Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Current Petitions

School Bus Safety (PE1098 and PE1223)

Tuesday 4 March 2014 Public Petitions Committee About 10:00–10:30 Petitions 45 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

45 contributions
David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

We move on to current petitions. We start with PE1098, by Lynn Merrifield, on behalf of Kingseat community council, and PE1223, by Ron Beaty, both of which are on school bus safety. Members have a note by the clerk and the submissions.

Stewart Stevenson was keen to come along for the committee’s discussion of the petitions, and I understand that he is on his way. When he arrives, I will invite him, with the committee’s agreement, to make a few general points. Before he arrives, I open the floor to committee members to express their views and give their thoughts on the next steps.

I highlight one point that members will be aware of. PE1098 is a long-standing petition, and I think that it is a very good one, but the clerk has reminded me to advise you that we have had no contact from the petitioner since March 2010. I put that point of information on the record. As I say, PE1098 has been a positive petition.

One first step would be to defer PE1223 to a future meeting so that we can seek an update from the Scottish and UK Governments on the progress of the section 30(2) order. Members will be aware that, under the Scotland Act 1998, it is possible to change legislative competence, as long as both Parliaments agree, with a modification through an order in council. That has happened in other areas, such as railways. It is possible for legislative competence to move from one Parliament to another, and to judge from the correspondence that I have seen between the two Governments, there seems to be keenness to try to get a change on the matter.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

I do not know if there is in fact keenness. The last time the matter was raised, I could not for the life of me see why things were taking so long. I do not understand the lack of willingness on the UK Government’s part to allow legislative competence to be transferred to the Scottish Government so that we can do something about the matter. We have lost sight—the UK Government has certainly lost sight—of what we are talking about. The end customers are the children who travel by bus. Having looked at the correspondence between our minister and the Department for Transport, I have no idea why papers are apparently just being shuffled around down south.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Mr Stevenson has arrived just in time. We know that you are very interested in the issue, Mr Stevenson, and that you have a strong constituency interest. Would you like to address the committee on the merits of the petition?

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

Thank you, convener. I am much obliged. I thought that you might be covering the petitions a little later, but fortunately the phone call came, so I am able to be with you.

It is worth our while to go back nearly four years, to when Mike Penning, who was then the appropriate minister at Westminster, came and gave evidence to the committee and indicated a willingness and a commitment to help out. In relation to what would be useful to us to progress the issue, Westminster has already provided the powers to the Welsh Assembly. The committee may wish to consider those points.

There is no magic bullet here, of course. It is a question of making some changes and seeing whether they help with bus safety in practice. In the north-east of Scotland and a couple of places in the south, there have been incidents of serious injury and harm to schoolchildren, and indeed death, in the vicinity of dropping-off and picking-up points of buses, and some of the proposed changes would appear to be helpful in relation to that. To be blunt, given that the petition has been around since 2008, we ought to be in a position to see some progress. I hope that the committee will keep the petition open and remain committed—as I am sure it will be—to helping not only my constituents but, more important, kids right across Scotland.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you. Just before you came in, Mr Stevenson, we were debating the use of section 30(2), which you will know from your time as the Minister for Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change, as it has been used, I think, in relation to another transport issue. Mr Brodie expressed frustration about the delay, particularly from the UK Government.

The letter that I received via Keith Brown from Stephen Hammond, Parliamentary Under Secretary of State for Transport, states:

“Robert Goodwill MP, Under Secretary of State, replied on 19 December”

—that was December 2013—

“that the Department for Transport officials are awaiting details of the functions for which transfer is being sought from Transport Scotland before proceeding.”

I am not making a party political point here, for obvious reasons. It is just that the Department for Transport seems to have patted the ball back to Transport Scotland for it to make some decisions.

It does not appear to me that there is any reluctance to transfer the powers, and I think that there is great willingness within the Scottish Government set-up to get some action if they are transferred, but what is your perspective?

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

You are quite right to distribute the issue among the relevant parties: Transport Scotland, the Scottish Government and the UK Government. It is relatively modest in scope, and administratively, such things often disappear a little bit too far down the pile. That is probably the case for all those who are party to the issue. However, I think that, as long as the committee keeps the pressure on, something will happen.

