Agenda item 5 is on the section 23 report “Developing financial reporting in Scotland” and on evaluation in the public sector. We are delighted to have Sir Peter Housden and Alyson Stafford still with us. I invite Sir Peter Housden to make a brief opening statement.
Official Report · Committee
Section 23 Reports
“Developing financial reporting in Scotland” and Evaluation in the Public Sector
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alyson Stafford 30
- Ken Macintosh Lab 25
- Mary Scanlon Con 12
- Sir Peter Housden 11
- James Dornan SNP 6
- Bob Doris SNP 4
- Colin Beattie SNP 3
- Willie Coffey SNP 3
The record
94 contributionsI will be very brief. Our view of the Auditor General’s report is that it is both timely and helpful. It contains a good set of questions to be discussing currently. We think that, in Scotland, we start from a good place on the issue, because the Government’s accounting processes accord with best practice and international standards, so there is a firm foundation. The UK Government’s move over a number of years to whole of government accounts is an important development on which the Parliament and Government need to reflect in order to establish an appropriate path for Scotland. As the deputy convener said earlier, changes are already under way that are associated with the Scotland Act 2012 and its implementation, and those raise questions about reporting.We therefore welcome this conversation. Alyson Stafford, who is our lead professional accountant in the Scottish Government, will work with Caroline Gardner on the issues and will be happy to pick up on any specifics that the committee might wish to ask about.
Thank you, Sir Peter—that was helpful. I invite questions from members.
link
When the Auditor General gave evidence, I raised with her the question of quality of data collection, and she said that, in relation to financial reporting by the Government, there does not seem to be an issue with the ability to capture relevant data to enable accurate reporting.However, a wider issue arising from that, which we have discussed repeatedly in the committee, is that pretty much on a legacy basis the quality of data that we capture across the public sector is generally poor. There have been cases in which the Auditor General has commented strongly that, although she has reached conclusions, they are based on evidence that is not as strong as it should be or could be, if there was better data collection. The committee has often discussed how best to implement a solution to that across the board.We see patches here and there and we get snapshots from different parts of the public sector that indicate clearly that there is a general problem. Clearly, the situation is improving in some areas, but there seems to be no joined-up effort to improve it 100 per cent across the public sector. The approach seems to be that, as and when an issue comes up, it is fixed. Is it possible to consider whether there is a better approach?
I agree whole-heartedly with the committee in attaching importance to the issue. Colin Beattie has pointed to the fact that there is a whole world beyond financial data; you are also right that there are legacy questions. It is important that, when policy is being developed, we have absolute clarity on the objectives of the policy, how we will know what success is and how it is to be measured.We must also understand how information is to be collected and reported, which is Colin Beattie’s point. Part of the problem with legacy issues has been the absence of a logical sequence and/or a shift in the perspective of programmes over the years. A programme might have begun with particular objectives but moved on to others, so the data that were originally collected no longer enable the committee and others to form an intelligent view on the success or otherwise of the programme.There is a whole-Government concern about those questions and a drive to improve quality across the board by tackling those legacy questions and by ensuring that our new policy work is appropriate in that way.12:00
link
I must emphasise that this is an audit committee and that, as a result, we work on figures and statistics. If the statistics are inaccurate or inadequate, it makes it very difficult for us to do our job effectively. In some cases, the figures that we have seen are quite equivocal.
I think that that is where our common interests lie. I, too, have a responsibility to get value for money and to deliver the Government’s programme, so I, too, need those tools to do my job effectively. Indeed, we are working with the chief statistician and others in the Scottish Government because we share your concern about consistently improving the quality of data.
link
I am pleased that you have a concern and that you recognise the issue, but is anything actually happening?
In the current programme of public services reform, the Scottish Government has what in our jargon is called a programme board, which is headed by a senior official who is responsible for delivering that programme. Part of the board’s responsibility is to ensure that the data arrangements that underpin that programme are adequate to the task. Inevitably—as the committee’s work has thrown up—boards often deal with legacy issues of less-than-perfect integration between systems, which I know has been an issue for members in the past, or have other concerns. That is where the responsibility is located, and we are certainly giving priority to that in our work.
