Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Current Petitions

Mosquito Devices (PE1367)

Tuesday 8 March 2011 Public Petitions Committee About 14:00 Petitions 33 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

33 contributions
Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

The next petition is PE1367, by Andrew Deans, on behalf of the Scottish Youth Parliament, seeking to ban the use of Mosquito devices.I welcome to the committee Fergus Ewing, the Minister for Community Safety, along with his officials, John Brownlie and Scott Wood. I am conscious of the time and the fact that you require to be away, minister. We intend to finish this session by half past 3 at the latest, if that is okay with you. If you had a short statement, you will get a chance to make points from it in response to questions. I am conscious that we are short of time, so we will move straight to questions. I am sure that, in the course of the discussion, you will get a chance to say what you want to say.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

What precisely did you mean, in your letter dated 25 January 2011, when you said:“we will consider very carefully all arguments made in relation to these devices; the submissions made to the Committee during the course of its consideration; and the proposals put forward by members of the Scottish Youth Parliament that the devices should be banned”?How, when and with whom will you consider those? We would appreciate more detail.

Fergus Ewing SNP The Minister for Community Safety · Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

We will consider them with all stakeholders, MSPs, interested members of the public and Her Majesty’s Government.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People has provided three issues to be considered in respect of the matter, which are set out in the petitioner’s letter to the committee of 10 February. What is your response to those issues? Will you take the suggested actions, which are: to work with the UK Government—which has control over the regulation of goods—to achieve a ban; to review whether public sector organisations have responsibility, under the public sector equality duty, to prevent the use of the Mosquito in relation to its discriminating against children and young people, especially those with disabilities; and to review whether the Mosquito constitutes a noise nuisance under the Antisocial Behaviour (Scotland) Act 2004? Will you respond to those three specific issues that have been raised by the SCCYP?

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

Certainly. In September 2010, I wrote to Theresa May MP and offered to work with her and her officials on the UK coalition Government’s approach to tackling antisocial behaviour. We have been seeking to arrange a meeting between our officials, and I propose that the Mosquito device could and should be one of the matters to be covered at such a meeting, whenever Theresa May agrees that it may take place.In relation to reviewing whether public sector organisations have the responsibility, under the public sector equality duty, to prevent use of the Mosquito in relation to its discriminating against children and young people, especially those with disabilities, I note that the Equality Act 2010 restates, simplifies and, where appropriate, harmonises the various equality legislation. It consolidated the three existing duties on race, sex and disability into a single equality duty that also covers age, among other characteristics. That duty, which will come into force in April, requires a public authority to have due regard to the need to eliminate discrimination, harassment and victimisation, as well as to foster good relations by tackling prejudice and promoting understanding. Some people may say that the Mosquito device fails on a number of those counts. That general duty can, of course, be enforced through judicial review.On the third issue—review of whether the Mosquito constitutes a noise nuisance under the Antisocial Behaviour (Scotland) Act 2004—I advise the committee that it is up to individual local authorities to determine how to address any noise nuisance complaints that they receive. Each local authority enforces the legislation in its own area and it is not for central Government to dictate to local government how it should implement its local duties.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

In its latest response, the Scottish Government states:“We consider that the mosquito device is not consistent with our approach as outlined in Promoting Positive Outcomes and is also not consistent with our desire to create strong supportive communities”.Is that the same as having reached the conclusion that I and the petitioner have reached, which is that the device is wrong in principle, and that if there is a way to rid ourselves of the use of the devices we must do it? Have you reached that conclusion, or is that yet to be decided?