I have not counted the number of interactions that the committee has had with the relevant parties, but when I printed out the list of interactions, it ran to more than a page, with one line per item, the first of which is a submission in 2009 and the most recent of which is a Scottish Government letter from the past month or two.

This has been a long-running issue, and if the committee continues to add its weight, it could ensure that Transport Scotland lives up to its obligations, that the minister then signs the necessary correspondence and that the officials down south keep the issue at the top of their in-trays. I know that they have many things to which they pay a lot of attention, of which this issue will merely be one.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Can you provide any other helpful advice to the committee to help us to resolve the problem?

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

What is being done is probably the correct thing. I have in my mind an example of something that took a terribly long time when I was the Minister for Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change. It related to Vehicle and Operator Services Agency inspections and the need for the police in Scotland, although they were not needed in England. Everybody agreed, but after three and a half years, the situation had still not been fixed even though, every time we wrote, we were told that it would be. It was just an administrative issue. There was not a lack of willingness; it just somehow happened. I think that this issue is probably a similar case.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

It seems to me that there is willingness to accept the terms of both petitions. The only thing that the Scottish Government probably does not want to do is to introduce a ban on overtaking school buses. In many states in America, people are not allowed to overtake school buses. I am not sure whether the legislation is at the state level or the federal level, but there are certainly laws in America to prevent that from happening. However, the Scottish Government does not want that particular aspect of what PE1223 calls for to happen—that is where we are. On the rest of the proposals, I think that there is willingness to achieve a solution.

10:15

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

I am not overly concerned about the detail. What we need to do is to get the powers, apply them and see what works, and we will then be able to see what we should progress in the longer term. I suspect that, until we try things, we will not have good data on which to base decision making. That data will help colleagues elsewhere in these islands to make decisions, too.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

I think that I heard Mr Stevenson say a moment ago that the powers had been devolved to Wales. However, when Keith Brown appeared before the committee, he said:

“The UK Government has confirmed that it is not prepared to devolve construction and use regulations that would allow us to prescribe the design of vehicles.”—Official Report, Public Petitions Committee, 13 November 2013; c 1790.

Has that power been devolved to Wales? It seems to be the one without which the Scottish Government feels that it could not give effect to the aims of the petition even if other powers were devolved or certain other dispensations were given.

I am just trying to understand the situation. Has Wales managed to go ahead without that dispensation, or has it been granted to Wales? I understand why there would be concern about different construction rules applying to vehicles in different parts of the UK, because they would be crossing borders, and complications could arise from that.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

I do not want to give you false certainty on the subject. I am not a master of the detail of what has been devolved to Wales. However, with regard to construction and use, I think that we are talking about seat belts rather than anything else. That is the subject that PE1098 deals with; the petition in which I have a constituency interest is not directly about seat belts.

In reality, most of the buses are fitted with seat belts, albeit that they are mostly two-point ones and not three-point ones. I do not take a position on the issue. My concern is more to do with the outside branding and how we control access to and egress from the buses. That is what Mr Beaty is most focused on.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

Jackson Carlaw asked part of the question that I wanted to ask, but I will make a general comment. Perhaps it is because of the sector that I come from, but I find it absolutely unbelievable that, as Mr Stevenson pointed out, we have allowed an issue such as this to go down the pile. I am sick and fed up of being told that we will get responses to queries in four weeks. I received a letter last week from the Home Office telling me that it would not be answering any more of my correspondence relating to an immigration issue, because immigration is reserved.

As I said earlier, we seem to be losing sight of why we are here. It is not a game between two Governments. We are talking about children and children’s safety. For the life of me, I do not understand why it has taken this length of time to come to some sort of solution. I suggest that we ask the minister to come back to the committee, hopefully with a solution but at least to explain why this is taking so long.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

I note that the letter from the Department for Transport dated 13 December states that the DFT was waiting to hear from Transport Scotland, which said, as far back as March last year, that it was going to provide a list of the powers that it felt needed to be transferred.