I cannot speak for the whole committee, but I fully support Colin Beattie’s point. Inadequate and occasionally inaccurate and inconsistent information has been a source of tremendous frustration for the committee.
I have a couple of questions that lead on from Colin Beattie’s comments, but first of all I want to disassociate myself from the deputy convener’s comments at the end of the previous evidence session, which I thought were inappropriate and undeserved.Has the Scottish Government identified areas of public service delivery where there are data gaps and, if so, what action has it taken to address them? I am thinking, for example, of staffing activity in general practices.
The gaps are very specific to particular issues. As I said a moment ago, we have for each major area of responsibility a programme board with a responsible senior official, part of whose responsibility is to ensure that they have the data tools to do their job, including tackling questions of different data sources and points of collection. I know from its early work that that has been a really important issue for the committee, which has wrestled with different data collection practices and frameworks in health boards, and with difficulties in accessing general practitioner data. That is a matter of historical fact and colleagues who are working on those programmes are seeking to ensure that we get the best possible fix on those issues and, importantly, as new policy is being developed, that we have an appropriate data flow that enables us to understand whether the programme is delivering its objectives and which we can share with the committee to enable it to carry out its scrutiny work.
Can we be confident that in a year’s time that flow of information and data will be much more readily available and consistent?
That is certainly our intention. As your work goes forward and as you deal with specific questions, I would want you to be progressively more confident that the legacy issues are being addressed to the extent that they can be addressed, and that new policy has a sound basis. That is an important priority for us.
I have a question about the 5 per cent cap that you might already have answered to a great extent. How do you plan to report the budgeted and actual position against the cap each year?
The cabinet secretary will set that out in his budget document; it will be set out in next week’s budget and I expect that to be the pattern from then on.
So, the issue is in hand.
Yes.
I have a final question. Your report states that“the Scottish Federation of Housing Associations estimated that the UK Government’s welfare reform measures will adversely affect the income of around 20 per cent of housing association tenants”—that could be a low estimate—“with implications for the financial stability of social landlords. Should any of these organisations get into financial difficulty, the public sector”,with the Scottish Government at the top of it,“may need to step in with financial and other assistance to secure continuity of services.”How does accounting for Westminster policy—policy failures, in this case—impact on financial planning and how do you get that information to us?
There is a wider landscape to which we must have regard, which can have financial and policy impacts on the Scottish Government’s programme. The UK Government’s financial settlement and policies are major contributors, but not the only ones. We therefore seek to monitor all those issues appropriately and effectively, offering advice to ministers on the implications for the Government in order to enable them to reach decisions and, where they deem it to be appropriate, to introduce new policy or to vary arrangements. Those are the issues on which scrutiny by the committee is available.It is, as we have seen in the context of financial reporting, open to the committee to develop new pieces of work, to ask new questions and to hold Government ministers and officials to account for specifics of that type. You have both those avenues to pursue if you wish.
Okay. Thank you very much.
I return to the subject of the 5 per cent rule—or limit, or whatever. You suggest that the cabinet secretary will give us more information on it in the budget. Can you explain what it covers? For example, when the Government pays back through a revenue finance programme does the money come out of only the revenue stream of DEL coming to the Government or does it come out of the capital stream, too?
The payment to support contracts that are revenue financed will come from our resource budget.
Does it come only from your revenue budget or from your capital budget as well?
I am sorry. To use the same language as you, it comes from the revenue resource budget.
I ask that because, as I understand it, the 5 per cent applies to the DEL budget. In other words, it applies to 5 per cent of revenue and capital together, but you then pay it solely out of the revenue budget. So, as a percentage of the revenue budget the figure will be higher than 5 per cent—the percentage will be different. Let us say that the capital accounts for roughly a tenth of the total budget. If you work out the percentage as a percentage of revenue and capital, the figure will be lower than if it were worked out simply as a percentage of the revenue budget.
