The fourth current petition is PE1458, by Peter Cherbi, on a register of interests for members of Scotland’s judiciary. Members have a note by the clerk, which is paper 4. We also have the clerk’s note of the meeting between the Lord President, Chic Brodie and me, and we have the submissions.
I will make a couple of points before we debate the petition. The petitioner suggests that we call the Scottish Court Service to give evidence on its existing staff register of interests. Moi Ali, the Judicial Complaints Reviewer, has provided an interesting additional paper in which she makes the powerful point that the issue is the
“failure to recuse”
and
“not ... a dearth of recusal data.”
Her letter is direct and straightforward and she pulls no punches about the issue.
The committee might wish to write again to Lord Gill to ask whether he considers that a record of declarations of interests, similar to that for several members of the judiciary in the SCS annual report, could be set up for other judges and sheriffs. Members will know that only a handful of them are involved in the SCS board; a much greater number are not members of that board, so they are not required to declare interests.
Those are key points for the committee. I throw the discussion open to members.