It might be interesting for the committee to write to the Government in Wales to ask what powers it required in order to give effect to the changes in the legislation that it made. That would give us a checklist from a part of the United Kingdom where the change has been successfully accomplished, and we could use that to determine the necessary requirements for the objects of the petition to be achieved. I feel that we are sitting in the middle, in a vacuum of understanding, and the Welsh experience would give us something against which we could benchmark what is happening.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

That is a sensible idea. We have two immediate proposals. One is to invite the minister to attend and the other—they are not mutually exclusive—is to write to ask the Welsh Minister for Economy, Science and Transport what her experience has been. What do members think of those suggestions?

Anne McTaggart Lab Glasgow
link

I fully agree with those two suggestions. It is a current petition; have we sought the Welsh Government’s advice on the issue in the past?

Anne McTaggart Lab Glasgow
link

It would be more than helpful, in that case, for us to do that, and thereafter to speak to our own Minister for Transport and Veterans.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I suggest that, if we are going to invite Keith Brown to give evidence, we also ask him to provide us with a timeline for Scottish civil servants’ communications with the Department for Transport at Westminster. During the third session of this Parliament, Mike Penning MP attended this committee and assured us that any request that was made by the Scottish Government to transfer the powers would be looked upon favourably. Now, more than three years later, we are told in Keith Brown’s letter of 9 January that the civil servants have just made an application to the Secretary of State for Scotland for transfer of those powers.

I would like to know what has happened in the intervening three years since Mike Penning gave quite clear assurances. The then minister for transport in the Scottish Government was present when those assurances were given, so it seems to be clear that there has been a failure to follow through on the issues that were raised at that time and on the assurances that were given by Westminster. I know that there are procedural issues relating to applications for transfer of additional powers under the Scotland Act 1998, but the reality, based on the letter of 9 January, is that we are only now being given the assurance that civil servants are finally making an application, more than three years after the event.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

That is a good point. Chic Brodie has just made an interesting point to me off-microphone: he has suggested that we have at a future meeting a representative of the UK Government as well as Keith Brown, so that we do not suffer from “It wisnae me” syndrome and can determine what is happening, because it is in our interests to ensure that the matter is resolved.

As I said at the start, I do not pick up that there is any political or policy reason for not transferring the powers. Both Governments seem to want it, but there seems to be some bureaucracy that has stopped it happening. How do members feel about setting up a future meeting at which both ministers appear together?

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

If such can be arranged, I have no objection to its taking place.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

In the meantime, we should still write to the Welsh Government.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

That would help to inform us as to what is needed.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

The other thing that we could stress when we write to the UK Government—this is a bit of a cause of mine—is that we can offer them an opportunity to give evidence by videoconference rather than in person. I feel that we should use that facility more; there is an associated climate change issue, and it might also allow us to arrange an earlier meeting. Do members agree?

Members indicated agreement.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

I concur with the comments that have been made so far and am happy with the recommendations that have been made. We can all see that it is a prime example of the wheels of government grinding exceeding slow, but when two governments are involved the wheels are not just grinding slowly, but are at dead slow or stop. I hope that section 30(2) of the Scotland Act 1998 will be used as soon as possible, but I am certainly happy with what has been suggested.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Unless there are any fresh suggestions, I shall summarise what we are doing. First, we shall write to the Welsh transport minister to ask about the Welsh experience of what happened in similar circumstances, so that we have that intel before the committee. Secondly, we shall set up a future meeting to be attended at the same time by Keith Brown and by representatives from the UK Department for Transport—whomever are the appropriate minister and civil servants—with the recommendation that the meeting be held by videoconference. We are not suggesting that we have the Welsh Government minister here at the same time. That would overcomplicate things. That is what I have picked up from the committee.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

