Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

“Housing in Scotland”

Wednesday 2 October 2013 Public Audit Committee About 10:00 Committee business 145 contributions · 12 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

145 contributions
Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

The next item on the agenda is another section 23 report, “Housing in Scotland”. Fraser McKinlay is going to give us a briefing on the report.

Caroline Gardner
link

I thought that Phil Grigor and I might like a break after the previous session, so Fraser will take over.

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

Good morning. Housing is important for Scotland’s people and communities. Well-planned, good-quality housing contributes to strong, resilient communities and supports economic growth. It is a national asset and an area of significant public investment.The Scottish Government has an ambitious vision to provide an affordable home for all by 2020. The environment in which the housing sector operates is not straightforward, and this is the first time that Audit Scotland has looked in depth at the housing sector as a whole. In this audit, which is a joint report by the Auditor General and the Accounts Commission, we have considered how Scotland’s housing sector works, how much money is spent and what that money delivers. We have taken a wide look at the whole sector and we will consider, in the future, whether we should look in more depth at some of the issues that have been raised by this work. We will obviously be interested in the committee’s views on that.We are not suggesting that there is a magic bullet that will solve the nation’s housing needs in one go. The strength of the economy and wider financial pressures have a considerable impact on the housing sector. The recession and constraints on lending have meant that the number of new houses that have been built by the private sector, the number of first-time buyers and the number of mortgages that have been approved have all more than halved. At the same time, public sector budgets have reduced, with the Scottish Government’s housing budget falling by around a third in real terms between 2008-09 and 2011-12.There are significant pressures on council and registered social landlord finances, in particular their capital budgets. Subsidies for RSLs have reduced at the same time as national targets on quality, energy efficiency and fuel poverty are placing increased demands on resources. Members will be aware that, since we published our report, the Scottish Government has increased its subsidy for new homes by £16,000 per unit, following an assessment of the financial capacity of councils and RSLs.At the moment, there is no easy option for funding housing. The economic climate has meant that more innovative sources of funding have had to be sought. In response to the pressure on resources, the Scottish Government is encouraging councils and RSLs to use alternative models of finance to lever private investment into housing. Those potential new sources of funding, such as bonds and pension funds, bring new risks and complexities that must be properly understood. To date, the use of those models has been limited and the extent to which they can compensate for the reduced levels of subsidy is not yet clear. Many councils and RSLs lack experience and expertise in alternative financing models, which is why we think that the Scottish Government should clarify the role that it expects those sources of financing to play in the future, and help councils and RSLs to understand how best to take advantage of them and minimise the risks involved.We would also like to see greater clarity in financial reporting. You will see, from the report, that the funding for housing is an extremely complicated mixture of public and private finance, with one-off capital payments and on-going revenue funding from several different sources. That can make funding streams hard to track and can cause difficulties for those who are planning and delivering housing.Good housing can make a positive contribution to improving a wide range of outcomes for communities, including economic growth, community safety and improved health. However, housing’s contribution to those wider aims could be improved. Local planning arrangements are complicated, and effective leadership is required at national and local levels to ensure that housing makes the biggest contribution that it can make to the achievement of better outcomes.I will pause there. I and my colleagues—Claire Sweeney and Sally Thompson, who were the team on the project—will be happy to answer your questions.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Thank you. You say that the local planning situation is complicated and, from reading the report, I gather that the funding arrangements are hugely complicated. It is difficult to get a clear idea of what is happening in order to make comparisons.Exhibit 6 on page 17 of your report shows the target for affordable homes that was set in 2011. What is the definition of “affordable home”?

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

I will ask the team to respond in a second. In the report, we make the point that there is a need for greater clarity in some definitions, and the definition of “affordable home” is one of them. There has been a real change in the past decade in how we view housing and the state’s role in housing. We have gone from a quite narrow definition of social housing to a much wider interest in affordable homes and helping people to get on the property ladder in the private sector. Claire Sweeney or Sally Thompson may be able to comment specifically on the definition of “affordable home”.

Sally Thompson Audit Scotland
link

As our report says, the terms “affordable homes” and “social homes” have previously been used interchangeably. “Social homes” generally means traditional council and RSL homes for rent at significantly reduced levels. “Affordable homes” adds to that the idea of mid-market rents, meaning that someone still rents their home at a reduced level but may be able to buy it in the future.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Your understanding is that the definition of “affordable home” is purely about homes for rent.

Sally Thompson Audit Scotland
link

It is also about homes to buy in the future. That is what the target is about.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Leaving the future aside, your understanding is that the affordable homes that are being built are only homes that are initially for rent.

Claire Sweeney Audit Scotland
link

The final bullet point at the top of page 12 makes the point:“Home ownership remains unaffordable for many people”in Scotland.“A property is classed as affordable if it costs no more than 3.5 times a person’s annual salary. We estimate that the average property in Scotland costs six times the average salary.”We have highlighted in the report that there is an issue about affordability.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

So, an affordable home could be a house that is available to purchase.

Sally Thompson Audit Scotland
link

In terms of the Government’s target, “affordable homes” means homes to rent in the long term and homes that people rent initially and can then buy.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

I am not following this. I know that people can have shared equity in their homes and can then purchase more equity in the future. Is the Government’s definition of an affordable home one that is currently rented even though it will be available for purchase in the future, or does it include a home that is available for purchase at no more than 3.5 times a person’s annual salary?