In terms of the arithmetic, yes—you are absolutely right.
So, that is how it is done.
Yes.
At the moment, the calculation is also done simply on Government revenue—it does not include local government spending. Let us take a school, for example. Let us say that the Government commitment to a PPP project were 50 per cent—it would be 60 per cent for a secondary school, but let us use the figure of 50 per cent. In your revenue, you would count that 50 per cent but the local government commitment would not be included.
That is right. In assessing it against the costs that fall on central Government, it is the central Government cost that is recorded.
So, local government borrowing and local government revenue finance are not included, despite the fact that that revenue comes from central Government. That long-term commitment is not accounted for in the 5 per cent rule.
Your exposition is absolutely right. Local government receives a grant from central Government and it has other income sources, as well.
What about other bodies? Let us take Scottish Water, for example. Would its liabilities—its future borrowing—figure in your 5 per cent rule?
The main relationship between the Scottish Government and Scottish Water is the loans that the Scottish Government gives to Scottish Water. I will use the same example as the Auditor General. When someone takes out a mortgage, they get the benefit of an asset that they can use, but they must pay the financing and other costs related to that over a period of time. That is the interaction that we are talking about. It is revenue-financed investment. For example, it is the non-profit-distributing models or whatever supporting schools, road transport or the college investment that is taking place through contracts that have been signed recently. It will also include the areas within transport that are on the regulated asset base. That is where an asset is being provided—for example, by Network Rail—and the financing of that must come out of our annual costs over a period of time. Depending on the contract, that could be 20 or 25 years.
So, Scottish Water loans would be treated separately, but the rail asset base would be included and the funding for any borrowing against the rail asset base would be included as part of revenue financing.
Where there are revenue costs that the Government must pay each year for the benefit of an asset that is being provided through a contract arrangement with another party, those costs would be included.
Let us take, for example, the Borders railway and the EGIP programme, which have changed from being privately financed to being borrowed for against the rail asset base. Do you count both for the 5 per cent rule for revenue finance?
Yes.
Both are counted.
Yes.
Local government and Scottish Water are not included, but other borrowing is included. Are there other major projects that I have missed that would be included for the 5 per cent rule?
It is about the financing arrangements that we have. Anything that comes under NPD-type contracts is included, as well as some historical contracts. Anything that was built under PPP or PFI arrangements, depending on which contract format was used, and requires the Government to meet revenue resource costs each year, is captured. We include both the legacy contracts and the new ones, along with the estimates of what we will take on in the future, based on the commitments that ministers have made.
I am anxious to get this right. Local authorities can sign their own contracts if they want to, although they tend to sign them in conjunction with the Government. However, rail is operating as an arm of Government. It is not operating independently; it is borrowing on Government revenue, not its own. Is that correct?
Network Rail will have its own financing arrangements to enable it to make capital investments in the rail network in Scotland. The key thing for the 5 per cent cap is that we recognise that there will be costs for the Government to pay over a number of years for the benefit of that asset being provided by Network Rail. Those costs are calculated and added in. That links in to the Auditor General’s comments. This is one of the provisions for which it is within the gift of the Government to ensure that the future costs of such commitments are taken into account and managed well within the current framework of our finances, bearing in mind that the commitments stretch for well over 20 years, in most cases.
Indeed. That is precisely the point that I am trying to get at. I am trying to establish clarity and transparency.There are two separate issues. One is the ability of Parliament and others to monitor specific projects or decisions. I am thinking, for example—although we did not raise the matter earlier—of our ability to scrutinise the decision around reprofiling of the EGIP project and the move from its being privately financed to its using rail asset based borrowing. There is a difficulty in the Parliament’s scrutinising that issue.The second issue, which has been flagged up in the report, is about the transparency of figures generally. The Auditor General explained at length why, following the global financial meltdown, it is more important that we all have the information to hand.The 5 per cent rule is designed to give some comfort, but it does not include all the future borrowing. That is the key point. There is a lot of borrowing going on in Scotland—against the public finances—for which the Government will, I imagine, be liable in the end. I could be wrong about that, but that borrowing is going on and government in its broader sense will be liable. Therefore, it should be publicly reported to Parliament in some way.
