I welcome Caroline Gardner, the Auditor General for Scotland. Accompanying her from Audit Scotland are Mark Taylor, the assistant director of the audit services group, and Gemma Diamond, the project manager of the performance audit group. We begin by considering the section 23 report, “Developing financial reporting in Scotland”, which deals with an issue that has been a hot topic—indeed, quite a critical topic—in the short length of time for which I have been a member of the committee.I invite Caroline Gardner to speak to the report.
Official Report · Committee
Section 23 Reports
“Developing financial reporting in Scotland”
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland 27
- Mary Scanlon Con 13
- Colin Beattie SNP 8
- Ken Macintosh Lab 7
- Bob Doris SNP 4
- Willie Coffey SNP 3
- Liam McArthur LD 2
- Mark Taylor Audit Scotland 1
- James Dornan SNP 1
- Gemma Diamond Audit Scotland 1
The record
67 contributionsThe devolved Scottish public sector manages and delivers public services that are crucial for almost every aspect of the lives of Scotland’s people. The Scottish Government spends more than £45 billion a year from a variety of sources, including the Westminster block grant, council tax and charges for services. Comprehensive, reliable and transparent financial information is necessary to help politicians and other decision makers to make good decisions, to help to hold public bodies to account for their spending and to ensure that there is public confidence in the management and sustainability of public finances. As the committee is aware, the Scotland Act 2012 will shortly give ministers new taxation and borrowing powers that are aimed at increasing autonomy and strengthening accountability. Those powers also raise the prospect of more variable revenues. That will increase the importance of managing and accounting for the public finances in a way that demonstrates financial stability and potentially builds investor confidence on the bond markets. It is important for me to stress that there is a lot that is good about financial reporting in Scotland, but the changing environment will bring new demands.Currently, much of the Government’s financial reporting and the Parliament’s own consideration focuses on spending against the annual resource and capital budgets. That is undoubtedly a critical area and will remain so. However, the implementation of the 2012 act will bring a new focus on revenue, and my report also highlights the importance of comprehensive, transparent and reliable information on the assets and liabilities of the Scottish public sector as a whole. Understanding the risks and opportunities that are associated with those assets and liabilities is essential to the management of sustainable public finances.In the report, we have pulled together information from around 100 sets of accounts from Scottish public bodies for 2011-12 to illustrate the assets and liabilities that are held and the opportunities and risks that they present.We found that the devolved Scottish public sector had assets of about £86 billion, including hospitals, schools and investments in loans and shares. We also identified liabilities of approximately £94 billion, including pensions and borrowings.It is important to be clear that the valuation of assets and liabilities represents a snapshot at a single moment in time, and often requires significant judgments to be made, together with the use of best estimates. It is not an exact science. Effective financial reporting enables such issues to be understood, so that the financial risks can be well managed.There is currently no published picture of the assets and liabilities of the Scottish public sector as a whole, although ministers have powers under the Public Finance and Accountability (Scotland) Act 2000 to prepare consolidated accounts that would provide that. We think that Scotland’s increasing financial autonomy, with the implementation of the 2012 act, offers a good opportunity for the Parliament and the Government to consider whether such accounts should be introduced.In the report, we suggest four specific areas in which we think financial reporting could be developed in that context. The first is how best to report the long-term consequences of investment decisions, including the use of borrowing and public-private partnerships to fund investment in assets. The second is for the Scottish Government to consider how best to report on its forecasts and other estimates, and how they are made, as its new tax-raising powers are used. It is important that it is able to show that the forecasts are soundly based and that it can explain the reason for any variances between actual and estimated tax receipts and the impact that such variances will have on the public finances. The third is for audited accounts of public bodies to include the identification of potential future liabilities, which need to be monitored and understood in order to manage the associated risks. Finally, we think that the Scottish Government could provide more transparent information on some complex accounting areas, such as adjustments to the block grant, which can be difficult for the Scottish Parliament and, indeed, the public to understand.In summary, the report highlights that transparent, comprehensive and reliable financial reporting is important to help build public trust and investor confidence. It supports accountability, and it is critical in providing the information that is needed to make good financial decisions for the future. The changing environment in Scotland means that now is a good time for the Scottish Government and the Parliament together to consider how financial reporting could be further developed, and the report is intended to be a constructive contribution to that debate.My colleagues and I will be happy to answer any questions that the committee may have.
