Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Current Petitions

Dairy Farmers (Human Rights) (PE1263)

Tuesday 8 March 2011 Public Petitions Committee About 14:00 Petitions 45 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

45 contributions
Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

PE1263, by Evelyn Mundell, on behalf of Ben Mundell, concerns human rights for dairy farmers.I welcome Richard Lochhead, the Cabinet Secretary for Rural Affairs and the Environment, and his officials, Martin Morgan and Angela Lawson. To ensure that the minister can get to his subsequent meeting, we will conclude this part of the meeting around half past two. I thank the minister for setting aside time to come to our meeting today.We also have with us Jamie McGrigor, who is keen to ask a few questions of the minister. I invite him to do so now.

Jamie McGrigor Con Highlands and Islands
link

For brevity’s sake, I will move straight to my questions, of which I have three.Given that the Government now admits that it considered human rights issues when deciding to continue with the southern isles milk quota ring fence, will it now tell us, in the interests of openness and transparency, what advice it received on human rights and what assessment it made of the issue around introducing a control on the use of property?When the consultation on continuing the ring fence was undertaken, why were individual dairy farmers not consulted? Did any of the organisations that were consulted consider human rights issues, competition law and the free market?Does the minister recognise that my dairy-farming constituents in the southern isles believe that, by continuing with the ring fence, the Government was making them bear individual and excessive burdens for the wider community interest that were not proportionate or in keeping with human rights? I will stop there, but I have three further questions that I would like to ask after the minister responds.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

As long as we have time to ensure that members of the committee can ask questions as well.

Richard Lochhead SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Rural Affairs and the Environment · Moray
link

I think that I heard you say that this was the last meeting of the committee this session, convener, which means that it is your last meeting of any committee of the Parliament, so I wish you all the best for the future in your personal capacity. I am grateful for the opportunity to come along and say a few words today.In response to Jamie McGrigor’s questions, I remind the committee that, following deregulation, Scotland was the only part of the United Kingdom to introduce milk quota ring-fence arrangements, which it did in four parts of the country in April 1993. That ring fence was applied to maintain milk production in peripheral areas, to help to ensure a supply of milk to the remote dairy enterprises. The ring-fence provisions are designed to provide continuity of milk production in that part of rural Scotland, to ensure that local creameries have access to a sufficient volume of raw milk to stay in production.14:15

I will come on to Jamie McGrigor’s first two questions but, in response to the third one, about whether I am aware that farmers in the southern islands who are covered by this particular ring fence believe that ring fencing is detrimental, I have to say that I am not really aware of that, because my understanding is that over the past years—going back to 1994, when this was introduced—the many stakeholders and farmers involved have supported ring fencing. I know that that is not the petitioners’ position but the National Farmers Union of Scotland’s position and that of other farmers in the ring-fenced areas was that they supported the approach as a means of ensuring that local creameries were viable and of working together to ensure that that was the case.On Jamie McGrigor’s first question on advice, the committee will be aware that, as has always been the position under devolution, ministers will not give any indication of whether they have taken advice or what the advice was. Of course, we take policy advice and we reach our own policy decisions, but according to convention we do not venture into legal advice, for very good reasons.Finally, on farmers not being consulted when ring fencing was applied, I have been the minister for only four years so I cannot go back to 1994 when this was introduced; I can only reiterate that when the ring fencing of milk quotas in this part of the country was introduced for what were seen as very good reasons—which I have outlined—it had widespread support because it ensured that milk producers in peripheral areas of Scotland were working together and ensured the viability of local creameries, in this case the Campbeltown creamery and the Arran creamery, which are still operational.

Jamie McGrigor Con Highlands and Islands
link

I disagree with the cabinet secretary. The ring fence was introduced in 1984 and in 1994, when there was deregulation, the whole picture changed. At that point the people who could sell their quota sold it, in some cases, in the 1990s, for 70p or 80p a litre, while those who were forced to keep it finally got it taken into their single farm payment in 2005 at 2.5p per litre.The Scottish Government has stated specifically that the removal of the ring fence for Islay allowed dairy farmers there to sell quota on the open market and thereby realise income that could be used to support other existing businesses or diversification. Why was it considered appropriate to deny the same right to Mr and Mrs Mundell and the other dairy farmers in the southern ring-fence area?

