At the moment, there is no mechanism for a hearing before the sheriff. There is the Lord Advocate’s investigation, which is carried out by the procurator fiscal; for most deaths, that investigation is, in practice, undertaken by the specialist Scottish fatalities investigation unit. Once we have reached a conclusion about the cause of death and the surrounding circumstances and once we have had that conversation with the family, consideration will be given to whether there should be a fatal accident inquiry under the terms of the current legislation. In some cases, there might be a petition to the court for a fatal accident inquiry.
If there is to be no such inquiry, the remedy open to the family is to take a judicial review of the Lord Advocate’s decision to the Court of Session. I would suggest that, because there is the remedy of judicial review to challenge the Lord Advocate’s decision, there is no gap of the kind that was mentioned earlier.
It may assist the committee to consider some of the cases that we are currently dealing with, from between October 2013 and 30 April 2014. There are 256 cases in which the death may well have been a suicidal death. We have done further work on behalf of and at the request of the families in relation to about 10 of those cases, in order to clarify matters. In the remainder of the cases, there have been no requests to do further work and no disagreements. In relation to the 10 cases, I do not think that there has been a disagreement as to the cause of death; there have been further things that families have wished to have clarified, we have agreed that it is appropriate to clarify them and we have instructed further investigations.