Thank you very much for that. I invite questions from the committee. One of our most vocal members on this issue is Colin Beattie, and I am delighted that he is first in the queue.
link
Thank you. The report is quite a meander through the public finances—it covers a great deal of ground. Would it be fair to sum it up by saying, “So far, so good, but there is still work to be done”?
Very much so, yes. As I said in my opening remarks, all the evidence is that financial reporting for Scotland’s public bodies is currently good. Reports are prepared in line with the international financial reporting standards and are audited by me or by auditors whom I appoint. It is very rare for us to have to qualify an opinion or bring a matter to the attention of the Public Audit Committee. Equally, however, the context is changing. With the implementation of the Scotland Act 2012 over the next few years, Scotland will have increased revenue-raising powers, and that will bring a need for more transparency and more focus in those areas.Stepping back a bit, with the events that we have seen over the past few years as the global financial crisis has affected Governments’ finances, there is a greater understanding among all of us of the need to understand the risks that are associated with the assets and liabilities that the public sector holds and the potential future liabilities that may come up. We are not alone in talking about the issue—it has been the subject of recent reporting by the International Monetary Fund, the International Federation of Accountants and others—and now seems a good time for the Parliament to be talking to the Government about how things might develop in the future.
link
You touched on the Scotland Act 2012, which has implications that the committee has discussed previously. Can you confirm that Audit Scotland is fully engaged in discussions with the Government and so forth on how to develop reporting on the public finances?
Absolutely. We are involved at two levels. First, we are very much plugged into the discussions that the committee has had with the Government, Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs and the National Audit Office about how the arrangements might work in future. Secondly, through the annual audit of the Scottish Government’s finances, my colleague Mark Taylor, who is on my right, is in close dialogue with the Scottish Government about preparedness for the new demands that will be made on the Government and the new reporting requirements. I think that we are pretty well plugged into that, although it is early days for some of the larger aspects of the act, such as the Scottish rate of income tax.
link
Looking at the report overall, there seems to be less comment on a lack of availability of information than there has been in previous Audit Scotland reports. It has been a consistent theme that, for legacy reasons, the Government has had a lack of information on which to base decisions. Would you say that that is not as much of an issue when we are discussing the public finances as it is when we are talking about areas such as the national health service?
Yes, you are right—that is not the focus of the report. What we are saying is that most of the information that would be required to provide a comprehensive picture of Scotland’s public finances is available and is included in the accounts of the 200 or so individual bodies that I and the Accounts Commission audit each year. What we do not have is a way to pull that together to ensure that those accounts are prepared on a consistent basis, such that that information can be presented to the Parliament in a way that lets it get the overall picture. The implementation of the Scotland Act 2012 seems a good opportunity to consider whether that gap should be filled.
link
You have taken a very broad approach by including not just the actual assets and the liabilities that derive from those assets directly but all liabilities in the whole public sector, from pension liabilities to anything that can be pushed in there. You have come up with quite a comprehensive figure, and yet there seem to be gaps. For example, paragraph 19 on page 13 states:“Scotland had total assets valued at approximately £86 billion at March 2012, with total liabilities of £94 billion”.However, the reality is that there are a lot of question marks over such figures, given that the first paragraph in page 15 states:“If councils were to value local roads using the same methodology as Transport Scotland, they estimate that the value of these assets could increase from £5 billion to £55 billion.”Could similar variation exist in other areas of the public sector that perhaps needs to be addressed more closely in order to get uniformity of approach? Otherwise, the figures really do not make much sense.10:15
I will ask my colleague Mark Taylor to provide further specific examples in a moment, but I think that you are absolutely right: the point is that any valuation of assets and liabilities is a snapshot at one point in time that involves judgment and estimates. At the moment, we are not in a position to be able to do that for the Scottish public sector as a whole, and we think that being able to do so is increasingly important. Mark, would you like to add to that?