There is a distinction between the scope of our constitutional landscape and the statutory arrangements that are currently in place for the Scottish Government. This good measure ensures that there is an appropriate financial management arrangement around the use of revenue finance to boost capital, which is obviously being pushed because, in the economic circumstances, infrastructure investment is seen as something that will help economic growth.Seeing that in the scope of what we have now, and separate from the recommendations or commentary coming from the Auditor General about our handle on and understanding of the wider liabilities across Scotland, you are right to suggest caution in respect of testing whether all those liabilities would sit at the door of the Government if things went to a particular place in any public body. There will not necessarily be the same line of sight in all cases.12:15
Indeed. On the same point, exhibit 10 on page 20 of the Auditor General’s report on financial reporting presents quite a stark and revealing picture of the rise in charges for private finance under the current Government.You are suggesting that the Government has a 5 per cent limit. I was trying to work out whether the projects that are listed in the graph in exhibit 10 are all included in that limit. Would you be able to hazard a guess at whether or not they are?
I do not tend to work on the basis of hazarding guesses, you will be pleased to know—
Yes, exactly.
Regarding exhibit 10, I would highlight local government as one area that functions in the way that we have just rehearsed. The costs that are shared with local government around the schools programme, for example, are shown in the graph for local and central Government. With regard to the 5 per cent cap, it is the central Government cost that we take into account.
So, in other words, if the graph was to include local government finance, we may be within the 5 per cent central funding cap, but we would be well in excess of 5 per cent if we added in all those additional borrowing commitments.
We would not necessarily be comparing on a like-for-like basis, though. We are dealing here with the funding that is available to central Government and comparing with that the cost that central Government actually has to face. That is around our present regime, with its particular construction based on Parliament authorising expenditure and overseeing the expenditure of central Government against the allocation that it is given.
There are two different issues. One is being able to monitor and authorise that on an individual basis, and the second is being transparent about the bigger picture and the long-term liabilities. As the Auditor General said earlier, if there are other costs that are coming our way, that has a bearing on our ability to assess affordability over the long term and on our decisions about borrowing.Specifically on contingency funding, a line in Audit Scotland’s report on key transport infrastructure projects, right at the very end at paragraph 102, states:“Transport Scotland and the Scottish Government have not reported publicly the larger £5,154 million estimated spending commitments over 30 years for the four revenue-financed projects.”I think that that was because they were not including contingency funding. Is that right? Does the Government not include its contingency commitments for those projects?
Can I just check that you are referring to paragraph 102?
It is at paragraph 102, on page 42 of the transport report.The question that I am trying to ask is, do you publish the contingency sum that is associated with either major or minor capital projects?
Paragraph 102 refers to those projects that are revenue financed. Linking in with what we said earlier, when those contracts reach financial close and are signed, and all the commercially sensitive engagement has therefore been completed, we put them all on our website and set out what the unitary payments are. Those are the future payments that will, in effect, be the Scottish Government’s liability.We have been publishing those contracts for some time, including for the historic PPP, NPD and PFI contracts, and anything in the same vein. One of the items that was published yesterday shows the three most recent NPDs that have been completed and sets out the future revenue streams.
Just to check, does that include the contingency sum that you set aside to cover those projects?
I am thinking about the language that we are using here. It is actually measuring. Those publications set out the sums of money that will be required and it is those sums of money that we then take into account against the future budgets that we expect to have as to how far that takes us towards the 5 per cent cap. That is the link between the two.
Can I just say—
I still have two members waiting.