Richard Lochhead SNP Moray
link

In response to the question on the timing of the introduction of ring fencing, my understanding of the timetable—I ask the officials to intervene if I am wrong—is that milk quotas, not ring fencing, were introduced in 1984.

Richard Lochhead SNP Moray
link

You said ring fencing, so I am just clarifying what you meant.In response to deregulation under the Conservative Government in the early 1990s and the disbanding of the milk marketing boards, it was felt that measures had to be introduced to protect peripheral areas, which is why ring fencing was introduced at that point—after deregulation, which came into force in 1994. That clarifies the timeline and the rationale behind the steps that were taken at various points in the timeline.I think that your final point was why the same rights were not afforded to those in ring-fenced areas as were afforded to those in other areas.

Jamie McGrigor Con Highlands and Islands
link

I said that the Scottish Government stated specifically that the removal of the ring fence for Islay allowed dairy farmers there to sell quota on the open market, allowing diversification. I am saying that Mr and Mrs Mundell and other dairy farmers further down the coast were not allowed to do that and that they therefore suffered a dramatic loss of money and of human rights.

Richard Lochhead SNP Moray
link

Notwithstanding the many pressures that for the past decade and more have faced dairy farmers across Scotland, including in Argyll and the southern isles, it is important to note that ring fencing was introduced on certain boundaries to take into account specific circumstances and that where the ring fencing applies can be changed.In the case of Islay Creamery, which unfortunately closed for commercial reasons, the farmers who were more closely aligned with that creamery were taken out of the ring fencing. Because we still have Campbeltown creamery and Arran creamery, the ring fencing boundary was changed so that the ring fencing still applied to the producers supplying those two creameries. We can adjust where the ring fencing applies, which is why the closure of Islay Creamery removed part of the rationale for the ring fencing in that area of Scotland. However, the reason for retaining the ring fencing for the Campbeltown and Arran creameries remains, which is why there is still ring fencing there, albeit with a slightly different boundary.

Jamie McGrigor Con Highlands and Islands
link

On that point, minister, only 20 per cent of the original dairy farmers in that area now exist, because most of the others have gone bankrupt. Does the minister think that it is acceptable for my constituents and others within the ring fence to continue to produce milk at a loss in the name of subsidising other businesses, namely the creamery, and the wider community?

Richard Lochhead SNP Moray
link

The member refers to some of the wider pressures facing the dairy sector and the reduction in the number of dairy farmers in one part of Scotland. I do not deny that situation for a second. The dairy sector in Scotland has faced huge pressures for many years. I visited a dairy farm in my own constituency yesterday, and the dairy farmer explained to me that in 1966 he had a dozen dairy cows and made a good living but today he has about 150 dairy cows and makes a substantial loss. That perhaps gives you an indication of the trends in dairy farming over the past few decades. That situation has applied to the member’s region and constituency, as it has applied throughout Scotland.

Jamie McGrigor Con Highlands and Islands
link

But at least those in other areas were able to sell their quota and diversify. May I ask one more question, convener?

Jamie McGrigor Con Highlands and Islands
link

Did the Government at any stage consider the economic impact on dairy farmers in the southern isles’ ring-fenced area of not being able, unlike virtually all other dairy farmers in Scotland, to sell or lease out their milk quota on the open market? If so, did the Government consider at any stage compensation for the dairy farmers affected?

