I am happy to keep the petition open at present while we seek answers to the additional questions that have been raised.
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Single Room Hospitals (Isolation) (PE1482)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- David Stewart Lab 12
- Anne McTaggart Lab 5
- Chic Brodie SNP 4
- Jackson Carlaw Con 3
- John Wilson SNP 1
- David Torrance SNP 1
- Angus MacDonald SNP 1
The record
27 contributions
link
I am happy to keep the petition open.
PE1482, by John Womersley, is on isolation in single-room hospitals. Members have a note by the clerk. Alex Fergusson MSP has a constituency interest. I do not think that he is able to attend this meeting, but I mark his interest in the petition for the record.
Members will be aware that there are two main options for action: we could write to the Scottish Government to request that a cost benefit analysis be undertaken of having 100 per cent single rooms, as opposed to 50 per cent, over the course of a hospital’s lifetime; or we could defer consideration of the petition until the Scottish Government’s review of the research of single-bedded accommodation is complete and the results have been published.
I ask for members’ views on either option. Indeed, if members have other options, I would be interested to hear them.
How long do we have to wait for the other information to arrive?
As we are aware of hospitals being built with single rooms, we should consider more than a cost benefit analysis of operational costs. It would be instructive to examine the capital costs that are involved in building 100 per cent single rooms as opposed to 50 per cent. We should certainly have that information from the south of Scotland.
In my book, the more important issue is the research into the sociability of single rooms as opposed to shared accommodation—in some cases, 50 per cent shared accommodation—but we should still ask for the capital costs.
We will keep a close watch and see when the review is complete, which will be announced by the Scottish Government. The other information is factual, so I would expect to get it in the next four weeks. The review is taking place over the course of a year.
I think that there was some information about the capital costs in annex A of the SPICe briefing. Perhaps Mr Brodie would like to check whether that is sufficient for his purposes.
Do we keep the petition open for that length of time?
It has rather satisfied mine, I have to say.
I am not altogether sure what we do with the petition. The Scottish Government’s policy is clear. The Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing has indicated that he will undertake a review. If we are going to continue the petition, it would be interesting to invite the Scottish Government to provide some feedback on the attitudes of patients who have experienced single-room hospital accommodation. My understanding is that feedback has been favourable, that some of the questioning that underpinned previous surveys of opinion was predicated on some rather pejorative suggestions as to what patients might be likely to experience and that, in fact, the reality has proved to be quite different.
We have given the petition a good airing. The Government’s undertaking that there will be a review in due course to ensure that it learns lessons from the petition is as much as the committee can reasonably expect. I am slightly less persuaded about drilling further into the cost benefit analysis. It is an issue of policy and it is for the Government to determine what it believes to be in the best interests of the health of patients. I am not sure that it is relevant whether the light bulbs cost more in those circumstances.
That is the length of the review, so that is what we would be suggesting in order to keep a watching brief on it.
To be clear, Mr Carlaw, you are suggesting that we take option 2, which is to defer consideration until the Scottish Government’s review is completed.
And in the meantime the other piece of information will be sought.
My view is that we should close the petition on the basis that the Government has guaranteed that the review will take place at some point, which is a sensible and pragmatic course of action.
Yes, that is correct.
I disagree wholly with that because of sociability, which I mentioned. My concern is that the Scottish Government’s review relates to research on single-bedded accommodation in hospitals. I trust that it will not only discuss whether such accommodation is good or bad but consider the alternatives. Having some multibedded areas in hospitals has a good social and, indeed, healing effect, so I would keep the petition open. The costs are important.
Have we kept other petitions open for that length of time?
We have two options: to close the petition or to keep it open until the Scottish Government’s review is complete. What do other members think?
Yes.
I think that we have to complete that work.
Okay—thank you for that.
The petitioner requested in his email of 26 May that we write to the Scottish Government to ask that a proper cost benefit analysis is done. I think that we should honour that request, and we should certainly keep the petition open.
Okay. The majority position is that we continue the petition until the review is finished and seek the piece of information that the petitioner has asked for. We will report that back at a future meeting.
I do not for the life of me understand why it would take a year to do research on single-bedded and multibedded accommodation. The tail is wagging the dog in some of these situations, and we really need to ask questions about when we expect such things to be completed.
We are expecting Alex Neil to appear before the committee soon to discuss another petition. If members want to ask him further questions, that is totally in order as far as I am concerned.
I am sure that the cabinet secretary’s response, which would be entirely reasonable, would be that he would like some people to experience single-bedded accommodation in order to comment on it. That might take some little while.
I am not sure whether or not that is an offer.
We could continue the discussion for some time, but I will draw a line under it now. We will continue the petition until the review is complete, and we will ask for the information that the petitioner is requesting.
In this meeting
Everything on 3 Jun 2014 →- 10:00 Current Petition Petitions · 83
- 10:45 New Petition Petitions · 124
- 11:45 Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- 12:15 Current Petitions Petitions · 27
- 12:15 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- 12:15 Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- 12:15 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- 12:15 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- 12:15 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.