Thank you, Auditor General. On the broader question, the gap between the assets and the liabilities is important as a piece of information largely because it establishes a baseline against which future direction can be established. It is also important to understand—this is at the root of Mr Beattie’s question—what lies behind the figure.Regarding the differences in accounting standards, one benefit of moving towards consolidated accounts for the public sector more widely would be greater harmonisation. Under the whole of government accounts approach, that is already under way, and much of the information that is available under whole of government accounts could be used. Efforts are under way to try to provide that harmonised approach. Roads is the largest area of difference, as we have brought out in our report. Comprehensive and transparent financial reporting provides an opportunity to explain such issues and to provide information on them for discussion and public consideration.
link
Thank you. One point that alarmed me is the statement, in the top paragraph on page 18, which says:“Councils may also take advantage of beneficial interest rates and borrow in advance of immediate need ... Councils often put these cash reserves on deposit or invest in shares and equity”.I am not sure what the difference is between shares and equity, but are you saying that councils are borrowing money from the public purse to have a punt on the stock market?
We are saying that councils have borrowing powers, which currently do not exist for most of the rest of the public sector in Scotland and across the United Kingdom. Obviously, those powers need to be used prudently and responsibly to ensure that the best use is being made of public money and that it is not being put at undue risk.It is worth saying that all 32 local authorities produce annual accounts, which are audited under the auspices of the Accounts Commission. Those reports are publicly available and the Accounts Commission produces an overview across Scotland on which it briefs the Public Audit Committee and other committees of the Parliament. That issue has not emerged as a significant concern in recent years, but we should be aware of those powers in thinking about the wider picture of Scotland’s public finances.One reason why the issue is particularly live at the moment relates to what has happened elsewhere over the past few years of global financial crisis. In Spain, for example, the problems that arose for the Spanish Government were as a result of borrowing by regional governments that either was not transparent or was not thought about in the context of overall affordability. When tax revenues fell, the local governments were unable to service their liabilities, which then fell to the Spanish national Government. There is no suggestion that we are in anything like that position here in Scotland, but that highlights the importance of having transparent and comprehensive financial information to understand what risks may exist.
link
To come back to my question, do we know of any council that has invested the money that it borrowed from the public purse in the stock exchange?
Councils have treasury management functions, which are there to take any money that is surplus to immediate requirements and invest it to ensure that the proper return is made on behalf of council tax payers and taxpayers in general. There is no implication that that is being done as an investment for the purposes of generating money, but councils should properly invest their money in line with treasury management. That is one of the things that auditors look out for as part of their audit work. We are saying not that there is an immediate concern about the use of those powers but that those powers exist and need to be understood in the context of Scotland’s public finances.
link
I accept that money is often borrowed a few weeks in advance of when it needs to be paid out and therefore, from a prudential point of view and for reasons of plain sense, councils should invest that money in the short term in order to keep some revenue coming in. However, I would be concerned if councils were investing that money in stocks and shares, because they might not get their money back.
Quite so. The point of the paragraph to which you referred is not to say that that is happening. As far as I am aware, the Accounts Commission’s audit work has only identified cases where the money is being properly invested in the way that you have described. Nonetheless, councils have that power.
link
As far as you are concerned, councils are not investing money in that way and it is just a potential issue.
As far as I am aware, that is not happening and the Accounts Commission has not identified that happening anywhere. However, those powers exist for local government in Scotland.
As I see no other members wanting to ask a question, I will ask a question of my own. However, let me first just remind the committee that we will also take oral evidence from the permanent secretary, who will be asked to respond to the report, under agenda item 5.Turning to part 3 of the report—I am referring to pages 24 and 25—I found the wording quite difficult. To say that the Scotland Act 2012 powers provide us with a “useful opportunity” does not tell us whether action is necessary. Is the report just good advice, or is it essential that something be done, or can we ignore the report? There are a lot of useful opportunities out there, so I did not find part 3 helpful. We need to know: should this be done? Does it not need to be done? Should we ignore it? I felt that we needed a better steer. I apologise if I have put that a bit robustly, but in my view that is a difficulty.For example, paragraph 48 includes the wording“The following features of investment plans likely to become increasingly important”.Paragraph 51 refers to“significant new powers and it will be important that the Scottish Government can demonstrate that investment plans are affordable”.What is that saying? The report states that“Risks affecting the valuation of forecasts and other estimates require ongoing monitoring”.Is that happening just now? Is it not happening? Should it be happening? I really do not know.Colin Beattie made a good point in summarising the report as saying, “So far, so good.” Is it so far, so good? Is the report card 10 out of 10? Does the report describe a “useful opportunity” that the Government can ignore? I would find it better if we could get a grasp on precisely what could be done better—or what is wrong, as I was going to say—and what absolutely requires to be done to deal with the new demands of the taxation and borrowing powers under the Scotland Act 2012. I found the report’s references to a little “useful opportunity” here and there to be unhelpful. Can you tell us what needs to be done?Every report that comes to our committee says that the data is insufficient, there is not enough evidence and information gathering is poor. I have sat and listened to that for nearly two years. In a previous letter to the committee, you wrote: “many of my and my predecessor’s reports to the Public Audit Committee have highlighted gaps in the availability and quality of data.”We have been at this for 14 years and we are still getting rubbish data. Can you just be clear about what needs to be done? In one sentence, what is your report saying?