Sally Thompson Audit Scotland
link

The Government is measuring progress against the target using all houses that are delivered through its affordable housing supply programme. That includes all council and RSL homes, all mid-market homes that people rent initially and may be able to buy, plus all shared-equity-type homes.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Okay, but that does not include low-cost homes that are available for outright purchase and which are no more than 3.5 times the person’s annual salary.

Sally Thompson Audit Scotland
link

No, it does not include homes that are not being delivered through one of the Government’s schemes.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

So, there has to be a rental component.

Claire Sweeney Audit Scotland
link

As part of that.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Does there have to be a rental component for the home to be classified as affordable?

Sally Thompson Audit Scotland
link

No, there does not necessarily have to be a rental component. There are shared equity schemes.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Shared equity schemes involve a rental contribution as well as a purchase element. I presume that, if a person buys 50 per cent of the equity, they will pay the capital sum of 50 per cent and pay a rent or the equivalent of a rent on the other 50 per cent.

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

This conversation shows exactly why we need a bit more clarity around the definition. As the note on exhibit 6 says—you have pointed this out—we recognise that the numbers are slightly different, depending on where they are taken from. As Sally Thompson said, for the particular target, the number is“the number of homes delivered through the Affordable Housing Supply Programme.”Sally Thompson has described those. Those numbers will be different from those in the new housing supply statistics. We can certainly try to clarify matters as best as we can, but this might be one of the things that you will want to pick up with the Scottish Government if you correspond with it.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

How do you assess whether the Scottish Government has met its target when you cannot define what the target is?

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

We can define the target, as it is described in exhibit 6. Sally Thompson has just described that.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Right. That takes me back to my question. Does every affordable home need to have a rental component?

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

I feel that we are getting hung up on the technicalities of what is and is not a rental component.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Well, no. How can we have a sensible discussion if we cannot understand what the target is? I understand that any house that is purely for rent would be classified as an affordable home in the social rented sector, and I think that you are suggesting that houses that have a shared equity element and which might have a rental component as well as a capital component are affordable homes, but houses that are available for outright purchase are not classified as affordable homes.

Caroline Gardner
link

We need to come at the matter from the other end. We know how the Scottish Government measures affordable homes.

Caroline Gardner
link

As we said in the footnote to exhibit 6, and as Sally Thompson has said, they are“homes delivered through the Affordable Housing Supply Programme.”That is how the Scottish Government has said it will measure progress. At the moment, that includes the various types of homes that Sally Thompson has outlined. There is no reason why the affordable housing supply programme could not include other types of housing tenure in the future, but we think that clarity around the definition would make it easier to understand how well the target sits against need and how well things are being delivered over time.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

You also say in that note:“These numbers differ from those recorded in the Scottish Government’s New Housing Supply statistics.”It is as clear as mud.

Caroline Gardner
link

As Fraser McKinlay has said, that is why we think that more clarity around the definition is needed. In narrow terms, the answer to your question is that the target involves“counting the number of homes delivered through the Affordable Housing Supply Programme.”

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Okay. You mentioned that the target was set in 2011. What was the previous target?

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

I will ask the team to come in on that. We are not aware that there was a specific target relating to that, but we will double-check that for you.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Was not a commitment made in 2007 on social rented housing?

Claire Sweeney Audit Scotland
link

We have looked at the particular affordable homes target and the background to how some of the thinking was established for it. In the report, we referred to the research that was carried out on behalf of the Scottish Government in 2005, which looked at how many affordable homes it was estimated needed to be built at that point across Scotland. We have not reported on any of the other targets in the report. We could come back to the committee on whether there is any other information underlying that; we looked at the particular target.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

I might be wrong, but I thought that, originally, a target was set in about 2007 for homes for social renting and then, in 2011, it changed to socially affordable housing with a different, complex, obscure definition. However, you are not aware of what was previously said about aspirations on social rented housing.11:30

Claire Sweeney Audit Scotland
link

We did not consider that as part of the report.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

I will seek further clarity. I do not want to get hung up on this because I want to ask other questions, but my understanding is that affordable homes will be defined as whatever the Scottish Government decides to spend its affordable homes investment budget on.

Caroline Gardner
link

Yes.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

There is a serious note to this. I do not seek to state the obvious, but what is an affordable home to one person might not be an affordable home to someone else because people are at a variety of income levels. That is an important point. The issue is monitoring how the Scottish Government uses the budget to make homes more affordable for people.I think that the convener said that there was a disconnect between affordable homes and new homes. Does the affordable homes budget all go into new-build homes or does it go elsewhere? I want to ensure that we are examining the same thing. When we talk about affordable homes, are we talking about new-build completions that the Scottish Government helps to subsidise, or are we talking about a wider range of investments in affordable housing?

