Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

“Scotland’s key transport infrastructure projects” and Major Capital Projects (Update)

Wednesday 4 September 2013 Public Audit Committee About 10:00 Evidence session 99 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

99 contributions
Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

The next item is oral evidence on the Auditor General’s report “Scotland’s key transport infrastructure projects”, and on the Scottish Government’s major capital projects update. I remind members that, following our evidence from the witnesses under this item, Sir Peter Housden will go on to give evidence on developing financial reporting in Scotland. I know that we are likely to stray into that, but I ask members to keep their questions on financial reporting until the next agenda item.I welcome our witnesses from the Scottish Government, who are Sir Peter Housden, the permanent secretary, and Alyson Stafford, who is director general for finance. From Transport Scotland we have David Middleton, the chief executive, and Ainslie McLaughlin, the director of major transport infrastructure projects. I invite Sir Peter Housden to make a brief opening statement. We will then invite questions from members.

Sir Peter Housden Scottish Government
link

Thank you, deputy convener. As you said, I am accompanied by my colleagues. Ainslie McLaughlin and David Middleton are particularly able to help the committee with questions on the portfolio of transport projects that is under discussion. Alyson Stafford will be able to assist particularly with matters concerning the infrastructure investment board, which she chairs, and the cross-Government accounting work and reporting. We will of course be happy to provide any further information that the committee may require subsequently to the meeting.I thought that it would be helpful if I, as principal accounting officer, set out the things on which I seek assurance in relation to the matters that we are discussing today. There are four. The first is about the quality of our technical and professional work, which underpins decision making by ministers, and the important role that we attach to external assurance. At key moments in the process, we seek external and independent advice to verify important decision-making stages. Secondly, there is the quality of business cases, on-going contract management and monitoring of finance and delivery, which are crucial to securing value for money. Thirdly, there is the timeliness and quality of the advice that we give to ministers for key decision-making processes. Finally, and by no means least, there is the matter of ensuring that our reporting to Parliament is helpful and appropriate.I am confident that we have a sound basis and strong arrangements for each of those four elements, both in general and in relation to the projects that are under discussion today. In that judgment, I draw confidence from the Audit Scotland report on our major transport infrastructure projects, particularly the Auditor General’s assessment that all five projects are well managed and have sound governance structures. Audit Scotland confirms that four of the five projects are on track to be delivered within the latest approved timescales, with the Edinburgh to Glasgow improvement programme now on a rephased basis. All five are within the latest approved financial envelopes.We did not recognise the reference in the press yesterday to a “£500m shortfall”. That appeared to refer to the difference between what were in essence the contract construction costs of the five projects that have been reported on to the Public Audit Committee and the figures that were used in the Audit Scotland report, which include a variety of other costs. I am happy to take the committee through the detail of that. It is not a shortfall or a mistake. Both sets of numbers are accurate and valid, but they are made up of different elements, and one cannot simply be subtracted from the other, with the suggestion that the difference represents a shortfall.More broadly, in considering questions about the reporting of the projects, the committee will recognise the significant broadening of financing sources and contractual arrangements in recent years. That arises from the wish of the present Government and its predecessors to make public money work harder and to use the terms of devolved funding arrangements within prudent limits to maximise investment in infrastructure. There have been an increasing range of schemes. Here, we are dealing with transport projects that are funded through orthodox capital, through the non-profit-distributing model and through Network Rail’s regulated asset base.Our reporting to Parliament has evolved, together with this landscape, as it has matured. We value this dialogue and the Auditor General’s report as an important staging post in the next phase of that evolution. We are keen to understand from the committee what format and criteria you would find helpful in exercising your task over what is, by any standards, a complex and varied set of arrangements.In our letter to the committee, we have undertaken to develop that standardised approach with you—working to the timescale that is suggested by Audit Scotland—to review the format and threshold for the public reporting of major projects and to codify our approach to the scrutiny of major investment projects through our infrastructure investment board.Finally, the Government has this week published an updated infrastructure investment pipeline on all projects that are valued at £20 million and above, and on the unitary charge payments that are associated with revenue finance projects that are in the £2.5 billion pipeline and which have reached financial close. The committee also sought assurance on matters concerning the 5 per cent cap on revenue finance capital expenditure. We expect the cabinet secretary to address that further when he sets out his spending plans to Parliament later this month.

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you, Sir Peter. I think that this is the first time that you have been before the committee, and I trust that there will be many more opportunities for us to hear from you in the coming months. Our first question is from Colin Keir.

Colin Keir SNP Edinburgh Western
link

With reference to the £500 million shortfall that was mentioned, I want to ask about the procedures and reporting practices that various Governments have used over the years. Has there been a misunderstanding of past and current practice, or has there been a change in procedures that has made people think that there is a difference and that there is a £500 million shortfall?