This report is slightly different from the usual reports that come to the committee, because it is distinctly about looking ahead as the new powers under the Scotland Act 2012 are introduced. The report is my professional advice as the Parliament’s Auditor General on the way that I think that the financial reporting by the Scottish Government should develop in that context. To be clear, the report does not focus on the issues of data quality, which I know are of real concern to the committee and come up through a number of reports on which the committee will take evidence later. This report looks at the Scottish Government’s financial reporting and the way in which the demands on it will change with the Scotland Act 2012.On what specifically should be done, there are two groupings. First, in my view, it would be very helpful for the Government, and particularly for the Parliament, to start to draw together a comprehensive picture of Scotland’s public finances as the Scotland Act 2012 powers come in. That is a summary of what Scotland owns and what it owes, what it spends and what it receives—
You think that that is essential.
I think that that is important in the context of the Scotland Act 2012.
So it is important but not essential.
There is growing international consensus that financial transparency, with comprehensive and reliable information, is important for economic growth and for the financial sustainability of any Government. The IMF has reported on that very recently.Mr Beattie’s summary of the report as “So far, so good” is absolutely right. In the context of the first 13 years of devolution, financial reporting has been sound and provides a very good basis going forward. However, the context is now changing with the Scotland Act 2012 and the possibility of further financial autonomy.The report is my professional advice about the way in which financial reporting to the Parliament and more widely could be developed in that context to address the comprehensive picture of what is owned and owed, what is spent and received, and the four specific issues that I highlighted in my opening comments. Those issues are the need for a better understanding of the assets and liabilities across the public sector and the risks associated with them; the reporting of forecasts of revenue and the way in which actual revenues compare against them; the long-term consequences of investment decisions, whether conducted through borrowing or through public-private partnerships of various sorts; and some of the complex accounting areas that can be very hard for all of us to understand. Addressing those four specific areas would also help to ensure that financial reporting keeps pace with the financial autonomy that the Scottish Government and the Scottish Parliament have.
There are certain things that it would be impossible to look at just now, such as the share of the UK debt. Are you saying that we should be more transparent about the backlog maintenance in the NHS, for example, which you set at £773 million, and the civil service pension scheme, and so on? Are you saying that much more information should come out in the budget from the finance secretary so that the Parliament is clearer about assets and liabilities, and that the reporting should be consistent given the point that Colin Beattie made?
Those are both really good examples. In the report, we say that assets are critical to the delivery of public services but they also bring with them both risks and consequences for revenue budgets over time. Clarity about the make-up of the assets and things such as maintenance backlogs would really help.Pension liabilities look like very large, scary numbers on paper. The pension schemes are funded and managed in different ways and the liabilities are changing over time. With the implementation of the Scotland Act 2012, we think that it is becoming increasingly important to pull together that information for Scotland as a whole and to provide a basis for the Parliament to understand it during its budget deliberations.
Thank you, Auditor General. I was just being advised by the clerk, as I warned you at the beginning of the meeting that I might be.
I have a range of brief questions—I will press ahead, convener.I thank the Auditor General for her opening remarks about the report, which reflects a new set of circumstances both in Scotland and in the global situation. Before we move on to the transparency issues, let us talk about accuracy. This will perhaps have relevance to subsequent discussions this morning. Are you confident about the current way of reporting public accounts? In the previous session, an underreporting of the costs associated with major capital projects was revealed along with a slippage of dates. You discovered that by looking at the major capital transport projects. Are you confident that the accounts allow parliamentarians and others to see the full picture of the accounts, as it were?
