 43 of the report, if I read it correctly.Also in paragraph 43, Audit Scotland points out that when individual colleges have the money,“the Scottish Government would expect colleges to use their financial reserves to meet”a proportion of their merger costs, or in your terminology,“a significant portion of their merger costs”.What happened when colleges did not have the money?
Some funding is available from the Scottish Government, through the Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council, for mergers. The question is bigger than just whether colleges have the money. It is about what the overall state of development of FE looks like in a region, what funding is available, to what extent that is earmarked for capital investment, and therefore what needs to be provided by the Scottish Government.
I do not really understand that. I thought that paragraph 43 was specifically about meeting the cost of all the mergers. I did not realise that it was about all those wider factors as well.
Paragraph 44 is the one that aims to explain what is happening. For each merger, a plan sets out the likely costs. There is then an agreement between the funding council and the colleges involved about how those costs will be met, which will reflect the amounts that are available in reserves but also the extent to which those reserves are already intended for capital investment.
Okay, but if a college in a region did not have any reserves, was the merger—the pulling together of the colleges—funded ultimately by the Government, in effect?
Yes.
Okay. Thank you.Paragraph 47 talks about the merger of three colleges to form the City of Glasgow College and mentions:“In May 2013, the SFC reported that the merger had delivered savings of about £5 million so far, and that the college had estimated total savings of over £26 million between 2010 and 2015.”Is that £5 million in savings a work in progress and do you expect the £26 million savings target to be met?
You will notice that the wording there is careful. We have reported what the Scottish funding council has reported and what it expects. We have not evaluated the costs and benefits of reform yet. We may do that in the future. The committee may wish to explore that point with the funding council.
The whole point of the merger programme and centralisation of colleges—as you said in evidence earlier to the committee—is to save money. If it has not happened in the case of the City of Glasgow College—and your correct wording on that is that the figures are the funding council’s observations—something is not going very well, is it?
I am saying that we have not yet carried out that evaluation and that it is something that the committee may want to explore with the funding council. We may well explore the matter in the future, but that is not what the report that we are discussing aims to do.
As one humble member, I think that you should look into that.
Thank you; I hear you.
I have a brief supplementary on Mr Nicol’s point to Tavish Scott. My understanding is that in the Highlands and Islands, the funding stream is different in that the funding for colleges is filtered through UHI and that that filter costs £15 million. That was not mentioned. Several of the colleges are concerned that they may get a lower level of funding per student than colleges elsewhere in Scotland. Is that a concern of yours?
It is the case that the arrangements are different in the Highlands and Islands because of the existence of UHI. I cannot comment on either the cost of that arrangement or what the impact may be in the future. That, too, is something that you may wish to explore with the funding council. We would pick it up in evaluating the progress of the reform, if we do that in the future.
First, on the issue that was being discussed a wee moment ago about the reserves, I had a look back at an Audit Scotland report from 2008—five years ago. At that time, the college reserves stood at £100 million. Now, they are standing at more than £200 million. I think that it is reasonable—I think that the public would expect it—that the colleges make some kind of contribution to regionalisation, given their substantial cash reserves.My question in that regard is about the move to public body status, which has been mentioned a few times. What is the likely outcome of that for the colleges’ cash reserves, given that they will be restricted in their ability to build up such reserves? Where is the money likely to go? Will it go into further capital investment?
As Graeme Greenhill said, the Government, the funding council and colleges are examining a number of options for how the issue of reclassification might be resolved, and all the options have pros and cons. Our interest is in ensuring, first, that they are transparent and that it is clear what has happened to that significant amount of public money that has been built up over a period. Secondly, our interest is in ensuring that the mechanisms that are put in place enable colleges, and the sector as a whole, to plan for the investment that is needed for the longer term.Also we want, in a wider sense, to ensure that the way the money is treated enables the Government as a whole, and the further education sector, to make good decisions between competing choices, and to prioritise rather than to go for short-term decisions because that is expedient. Those are the criteria that we will apply in examining the resolution that is reached. However, it is too soon to talk about the decision that the funding council and the Government might take.
Looking back on the five-year period that we have just come through, despite the commentary about funding cuts and so on, the colleges’ cash reserves have doubled, which is significant and must be acknowledged in the committee. I ask you to clarify the comments that Mr Macintosh made about paragraph 32 on student numbers. A figure of 48,000 fewer people was mentioned and we have heard that 1,200 staff have left the sector. However, your report states that“colleges continue to meet ... targets for learning activity”and that the full-time equivalent number of students has“remained broadly constant at about 120,000 to 125,000”.That tells me that there has obviously been a shift in emphasis from part-time to full-time courses, and that those 48,000 people have not disappeared, because a substantial proportion of them must have converted to full-time courses. Is that the case?
We certainly do not know whether that is the case. The committee might want to explore with the funding council what it knows about the individuals who make up the sheer head count numbers that we have. However, I am happy to restate that what we say on student numbers is a direct reflection of the Government’s proper policy choice—it is the Government’s role to do that—to focus on younger and full-time students because of the link to employability and the economic priorities. We can see that clearly in exhibit 9, which shows an increase in full-time students against a decrease in part-time students. Exhibit 10 shows that, as you say, the colleges have met their targets for learning activity, which is measured in weighted student units of measurement.
How can we lose 1,200 staff from the sector but maintain learning activity at previous levels?
That is a question for the funding council and individual colleges. I suspect that the answer is in part about the merger and reform agenda. Some of it will be about regionalisation and the ability to plan across a region how best to meet learning demand in the area. It is a question for the sector, rather than for us as auditors.
The report mentions that the number of young people attending college has increased. I have two questions on the opportunities for all scheme. First, do you plan to monitor the outcomes of the scheme—I see that monitoring of outcomes is suggested in the report. Given that there will be more 16 to 24-year-olds going to college, will you monitor the end result, such as whether people go on to university or employment? Do you have any way of monitoring the result?
My answer to that will be similar to my answer to an earlier question.The first step is on how the funding council and the Government monitor the impact of their policy choices, as they should be doing. That is one of our recommendations. If we decide to do an evaluation of the reform programme as a whole, those are very much the sort of questions that we will explore, along with the question of teaching quality that Ms Scanlon highlighted.
Was there anything previously, or is there anything now, to let us know where students go when they leave college?
Phil Grigor can perhaps help with that.
In the new outcome agreements, quality of education covers issues such as retention rates, qualifications achieved and destinations. The improved outcome agreements—they have certainly improved since last year—focus more on delivery of education and where students go as a result of it. We would like them to improve further and become more outcome focused so that there is a greater link-up with the wider education agenda and overall policy.
You also talk about a possible knock-on effect being that people aged 25 and over will have less access to college. The Government made an extra £61 million available in the hope that it would help to mitigate that. Will you be able to monitor that extra money going into the system to see whether it has a positive effect for those who are affected?
Yes. If we carry out an evaluation of the whole reform programme, that is one of the probes that we will use. We expect that the Government and the funding council will monitor the money first—we should review what they are doing rather than monitor it instead of them.
Do you have a question, Mary?
No, I have already asked it. It was on the £15 million for the UHI.
It has been a long session, which indicates the interest that there is in Scotland’s colleges. It has been very useful. As well as giving us an explanation, you have highlighted a number of questions that we may want to pursue with others. That has helped to shape our thinking on where we might want to go. Thank you very much.
In this meeting
Everything on 2 Oct 2013 →- 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 180
- 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 145
- 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 45
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.