In that case, this will be my final point.The Auditor General published a helpful set of dashboards that might be a useful guide. She also suggested some principles for public reporting on infrastructure projects:“Specifically, information should help the Parliament to assess ... What projects are under way and how are they progressing compared to previously approved time, cost and scope targets? ... What are the full financial effects of current and planned infrastructure investment and in particular how does spending compare to 1) the capital budget and 2) the Scottish Government’s five per cent affordability limit for revenue-financed investment?”Do you agree with those principles?
I will just find that in my papers, if I may.
Sorry. That was quite a lot to read out.
Yes.
What is the paragraph reference?
Sorry. It is annex B on page 11 of—oh, sorry. This is a committee paper, is it not?
It is a public paper.
So it is public. It is annex B and is on principles that the Auditor General suggested might be used by the Government in reporting to the Parliament. It is about public reporting. It is on page 11 of the paper after the section headed “Major Capital Projects update – options”.
Perhaps the witnesses do not have a copy of the paper.
Sorry. I now see the section that you are referring to, which refers particularly to“the full financial effects of current and planned infrastructure investment”,and how spending compares“to ... the capital budget and the ... five per cent”.Those are the sorts of things that we track in terms of good financial management. It reverts to Sir Peter Housden’s earlier comment that there is an awful lot of detail behind this. There is also a range of different financing arrangements. For example, we have already talked about NPD, and there is the regulated asset base. More recently, we have loan facilities through something called financial transactions, which is a consequential of budgetary decisions that were taken in the UK Government. Those are the areas that I think we need to work through with the committee and with Audit Scotland on how we capture that information. It is something that is accessible to the committee, bearing in mind the different types of funding arrangements, which are quite multiple and set out in a complex way. However, I am happy to work with the committee on that basis.
Thank you.
link
I have a brief question first in relation to exhibit 10—“Estimated annual PPP charges for PPP projects currently in progress, over the period of the contract”—to which Mr Macintosh referred. I know that this is not the witnesses’ exhibit, but I would like to know how the Scottish Government would report that information. I am conscious that someone looking at exhibit 10 could say, “Ah! Since 2007, there’s a dramatic increase and trend there.” However, of course, to get the full information you need to know when projects were started, because peak costs may be a year, 10 years or 15 years from the commencement date.When the Scottish Government reports on PPP, PFI or NPD projects, would you seek to be a bit more sophisticated in terms of tracking? For example, a future Scottish Government from whichever party could be presented with a table like the one in exhibit 10 that might look as if there has been a significant increase in the Government’s borrowing or their revenue commitments via public-private partnerships and NPD. However, that would not be the full story, because the essential thing is when the contracts were signed and when those liabilities were entered into. Would the Scottish Government seek to report in a more detailed way so that this committee and others could see the full picture?
I will take this one. You are right to pull out that there is quite a lot of lead time before you would ever see something on a graph like exhibit 10, because there is the policy need and the concept of actually saying that a particular project needs to be delivered. There are also all the assessments that happen around the appropriate way of financing the project, such as the value-for-money case, economic assessments and so on.Therefore, the costs that are recorded in exhibit 10 are recorded only when those assets have been completed—when the contract and construction have been delivered and the assets have been passed over for use in the public sector. It is at that point that the revenue finance liability—the requirement to meet those costs—passes to the relevant part of the public sector or central Government to pick up. How much information we can set out about that lead time is something that we would want to take away and work through.The key thing from the point of view of assessing financial affordability and having the good discipline of working within the 5 per cent cap is to ensure that we have this information available. We would need to work through the background to the lead times and the lead-up to the costs in question. I think that we could probably do that on a generic basis and give some idea of what happened in particular years.
