Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

“National concessionary travel”

Wednesday 10 November 2010 Public Audit Committee About 09:30 Committee business 67 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

67 contributions
The Convener Hugh Henry
link

Item 5 is a section 23 report entitled “National concessionary travel”, on which I invite the Auditor General to brief the committee.

Mr Black
link

Barbara Hurst will introduce the report.

Barbara Hurst Audit Scotland
link

That was a rather hard evidence act to follow, but I will do my best. I hope that Mr Hepburn has seen in his first Public Audit Committee meeting that audit is actually quite interesting.

Jamie Hepburn
link

And substantial.

Barbara Hurst Audit Scotland
link

The report was published in early October. The national concessionary travel scheme was introduced in April 2006 with all-party support. It provides free bus travel to everyone who is over 60 and to people with some disabilities. The audit examined the scheme’s development and management and its impact and cost.The national scheme was developed from previous concessionary travel schemes that councils had operated in one form or another since the late 1960s. In April 2004, the Scottish Executive announced its plan to standardise concessionary travel by introducing a centrally administered scheme that would provide free local and national bus travel at peak and off-peak times to everyone who is over 60 and to people with some disabilities.To help its consideration of the scheme, Parliament was provided with information on the likely reimbursement cost that would be paid to bus companies in the first two years of the scheme’s operation. That cost subsequently amounted to £159 million in 2006-07 and £163 million in 2007-08. However, information on the administrative costs and the costs of introducing the supporting technology—particularly the electronic ticket machines on the buses—was not available, and the scheme’s likely long-term costs were not projected.When the scheme started, basic management information was in place to allow the scheme to get up and running, but robust systems were not in place to validate bus company claims and the supporting ticket machines were not installed. The machines are important because they help to avoid error and fraud. They scan each bus pass, record details of the journey and send the information to Transport Scotland to be used in calculating reimbursement. We found that implementation of the machines is still not complete.It is fair to say that no system is completely error and fraud proof. Even with the ticket machines, some risk remains of the issuing of tickets for destinations that are further than passengers are travelling and of the false use of bus passes.12:00

The full implementation of the technology is expected to take four and a half years longer than originally planned and likely to cost more than four times the original budget—£42 million as compared with the original budget of £9 million, with additional running costs of around £3 million a year.I have a sense of déjà vu because of your earlier discussion on the SPSA about ICT but, in this case, the considerable delays in introducing the technology were due to a number of factors, including the fact that the technology had never been used before and is still evolving; weak contracting arrangements, which we outline in the report; and Transport Scotland’s lack of staff with the necessary skills. That left the scheme potentially more vulnerable to error and fraud at its introduction but, within 18 months, Transport Scotland had strengthened the governance arrangements and put in place more robust systems for checking and validating bus company claims. It is not known how much money has been claimed fraudulently or in error, although Transport Scotland is now developing a model to quantify the value of inaccurate claims.On the impact of the scheme, we all know that it is widely used—over a million travel passes are in circulation and around 80 per cent of people aged over 60 have a pass. Eligibility is standardised and it offers increased access to free bus travel for older people and for some people with disabilities. However, research that was commissioned by Transport Scotland found that the scheme has had limited impact on improving social inclusion and health or promoting a shift from car to bus. The Scottish Government’s review in 2009 said that there was insufficient evidence that the scheme is achieving more than the previous local schemes. In relation to its success in benefiting specific sections of the community, there is some unexplained variation in the take-up of disabled concessionary travel passes across council areas and there are some people who, although eligible for the scheme, cannot benefit from it because they cannot physically access a bus or there is no bus in their area.Costs in real terms have increased from almost £173 million in 2006-07 to just over £199 million in 2009-10 and are expected to continue to increase, although it is not possible to predict exactly what future costs will be. However, we tried to project some of those costs, as exhibit 7 on page 17 of the report indicates. The projections that we used are based on the estimated growth in the 60-plus population, different assumptions about fare increases and an assumption that current use will remain constant. They show that the uncapped costs of the scheme could reach between £216 million and £537 million a year by 2025. The independent budget review did a similar projection and came up with slightly higher costs than ours, which shows how difficult it is to project in this area.The cost of concessionary bus travel has increased at a faster rate than the number of concessionary bus journeys recorded. The reasons are not understood fully but are likely to include increases in bus fares, a more generous reimbursement rate paid to bus companies than under previous schemes and the inclusion of longer-distance national travel. Following an independent review, the Government has reduced the reimbursement rate from 73.6 to 67 per cent of the adult single fare with effect from April this year. However, the bus industry does not believe that the reduced rate adequately covers the costs of carrying concessionary passengers and believes that some routes or services might have to be cut as a result. We are already beginning to see some routes being cut, but we cannot say that it is necessarily attributable to the concessionary travel scheme. When we were doing the report, it was too early for us to assess what the impact of that reduction will be.Overall, the report highlights a number of issues that are not necessarily unique to the scheme and which we have seen before in different schemes. They include the adequacy of the financial forecasting; the use of consultants in implementation; and increases in time and cost budgets for major information technology projects of the type used here. As ever, we are happy to answer the committee’s questions.