Sally Thompson Audit Scotland
link

Your first point—that affordability varies depending on income and house prices—we raise in the report. There is quite a variation in rent levels throughout the country. Reduced subsidies and tightening budgets will have an impact on rent levels. The report calls for greater clarity in future about what an affordable rent level is, because affordability is not defined in relation to rent.The affordable housing budget is wider than just new builds because it includes properties that can be bought under the shared equity schemes.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

That is helpful. We cannot make a direct comparison between new-build social housing and the extent to which the Scottish Government has extended affordable housing in the country. They are clearly two separate things.I will ask a question about housing association grant funding, but it will not be based on the report because it is complex and impenetrable in some respects. I was a member of the Local Government and Communities Committee in the previous session of the Parliament before I moved on to other committees in this session. There was always a debate with the social housing sector about the level of HAG needed to make social housing affordable and provide the sector with a business model to build new-start social housing.With a 36 per cent cut in the Scottish Government’s capital budget from the UK Government, there was clearly always going to be less money to spend on new-build social housing. As your report says, some of that clearly fed through to the level of funding for new-build social housing. The Scottish Government reduced the average level of subsidy but, although it is nowhere near the initial levels of subsidy, it has recently increased it again by £16,000.Do you have any comments to make on how the Scottish Government used evidence on the barriers to new build in the social housing sector, to which it responded by increasing HAG by £16,000? I caveat that question by saying that, on one level, the less of a subsidy per unit we give the social housing sector, the more social housing completions we get and the more affordable houses there are within the sector, so I am always keen for the HAG moneys to be as low as possible, to be frank, because we get more completions out of it. Was the £16,000 increase an evidence-led approach to increasing the subsidy in the social rented sector?

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

My caveat is that we did not cover the HAG increase in the report, because it happened after we had done the work. The picture is fast moving and we keep up as best we can.We looked at the levels of resourcing and funding that are available to RSLs and councils for new build. I think that a working group was set up to look at the issue over the spring, which resulted in a recommendation to the Scottish Government. That, in turn, resulted in the additional £16,000 per unit subsidy. That is the broad picture, Mr Doris; the team might want to say a wee bit more.

Claire Sweeney Audit Scotland
link

Fraser McKinlay is right: a working group was established and its report fed back to the Scottish Government that an increase was needed. The working group also highlighted the need for consistency over a longer period in that regard, which was interesting.The report echoed the concerns of the Scottish Housing Regulator about the pressures on the housing sector in Scotland and the need for changes to be made to the resources that are available for housing, if targets are to be met. That was a particular concern, and the Government reacted to the report, which is why the subsidy was increased.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

That is reassuring. Although I want HAG levels to be as low as possible, it is important to get the appropriate balance, to enable development in the social rented sector to continue appropriately. It seems from what you have said that the Government responded on the basis of the auditable numbers from the sector.I wish that I could ask more questions, but I found the report hard to penetrate with a view to asking focused questions.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

I will come to the defence of Audit Scotland and the Accounts Commission. I think that the report is admirably clear. It has identified how unclear things are, which is hardly the fault of Audit Scotland or the Accounts Commission.Bob Doris asked a very interesting question. Mr McKinlay, I take your point about not having considered the issue in depth, but did you find regional variations in Scotland? As Mary Scanlon and I know, the situations in Colonsay and Glasgow are very different—I would not begin to make a judgment about housing costs in Glasgow. Did you find that the one-size-fits-all approach, or a £40,000 or £56,000 subsidy per house, does not help housing associations, which face different pressures in different parts of Scotland?

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

I ask Claire Sweeney to respond.

Claire Sweeney Audit Scotland
link

Yes, the issue came up in a few aspects of our work. Another issue that was raised was the planning arrangements and how money is allocated across Scotland.I should make it clear that the work is not an audit of what is happening across each area in Scotland. However, the different pressures in different areas came through quite strongly. We tried to highlight a couple of examples in the report, to bring the issue to life. For example, we talked about the tensions in Aberdeen in the context of job creation and the link between housing and the local economy.The challenge that we make in that regard is to ask to what extent the use of public resources is being mapped, so that resources go where they are most needed and are relative to local circumstances. That is an important point.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

That is helpful. Exhibit 9 on page 24 shows that there are—if I have added them up correctly—25 separate funding streams. Why did you not recommend simplification of what must be a pretty complex picture even for the cleverest housing professionals in Scotland?

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

There is no doubt that the picture is complex, as exhibit 9 and a couple of other exhibits demonstrate. The housing sector told us that this was the first time that anyone had tried to get it on a single page—and that was not a straightforward task.If such a recommendation does not come through clearly enough, we will reflect on that, Mr Scott. There is definitely something in the report about making the situation more understandable. As I said, there is no easy option or silver bullet that will fix everything. It is about leadership and the Scottish Government being clearer about the funding streams and, in particular, the new funding models, which are not new in themselves but are new to the housing sector.A community-based housing association that has 200 houses and wants to build more will struggle to get its head around the funding streams—as will some of the bigger housing associations and councils, for that matter. There is an issue to do with capacity building for housing associations and councils, to help them to understand the complex landscape. Simplification would be a good thing, if there are opportunities in that regard.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Paragraph 38 of the report describes, in your language, the fact that some schemes are “not always evaluated” but are then changed. Surely that would be a failure of the public pound. Did you assess why those schemes were changed?

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

I will ask Claire Sweeney to give more detail on this. The point is that we just do not know whether the schemes were good, bad or indifferent, because the Government did not evaluate them, and the world then moved on. There is a question around how the Scottish Government and councils are ensuring that we are getting absolutely the biggest bang for our buck out of the spend on social housing, in all its complexity.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Do you know how many schemes were, to use the language of paragraph 38, not evaluated and then changed?