I presume that we would invite someone from Transport Scotland along with the minister.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Yes. The minister would normally bring along representatives from Transport Scotland, although we could suggest it in the letter to Keith Brown.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I just want to reiterate my point, convener. Are we writing to ask the Scottish Government for a timeline? In 2010, we received an assurance that the issue could be dealt with by the Scottish Government and UK Government, but I am concerned about the letter of 9 January, in which the minister assures us that civil servants are only now applying to transfer the powers. It would be interesting to get a timeline and to hear what discussions have taken place, and why it has taken so long to get to the stage that we have now reached—more than three years later.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

We need to be clear about the objectives of the engagement with ministers. I suspect that, if ministers from both Governments thought that we were seeking to establish a negotiation “live, on air” to resolve matters, the powers that be around them would recommend that they think twice before participating. We are really seeking to clarify the issues so that Governments can resolve them, rather than trying to broker that resolution, which might be frowned upon.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

It might raise the eyebrows of some civil servants if there was a suggestion that we are doing that. Perish the thought.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I draw members’ attention to the Official Report of 10 October 2010, in which Mike Penning gave a clear assurance that if the Scottish Government were to apply for the transfer of the powers, that would be considered favourably. I understand Jackson Carlaw’s reservations about the committee brokering negotiations between the Scottish Government and the UK Government. However, if a UK Government transport minister gave us such a clear assurance in October 2010, that means that the committee has a clear role in brokering some kind of agreement between the UK Government and the Scottish Government so that we can move the petition forward.

It has been quite frustrating sitting here for almost four years, listening to the same debate, and not seeming to get any further forward except that an application is now being made via the Secretary of State for Scotland to the UK Government for the transfer of powers.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

It is worth reminding ourselves that there has, of course, been a change of Government down south, although I do not believe that that is material in any sense. Mike Penning felt quite passionately about the issue. If I recall correctly, he was a fireman in a former life and so, in that capacity, had to deal with the consequences of accidents on our road networks. He therefore had a lot of personal oomph behind making something happen. That is not to criticise any of his successors, but sometimes when a matter is personal, things can happen more quickly.

I am confident about and happy with what I am hearing and I am sure that my constituent, Mr Beaty, will be too.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

Mike Penning is a member of the current Government.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

There has been continuity, in that sense.

The difficulty is with the definition of the powers. That is why I think that the exercise of writing to the Welsh Administration will be helpful. There might well have been an understanding that powers could be transferred, but there might have been a subsequent request or it might have emerged that powers that go beyond those that were initially envisaged would have to be transferred. That is why I would like to understand how the transfer was achieved in Wales; it would make things clearer and easier for us.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

We have a good programme of action for dealing with the petition. John Wilson has another point.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

It is just a correction, convener. I gave the date of the meeting to which I referred as 10 October 2010, but it was on 26 October 2010.

10:30

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you for that. We have a clear plan of action for Ron Beaty’s petition. I look forward to the subsequent meetings and to getting the issue resolved. I thank Mr Beaty for being in the gallery today.

PE1098, by Lynn Merrifield, is another good one. However, my understanding is that she has now emigrated. In theory, there is nothing to prevent us from continuing the petition, but the clerks have not been in touch with her since 2010. Unless members feel strongly about the issue, it would probably be best to close the petition on the basis that we have no contact with the petitioner.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

Some time ago, the committee decided to conjoin the two petitions because of the crossover between the issues. I am keen to keep the petition live, because we have been running the two petitions side by side and we have always discussed them together. The main issue in Lynn Merrifield’s petition is seatbelt safety, which is as relevant today as it was when the petition was originally lodged.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Personally, I am relaxed about the issue. I just thought that I should do my duty and ensure that the committee knows that there is no current contact with the petitioner. As John Wilson said, Lynn Merrifield’s petition is mainly about three-point seat belts, which Stewart Stevenson has referred to. If members feel strongly about it, I am totally relaxed about keeping the petition open. Do we agree to keep it open?

Members indicated agreement.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I thank Mr Stevenson and Mr Beaty for attending.

  1. 10:00 New Petition Petitions · 12
  2. 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 45
  3. 10:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  4. 10:45 Current Petitions Petitions · 13
  5. 10:45 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  6. 11:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 19
  7. 11:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 14
  8. 11:00 Committee Working Practices Committee business · 7

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.