Sir Peter Housden Scottish Government
link

I am not sure that I have the answer to that question. We did not recognise the use of the word “shortfall”. My point to the committee is that both sets of numbers are in essence valid and accurate, but they refer to different things. It is not a shortfall.

Colin Keir SNP Edinburgh Western
link

I just want to find out whether there has been any change that might have confused those who made the claims.I turn to my next question. Are you absolutely sure that your procedures will keep expenditure below the ceiling of 5 per cent of the departmental expenditure limit?

Sir Peter Housden Scottish Government
link

Yes. The cabinet secretary introduced the cap in 2011 and, as the Auditor General points out, everyone agrees that it is a sensible thing to do, to help track spending within prudential limits and to provide a guidepost for forward planning. In answers to parliamentary questions, we have provided information on spending against that cap. As I said, I expect the cabinet secretary to return to that when he sets out his proposals later in the month.

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Before we move on to James Dornan, I would like to talk about the 5 per cent cap. I note in your written evidence your response to a line of questioning that was pursued by Tavish Scott on how the north hub’s £700 million spend relates to the 5 per cent limit on the proportion of DEL. You say that it can be used for repayments that are associated with infrastructure investment but, in contrast, you go on to say that the 5 per cent limit relates only to revenue commitments that are associated with the Scottish Government. I find it confusing that the 5 per cent in the north of Scotland appears to be different from the 5 per cent elsewhere.

Sir Peter Housden Scottish Government
link

As I understood the Official Report of your previous discussions on the matter, the point that Tavish Scott was addressing was whether hub projects are wholly included in the 5 per cent cap. The answer, as we heard from the Auditor General this morning, is that the central Government element of the contribution to hub projects is included in the 5 per cent, but hub projects typically include significant contributions—in the case of schools, for example—from local authorities. Interestingly, to go back to your point, that makes the link with financial reporting, because one thing that we should look at in the longer term is whether, in that consolidated financial reporting across local and national Government, it would be useful to have a picture of the totality of central and local government revenue spending against capital projects.

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

It is not just the totality. We also need consistent reporting across Scotland, as was mentioned earlier by Colin Keir.

James Dornan SNP Glasgow Cathcart
link

I have a short question about transparency in infrastructure projects. How transparent are existing projects compared with the previous PFI and PPP projects? 11:00

Sir Peter Housden Scottish Government
link

We have always sought to render for Parliament and the public an accurate photograph of the picture of spending, but I think that the seminal moment was the Auditor General’s report in 2008 and the decisions and work of the committee’s predecessor in 2009, which set the framework for subsequent Scottish Government reporting. As I said, a variety of new financing sources have become available to Government over that period, and the committee is right to want to see a comprehensive and consistent basis for reporting them to Parliament. In our letter to the committee, we have committed to take that approach and to undertake that work with the committee, and we are happy to do that. However, the frame for all of that was set by the 2008 and 2009 work of the committee.

James Dornan SNP Glasgow Cathcart
link

Does that mean that the NPD model, for example, is less opaque than PFI/PPP? Is it easier for us to get information with it and for you to report it?

Sir Peter Housden Scottish Government
link

I do not want to venture a judgment on the types of material that were presented in Scotland on PFI as opposed to NPD, because I have not seen that type of information, but we would be happy to offer a commentary if the committee would find that helpful. Following the 2008 and 2009 work, we have sought to present an evolving and complex landscape as clearly as we can, and we shall continue to do that on the basis of the Auditor General’s helpful report.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

You mentioned 2008-09. For clarity, I want to ensure that we are talking about the same thing in asking my question. My understanding is that, in the past few years, there has been an improvement in the amount of information that has been made available to the committee and others and that, in 2008-09, there was the first opportunity for structured reporting to the committee every six months on large infrastructure projects. Will you say a little bit about that and compare that with what happened before?

Sir Peter Housden Scottish Government
link

I think that that is correct. Since 2009, six-monthly reports have gone to the committee on projects of over £50 million. That was part of our response to the committee’s earlier work. From February this year, we have put a fuller list on the web, with information on projects of over £20 million plus all schools and community health projects that are being delivered through the hub initiative. Clearly, that represents an increase in transparency. It covers costs and key delivery milestones. We updated the information yesterday as part of our pipeline and included more information on total capital investment costs along with contract costs where they have been different. Those things represent improvements in the way that you have described.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

That is helpful. I will not draw you on the matter, Sir Peter, but one reason for asking the question was to get that on the public record and to show that the Scottish Government has made continual improvement in reporting and transparency. I believe that the reports in the press to which you diplomatically referred in your opening remarks came from a former convener of the committee, Iain Gray, who was the Parliament’s finance minister in 2003. My understanding is that there was less openness and transparency when Mr Gray was the Parliament’s finance minister, and I find that there is a—

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I am sorry, Mr Doris, but I ask you to address the report that is in front of us. What Iain Gray said or did not say as finance minister or shadow cabinet secretary is not really important. I would like you to address what we are discussing today and address Sir Peter Housden.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

Let me rephrase that, then. Compared with 2003, when Iain Gray was finance minister, and despite Iain Gray’s flawed attacks in the press, does Mr Housden think that transparency and openness have improved in reporting to the committee on large infrastructure projects? More important, where there is more to be done, are you ready to address those issues and improve reporting further?

