link
Thank you, convener. I appreciate the opportunity to say a few words before the committee considers the petition.
I am here to urge the committee to take the petition seriously. I think that very few people would want to do away with supermarkets, and very few would deny that, when they came on to the high street, supermarkets added something genuinely new to the retail environment and the sector.
However, we have reached the point at which the scale of the domination by a handful of multinationals is getting absurd. I remember the Scottish Parliament discussing some of these concerns about 10 years ago. At that point, the big four controlled somewhere between two thirds and three quarters of the retail sector in this country; their share is now getting close to 90 per cent, and it is still expanding.
The petition raises some specifically local issues, but all members will recognise that this is happening in every community. Many dense urban communities and rural communities find that competition in retail is now simply a choice between one supermarket and another instead of the rich diversity that they used to enjoy.
Your priorities might be those that local government and national Government talk about such as diversity, vibrancy in town centres and competition, or they might be about having shorter supply chains and greater trust and resilience in local economies. Because of the nature of their logistics, supermarkets will always be bad at the latter, and we will continue to see problems with the long, complex supply chains that gave rise to the recent meat scandal. Whether we are making the sustainability argument or the competition argument, we should recognise that the objectives that local and national Government is setting such as rich retail diversity and vibrancy in town centres are not being met.
I hope that the committee will give very careful consideration to the various options, whether they be use classes or some other mechanism, such as giving local authorities the ability to consider the cumulative total of floor space that an applicant has rather than simply the individual premises for which permission is being applied or for which permission might not be needed. Whatever the mechanism, we have to recognise that the public policy objectives that Governments have been talking about for a long time are not being met and are, in fact, being undermined by the continued dominance of supermarkets.
We could be here in another 10 years’ time with four companies controlling 95 per cent-plus of the retail sector in this country. That is not competition, and it is not sustainable. Whatever side of the argument you fall on, it is time to recognise that objectives for the common good are not being met.