Claire Sweeney Audit Scotland
link

That is a common thread throughout a lot of what we considered in the report. There are two additional points to mention. One is the need for more consistency and stability over time. Housing is a significant national asset that requires long-term investment, so it is not something that can be dealt with on a short-term basis. There are other exhibits in the report that show money coming in throughout the year. There is an attempt to put money, where it is available, into the housing sector, which is a good thing. That is fine, but we are arguing that a sustained, clear and transparent plan over a length of time is required to enable the housing sector to deal with the priorities that it faces.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Would you be so good as to furnish the committee with the number of schemes that changed and were not evaluated over the period of your inquiry?

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

We will certainly look into that.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Thank you.In the last sentence of paragraph 38 of the report, you state:“Preparing bids can be time-consuming and costly, particularly for smaller organisations.”In your view, will that very fair point be taken into account in the development of the new financial models? In the work that you do with the Government, will you recommend that in simplifying the structure—I cannot urge that enough—instead of coming up with 27 more funding streams, the Government should work that down to an easily digestible number and should be very conscious of the small organisations that have to bid for those funding streams?

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

Yes. That would be a really important part of the process from now on. The point about the newer models of funding is not so much about the complexity in the number of different funding sources; it is about understanding the complexity in terms of risk and what the smaller organisations in particular are taking on in going through the process.

Colin Keir SNP Edinburgh Western
link

My questions are basically about the welfare reform that is currently taking place. You have made a couple of comments in paragraphs 54 and 55 of the report; there is also a comment somewhere that says that rent rises need to be considered. Is there anything aside from what you have written in paragraphs 54 and 55 that we need to dig into and on which we need to get information? What you have said about the subject is a bit limited. Welfare reform is having a pretty drastic effect right now, and it is important to consider how that effect might carry on in the longer term.

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

The short answer to your question on whether there is more to be said is yes—there almost certainly is more to be said. As I have said, the report represents the first time that we have tried to take an overview of the housing sector, and we have not gone into depth on the impact of welfare reform. That is partly because it is quite new, and the picture is still emerging. In a different part of our work, we have undertaken a survey of councils and their preparedness for welfare reform. There is no doubt that every council in the land has welfare reform in general as one of its top one or two risks—in particular, the spare room subsidy policy and the impact that it will have on rent arrears and other things. That is before we even get into some longer-term issues around what it means for councils’ housing stock and the different nature of houses that might be required in future.We could examine the impact of welfare reform on housing in more detail—we may do so in the future—but you are right to say that we have not done so much of that in the report before you today.

Colin Keir SNP Edinburgh Western
link

I will leave the next question that I was going to ask.11:45

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

I will follow up on that point. You spoke about the implications for local authorities of the bedroom tax, or bedroom subsidy, as you call it. That is right and many councils will feel a lot of financial pressure, but they are better able to cope with that than many of the small housing associations are.Have you considered what the consequences could be for those housing associations? They are more exposed to bank borrowing than to borrowing from other sources. If they cannot keep up their repayments because of reductions in income, they potentially face going out of business in a way that a local authority would not. They could be open to takeovers from larger housing organisations from elsewhere in the country. Has there been any study of what welfare reform might mean for the housing association sector?

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

I will ask the team to come in on this question, but that is the core work of our colleagues in the Scottish Housing Regulator. The SHR is acutely aware of the problem, which has been its main priority for the past couple of years. It is considering the potential impact on housing associations, particularly some of the smaller ones.The business model for housing associations has had a sound basis for a long time. Welfare reform introduces a significant change to that basis. For some of the smaller ones in particular, the margins are very tight. It does not take much of a reduction in rent or an increase in rent arrears for there to be a pretty fundamental impact on the business model for some small associations. Colleagues in the SHR are acutely aware of the problem and have done some work on it.

Claire Sweeney Audit Scotland
link

That is right. We spoke to some housing associations as part of the audit. That was far and away the biggest risk that they mentioned to us at the outset. It was a consistent concern for them. We have worked closely with the SHR to produce this report. Many of its recent reports highlight the pressures on housing regulators in relation to welfare reform, and it keeps a close eye on this risk. It is a big concern for some of the smaller housing associations.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Might you look into the financial implications for the associations?

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

It is more likely that the regulator would do that specific work. The SHR has responsibility for oversight of the housing association sector. We do not audit the RSLs directly. We can do whole-systems work, but our colleagues in the SHR would do the work on individual housing associations.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

I know that a couple of housing associations in my constituency already report a drop in demand for some of the properties with a high number of bedrooms. It is clear that this drop will affect their rental income revenue stream. They also appear to be trying to take some steps—I am not sure whether reconfigure or redesignate is the word to use—to alter the number of bedrooms in a house to overcome this daft UK policy. It would be a useful piece of work to study the impact of that change in the medium to long term on stock levels for housing associations, and how they deal with the situation. It seems to be quite serious.The report refers to the expected increase in the number of single-person households over the next 20 years. All of that is worthy of further work in the context of policy.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

I know that Audit Scotland’s remit is slightly different, but I wonder whether there might be some opportunity for joint activity with the regulator in which the regulator specifically examines the housing aspect and you consider the financial implications. Increased financial problems that result in housing associations going out of business would have huge financial repercussions. It might be useful to see whether a joint report could be done.