Richard Lochhead SNP Moray
link

I will answer what I can of that question, because we are going back to 1994 when the ring-fencing concept was introduced and implemented. On the adjustments since then to ring fencing in the areas that are covered, a range of factors are taken into account. For instance, when the Islay Creamery closed, the situation facing that remote island community was considered and the decision was taken to change the ring-fencing boundary so that some farmers were able to go into the general market with a quota.Again, though, the remaining ring-fencing area, which covers the member’s constituents and the two creameries that I mentioned before, had widespread support—from the creameries themselves and all their employees, and many of the other dairy producers who supplied the creameries.It is worth pointing out to the committee that there is a mutual interest among dairy producers to stay within the ring fence to supply the one creamery, because if the number of farmers supplying one creamery was reduced, the creamery’s viability could be harmed. That would not be in the interest of the people who still want to supply it, who want to support the creamery and all the employment that comes with that. That is why there is widespread support for ring fencing among many dairy producers.

Jamie McGrigor Con Highlands and Islands
link

Minister, the creamery was not obligated to pick up milk from the farmers in question.

Richard Lochhead SNP Moray
link

I can only give you the rationale that was used for the decision making on ring fencing.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

Thank you. Do members have any further questions?

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Good afternoon, minister. You stated, quite correctly, that Governments of whatever political complexion do not reveal their legal advice. However, the information that committee members and I have is that the advice to Scottish ministers at the time in question on the ring-fencing provisions and human rights was provided by qualified officials who were conversant with the European convention on human rights and associated case law.Will you tell the committee not what the specific advice was but, in general terms, whether it was a unanimous view or whether opinion was divided?

Richard Lochhead SNP Moray
link

I cannot answer that question. Ministers take advice and reach a policy decision. On this issue, we have considered the human rights legislation and been made aware that article 1 of protocol 1 of the European convention on human rights permits a state to“control the use of property in accordance with the general interest”.In reaching a policy decision, ministers can take comfort from looking at the human rights legislation.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

I guessed that that would be the response, given Angela Lawson’s emphatic head shaking.For the record, will you reiterate the main reasons why the Scottish Government considers that milk quota ring fencing is not the most important determinant of a farmer’s ability to earn a living?

Richard Lochhead SNP Moray
link

As I alluded to, a number of factors affect the profitability of dairy farms. Jamie McGrigor might dispute this, but I have looked into the issue and am unaware of any other dairy farmers who have approached us asking for the same outcome as the petitioners. I believe that 40 or so dairy farms supply the Campbeltown creamery and that 30 or 35 supply the Arran creamery. Those dairy farms will take into account a number of factors in running their businesses—some diversify and some do not. The fact that none of them has approached us on the issue tells me that they feel that the ring fencing is in their interests generally. I have not been contacted by other dairy producers with similar views to those of the petitioners.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

I ask Jamie McGrigor what contact he has had with other dairy farmers.

Jamie McGrigor Con Highlands and Islands
link

I have spoken to several dairy farmers about the issue and I can assure the minister that the people who are presenting the petition are not the only ones who are affected by the ring fencing and who cannot sell their quota for 80p per unit, as it is now worth 0.35p per unit.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

I must bring the questioning to a close, as we need to discuss where we go with the petition. I seek members’ views on our options.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

We are grateful to the cabinet secretary for coming and for his evidence. This is the committee’s last meeting, so there are two alternatives. One is to close consideration of the petition, but I am averse to that. Instead, we should suggest to our successor committee in our legacy paper that it should pick up the issue, particularly given that the advice that we have is that the Scottish Government will undertake a review of the ring-fence provisions in 2012 in advance of the planned abolition of the milk quota regime by the European Council in 2015. The issue is still a live one and, for the petitioners, it is important and serious. Including the petition in our legacy paper would enable the petition at least to stay alive, and if our successor committee so wished, it could take it up at the appropriate time, which might be in the lead-up to the review in 2012. That is not wholly satisfactory, but it is the only thing that I can think of to keep the petition alive.14:30

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

Sorry, but I disagree with Bill Butler. The petition is fairly narrow in that it asks the Government to“accept that individual dairy farmers have human rights and that these have been breached by the operating rules of the ring fencing mechanism”.The Government has clearly told us that farmers have human rights, but in the Government’s opinion they have not been breached. It is not for us to make a judgment on that rather thorny legal question—that is for higher powers. If the petitioners are to get any satisfaction, the issue would have to go to a higher court: the European Court of Human Rights. We cannot refer the matter to that court, so it is up to the petitioners to do that. The Government has made it perfectly clear that it does not accept that there has been a breach of human rights. What more can be achieved by keeping the petition alive for the Government to tell us again that it does not accept that there has been a breach, which is the logical extension?