Sir Peter Housden Scottish Government
link

There are three points in that, which I will take in turn.First, I cannot offer a view on arrangements from 2003 forward. Secondly, however, I can say that, from 2008-09, there has been a significant change and increasing transparency in the format of the reports in question, which has been driven by the work of the committee. Thirdly, we are indeed committed to continuing that improvement in dialogue with the committee.However, I do not think that this is a straightforward task for you or for us, because the range and complexity of the funding sources and the scale of projects and the different stages that they go through mean that there is an enormous wealth of data to be rendered in an intelligent way. We will of course work with Audit Scotland and the committee to produce something that meets your needs.

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I remind members that we should not ask civil servants to comment on or offer judgments or opinions on party-political issues. I thank Sir Peter Housden for remaining on the subject of the Audit Scotland report.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

Ms Scanlon, I have a detailed question that is not remotely political, if that is okay.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

I appreciate your indulgence in allowing me to put that evidence on the record, even though you would rather—I assume—that I had not done so.Sir Peter, you said that reporting the overall cost of projects can be complex. For example, the cost of land purchase might sometimes be included in the overall cost and sometimes it might not. Will you say a bit more on how we have to be careful about how we use the data that is presented? For instance, could the construction costs of a project be pretty healthy but the overall cost of the project be misrepresented because of the land-buying costs? When we ask for more detailed and consistent data, the right boxes might be ticked, but that might not necessarily mean that the data is presented in a way that compares apples with apples. Might there be such dangers in how we get information?

Sir Peter Housden Scottish Government
link

That is a fundamental point, because attention will often be focused on the contract prices. The question will be how much the Scottish Government will have to pay following a tendering process for construction works. That guides attention to a particular set of costs, but they will not represent the total cost, however defined. It might be helpful to hear from David Middleton specifically on the transport aspects, as that will bring out the flavour and the reality to which you properly point.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

Often, in commenting on existing bodies of transport infrastructure work and future work, the market—the contractors and potential funders, depending on the source of finance—will be interested in the potential contract price for the amount of work that they will be bidding to undertake. In that context, it could confuse the figures if they included whatever cost had been incurred for preparation and land purchase.The M74 extension is an example of a completed project—as opposed to the live projects that have been reported on—that I hope people will agree is in good use. The costs of that are often discussed in terms of the amount that was involved in building the motorway, which is a substantial stretch of motorway around part of Glasgow. However, not surprisingly, the total project costs were somewhat higher, because it was an urban motorway and a considerable amount of money had to be spent to buy the land and prepare the project for the contractor to build the motorway. In that context, there was quite a gap between the total project cost and the actual contract cost.Ainslie McLaughlin, who is sitting on my right, knows a lot more about that than I do, but my answer may suffice. We would emphasise projected contract prices for some purposes but provide costs in other cases for accountability purposes—we have never sought to hide that. Wherever there has been advance purchase of land for live projects, we have always been asked to account for all the costs. We will often be probed at public inquiries, through PQs and in other ways to display the costs that have been incurred before we get to the tendering stage.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

That is genuinely helpful, because some commentators have sought to compare whole-project costs with construction costs. They then consider the differential cost and assume that there is an issue. However, I think that it has clearly been pointed out that the costs have to be accounted for differently because of the purchase of land and possible pre-construction costs.

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you, Mr Doris, for seeking clarity through that question.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Thank you, Sir Peter, for your earlier remarks attributing some of the good work that is being done to Audit Scotland’s report and the work of this committee—certainly during my earlier years as a committee member. I recall that, at that time, some of us wondered where the reporting was on capital projects and so on. That led to what we now get at the Public Audit Committee.There was a discrepancy in the figures but, as far as I am concerned, you have explained perfectly well the difference between the figures in the Audit Scotland report and the information in the reports that were given to this committee. That gives rise to the opportunity for us as politicians to make capital out of that, so it is important for me, as a member of the Public Audit Committee, to ask you to ensure that all the data that you present to us is consolidated and includes everything, and that no opportunities are provided for politicians to interpret the figures in the way in which they often do. Audit Scotland has also said that on a number of occasions. I make a plea for you to include everything so that we have the big picture.You asked whether the data quality in the reports that we get is good. I think that it is good, but I would not like to go from one extreme to the other—from having nothing, as we did in the past, to having hugely detailed, almost micromanaged, Microsoft project-type presentations on every capital project that is going on in Scotland. I do not think that that is the committee’s role. I like the top-line figures being summarised in the way that you have, but I make a plea to you—I think that the convener and other members of the committee would agree with me on this—to include all the data so that there is consistency that we can rely on. Is it your intention to provide that for us in future?