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

We can approach that in several ways. As we think about what else we might do on the back of this report, we will work very closely with colleagues in the SHR to decide what to do next and then potentially to work with them. We have already done some work on welfare reform in our prospective forward programme. We have still to decide how best to get into that big subject, but it is clearly such a significant issue and risk for the public sector that it is already on our radar for future reports.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I was looking at page 37, and at paragraphs 79, 80 and 81. Paragraph 81 in particular contains a fairly alarming figure for councils’ “spend on management, repairs and investment and their lost income through empty properties”,which are the things that councils manage. It says that “council income will be £1.9 billion less than is needed to cover the costs of existing stock”,whereas RSLs will have an excess of £3.9 billion.Do councils have robust enough systems to be able to make those projections on their own? The projections obviously inform the way in which they handle their investment in their properties.

Claire Sweeney Audit Scotland
link

We undertook that work to see whether there were any issues that we could draw out by comparing how the two parts of the sector operate. We took estimates and used some indicative figures to draw that out. We did not look at local services in great detail as part of the report, but we drew on published information to give an indication of how well RSLs and councils are managing their housing stock, so that we could think about what the financial implications might be over the longer term. We thought that it was a useful approach to give an indication of any issues arising and any lessons that could be learned between the two sectors. We have shared the information with the Scottish Housing Regulator, which was interested in the methodology, and we are thinking about lessons for the RSL and local authority sectors going forward. The report shows projections over 30 years and looks at all things being equal, although we know that there are big differences between the RSL and local authority sectors. In essence, the biggest differences are that council rental income is generally lower and that councils tend to spend more on reactive repairs than RSLs do. Councils generally have longer void terms—empty properties. There is also geographical variation across the whole of Scotland for both councils and RSLs. The work is just an indication, but we thought that it was a useful start to get into looking at some of the issues and comparing the RSL and council sectors.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

You mention higher subsidies, but you also say that“the financial relationship between the income and expenditure ... is directly comparable.”

Claire Sweeney Audit Scotland
link

In that passage, we were trying to get at the extent to which there is longer-time financial planning for housing. We have highlighted housing in the report as a significant national asset that needs to be invested in, and we were interested in drawing out whether people are taking a longer-term view of the houses.It is also interesting to consider the role of the Scottish Housing Regulator with regard to the health and strength of the RSL sector. We thought that there are probably some things that could be learned between the two. The report was just a start, to get into that agenda. We did not look at services at a local level, but we tried to draw out whether there are any lessons to be learned.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Earlier, we talked about the financial threat to smaller RSLs, but your report seems to indicate that, overall, the RSL sector is fairly robust.

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

It depends on the timeframe that you are looking at.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Over 30 years, and it is comparable.

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

Indeed, and on that basis, as Claire Sweeney tried to describe, there are interesting differences in how the sectors manage their stock. I think that there are lessons to be learned about ensuring that there is investment now and that the stock is well maintained and will remain in good condition into the future. In paragraph 82, we highlight the fact that the Scottish social housing charter includes the issue of how RSLs and councils manage their stock, and colleagues in the SHR will be doing a report on that next year, which will give us a good sense of how they are progressing. Again, we can continue to keep an eye on that within the housing sector to see how different providers are managing their stock.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I realise that you have put a lot of estimates into the report, but you say that the figures for RSLs and for councils are comparable. Do councils have the tools to do those projections themselves? You say that there will be a £1.9 billion shortfall over 30 years, which is not a small sum. Presumably, that is £1.9 billion in current funding. What are you going to do with that?

Claire Sweeney Audit Scotland
link

We have shared the methodology, which is on our website. More detail underlies the figures. Anyone could run the projection, because the figures were drawn from publicly available information. There is a model that others can use to get into the figures.It is worth mentioning the difference in the scale of RSLs. Some are very big organisations and some are very small and local. That is another tension that came through clearly when we carried out our work. Some of the local and small RSLs are focused on community capacity building and regeneration issues in the community. The financial climate presents a risk for those smaller RSLs in dealing with welfare reform and other issues that have been talked about.We are interested in what the RSL sector will look like, given the financial pressures. The range of organisations needs to be thought about and we refer to that in the report.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Have you considered making the calculation of the projections part of the audit of councils, which would give them information, comfort or whatever?

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

I am conscious that it feels as if I am not answering your question properly, but I am struggling to understand why. Councils routinely get external advice and expertise on the value of stock and what needs to be spent on it. If that is part of your question, I do not think that we have any concern about the process that councils go through to ascertain those numbers.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

My concern is that the report tells us that there will be a deficit in council income—councils will make a loss on their housing, which they will have to absorb. How do we feed that into council processes? It is clear that whatever they are doing now is not throwing that up; otherwise, they would react to it. How do we get the information into council processes so that they can react to it? They have 30 years to fix the situation—the crisis will not hit tomorrow.

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

As with all our joint reports for the Auditor General and the Accounts Commission, we have engaged with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities. As part of that exercise, COSLA was involved in the advisory group. Local government has had input and is aware of what is in the report. The issue will be part of the follow-up work that we routinely do for our impact reporting.It is not necessarily the case that councils do not get it. The reality is that they must make difficult decisions about how they spend their money year to year. Even if they recognise the number, making progress against it is a difficult question, given the competing challenges on their resources.