Yes. Each of the 200 or so public bodies in Scotland produces accounts that are in line with international financial reporting standards and are audited either by me or by the Accounts Commission in line with the global auditing standards. That reliability is there. What we do not have is a place where that information is pulled together for the Scottish devolved public sector as a whole in a way that would let you, as decision makers, make good decisions for the long term about investment, for example; that would help to hold people who are spending public money to account for it; and that would help to build public confidence and, in the future, investor confidence in the sustainability of the public finances. That has been much less important up to now but, as we move into the territory of the Scotland Act 2012 and new tax and borrowing powers, that comprehensiveness and transparency will become more important.I should clarify that, in the report that we produced on the transport projects, we focused not on the costs as captured in the accounts, but on some inconsistencies in the way in which progress on major projects is reported to the committee. You will have the opportunity to explore that a bit further with the accountable officer later.10:30
Exhibit 10 on page 20 of your report shows the estimated annual PPP charges. It is an interesting and revealing graph that shows the rise in the use of private borrowing. How big a portion of that graph represents the major capital projects as opposed to the cumulative total of all the minor or non-major capital projects? How significant would those major capital projects be?
I do not have those figures readily to hand and I do not want to risk misleading the committee. We could provide you with that analysis separately, if that would be helpful.
If £0.5 billion of slippage, as it were, has been revealed in the major capital projects, which receive a certain level of scrutiny, I am slightly worried that less major projects—minor projects if I may call them that, although I am not sure that £20 million projects are minor—or less high-profile capital projects may be underreported or be reported in different terms in the sense that your analysis of them would be different from the way in which the Government would report on them. Do you believe that to be the case? Is that a potential worry?
I simply do not know at this stage. We reported on the five major transport projects because they account for a large part of the infrastructure investment programme and are critical for the development of Scotland’s transport infrastructure. What I said in introducing that report to the committee still stands. The Government’s action in setting a cap for the amount of future revenue funding that it wants to commit to the revenue consequences of capital projects is a very good move. It helps transparency and it helps to ensure that decision making is sustainable.There is nothing wrong, in principle, with funding capital through revenue. We all do that when we buy a house on a mortgage. The next step, though, is that the Government should consider how it reports commitments against that cap to the Parliament to ensure that that is transparent. There are some definitions to be clarified regarding what is included in the cap and the way in which reporting will happen. That is very much the next step in what is already a positive direction of travel by the Government in this area.
James Dornan has a supplementary question.
You touched on the fact that the Scottish Government has already recognised some of the problems that Ken Macintosh is talking about. I believe that its intention is to lower the bar from £50 million to £20 million to ensure that there is more transparency than there is at present regarding projects that, although by no means minor, fall between those two figures. Is that true?
You will have the opportunity to explore that further with the permanent secretary later this morning. The broad point that we are making is that setting the cap is a good move and the next step is to be clear about how commitments against the cap will be reported in the future. There are a number of options for how that might be done, and it seems to us that that is the next step to be taken.
Three other members are waiting to ask questions. I ask you to wind up your questioning, Mr Macintosh.
I have a number of issues, but before we move off the subject let us return to the graph that is exhibit 10. It is divided into PPP charges for local government, the NHS, public corporations and central Government. Would the local government charges be reported only through the Accounts Commission? Are we talking about local government projects that are financed by central Government? I am thinking of schools, for example, which are central Government PPP projects. In other words, is that central Government PPP projects?
No, it is all PPP projects. The local government ones will be reported through the 32 sets of individual accounts for the 32 local authorities and will then be pulled together by the Accounts Commission in its overview report. There will be some consequences for the Scottish Government from local government PPPs, both through direct funding and because around 80 per cent of local government funding comes from the central Government pot. That is why I propose that the discussion about how the overall picture for Scotland’s public finance is presented should take place now between the Parliament and the Government.
Does the 5 per cent rule apply to the total figure or just to the blue part at the bottom of the chart in exhibit 10, which shows the charges paid by central Government?
The 5 per cent cap relates to the Government’s own investment in PPP projects, whether they be private finance initiative or non-profit-distributing. A number of definitional issues can be clarified in taking that forward, and there is a need to report commitments against that in future.I ask Gemma Diamond to clarify the position.