Sir Peter Housden Scottish Government
link

Yes, I think that that is a very fair and important summary.The anchor point for me with any data that we provide is not only that it should be accurate, but that we are quite clear and transparent about what it is describing—in other words, its basis—particularly when we bring figures together in a total, so that the committee and people more broadly can see what the constituent elements are.I am also keen that we provide the maximum degree of transparency so that if, through the proper processes of parliamentary scrutiny, the committee wishes to dive down further to a level of specific detail, that is possible and the information is navigable. There are some limitations to that, particularly in relation to commercial confidentiality, as the committee has recognised in its work, but—subject to those considerations—I think that we should be explicit about the bases for the information and provide transparency through to the level of detail that the committee would find helpful.We are certainly not suggesting that broad generalities will enable the committee to do its work. It is clear that the committee needs the right to get into the heart of such issues at levels of detail. I think that it is a professional challenge for us, with Audit Scotland, to make that route open and accessible, and to produce intelligible data.

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

We will have an opportunity to ask you about that in more detail under the next item.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Sir Peter, you started by saying that you draw confidence from the Auditor General’s report. In her report, she said that the figures that the Government presented were “inconsistent and incomplete”. Furthermore, she said:“There is no information to help assess the affordability or otherwise of such projects.”How do you draw confidence from those remarks?

Sir Peter Housden Scottish Government
link

I have three things to say about that. First, the general context, as the Auditor General’s report makes quite clear, is one of well-managed projects that are delivering their intended benefits for Scotland. The Auditor General properly points out, as the committee has done, that there are real advantages in having a consistent set of data available in order to scrutinise work. We have acknowledged that and said that the evolution of reporting from 2008-09, which is taking place across a landscape of gathering complexity, is not at a finish point, so we would like to work with the committee to ensure that it has the data that it needs.On your third point, however, we can indicate that there is data in the public domain on the affordability of such projects. That is not to say that it could not be rendered more clearly and comprehensively. If we consider the issue of affordability in the context of the cap, the Government has answered a parliamentary question on that and published information on it in its budget report for 2013-14, and we expect that Mr Swinney will return to the issue. We are looking at a process of continuous improvement. Looked at in the round, the report gives me confidence—and I venture that it should give the committee confidence—that the projects in question have been well managed.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Do you agree with the Auditor General’s main point, which is that the Parliament should be made aware of the total cost of the projects, not just the construction cost? In other words, she is saying that there is a difference between the two. Do you agree with that point?11:15

Sir Peter Housden Scottish Government
link

Yes. An important part of the reporting framework that we are moving towards is that such data will be readily available across the range of projects.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Given that the information was not provided to Parliament previously, how do you monitor the difference between the construction cost and the total cost?

Sir Peter Housden Scottish Government
link

Again, I think that it would be helpful for you to hear from David Middleton on the transport aspect.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

We are accountable for all our spending and we report in various ways, certainly to the centre of the Scottish Government. When budgets are published, we require budget cover for expenditure on projects such as the Forth replacement crossing and—in the past—the M74 and the M80. That is the gross expenditure that we are incurring in that year on the project as a whole. Where we are preparing for projects in the future and incurring expenditure on land acquisition and site preparation, that will be explicit in our accounts and our budgets.

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I have a supplementary question on that issue. Sir Peter, you mentioned that the projects are very well managed and you have been very complimentary, saying that everything that you do is just wonderful. However, I highlight exhibit 8 on page 35 in part 3 of the report, on“Financial management and public reporting”,which is headed“Assessment of project cost estimates against good practice requirements”.The Edinburgh to Glasgow rail project is rated against nine good practice requirements, and you meet three. That does not show that the project is well managed. Three out of nine is 30 per cent.

Sir Peter Housden Scottish Government
link

Can you remind me of the reference for that?

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

It is exhibit 8 on page 35 in part 3 of the Audit Scotland report “Scotland’s key transport infrastructure projects”. The title is“Assessment of project cost estimates against good practice requirements”.You may not agree with the Auditor General on the £500 million shortfall or whatever, but it is clear from exhibit 8 that, for the Edinburgh to Glasgow rail project, you meet three out of nine good practice requirements. That does not show that the projects are well managed.