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

I will be forthright with the committee. The Scottish Government does not support and has never supported the use of the devices. The devices are incompatible with the approach to tackling antisocial behaviour that we have adopted, and it behoves me to say that we do not equate antisocial behaviour with young people. When we talk about antisocial behaviour, we are often talking about people who are as old as I am, or even older than that. To stigmatise young people is plainly wrong, given that the vast majority of young people are a credit to themselves, to their communities and to their parents and display pro-social behaviour.The approach that my friend Harry McGuigan and I have set out is outlined in our framework, “Promoting Positive Outcomes: Working Together to Prevent Antisocial Behaviour in Scotland”, which was published jointly by the Scottish Government and the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities in March 2009. We do not see the use of the Mosquito as being synonymous, consonant or consistent with the approach that we have adopted to addressing the minority of young people who get involved in a bit of bad behaviour.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

So, we all generally agree that the Mosquito is a completely undesirable method of—supposedly—tackling antisocial behaviour. We are left with the three main options that the petitioner has suggested, but the two main options for getting a national conclusion to this are that the UK Government might consider the Sale of Goods Act 1979 or that we review whether local authorities have a responsibility under the public sector equality duty—which you just mentioned—not to discriminate, harass or victimise, but to eliminate those behaviours. The Mosquito obviously discriminates against people under the age of 25—as well as my colleague, Nigel Don, who once heard such a device—and harasses those who hear it, especially children and babies who cannot tell their parents what is wrong with them. It victimises them. So, we are left with the UK Government option or the public sector equality duty. What would you advise is the best way of getting rid of the devices as quickly as possible?

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

I was impressed by the way in which the petitioner—Andrew Deans, who is a member of the Scottish Youth Parliament—took the matter forward. In giving his evidence, he spoke without using notes, which you remarked on. I also agree with John Farquhar Munro, who pointed out that very young children and toddlers would be worried, disturbed and upset by the noise, which they would not understand, and that their parents would not know what was happening. Those points were very well made by committee members and there was strong unanimity of approach.It is for the committee to determine the best approach. One route would be a legislative approach, which would require consideration of whether there is a basis for a ban on the device. It is not clear to us that the legislative competence to impose such a ban rests with the Scottish Parliament; therefore, various issues regarding legislative competence would have to be fully explored. Perhaps foolishly, I looked at paragraph C7 of schedule 5 to the Scotland Act 1998, which appeared to be relevant—however, we act not on the basis of my advice, but on that of the Scottish Government legal directorate, and we do not have that advice. Nevertheless, I think that there is a case for a ban. That is a matter that I would want to discuss with Theresa May, to get the UK Government’s views. There may be an argument that more evidence is required, especially if we move from a position of general disapproval—on which there is agreement—to a ban, which is a step on which other views would be needed.I have given some thought to—and am happy to run through, if the committee would find it useful—other areas where work might be needed. The committee or, indeed, Parliament would be free to take that work forward as it saw fit and in the manner that Anne McLaughlin has highlighted.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

The committee would be keen to hear about that, but I think that Cathie Craigie has another question.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

I am glad to hear that the minister is going to continue the discussions with his Westminster counterpart, because it would be good to have a UK-wide solution to this. However, I believe that, under the Antisocial Behaviour etc (Scotland) Act 2004, local authorities and the police have the power to seize noise-making equipment from premises. As the Mosquito is a piece of noise-making equipment—even though those of us just over 25 cannot hear it—I wonder whether it would be covered under the 2004 act.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

John Brownlie is more familiar with that part of the act. Would it be in order for him to answer that specific question, convener?

John Brownlie Scottish Government Directorate for Safer Communities
link

As you have said, Ms Craigie, powers exist to seize noise-making equipment. However, when I discussed the issue with a local government colleague who is the head of a noise team, he indicated certain difficulties in that respect, simply because of the problem of detection. If, for example, I were to walk past this thing, I would not in all likelihood know that it was there. If the minister was happy for me to do so, I could certainly explore the matter further with our local government colleagues who, as he has pointed out, are responsible for exercising these powers.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

I take John Brownlie’s point about problems with detecting this equipment. However, younger people have been used to implement other legislation, for example by being involved in test purchasing. Could there be some combination in that respect?