Claire Sweeney Audit Scotland
link

Local authority colleagues with whom we engaged as part of the work were very interested in what lay beyond the figure and some of the issues that it threw up. One such issue is rent levels across Scotland, which we touched on in the report. That is part of the mix, which includes not just other financial flaws in the housing system but local decisions on rent policies and how they work.A lot of factors need to be taken into account. However, people have received the messages. The Scottish Housing Regulator understands the methodology that we used and some of the tensions that lie in that. The issue is of interest and we will keep an eye on it, particularly in relation to the report’s impact and where it goes next.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I thank Colin Beattie for taking one of my questions; that reduces my time, which is fine.You tell us at the top of page 29 that something is not clear, and I am not sure whether my questioning will make it clearer, but I feel that I should raise the issue. The report says:“The Scottish Government is promoting alternative models of finance, but these carry risks and the extent to which they can compensate for reduced levels of subsidy is not clear”.You tell us that that is not clear, but I am asking for a bit more clarity, which seems to be a contradiction in terms.I have heard about the subject in the chamber often. From the answers that I have heard, I thought that the Government was confident about how it was proceeding with such funding. What you say causes me considerable concern. If the position is not clear to Audit Scotland, how clear is it to councils and RSLs? Can you help?

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

I will do my best.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I am also concerned about the risks.12:00

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

Sure. Our point is that, first, there is a gap between the amount of housing that we need and the number of houses that are being built. The attempt to fill the gap is being made in a very difficult financial climate for housing. I think that the Scottish Government is right to look at different ways of trying to fill the gap, hence the alternative funding model. We are not criticising the use of such a model in any way, because the Government must try to find a way of plugging the gap. I guess that what we are saying is that it is just too early to say. We do not yet have enough evidence to say whether the take-up of the alternative models of finance will be sufficient to plug the gap and to make good the reduced level of subsidy, even with the increase that was announced recently.That is why we said that the situation is not clear, although we may have more evidence in a year or two that would allow us to say more. Our recommendation is that, given that the Scottish Government has said that alternative models of finance are a potential solution for plugging the gap, greater support and leadership is required on its part to help councils and RSLs get to grips with those alternative models, take them up and start using them. There is a big capacity-building question for all housing associations and councils—particularly the smaller ones—in trying to understand matters such as the bond market, which I do not even begin to pretend to understand. It is therefore important that the social housing sector is helped along that road, if it is seen to be part of the solution.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

My second question is on leadership. Lack of leadership is a constant theme throughout the report. On “Planning and management” in part 3, you again say that there is a lack of leadership. You also said in your opening comments that there is a lack of leadership.You just explained why the situation is not clear, but you did not clearly explain the risks. Obviously, you have information that has led you to highlight in the report that the Scottish Government’s“alternative models of finance ... carry risks”.Where is the leadership not coming from? Further, where should the leadership be coming from? Tavish Scott and Bob Doris have talked about the complexities of the report, which is a bit of a muddle. Who should be leading? My second point is about the risks.

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

I will start on the leadership question and the team can come in on the more specific points around the risks. The leadership question has a number of levels. We have tried to be reasonably specific in the report where we think the Scottish Government has a role around leadership. For example, one role would be around the alternative models of finance that we have spoken about.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

So, housing ministers should be leading. Is that what you are saying? Is there a lack of leadership from the ministerial level?

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

As I said, I think that we have been quite specific in the report that there is a job for stronger leadership from the Scottish Government around helping councils and RSLs understand and use alternative models of finance more effectively. We make a point later in the report about the extent to which housing is playing its full part in, and is well connected to, other policies, which I think is partly a Scottish Government issue and partly a local issue. We have done community planning work recently in three places in Scotland and found that housing was not plugged into the community planning framework locally strongly enough or at a sufficiently strategic level. When we talk about stronger local and national leadership later in the report, that is the kind of thing that we are getting at. It is about being much clearer about the role that housing can play in improving health and wellbeing, the economy and so on.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

The recommendations on page 30 make the point that the Scottish Government should provide leadership.

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

Yes.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Perhaps I missed this, but what about the risks? What are the risks?

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

The team will come on to those now.

Claire Sweeney Audit Scotland
link

The risks are largely financial. As we say in the report, the environment is challenging anyway and the approach that has been taken is one option. That is not to say that there are not risks with taking other approaches, but there are clearly financial risks around some of the newer alternative models of financing. Those risks change over time and depend on a range of different factors. Different financial mechanisms can be used, each of which has its own set of risks and challenges.Some common risks relate to the stock, to the possible financial impact from underwriting guarantees if those go wrong and to the potential effects on the market. A raft of different issues need to be taken into account, depending on which model is pursued, such as the effect on rental income, the condition of stock and existing loans and covenants. All those things need to be taken into account before determining whether something is a viable option.Lessons can be learned from elsewhere—from other parts of the public sector, from England and from overseas. Lessons can be learned from where things went wrong or did not work out, but there is certainly an appetite for that. Other bits of the public sector are more familiar with some of those issues, which may be new for housing.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

At paragraph 59, the report states:“Many councils and RSLs lack experience and expertise in alternative financing models.”Coupled with that are the risks that you mentioned. Obviously, that is where the leadership is needed.My final question is on exhibit 7, which is on page 21. Why is there £9 million more announced funding than there is in reality? How could the Government announce £9 million more than is actually available?