Sir Peter Housden Scottish Government
link

Perhaps David Middleton can enlighten us here.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

We said that we would take note of the Auditor General’s report, consider it and report on our processes. With regard to the way in which that information is presented, we believe that the Edinburgh to Glasgow improvement programme has already served Scotland well. It is a programme of projects rather than a single project—for example, Cumbernauld electrification is proceeding at present, and Network Rail has the main contract for the main electrification between Edinburgh and Glasgow out to tender. It is, in many ways, an ambitious programme. There are one or two “Partially” ratings and a couple of non-applicable aspects listed. We felt that—

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

There are quite a few “No” ratings as well.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

We felt that we took appropriate account of risk in the project. The Auditor General’s report contains comments about the Borders railway project and the Edinburgh to Glasgow improvements with regard to the updating of business cases et cetera. However, it struck me on reflection that that has a lot to do with their being rail projects, which have a particular financial mechanism wrapped around them that is not just a matter for the Scottish Government through Transport Scotland, but is validated by the Office of Rail Regulation.We like to think that we have an impressive track record of delivering rail projects with Network Rail. The Airdrie to Bathgate project was completed on time and on budget, as were the Paisley corridor improvements, which do not always rate as high-headline but still comprised £170 million-worth of infrastructure plus another £60 million of station and platform improvements.On the Edinburgh to Glasgow improvement programme, we had to make a change in scope—that was explicit—around the affordability threshold, but I believe that we are nonetheless on track to meet the target for that project of electrifying the line by December 2016. We have taken appropriate account of optimism bias and risk, and I hope that, when the project is more fully developed and we can see it being developed, it will be viewed as a much better example of good delivery by Transport Scotland, as other rail projects have been in the recent past.

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Mr Middleton, do you understand why it would raise warning signals for us—as cross-party members of the Public Audit Committee in the Scottish Parliament—and that we would be concerned when we are told that you neither included the capital costs in your business case analysis nor know the life-cycle costs and revenues?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I understand that, and I am sorry if anything that I say gives the contrary message. The table is a very stark presentation. I understand why people like stark presentations, but I think—

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

That is what we are looking for.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

If members were to go through the individual items, there would be more to be said. I do not think that the Auditor General said in the report’s recommendations and key messages that the Edinburgh to Glasgow improvement programme is in trouble or is a project at risk. She recorded accurately that the scope was adjusted by ministerial decision, but she still says that Audit Scotland feels that we are on track to deliver to the amended timescale. The conclusions and recommendations ask us to look at our processes and we will take those recommendations forward.I do not believe that some of the findings are quite as stark as the “No” ratings in the table suggest, and those ratings are not carried forward into general comments on the state of the projects. However, I understand the point and I would be happy to expand on the detail in any way through any follow-up, as we think that we have delivered rather better than some of the stark terms suggest.

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you. We can only go on the Auditor General’s report; we are tasked to scrutinise the reports. As a lecturer in a previous life, I note that 30 per cent is not a good mark.Kenneth Macintosh has some more questions—I apologise for interrupting him.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

To continue from where we were, the Auditor General has revealed a £500 million difference between the construction cost and the total cost of the projects. How were those figures presented to the Parliament for accountability?

Sir Peter Housden Scottish Government
link

My report to the Public Audit Committee on projects that are in the pipeline gave figures that described, essentially, the contract construction costs. Audit Scotland reached the larger figure by including a range of other costs associated with the projects. I would be happy to take the committee through that project by project if it would be helpful. The key point is that both sets of figures are accurate and valid. They are just describing different things.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

My point is that it is the job of the Public Audit Committee and the Parliament to hold the Government to account for these figures. You have presented a set of figures that is missing £500 million and I am trying to work out whether that figure has been presented to Parliament in some other shape or form. Can you point to the documents in which the £500 million is published? How can we follow or scrutinise the figures to see whether there has been slippage, whether the projects are on target and so on?

Sir Peter Housden Scottish Government
link

The burden of the proceedings at the committee today, Mr Macintosh, is really to say that Audit Scotland’s recommendation is that a uniform set of costings should be made available to the committee in a more consistent format. As you will have gathered from our letter and our testimony this morning, we endorse that recommendation. It would be possible to identify, for each of the projects concerned, the detailed reporting to Parliament of each of the costs. I am happy to do that after the meeting if it would be helpful.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

In your introductory remarks, you suggested that one of your duties is to provide Parliament with helpful and appropriate information. You have provided information on all the major capital projects, but it does not include £500 million of the costs associated with them. I am trying to find out in what helpful and appropriate way you have presented that information to Parliament.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