link
I want to move on and talk about projections. It would be quite helpful to look at such information and see estimations of how close that would take you to the 5 per cent cap, because such projects are long-term investments. The point of having the cap is to ensure that we do not prevent future Governments from having the flexibility to make their own policy decisions.I want to talk about projections, but in relation to another matter. In part 3 of the report, the Auditor General talks about the opportunities that exist to go further in the development of financial reporting. In particular, she talks about the need to be able to estimate future tax income under the Scottish rate of income tax and the discussions that will have to take place on that between the Scottish Government, HMRC, the UK Government and the OBR. An accommodation has been reached between the Scottish Government and the UK Government whereby, from 2016, for the first two to three years—regardless of any variation in the Scottish rate of income tax—the Barnett block grant will be retained. Only at that point will we become open to variations and fluctuations in income tax levels. I do not know whether it would be this committee or the Finance Committee that would want to look at that. When can we expect to get Scottish Government projections for what the revenue will be from a Scottish rate of income tax based at the base rate, without any fluctuations or variations? Can we expect such information to be provided by the independent fiscal office, the establishment of which there has been talk of? When do you expect that we will be able to see such information?I realise that I am not being as concise as I could be but, rather than scrutinising things after the event, it would be helpful if this committee or the Finance Committee could have some projections that will tell us whether there is to be a shortfall—I would like to think that, with good economic policies, there could be a surplus—before we find out the realities. In what year do you think that we will get the first set of projections from the Scottish Government for what the revenue will be from the Scottish rate of income tax?
You have outlined that there will be a period between the Scottish rate of income tax starting in 2016-17 and the Scottish Government being required to manage any risk to do with variability. It is fair to say that the Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Employment and Sustainable Growth is still to set out the detail behind the question that you raise. What I can say is that the OBR began to produce five-year forecasts for the receipts from the devolved taxes—which are a more immediate issue for us and for which there are not the same transition arrangements—in March 2012. Those are updated and we use that information. That probably gives you a reasonable idea of the sort of lead time that we would want to work to for the Scottish rate of income tax.
link
That is quite helpful. Perhaps I should have asked my question in another way, as it was less about when that will happen and more about what the reporting procedures will be and whether they will involve the Public Audit Committee or the Finance Committee. Has any thought been given to whether the Public Audit Committee will scrutinise those projections and the realities, or whether that will sit with the Finance Committee? That might not be a question for today. In part 3 of the report, the Auditor General talks about opportunities for the Parliament to go further in the future as it gains more power and responsibility fiscally and in other areas. Do you have any initial thoughts about where such scrutiny would take place?12:30
You are right to highlight the Finance Committee as well as the PAC. There will be particular areas that are specific to the PAC and specific areas for the Finance Committee. There will also be areas where there will be appropriate interaction with both committees.I recognise the role of the Finance Committee in scrutinising tax forecasts, which would be part of its review of the spending plans that are set out in budgets. I expect that you in the PAC would have a role in examining tax receipts and forecasts by way of scrutinising the audit arrangements and reports that come from activity to forecast and build in receipts from taxation. The devolved tax collection accounts would support that. Does that help you?
link
It does help. I do not think that there has to be complete clarity just now. This is a repetition of what I said earlier about such questions being asked at such an early stage by the Auditor General, which is helpful in establishing how we take the matter forward. As long as these issues are on the radar and the Government is thinking about them, I am content. I am sure that we will return to the matter.
Very much so.
I call Willie Coffey, and we will then wind up the evidence session.
I would like to develop a broader picture. Colleagues have been excellent at picking out some of the detail. Sir Peter, the Auditor General presented a report showing us a landscape of assets and liabilities. Is it too early? When will the Scottish Government form a view about that picture of assets and liabilities, and about how accurate it may be? Is it as complete as the Auditor General presented it to us? You heard some discussion among members about things that were perhaps omitted on either side of the balance sheet. What is your view of that? When will you develop the Scottish Government’s impression of what that landscape will look like, so as to establish the baseline that the committee discussed earlier?
There are some big considerations in play, as you describe. There is an important discussion to have, including with yourselves, about what would be helpful and appropriate for your purposes. Rather in parallel with the major transport infrastructure projects, there is a huge wealth of data that could be brought to the table. Transparency, and being clear about the bases on which different numbers are included and aggregated, will be really important.We think that the relatively recent publication from the Auditor General is very useful, and we look forward to engaging with her on all the issues. I am not sure that I would venture a timescale for the conclusion of that but, as I said in my introduction, the report is timely because of the Scotland Act 2012 and other matters, and it will form part of our continuing work programme with Audit Scotland.