John Brownlie Scottish Government Directorate for Safer Communities
link

I will certainly discuss that with our local authority colleagues.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

I certainly invite the minister to make his suggestions about the way forward because, to be honest, I think that they would be helpful. Before he does so, though, I point out that I know that the device that I mentioned the last time we discussed this matter is still there, because I deliberately drove, then walked, past it yesterday. However, either it has been changed or it has rectified itself because, when I first got to the place in question and wound down my windows, I thought, “Mmm—it’s off.” Then I heard a much fainter very high-pitched squeal. If we stopped and, rather than smelling the roses, used our ears and listened, we might be able to hear these things.That said, I also asked the readership of The Press and Journal, which is reasonably widespread over the north-east, to let me know whether they had found any of these devices. I have not yet received any replies. It might be that youngsters do not read The Press and Journal, but it might also be that there are simply not many of these things around. As I said, I am interested to hear the minister’s suggestions on how we might take this forward. After all, he knows the context far better than we do.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

I read in the Official Report of the committee’s previous discussion of this matter that Mr Don had experienced one of these devices when he was out canvassing. Sometimes you get more than you bargain for when you undertake such activities.As John Brownlie has alluded to, my officials have, in an attempt to obtain more information about the extent of the use of the device across Scotland, contacted antisocial behaviour practitioners across Scotland through the practitioner network. Of the 20 who replied, all were aware of the device and six were aware of its use in their area; three out of those six said that the use was historical. From that limited canvassing exercise, the extent of the device’s use across Scotland seems limited and sporadic, as far as local authorities are aware. Several respondents made it clear that they did not consider using the device to be in line with their approaches to tackling antisocial behaviour. I hope that that information is of use.I will now respond to Nigel Don’s first point, which I was invited to deal with second and which was on organisations that we might wish to ask again or for the first time for advice and information. I understand that several organisations did not respond to the committee’s request for information, such as the National Autistic Society, the Royal National Institute for Deaf People, the Association of Scottish Community Councils, the Federation of Small Businesses and COSLA.I have obtained

information from officials that suggests that the evidence might point in different directions—it is not all one-sided. For example, I understand that a senior audiologist—Angela King of the RNID—said:“The ‘Mosquito’ emits a very high-pitched sound (16.5-17kHz) that is just within the range of human hearing for young people but will not be heard by most people over the age of 25.As we get older we gradually lose our hearing—and we lose it from the high frequency end of the sound spectrum first.”She added the interesting point that“We understand that the sound from the ‘Mosquito’ can become extremely annoying to young people, but is not at a level that will cause any damage to hearing.”Depending on the approach that one pursued in considering whether a ban might be justified, if the issue were within devolved competence and if the purpose were to protect health, it would follow that evidence on whether the devices are injurious to health would need to be taken from a variety of sources. I would think that the lady whom I just quoted is one such source.I know that evidence has been obtained from other sources and I in no way deprecate the committee’s substantial efforts, which have resulted in extremely useful evidence. Nonetheless, I say with respect that, if members were inclined to investigate further whether the issue is within devolved competence and if the purpose were protecting health, more evidence would plainly be needed.For completeness and in the interests of applying the second principle of natural justice, which is to hear the other side of the case, it would be useful to seek further views from the device’s manufacturer, Compound Security Systems, from Merthyr Tydfil in south Wales. Any decisions could have implications for jobs and it would only be fair to the company’s employees that they and their employer should have the right to offer their views. It would also be useful to have the manufacturer’s views on the device’s legality and its use in other countries. As we might expect, the company argues on its website that the device is not injurious to health. I make the point in passing that, if one’s approach to the issue is to consider whether we should ban the device, obtaining more evidence might be useful.I appreciate that we are close to the end of the parliamentary session. I can only speculate on whether I will achieve my first date with Theresa May before we go into purdah.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

I am sure that she will be terribly disappointed if that does not happen.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