The Convener Hugh Henry
link

Thank you. It is fair to say that the national concessionary travel scheme is popular but expensive, so it is right to ask whether we are achieving value for money spent. I will ask three questions about what you touched on. You mentioned a take-up rate of around 80 per cent. Do we know who the 20 per cent are?

Barbara Hurst Audit Scotland
link

I do not think that we do, no.

Graeme Greenhill Audit Scotland
link

No.

The Convener Hugh Henry
link

We do not know whether it is made up of people from lower socioeconomic groups, or people who have disabilities. We have no idea who they are.

Graeme Greenhill Audit Scotland
link

The evaluation that Transport Scotland carried out in 2009 concluded that take-up and usage are higher among those in less well-off areas but that the rate of take-up since the scheme’s introduction has been higher among the more affluent and those in employment.

The Convener Hugh Henry
link

That is useful to know.Are there any costings for how much we are spending on some of the longer, national routes? For example, in Renfrewshire during the summer months, buses run to various points in Argyll and the Trossachs, and there is also the Glasgow to Edinburgh route. Do we know how much the longer and more popular tourist-type services cost?

Graeme Greenhill Audit Scotland
link

We do not have that information. Could we get it from Transport Scotland?

Sally Thompson Audit Scotland
link

Transport Scotland’s information would provide us with the amount that each bus company is paid. For example, we could find out how much Scottish Citylink is reimbursed for its services. The reimbursement is standard proportion of the adult single fare so, if that is £10, it costs an awful lot more to the public purse than if it is £1.

The Convener Hugh Henry
link

It would be interesting to know whether more people are travelling free on those expensive routes. I do not know whether £10 is the cost of a return fare between Glasgow and Edinburgh, but the nominal cost of a trip to Argyll is somewhere between £12 and £15. That type of trip could eat up a substantial part of the budget, and it would be useful to know whether the number of such trips is disproportionately high compared with the relatively short routes that people need to travel for whatever reason.You mentioned ticketing. I have written to ministers about people in Paisley, for example, taking a relatively short journey but being issued with a ticket for Glasgow. Does that result in a higher return to the bus company?

Barbara Hurst Audit Scotland
link

Yes, it does, if there is a differential pricing structure, because the bus company is reimbursed with a percentage of the ticket price.

The Convener Hugh Henry
link

There seems to be a significant amount of concern in my area, and probably in other members’ areas, that the tickets showed an overestimation of the journey that was travelled. People are worried that that would result in higher payments than would be legitimate.

Graeme Greenhill Audit Scotland
link

As Barbara Hurst said earlier, no scheme is foolproof. The electronic ticketing machine system still requires some manual intervention. When a person gets on the bus, they put their concessionary card on the reader, but they still rely on the bus driver to ask the person how far they are going to travel and to press the correct button. There is anecdotal evidence that that does not happen every time, for whatever reason.

George Foulkes
link

I had better declare my interest, and I am not disabled.The report states:“recent research shows that NCT has had only limited impact on improving social inclusion, improving health or promoting a shift from car to bus.”Was that research carried out by Transport Scotland?

Barbara Hurst Audit Scotland
link

By the Scottish Government, yes.

George Foulkes
link

Who did it for the Scottish Government?

Barbara Hurst Audit Scotland
link

Do we know who did it?

Sally Thompson Audit Scotland
link

Halcrow.

George Foulkes
link

Who is Halcrow?

Graeme Greenhill Audit Scotland
link

I think that it is a general transport consultant.

George Foulkes
link

On what basis did it produce the report? It reached a definitive and, I think, totally contestable conclusion, given my experience and the experience of Age Scotland and many other organisations, which have evidence to show that more and more people are getting out of their houses and we are having to spend less on social care, home helps and everything else because people are getting out and about. Who carried out the research? Halcrow is a transport consultant; it knows nothing about social care, does it?

Sally Thompson Audit Scotland
link

The methodology that Halcrow used was to take information from the Scottish household surveys, which includes travel diaries. It compared bus use before and after the scheme was introduced. It ran quite a lot of focus groups and carried out quite a lot of surveys of users and non-users to see the differences in their use of the scheme in order to form judgments.

George Foulkes
link

I would like to see some of that evidence if possible, because the conclusions go against all the information that I have. I used to be director of Age Concern Scotland and we campaigned for a long time to get a national bus scheme on the basis that it allows people who would otherwise be housebound to get out and about.I would contest another point. You said that the routes are being cut as a result of the scheme. The opposite is the case. Routes are now viable because people who get concessionary bus travel are using them—the companies get money in from the local authorities. If routes relied on fare-paying passengers, they would be cut,

because they would not be viable. I find all this really disappointing.