The cap covers the commitments that the Scottish Government is financing and will therefore include a portion of the local government commitments that the Scottish Government has agreed to finance. That is why we have suggested that there be very clear reporting about exactly what the cap covers and how it is being measured to ensure that, particularly in relation to local government projects, we are clear about what is being financed by local government, what is being financed by the Scottish Government and therefore what the cap relates to.
Does that also apply to NHS projects?
The situation with NHS projects is more clear cut because all NHS financing comes from the Scottish Government. The report covers commitments by NHS boards, but they are funded through funding from the Scottish Government to the 14 territorial health boards and, where appropriate, the special health boards.
I want to be clear about this. Because it comes directly from the Government, NHS spending is covered by the 5 per cent cap. Local councils are additional to that. Are projects involving Scottish Water or, say, rail-asset-based borrowing also additional?
Those are all very good examples of why we have recommended that the Scottish Government develop further its reporting about the cap and the commitments about it. Obviously, for the cap itself to be useful it is important to be clear what is and is not included; it is also important that there is reporting against that about the commitments that have been made and the timescale on which they have been made. However, the Scottish Government will wish to answer those questions for the committee as it takes forward its own thinking about the operation of the cap in practice.
The member makes a very good point, but I point out that it is covered in Peter Housden’s response to the committee and I am sure that you will get the opportunity to pursue that line of questioning when Sir Peter comes before the committee.Before I call Liam McArthur, I should put on record that he has already given his apologies for having to leave this meeting early.
link
Thank you very much, convener.Auditor General, you referred in your opening remarks to the renewed importance of forecasting as a result of the new tax-raising powers under the Scotland Act 2012. Indeed, you also acknowledged its importance in commanding confidence and suggested that it be seen as independent, and I believe that in May the cabinet secretary undertook to establish an independent forecasting unit. I do not want to draw you on the question whether such work should necessarily be done separately or whether it could be done through the Office for Budget Responsibility, but working back from the point at which such a unit is likely to be called on to provide forecasting do you have a view on the timeframe for its establishment?
The question of the vehicle through which forecasts are made is obviously a policy matter that falls outside my remit and which I would therefore not comment on.As far as timescales are concerned, we know the timescale for the implementation of the Scottish rate of income tax, which is by far the most significant of the new tax powers, and it will be important for the new forecasting regime to be in place in good time to inform that. As you have said, the Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Employment and Sustainable Growth has announced his intention to set up a Scottish fiscal forecasting body, and we recently responded to the Finance Committee’s consultation about how that might be done. I am not sure that we can say very much more on that issue at the moment.
link
But you think that it would need a period of time to bed in ahead of the new income tax rate being set and implemented.
As would be needed for all the new tax and borrowing powers under the Scotland Act 2012. The person who leads day-to-day Scottish Government audit, Mark Taylor, is keeping a close eye on the matter as part of the audit work and at the moment we have no concerns about the progress that is being made. However, there is clearly a lot to be done before the new powers come fully into effect.
Thank you, Mr McArthur. I call Bob Doris, to be followed by Willie Coffey.
link
I know that it is your first time in the chair, convener, but you made me smile when you asked Ms Gardner for her thoughts about Scotland taking on its share of the UK national debt. I assume that Ms Gardner would look at that only if she were auditing Scotland’s share of the UK’s assets, which seems to be forgotten about whenever the debt is mentioned. I simply wanted to put that aside on the record.
I was quoting from the report, Mr Doris. I do appreciate that that cannot be done.
link
I am delighted that you have clarified the matter, convener, but I thought it important to put the comment on the record.I must compliment and congratulate the Auditor General on this report, because it shows that her office is geared up to analysing and scrutinising any more powers that Scotland might get, irrespective of what the end point might be—of course, we are not here to discuss the politics of that but in my view the end point would be independence—and is capable of holding the Government to account independently. The report also highlights some challenges for the Scottish Government and the committee should scrutinise the Government’s response to those challenges. What would be a reasonable timescale for this committee in its scrutiny role to ensure that the Scottish Government has made suitable progress? I believe that your conclusion was that we are doing okay, but we can do better and with more powers we have to progress further. What is the timescale for ensuring that the Scottish Government continues to develop its sophistication in dealing with this matter?
