The seventh and final current petition is PE1494, by W Hunter Watson, on mental health legislation. Members have a note by the clerk and the submissions.
As the Scottish Human Rights Commission says, compatibility of the Mental Health (Care and Treatment) (Scotland) Act 2003 with the European Convention on Human Rights is, of course, ultimately
“a matter for the Courts.”
It is fair to say that there have been concerns about inconsistent practices in relation to electro-convulsive therapy under the 2003 act, but the independent review of practice and the Scottish Government’s proposed new mental health bill will, of course, allow participants and other concerned individuals to express their views on any proposed change.
I throw open the discussion for comments and points.
On that last point, it is important that the petitioner and others submit their views in the consultation. The petitioners have certainly generated emotion on that particular issue and emotion has been generated among the petitioners and others who are directly involved. It would be appropriate for us not to do anything other than suggest that the consultation proposals embrace the points that the petitioner and others have made.
I declare an interest. In my register of interests, I am still the deputy convener of the cross-party group on mental health.
Mr Brodie is right: the subject is very emotive. It is clear that a wide range of evidence has been provided to the committee on the issues that the petitioner has raised, particularly from the medical profession and others who have a particular point of view to justify their continued action.
It is clear that, once again, this is a petition that has to be treated with a great deal of sympathy and concern in light of both the issues that have been raised and individual circumstances. In some cases, the treatment might seem to be against the person’s human rights but, given the evidence that we have received to date, it is difficult to see how we can take the matter much further forward.
We should move to close the petition under standing orders rule 15.7, on the basis that there is broad agreement from the various organisations that the 2003 act is compliant with human rights legislation. There is a Government consultation on proposals for a mental health bill, and the most appropriate approach would be for the petitioners and others to submit their views to it in order that it benefits from the widest possible advice.
Before I bring in other members, I point out that we can obviously still pass to the Scottish Government any and all submissions that we have received on the petition, so not one word of any submission will be wasted when it comes to forming future Scottish Government policy and new legislation.
Convener, I agree with what you said about passing on the information that we have collated and with Jackson Carlaw’s suggestion that we should close the petition under rule 15.7 but ensure that the petitioners can submit their views to the Scottish Government.
I support Jackson Carlaw’s proposal to close the petition under rule 15.7. In doing so, however, I note that it is important how we record this, because on one of the previous petitions we asked the Government to consult the petitioner as part of any consultation about community pharmacies. Therefore, I strongly urge the Scottish Government to consult not only the petitioners but other members of the public who have made submissions to the committee on the issue. Although a number of professional and medical bodies will no doubt be among the statutory consultees when the Government holds its consultation, it is important that the individual members of the public, including Mr Watson, who have taken the time to submit the petition and other written evidence, should be part of the consultation process. I urge the Scottish Government to make every effort to contact the individuals who have made submissions, so that it can get their views as part of the consultation process.
I also agree with the suggestion that all the paperwork that the committee has received on the petition to date be submitted to the Scottish Government as part of the committee’s provision of evidence to it on any consultation that takes place.
David StewartLabThe Convener · Highlands and Islands
Thanks. We can certainly do that. If the committee agrees to close the petition, we can also write to the Scottish Government in those terms. Does Chic Brodie agree to that?
Absolutely. Although I am in general agreement with the suggestion, my one concern is that there are now only three weeks left before the consultation period ends. If we are to take this approach, I suggest that we must be fairly quick in asking the Government to make contact. Of course, as we have agreed, the Government will have all the evidence that has been submitted to us.
Chic Brodie is right about the timescale for the consultation. It might be useful if the committee also suggests to the Scottish Government that it extends the deadline for submissions to allow the individuals who have made submissions to the committee to be contacted by the Scottish Government to ensure that any information that they want to provide as part of the consultation process can be considered as part of the discussions that take place in the review of the responses to the consultation.
David StewartLabThe Convener · Highlands and Islands
In summary, we will close the petition under rule 15.7, but emphasise that all the documents that we have received as part of our consideration of the petition will be sent to the Scottish Government, that we will write to it to ask it to contact interested parties and, finally, that we will ask it to extend the submission date for evidence.
I thank Mr Watson for his time and trouble in preparing the petition and thank him very much for the petition.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.