Claire Sweeney Audit Scotland
link

This probably comes back to the message about the confusion over whether bits of funding have been announced previously or as part of another package. It was quite a challenge just to get to this point to articulate the changes to the funding arrangements over time. The report tries to set out what the top-line figures were at different points in time. Exhibit 7 tries to illuminate all the changes that have happened over time within that two-year period.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

So the figure that I have referred to may not be accurate. The amount involved is not huge, but it is still significant.

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

The two columns in exhibit 7 relate to two different years—I hope that I have understood your point correctly—and cover the announcements from 2012-13 and then the 2013-14 affordable housing supply budget line. I made this point slightly flippantly earlier, but the team had to spend a lot of time trying to get underneath this stuff. It was incredibly difficult to produce the exhibit on page 21—

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

The reason that we make the point about announcements is that an awful lot of the information comes through announcements in Parliament and other places. We had to spend a long time piecing together the information. However, you ask a very good question.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I just wondered how the announcements balanced with the actuality.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I want to ask about the report’s rather worrying conclusion that we will not meet housing demand over the next 20 years. How will that reveal itself? Will there be more kids living with their parents? I ask because I have six kids, so that is a frightening prospect.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

You need a couple of extra huts.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Yes, the sheds are going up in the garden as we speak.More seriously, does that mean that people will be living in unsuitable accommodation? Will the problem be reflected in longer waiting lists than already exist?

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

I will ask the team to respond to that, Mr Macintosh. I have only three kids, so perhaps I will not be in quite as bad a shape as you.It is difficult to tell, but there may well be a combination of all the things that you have mentioned. In this section of the report, we have tried to hold up a mirror to the Scottish Government and to the public sector by taking the research that was done back in 2005. The evidence suggests that there is a real gapWe have tried to map the trend on best-case, average-case and worst-case scenarios. Over that time period, many things can change, but the signs are that we will not have enough houses unless we do something quite different to meet need, in terms of overall numbers and of the shifting demographic and its implications for the housing stock.I am not sure that I can answer your question about what that will mean, but I think that it might well involve a combination of the things that you mentioned.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

The current recession is clearly having an impact, but you seem to be suggesting that a different approach is needed. In other words, you are saying that, rather than being related to a particular recession, the problem is structural; it is an on-going issue that will not go away if the economy picks up. Is that right?

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

It is absolutely clear that what has happened in the economy since 2007-08 has made it much more difficult to make progress. To be fair, the Scottish Government has responded to that by introducing new initiatives and different ways of generating more house building on the supply side. The financing that we have mentioned is one example of that.I do not know whether any of the team would like to add to that.

Claire Sweeney Audit Scotland
link

As we highlighted in the report, there are still shortfalls with the information that we have. For example, issues have been raised such as people living alone or living longer. We do not have sight of information that gives more detail about people with particular disabilities, which might lead to a need for a different type of housing. The ageing population will have an impact. The housing sector in its broadest sense faces a raft of challenges. We tried to emphasise clearly in the report that although there were challenges to do with the recession, the amount of housing stock and how suitable that stock is, it is a challenging time for housing in Scotland.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

You measured completions. Did you measure new starts as well?

Sally Thompson Audit Scotland
link

The Scottish Government does that. It keeps a database on starts, completions and approvals.

Sally Thompson Audit Scotland
link

For the purposes of the report, we focused on completions—the number of houses that were built.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

A particularly alarming figure on fuel poverty is given in exhibit 6 on page 17, which says:“In 2002, 13 per cent of people were living in fuel poverty. In 2011, 30 per cent of people were living in fuel poverty.”Are you confident that that figure will be reduced, or will it continue to increase?

Claire Sweeney Audit Scotland
link

That is one of many issues in the report on which we could have carried out more work. The report provides an overview of housing in Scotland. We tried to reflect all the different elements of housing policy and the breadth and complexity of the housing sector, so there are a number of issues on which there could well have been greater focus. They include issues to do with homelessness, capacity in the sector, the new-build programme and fuel poverty. We drew out issues that we thought were significant enough to warrant a place in such a report, but there is undoubtedly a big story behind quite a lot of the issues that are raised in the report.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

There is a target of abolishing fuel poverty by 2016. Is that even remotely possible?

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

I do not think that we are in a position to say whether it is possible at this stage. For me, that is a good example of how housing is central to a bunch of other stuff. The fact that we are heading in the wrong direction on the fuel poverty target is not just to do with housing. A bunch of stuff will be happening that will be contributing to that. That is why we think that the housing element of public policy—particularly when it comes to improving outcomes, reducing inequality and dealing with issues such as fuel poverty—is central and needs to be more central.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Part of that would be retrofitting—trying to improve the energy efficiency of existing older houses. Did you look at that?

Sally Thompson Audit Scotland
link

Yes. As we mention in the report, partly in response to fuel poverty and the targets on energy emissions, the Government is considering increasing energy efficiency standards for homes. There is already an energy efficiency standard that all council and RSL homes have to meet, and the Government is looking at raising that standard to help to address such issues.12:15

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Could you also look at existing older properties in the private sector, which, I would think, would form the majority of Scottish housing?

Sally Thompson Audit Scotland
link

The current standards are just for the social housing sector.