I know that the election is coming up but, if it were not and if we were carrying on as normal, what would the Scottish Government do? I take it that your suggestions for taking evidence were for the committee to pursue. You said that you were trying to have a meeting with Theresa May, at which you have asked for the device to be on the agenda. However, I have asked her to do things and she has said no. That meeting cannot be the only way forward.The main issue was not health but discrimination and abuse to the ears, whether or not it affects people’s hearing. If Theresa May said no to a meeting, what would be the way forward? Would a two-pronged or three-pronged approach be taken? We want to pass on to the petitioner what will happen. We can say what the committee will do, but what options is the Scottish Government considering pursuing?15:15

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

We recognise that the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child must be considered in this case. The committee has looked into that. Article 15 clearly recognises the right of children and young people to freedom of movement and peaceable assembly. We strongly support that right, but the article also recognises that the exercise of such a right should not impact on the protection of the rights and freedom of others. Like Anne McLaughlin, we are particularly concerned about the indiscriminate use of Mosquito devices, which can result in young people under 25, from the newborn to young adults, being treated as a nuisance regardless of their behaviour. We could not support such indiscriminate use of the device, which affects everybody irrespective of whether they are doing anything that anyone would see as objectionable.I mention that rights aspect simply because I know that the committee has considered it and it is part of the relevant statutory overlay. However, I think that there could be, to coin a phrase, a third way, which would be to consider how to regulate the use of the device. That could be done either by the Scottish Parliament acting alone or by our acting with Westminster. For example, a mechanism could be established to ensure that the device’s use was responsible and proportionate. Some may argue that that is not possible. Others, including the Scottish Grocers Federation, have argued that it is a useful device but only as a last resort to deal with difficult situations. The committee could weigh up the argument in that regard.It may be possible to provide regulations on who would be authorised to use the device. In other words, there could be a licensing provision so that, for example—I just suggest a possibility here rather than an approach that we have adopted as our view or policy—police officers would be the only people who were authorised to use it. More widely, security officers who were properly regulated, as they now can be, could be so authorised. Alternatively, there could be a combination of regulating the person—that is, restricting the people who would be entitled to use the device—and restricting the purpose. Both person and purpose could be the subject of regulation.Those matters are worthy of consideration, as we have reached no fixed the view on the issue. Again, though, I would hope that the Scottish Government could consider them with Her Majesty’s Government in due course, whether in this parliamentary session or early in the next one. I would want that to happen, were I in a position to do anything about it.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

One of the petitioner’s suggestions was that the Government could review whether public sector organisations have a responsibility on this issue under the public sector equality duty. Will you ask your officials to look into that as an option? That would seem to be the clearest way forward. I find it difficult to understand the argument that the device does not discriminate, harass or victimise young people.Is the minister aware of how the Co-operative Group dealt with groups of young people? I do not necessarily approve of treating all young people the same but, when groups of young people were hanging about outside Co-op stores and they wanted rid of them, they played classical music, which was very effective in that regard. No one was dreadfully upset; it was just that the music did not match the young people’s taste.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

I am happy to give an undertaking to look into the general question further. However, it is likely that I may be advised that, in doing so, it would be necessary to obtain more evidence as part of the process. The equality duties that I described earlier—namely, inter alia, the duty to have due regard to the need to eliminate discrimination, harassment and victimisation—would suggest that there may be a prima facie case to consider. Whether a case could be made out in evidence would, I think, take a great deal of investigation. However, I am happy to ask my officials to consider the issue and obtain more detailed answers than we could give today about whether, as Anne McLaughlin suggests, the equality duties might be a route and a remedy.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

Will you consult the petitioner, who is currently doing a lot of work on that anyway and might be able to help to provide some of the evidence?