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

I agree with Bill Butler’s suggestion, particularly since the review will include a full public consultation exercise, which might well bring forward the other dairy farmers from whom we have not heard. That might give a more balanced picture of the overall situation.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

We have two diametrically opposed suggestions. Are there any more views?

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

Last week, we closed some petitions on the basis of what they actually asked for, despite the fact that further developments were to come. In doing so, we advised the petitioners to produce a different petition when those developments occurred. I agree with Robin Harper. There will be a review in 2012 and there is nothing to prevent someone from lodging a different petition at that time. I am not sure that we can do anything more on what the petition asks for.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

Given that the petition is specific and that there are two differing views on the extent to which other dairy farmers are affected, it might be most appropriate to close the petition, but to contact the petitioners—they are in the public gallery today—to suggest that they lodge another petition that is slightly wider in scope. If other people are affected, they might want to be part of that future petition. I do not know, but I just throw that into the discussion.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

I agree with the convener. The Government’s response has answered the questions in the petition. The Government clearly does not believe that individual human rights have been breached by the operating rules or that the rules operate unfairly against the petitioners. However, Mr and Mrs Mundell have put an awful lot of work into the petition and have raised awareness—certainly with me—of the issue and of other issues that need to be considered. The Government says that it will review the ring fencing in 2012, but that is a long time to leave the pressure on Mr and Mrs Mundell to keep going.We would perhaps welcome another petition on the issue in the next session of Parliament. Mr and Mrs Mundell and some other people could run with the issue to keep the pressure on the Government for a review and to ensure that dairy farmers are involved and consulted when the review takes place. There is generally a period of time before a review when the ground rules are set on issues such as what will be reviewed and what questions will be asked. That would be an opportunity for Mr and Mrs Mundell and others who are similarly affected to set the agenda. On that basis, I recommend that the existing petition be closed, but I advise Mr and Mrs Mundell not to give up.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

We have heard a mixture of views. I think that we are swinging towards closing the petition. I am conscious that Mr Lochhead has to get away. We need to reach our conclusion. Are you okay to stay for another minute or two, minister?

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

Keith Brown, the Minister for Transport and Infrastructure, is coming before the committee after you, minister. He, too, has big time pressures on him. I call Robin Harper, but ask him to be brief.

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

May I ask Jamie McGrigor a very quick question?

Jamie McGrigor Con Highlands and Islands
link

I will give a very quick answer, convener.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

We are literally at the point of having to make a decision. We are in a situation where it is not appropriate for witnesses and committee members to ask questions of each other.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

It seems that the majority of the committee are going for closure. The issue will not go away; Mr and Mrs Mundell know that. I have a suggestion for them. Perhaps they could quickly lodge a similar petition with other supporters in the new session of the Parliament. I hope that they find that suggestion acceptable. I will not divide and I will not press.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

Given the work that the petitioners have put into the petition, it is only fair that, in closing the petition, we should approach the Government asking it to consult fully the petitioners on the issue. We should ask it to hear the issues that the petitioners have raised and consider the answers that have been given thus far.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

Thank you. I propose that we close the petition on the grounds that we have discussed and with those provisos. Are we agreed?Members indicated agreement.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

I thank the cabinet secretary and his officials for their attendance.

  1. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  2. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 45
  3. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 28
  4. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 33
  5. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  6. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  7. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 14
  8. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 11
  9. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 14
  10. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  11. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 28
  12. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  13. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 9
  14. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 12
  15. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  16. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  17. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  18. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  19. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 12
  20. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  21. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  22. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  23. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 19
  24. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  25. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  26. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  27. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  28. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 9
  29. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  30. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  31. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  32. 14:00 Annual Report Committee business · 8
  33. 14:00 Legacy Paper Committee business · 35

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.