Claire Sweeney Audit Scotland
link

That said, the report highlights issues with regard to the state of private housing stock and its broader implications for the public sector and housing in general. Although we focused on public finance and resources in the public sector, we could not ignore the significant part that the private sector plays and have tried to bring it in where relevant.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

This will be your final question, Ken.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

All right, convener.As far as I am aware, most of the public finances are used to support new build in the private sector and to spark private purchasing of new-build housing, whereas in the rest of the UK they are used to buy older homes as well. Did you look at the effectiveness or uptake of such programmes and whether they represent good value for money?

Claire Sweeney Audit Scotland
link

We did not look at such schemes at that level of detail.

Sally Thompson Audit Scotland
link

The new money that was announced earlier this week includes help for first-time buyers to buy homes and for second-time buyers to move on to new homes. As a result, an element of that money is for older properties.

Sally Thompson Audit Scotland
link

My understanding is that a first-time buyer could use the money that way. However, the second-time buyer has to buy a new property.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I had only one more question, convener, but I will let you move on.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Okay. We will have a final question from Willie Coffey.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Despite the recession, which a few people have mentioned, and despite huge cuts in capital and revenue budgets of up to 29 per cent, we are in a good place as far as house building in Scotland over the past period is concerned and the Scottish Government’s achievements over the past few years have been pretty good. My information and research has thrown up three particular figures. I will try to use terminology that I think I understand, convener. In the past six years, 6,000 people or families have been able to buy property under shared equity schemes; 30,000 new houses have been built in terms of the social housing definition; and with regard to council house building, which, as previous housing spokesperson for my group in East Ayrshire, is close to my heart, nearly 4,000 new council houses have been built.I have always tried to persuade people, particularly in my constituency, to continue to rent, because it is a really attractive option for the future and indeed became more so as the recession bit hard. I therefore do not think it is any surprise that because of the recession the Scottish Government attempted to remodel how some of these—

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Do you have a question for Audit Scotland?

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Yes, convener, but it is important to make these points. After all, others have had the chance to make their points.What worries me more in the long term is whether supply can meet demand. Mr Macintosh referred to that in his questioning and the Auditor General’s report mentions that there will be more single-person households over the coming years. I am worried about the long-term planning for that issue, and wonder whether the report could have contained a stronger message to the Scottish Government and other partners to get together to think about this issue more forcefully over the next few years.I am also worried about the impact of these changes, particularly the benefit changes, on the private rented sector and its ability to meet the Scottish housing quality standard, which, as I understand it, the sector is not required to do at the moment, and I think that there is a good piece of work that either our committee or one of the other subject committees could do on that matter.Overall, though, performance over the past few years has been pretty good.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Stunned silence from everyone.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Well, the question is about looking to the future.

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

I absolutely take your point about the long term, Mr Coffey, and we can certainly reflect on how we have worded our recommendations in that respect. When we talk about how the long-term vision underpins national policies and informs local planning and practice and the need for a clearer strategy, that is exactly the kind of thing we are getting at.I said earlier that a lot of activity and innovative thinking is going on in difficult circumstances. We have spoken about exhibit 6, which shows some things that are good in their own right, but they have come along at a time when money is reducing and it is more difficult to get funding for housing.It is also worth referring to exhibit 5 in this context. It demonstrates that the structure of housing has changed beyond all recognition since the early 2000s; consider how many council and RSL homes we used to have. The world is very different now and we encourage the Scottish Government, councils, RSLs and others to get around the table and start thrashing out the discussion about the future and how to meet the need.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Audit Scotland does not look at the private sector and the standards that we expect of it, but someone should, convener, whether it be us or another committee. That piece of work needs to be done because of the impact of many of the changes that we are seeing just now.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Audit Scotland has looked at housing from a specific point of view, and at the Government’s targets and budget. Willie Coffey makes a relevant point, because more people are now being pushed towards the private sector, for whatever reason, which means a significant cost to the public purse. Could that fall within Audit Scotland’s remit in some future work?

Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland
link

It is worth bearing it in mind that councils are the strategic housing authority for their local areas and they need to consider the housing system in the round. Exhibit 1 shows that more than three-quarters of housing in the country is in private hands. Interestingly the real change has been in owner-occupied housing rather than in private rented housing, the levels of which have come down since the 1970s. We cannot work on private housing directly, because our job is about public spending, but in looking at how whole systems work, we would look at how the Scottish Government and councils are reflecting the private sector and the market in shaping what they can do. Even then, we can see real shifts in the past few years in the extent to which the Government is trying to influence, shape and intervene in the private market in a way that it would not have done some years ago, and we have seen some announcements on that recently. The emphasis is clearly already shifting and we will continue to track and monitor the situation as part of our work.However, to be clear, I do not think that we could go in and do a specific audit of the quality of private sector rented accommodation. That is not within Audit Scotland’s remit.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

I accept that. I know that the Infrastructure and Capital Investment Committee will be looking at the proposed housing bill, which will include a number of issues to do with the private rented sector. I was thinking about the financial implications for the public purse, given the changes in the way in which housing benefit is being managed. I know from my constituency that there has been an increase in the number of people who are in private rented housing and the rents are significantly higher than they are in either the housing association or council sector. That will impact on the housing benefit budget. Perhaps that is something that Audit Scotland should keep its eye on and, if you could make a relevant contribution to the Infrastructure and Capital Investment Committee, I am sure that it would be appreciated.Thank you for that. Again it just shows the interests and challenges that there are in housing.

  1. 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 180
  3. 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 145
  4. 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 45

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.