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

I would be happy if the petitioner, and anyone else who has an interest, wishes to contact us with their views on the matter. However, from my reading of the Official Report, Mr Deans has already done a fairly good job of putting his views to the committee with great passion and clarity.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

I understand that Mr Deans is watching the meeting on the television so I am sure that he has heard that invitation.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

The issue for me is that the use of the devices is unknown. We do not know how many retailers, shopping malls or private individuals are using them. Until we know the extent of their use throughout Scotland, we will remain unclear about how to advance the issue. It sounded as though the Mosquito device that Nigel Don mentioned hearing was in a residential estate. The devices can be and are being sold to private individuals for use outside their houses or business premises.If the minister is prepared to take the issue forward, will he give us some assurance—although I am not sure how he will be able to deliver on it—that, in consultation with local authorities and the police, he will try to determine how many of the devices are in operation in Scotland so that we have a good estimate of how widespread their use is and what the impact is?I have to take issue with the minister on protecting young people and how they get their message over. How do we ask a two-year-old who is disturbed by a Mosquito device that is emitting a high-frequency sound about their views and experiences? How does that two-year-old explain those views and experiences fully to the people who use the devices or the local authority environmental health officers who are supposed to monitor noise pollution in their areas?

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

John Farquhar Munro made the point earlier that young children, such as two-year-olds and toddlers, may well be disturbed, distressed and upset when within hearing range of a Mosquito device but their parents would not necessarily know why they were distressed. As I think I made plain earlier, that was a very good point. I agree with that point; I do not intend to contradict it or take a different view.On how many Mosquito devices there are and what we can do to ascertain the extent of their usage, I have run through the evidence that we obtained from the inquiries that we already made, largely because of the petitioner’s pleadings and the committee’s exhortations to find out from local authority antisocial behaviour practitioners how extensive usage is. Among 20 respondees, there was limited evidence of usage and much of it was historical. That appears to suggest that usage is limited. We would expect that, were usage widespread, it would lead to complaints. I am pretty sure about that. The views expressed by members of all parties on the committee would be shared by a great many other people in Scotland. We would also expect antisocial behaviour practitioners to be aware of extensive usage and expect it to emerge in the local press and in local debates throughout the country. Through logical deduction, that suggests to me that usage is, happily, limited. However, Mr Wilson makes the point that we do not have evidence. I suspect that we could obtain it with some difficulty. It might not quite be a fishing expedition, but it would be something quite close to that and I would be a bit wary of giving any specific commitment today. That is not to detract from Mr Wilson’s point. It is important to know how widespread the usage of Mosquito devices is, but it may be difficult to find the answer to that question. The earlier, primary questions are who has the power and how it can be employed; and how we go about working with Her Majesty’s Government and whether it would not be better to act across the UK. Of course it would be best to serve all the peoples in the UK in finding a fair solution.Those high-level issues of principle and politics are, perhaps, the ones that we could advance early in the next session of Parliament. I hope that that will be the case, irrespective of who sits in my chair and who sits in the committee’s chairs.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

I will not be sitting in this chair.I ask the committee for views on what to do with the petition.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

There is no doubt that we should continue it. The minister has made some helpful suggestions that we could follow up and I suggest that we go with those in the first instance.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

Does the rest of the committee agree? Members indicated agreement.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

We will continue the petition and it will go into the legacy paper for the successor committee.I thank the minister for attending and for being helpful and constructive. I also thank Scott Wood and John Brownlie.Under rule 7.4.1 of standing orders, I suspend the meeting of the committee. We will suspend for approximately 10 minutes. If members of the public clear the gallery, we will call them back in when we restart.15:27 Meeting suspended.

15:46 On resuming—

  1. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  2. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 45
  3. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 28
  4. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 33
  5. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  6. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  7. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 14
  8. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 11
  9. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 14
  10. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  11. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 28
  12. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  13. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 9
  14. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 12
  15. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  16. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  17. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  18. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  19. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 12
  20. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  21. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  22. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  23. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 19
  24. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  25. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  26. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  27. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  28. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 9
  29. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  30. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  31. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  32. 14:00 Annual Report Committee business · 8
  33. 14:00 Legacy Paper Committee business · 35

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.