I am always mindful of what the public might think of all this work going on, and of how easy or difficult they might find it to access this kind of information. I always like to bear it in mind that, ultimately, we want to report to the public in Scotland about how Scotland is performing and so on.
Hear, hear.
Whatever we do on data gathering, preparation, interpretation, analysis, evaluation and so on, it needs to be intelligible and understandable by the ordinary man and woman in the street. I would like to think that the contribution that we can make to this work would include that important element, so that the public can access this kind of information easily and readily.
That is a very important point. One of the aspects of Scottish government that has attracted international recognition and attention is the national performance framework, which provides a range of important outcomes, which are reported on in a transparent and regular way. The cabinet secretary is committed to the continuous development of all that, and appropriate financial information in parallel is an important component of an overall picture.
I will ask two brief questions. First, what more can be done to explain the potential liabilities, and what financial risks do they present for the Government, from where we are at present? Secondly, has the Scottish Government identified areas of public service delivery where there are currently gaps in the data that it gathers, and what action are you taking to address that?
I will take the first question on liabilities and risk. Our consolidated accounts capture the liabilities and risks that sit at the Scottish Government’s door. As the Auditor General has said, those accounts are prepared on the basis of international financial reporting standards and for the past seven years have received a clean audit opinion. However, the discussion about risk, where it can be best managed and how that plays with our value-for-money duty is an interesting one, and such questions are worthy of further discussion.With regard to the main areas of liability, our accounts set out disclosures, notes and explanations in line with what is expected in the standards for preparing them. As for making some of that information more accessible, I know that it can be terribly technical and complex, and we are happy to look at whether we can supply additional narrative without making the accounts so big that they just do not inform readers.
Mr Coffey made that point very well. Indeed, the Auditor General has suggested that the Scottish Government consider developing its financial reporting to provide more information on potential liabilities. We look forward to that.
My only other point is that we need to understand the landscape in which we manage those liabilities. The Government receives annual funding and has by statute been largely set up to authorise expenditure. Under the rules that we work within as things stand—and indeed under the auspices of the Scotland Act 2012—we are not in a position to build up any reserves and when we consider future liabilities, we are looking at how they might crystallise in any individual year and how we are placed to meet them. That is quite different between central and local Government and it is useful to bring out that distinction. We need to be really clear, when we explain about liabilities, about the means at which point and in which timeframe we are able to deal with them.
Thank you for that.Have you identified any public service delivery areas where there are data gaps and, if so, what are you doing about them?
The answer is no, convener. I do not believe that there are gaps. The national performance framework, which I have already mentioned, would sit at the top at what seems to me to be a whole raft of strong and excellent practice with regard to data in Scotland. In that respect, I would single out the financial and performance management of the NHS in Scotland, which is widely regarded as excellent.In relation to new policies, the work on the minimum pricing of alcohol depends on a critical evidence, analysis and data argument. Great attention has been paid to that work, which has been acknowledged and recognised by the UK Government and others that share those objectives. We have also seen good practice in relation to how we define and measure the legacy of the Commonwealth games and how we come to more of an understanding about some of the geographic and demographic aspects of youth employment. There is lots of really good practice, but continuous improvement must be our goal and we entirely share the priority that the committee has attached to it.
Thank you.I thank colleagues for what I thought was an excellent session with thorough and robust questioning. We have made tremendous progress with regard to understanding each other and working together in future. I also thank Sir Peter Housden and Alyson Stafford for their co-operation and the very helpful evidence that they have given. I hope that we see you again soon.We now move into private session.12:39 Meeting continued in private until 13:02.
In this meeting
Everything on 4 Sep 2013 →- 10:00 Interests Procedure · 8
- 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 67
- 10:00 Section 23 Reports Evidence session · 99
- 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 94
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.