To supplement what Sir Peter said, each of those projects will have been through its own scrutiny. Some have had direct legislative scrutiny in this Parliament, as the Forth replacement crossing had and, going back a bit, the Borders railway had through the Waverley Railway (Scotland) Bill. The sum and substance of the presentation to the Parliament of each individual project is not represented by the permanent secretary’s six-monthly letter. As Sir Peter said, it can be expanded to include all the figures, but it is not, of itself, a request for authority to spend. The authority to spend comes through specific legislation and, ultimately, through the budget.For example, the Forth replacement crossing was, as I think the Auditor General recorded, very fully reported. As regards the costs, whenever ministers have had to make written or oral statements about specific projects or announcements about proceeding on the M8 bundle, the Aberdeen western peripheral route or the Borders railway, they will have communicated to Parliament the full range of activity that is being undertaken to take forward those projects. The appropriate spending is then presented at the appropriate time within the budget estimates.The fact that one presentation emphasising the construction and capital spending aspect of the programme has looked at the construction cost does not imply that there has been any lack of authority obtained in the usual ways for the rest of the spending on those projects, which in some cases has already been undertaken. In the case of the AWPR, for example, a certain amount of spending has already been undertaken to prepare for the procurement, which is now under way through invitations to tender, which were issued after the report was concluded.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

My question was not implying in any way that there is a lack of authority. It was about accountability to Parliament. As I understand it, the point of giving six-monthly reports to the Public Audit Committee is specifically so that we can monitor the huge sums of public money that are being spent on these projects. The point is that £0.5 billion is not being reported in an accountable manner. As far as I can tell from your answers so far, you do not provide that information to the committee in an accessible manner. Am I right?

Sir Peter Housden Scottish Government
link

The burden of my response and David Middleton’s response was to say that, if you look at the totality of the Parliament’s processes through legislation, through the work of this committee and through specialist committees including the one that deals with transport infrastructure, that information will have been made available. The burden of the discussion today, with which we agree, is about the possibility of a further evolution of the overall reporting framework that would enable this committee to exercise scrutiny in the way that it would like. We agree that that would be a good evolution.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

In the Auditor General’s report, a particular piece of information about the Edinburgh to Glasgow improvement programme suggests that the completion date has slipped from 2016 to 2018 or 2019. How would that information have become part of the Parliament’s domain if it had not been for the Auditor General?

Sir Peter Housden Scottish Government
link

Again, David Middleton or Ainslie McLaughlin will be able to help here.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

Mr Brown has made repeated statements to the Parliament to clarify the position on EGIP. There have been a number of parliamentary statements and debates on rail over the past 14 or 15 months and members of the Parliament, with their interest in EGIP and other projects, are not slow to make representations to the transport minister. Therefore, we regularly report on the progress of the various projects. Mr Brown has reported on EGIP on a number of occasions and recently he clarified the timetable.It was always clear that, because of the changes in the scope of EGIP, the full achievement was going to be delayed. That was to do with the affordability questions and a need to rephase the project, but it is in the context of a transparent and substantial commitment of £5 billion to rail services in Scotland over the next five years. In that context, Mr Brown has been quite explicit about how EGIP has had to be rephased.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Mr Brown may have made a number of statements, but before the Auditor General told the committee that, instead of being completed by December 2016, it would be completed by March 2019, was that information made available either through Mr Brown or through any other means?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I think that Mr Brown clarified the timings of aspects of EGIP in a debate in May this year. The Auditor General’s report was published towards the end of June.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Did Mr Brown clarify that the completion date had slipped to March 2019?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

That date is to do with the full achievement of EGIP with the best achievement of journey times. I think that Mr Brown said that the electrification from Glasgow to Edinburgh would be complete, as intended, by December 2016. As regards the consequent requirement to make improvements to Queen Street station, which is the new factor that was brought into the equation by the changes that were announced in 2012, we cannot start work at Queen Street station too soon. We have the Commonwealth games and other matters to deal with, and the need for full changes to the platforms to allow the longest trains to have the best service pattern means that the full achievement of EGIP as previously envisaged will slip to March 2019. I think that Mr Brown was quite explicit on that in May 2013 and I do not think that the Auditor General’s report, which was published a month later, provided a new slant on it.11:30

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Sir Peter, do you agree that the point of the six-monthly reports to the committee is to ensure that the committee and the Parliament are aware on an on-going basis of how much the projects are costing and exactly when they will finish? The point is to monitor the projects, so do you agree that all the information should be not only available but flagged up and that it is your duty not just to be helpful and appropriate but to highlight the issues?

Sir Peter Housden Scottish Government
link

The account of EGIP illustrates the complexity of such projects across the board. Building on the framework that the committee established, we have sought to provide helpful information in consistent formats. However, we need to underpin that—as I believe that we have—by ensuring that, whenever we publish information about projects, we are clear about the basis on which the information is calculated. That provides transparency.We are discussing a further evolution of the framework for how I report to the committee and we are happy to do that. We acknowledge again that, across the evolving landscape, it is a good thing to look consistently to improve the format of the information that is available to the committee.