In my view, this is a very timely moment for the conversation to start. I recognise the deputy convener’s frustration with that phrase, but I think that in order to make the best progress it is important that there is a conversation between the Parliament and the Government.As we know, the 2012 act is being implemented with the establishment of revenue Scotland in the new legislative programme, the introduction of the landfill tax and the new land and buildings transaction tax and the setting of the Scottish rate of income tax in 2015-16. This conversation is starting now and developments in financial reporting over the next couple of years would be a good accompaniment to the changes in the financial environment that come from the existing constitutional position.As you have said, I am in no position to comment on where fiscal autonomy might go after that, but given the legislation on the statute book that is being introduced over the next couple of years I think that this conversation should happen in parallel.
link
That was helpful.You might get the chance to discuss this issue later in private session—if you think that that would be a more appropriate setting, please say so—but how much progress should this committee have made by this time next year in its conversation with the Scottish Government about financial reporting? Is one year a reasonable time? Will your office be reporting on how the Scottish Government has improved in this area in the next year?
We will be keeping a close eye on the Government’s preparations for the implementation of the Scotland Act 2012 through the annual audit process, and there will be an opportunity to draw the issue to the committee’s attention if necessary. That said, it might be helpful to distinguish between agreeing the principles for the development of financial reporting and putting them into practice. It takes time to change the format of annual accounts, particularly if their scope is increasing, and that will have an impact on the Scottish Government finance team and potentially on public bodies across Scotland as well as on my audit teams. There is certainly scope to make progress on agreeing principles, but a bit more time should be allowed for implementation to take account of the realities of doing that well and in ways that support the Parliament as well as they can.
link
That, too, was helpful.I will not ask any more questions, convener. I am sure that we will discuss in a bit more detail how the committee can best do that when we have that conversation later in the agenda.
First, I want to offer a couple of comments. For a start, I think that we can see the difficulty of establishing a baseline. Members have already mentioned a number of items that might not be covered in the asset base or indeed on the liability side and I look forward to seeing whoever it might be attempting to reach an agreement on what that baseline should be.Secondly, I like to think that our role as the Public Audit Committee has played quite a part in this report’s development. I know that it has principally been born out of the changes as a result of the Scotland Act 2012 and that that has probably been imperative; however, I am absolutely delighted to see throughout the report reflections of many discussions that have taken place in the committee over a number of years. Indeed, that is why I like this report—it is a staging post on the way to where we want to be.10:45
With regard to your comment that consolidated accounts do not give the bigger or broader picture, we know that all the public sector bodies report and provide accounts but the fact is that they all tend to do so in different ways. Would you encourage in future a progression towards a kind of common data gathering and data reporting standard in the public sector to ensure that such data can be easily consolidated and understood by the likes of us? What role would, say, ISD play in assisting us in achieving that aim?
The framework is already in place; after all, all public bodies in Scotland already prepare their accounts to a common accounting framework. There are, as Mark Taylor outlined, some differences around the accounting policies for valuing certain assets and liabilities, but that can be ironed out in the process. Interestingly, at a UK level, there are whole-of-Government accounts that provide that kind of comprehensive picture but we do not have the subset that relates to Scotland as a whole. Although there are consolidated accounts, they exclude not only local government but some other parts of the public sector.Really good groundwork has been carried out, but this is all about taking the next step. As the Scotland Act 2012 comes into play and as we think about the new risks that come with those revenue-raising and borrowing powers, we need to consider the financial reporting that the Parliament and other stakeholders in Scotland’s public finances will need to make the system work as well as it can.
You mentioned outcomes, performance and so on. How might we take things further with regard to reporting on such matters? That has been the subject of discussion not just by this committee but elsewhere for a number of years now.
It is a great question, but it was not the subject of this report. At the moment, we are engaging with the Scottish Government in the development of the outcomes approach and what that will mean for the way in which we audit Scotland’s public services. I hope that we can show more of that in future but this report is more about reporting the finances side of the equation rather than the outcomes and performance side.
I appreciate that response.
I thank the Auditor General and her staff for their evidence. We will now change panels.10:47 Meeting suspended.
10:49 On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 4 Sep 2013 →- 10:00 Interests Procedure · 8
- 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 67
- 10:00 Section 23 Reports Evidence session · 99
- 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 94
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.