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

We will come back to that under the next agenda item.Willie Coffey and Bob Doris would like to ask brief supplementary questions on the back of Ken Macintosh’s question.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

I remind colleagues where we are and where we came from. As Sir Peter Housden remarked, before 2008, we had no reporting like this—nothing. We did not know how capital projects or programmes were functioning. I am not aware of there having been any reporting to any committee—not even to the Finance Committee. We have come a considerable distance since 2008-09. Perhaps members could reflect on why such information sharing was not normal practice from the Parliament’s establishment. That point must be made.When a politician is presented with a table that has ticks on it or with boxes that say yes or no, it is easy for the politician to add them up and say that there is good or poor performance. However, in the example that the deputy convener gave of EGIP, there are 12 categories in the table—it is all about whether elements are in the business case analysis—and only three of them say no.

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Yes, but some elements are not applicable.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

I know. I am saying that, when such tables are provided, what I described happens. The more important point is that Sir Peter Housden and David Middleton have said that they wish to include the kind of issues that Audit Scotland has reported on with regard to the business case and the data so that we get the broadest and biggest picture, which will allow us to scrutinise everything satisfactorily. That commitment has been made, and I appreciate that.

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you for that. To be fair, the table was produced by the Auditor General, not Sir Peter Housden, and it was designed to examine the projects and mark them against good practice.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

We are getting to the nitty-gritty of how we can constructively take forward greater scrutiny and better reporting. That is where we should be as a committee—always trying to improve.Sir Peter, would you be minded to include in the six-monthly reports that the committee gets details of slippage and completion rates? Would that be done as standard for something such as EGIP? I think that Mr Macintosh suggested that you should report any slippage immediately to the committee, but I am not sure whether that is correct. Would you do that, or would you mop up such issues in the six-monthly reports?We are the Public Audit Committee, but another committee might have a lead interest in being informed of any delays in large transport infrastructure projects. Where would the information on slippage best go—to us or another committee? For example, I sit on the Health and Sport Committee, which receives regular updates on the progress of the Commonwealth games 2014 project as a matter of course. There are examples of good practice across the Government already, but I am interested in how the process would work in relation to large transport infrastructure projects. Would the information come to the Public Audit Committee as part of the six-monthly report—and, if not, could that happen—or would it go to another committee?

Sir Peter Housden Scottish Government
link

That point is important. The Public Audit Committee’s work sits atop the work of specialist committees, and understanding that division of labour to enable committees to do their work is an important parameter for the future.I would not want to venture views today on what might or might not be included in the six-monthly reports. There is a proper dialogue to have on what the committee would find most helpful and salient and on how we might help to provide the tiers of information that would enable the committee to access greater detail when that is appropriate. That is a subject for further discussion and on which we look forward to subsequent work with Audit Scotland and the committee.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

For clarification, at what point in a project’s lifespan is the project included in the 5 per cent cap? Given that projects can change as they move forward—for example, when the contract is signed, its value might be different from that when the project was first included in the budget given to Parliament—at what trigger points is the value adjusted within the 5 per cent cap?

Sir Peter Housden Scottish Government
link

Alyson Stafford will be able to assist.

Alyson Stafford Scottish Government
link

On the 5 per cent cap, all contracts that have reached financial close and have been agreed to will be part of the core costs that we track. As for additions beyond that, clearly the budget announcement of a £2.5 billion pipeline of projects a few years back set out a future commitment. We work with the people who are leading those projects to get the best estimates of costs and of when the contracts will reach financial close. Therefore, we have an indicative estimate of where and in which financial years the costs will fall, based on the progress of the NPD projects.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

To be clear, do contracts drop into the 5 per cent cap when they are signed?

Alyson Stafford Scottish Government
link

Contracts that have been signed are already counted, so we have a lot of history on contracts that have been in place over a number of years. They are part of our calculation. Over and above that, we provide ministers with estimated costs of prospective contracts that will go through procurement or the early planning phases and of the year in which those costs might fall. We add those estimated costs to the baseline of known costs and measure that against the 5 per cent cap that has been set.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

That is understood. I asked whether there are trigger points at which you update or adjust the estimates. Is that an on-going thing, or does that happen only at certain points in a contract’s life cycle?

Alyson Stafford Scottish Government
link

For our internal management, the main trigger points that we use are what we describe as fiscal events, which mainly relate to the UK budget phases. Usually, there is a budget around March and there is an autumn statement. Those fiscal events are material because the cap is based on a percentage of our actual allocation, so our forward estimates of that allocation are obviously relevant, in addition to the forward estimates of the costs that are set against projects. We get the best snapshot broadly at six or seven-month intervals, depending on those fiscal events.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

If a Government project was going over budget—of course, Government projects never go over, but let us talk theoretically—when would you capture that?

Alyson Stafford Scottish Government
link

If the project has completed its contracted phase, it will be included as an actual figure. If the project is part of the £2.5 billion pipeline of NPD projects that was announced, we will build in estimates based on the £2.5 billion commitment that was outlined.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

So there is a rolling update.

Alyson Stafford Scottish Government
link

There is a rolling update on a six-monthly basis, which seems to be the best interval. We do not look at such matters every week; we tend to work on them on a six-monthly basis.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

So, every six months, you review the outstanding projects to see whether they are still on schedule and whether there are overruns or other commitments that might affect the 5 per cent cap.

Alyson Stafford Scottish Government
link

Largely in terms of the procurement and contracting arrangements, yes.

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I will raise two questions. The first follows from what Colin Beattie asked about local government spending; of course, there are significant projects in local government and in the NHS. How closely do you work with local government to offer advice and support on major capital projects?

Sir Peter Housden Scottish Government
link

Alyson Stafford might be able to help, because the hub development is central to that.

Alyson Stafford Scottish Government
link

Local authorities have their own capital allocations and their own means to raise money. They have their own structures and processes for that.

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I appreciate that.

Alyson Stafford Scottish Government
link

The interface with the items that we are discussing is through the hub project. There is oversight through a hub board, and hub regions have been established. Local government also has access to information through construction procurement advice and the Scottish Futures Trust; that is how advisory facilities are made available.

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

So there is quite close co-ordination between local government and national Government on major capital projects.

Alyson Stafford Scottish Government
link

That depends on the scheme. For example, because there is a national programme for schools and a national programme board to oversee those projects, there is greater visibility and interaction between central Government and local government, as they have a shared interest in delivering that programme.Hub is another model that Sir Peter Housden has mentioned, and a lot of that work relates to community facilities and local facilities for health and social care. Anything beyond that is largely in the gift of local government; it is usually on national programmes that we work closely together.

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I appreciate that, but the committee’s role is to look at value for taxpayers’ money. We are not allowed to hold up national newspapers in Parliament, or we will be reprimanded by the Presiding Officer, but I picked up my copy of The Inverness Courier this morning and read that the Inverness bypass building costs are rocketing by £270,000 a month. As a taxpayer in Inverness, I know that that does not exactly lead to trust and confidence in our financial reporting and support.There have been many projects in which the Scottish Government has been involved and many in which it has not been involved, and I do not wish to lay the blame at your door. Registers of Scotland said that it could have done with more back-up from the Government, and I am concerned about other cases going forward, because £270,000 a month is a significant amount.

Alyson Stafford Scottish Government
link

I agree with your observation. You might wish to explore the subject further with the Auditor General, from the point of view of the Accounts Commission’s findings on oversight of local government.

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

We are due to finish at 11.45 and we are almost on time, so I shall come to my final question. Sir Peter, I will ask you about your response to the committee. Like other members, I read annexes A and B to paper 5. As this might be my one and only opportunity to chair a committee, I shall take full advantage of my remaining two minutes.In annex A, you respond to the question:“What is the response of the Scottish Government to the key messages and recommendations made in the AGS report?”I was not impressed by your response, which states:“We commit thereby to work with Ministers”.I am sorry, but I do not think that that is good enough. In response to another question, you state:“We will undertake a ... review”.In a third instance, you state: “We are reflecting on how best to respond to this recommendation”,and references to the 5 per cent limit are all over the place. I am speaking personally but, as a committee member, I do not need you to write to tell me that you will work with ministers. We assume that you will work with ministers.I have been ticking my checklist again and I find from annex B that, out of eight recommendations, you agree with two. I do not find that helpful. You say that you will “undertake a further review”, at one point you say that you will work with colleagues in the Scottish Government and you say:“Our risk management framework is reviewed annually”.You also say that you will consult other bodies. I find that insulting, not only to the committee but to the Auditor General, to whom we look for fair and accurate representations. I am not here to make a party-political point, and I am sure that you have not been ignoring John Swinney all these years, but I do not wish to get a letter that says that, all of a sudden, you will work with ministers. That is not good enough. I would like something a bit more robust than that.Those are my comments and I would be happy if you would like to respond, because I was not impressed.

Sir Peter Housden Scottish Government
link

This morning’s conversation has been helpful for us in understanding a broad range of perspectives from the Parliament. We found the Audit Scotland report wide ranging; it covered a significant number of issues that we need to reflect on in the light of your comments. In some ways, we also need to bring together the day-to-day realities of delivering the projects, with their accounting, reporting and evaluation, which David Middleton and Ainslie McLaughlin gave a flavour of this morning.This is tricky to get right, and Audit Scotland has suggested a process through to the end of the year whereby we should resolve things. That should enable the committee to reach a view on whether that provides a basis for its work. We are committed to doing that and I am grateful for the comments, advice and steer that we have had this morning.

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I would like to think that, in the future, we could have a better partnership and better co-ordination. I would respect you much more if you did not respond in the tone that I described.11:46 Meeting suspended.

11:55 On resuming—

  1. 10:00 Interests Procedure · 8
  2. 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  3. 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 67
  4. 10:00 Section 23 Reports Evidence session · 99
  5. 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 94

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.