Mr Black
link

It might be helpful to bear in mind that what the evaluation was doing—I am sure that the team will correct me if I am wrong—was considering the added benefit that came from the national scheme compared with the schemes that were operated by local authorities beforehand. As our report summarises, some people who were eligible under the local schemes are no longer eligible now, so it is a mixed picture. It seems to me that a key question is what extra benefit in terms of quality of life has been introduced by the scheme.

George Foulkes
link

I would like to know a bit more about the survey. One of the good things that the Scottish National Party Government has done—I will praise it for a change—is that Stewart Stevenson has said under pressure that he will maintain the scheme, not reduce it, and keep the criteria as they are at present. In the Audit Scotland report, you have almost a manifesto for cutting the scheme and reducing it. This is the first time that I have found an Audit Scotland report deeply disappointing.

Mr Black
link

I will respond to that very strongly. Under no circumstances whatever will I or anyone in Audit Scotland advocate a policy in this Parliament. The moment we do that, our credibility is undermined. There will be occasions when the findings of our reports might not entirely accord with the personal policy preferences of parties or members of the committee, and I fully respect that, but the evidence will have been prepared robustly. We cannot authorise or validate the Transport Scotland-Halcrow report, but it seems reasonable to refer to it in our report to you.

The Convener Hugh Henry
link

It would be helpful if you could provide whatever information you have available.

Jamie Hepburn
link

I thank Ms Hurst for her evidence and for kindly welcoming me to the committee. I am finding this very interesting although, like George Foulkes, I find the report disappointing. That is not because I think that it is evangelical in any sense but because some of the findings are a little worrying. I want to explore paragraphs 24 to 31 in the report.Paragraph 27 describes how the bus companies have been permitted to calculate their claims for reimbursement under the scheme. I see that two approaches were survey based and one was more accurate, in the sense that it is based on ticket sales—notwithstanding the concerns that we have already explored about the accuracy of that. I find it very interesting that, given that that option was available, it was not insisted on across the board. I know that this is a policy question to some extent, but should the ETM installation have been a prerequisite to taking part in the scheme in the first place? Would it have been a more robust system in Audit Scotland’s opinion?12:15

Barbara Hurst Audit Scotland
link

It certainly would in the sense that ETM technology would have provided more reliable information to Transport Scotland but, as we show in the report, it has taken a long time to get the ETM system up and running and, in its absence, different systems were put in place. It is clear that some of them look less than robust, particularly if a bus company can choose the routes that it surveys.

Jamie Hepburn
link

You say that ETM technology has taken time to set up, but the report states that some bus companies “had ETMs installed or its own ticketing equipment allowed it to determine the number of concessionary travellers for each fare stage.”The bus companies are making money out of concessionary travel—they are being paid a public subsidy. If they wanted to take part, could they not have got on with it? Some companies were able to use the technology; why could they not all do that?

Graeme Greenhill Audit Scotland
link

As the report says, it has taken time to roll out the technology. A decision was taken to introduce the scheme in 2006. If bus companies had been able to enter that scheme only if they had the technology in place, large parts of the country might not have been able to participate.

Jamie Hepburn
link

Arguably, would the companies not have had an incentive to get a move on if they wanted to take part in the scheme? I will take that lack of response as a maybe.I am concerned by something else. I see that there is a range of ETM equipment. That is not a concern per se, but it is up to the bus companies to decide which ETM supplier to use. Is there a range in cost of the machines, or is it a standard cost?

Graeme Greenhill Audit Scotland
link

There is a range of costs. It depends on how much additional technology the bus company wants to install. Transport Scotland meets the cost of the basic machinery, but the additional cost—

Jamie Hepburn
link

I suppose that my question should have been whether the cost to Transport Scotland is standard?

Graeme Greenhill Audit Scotland
link

Yes.

Jamie Hepburn
link

That alleviates my concerns a little. Do you believe that the complete roll-out of the ETMs will affect the global cost of the scheme in either direction? Will it increase or reduce the cost?

Barbara Hurst Audit Scotland
link

I think that the roll-out is almost complete, so I think that the costs that we cited will be in place. There will be additional running costs, but it is unlikely that there will be a significant extra cost now.

Jamie Hepburn
link

Sorry—I meant the cost of claims for journeys.

Graeme Greenhill Audit Scotland
link

I think that it would be very difficult to say that with any certainty. Now that ETMs are in place, we would expect the scope and potential for fraud and error to be reduced, but it is difficult to say whether that will be overtaken by the increase in the number of older people who qualify for bus passes.

Jamie Hepburn
link

Maybe not cost in terms of numbers of journeys or where the journeys are.

Graeme Greenhill Audit Scotland
link

I think that the same answer applies.

Jamie Hepburn
link

I presume that cost is something that Audit Scotland will keep an eye on and report back on in future.I will move on to the issue of fraudulent claims. Paragraph 31 of the report states:“Transport Scotland pursues instances of suspected fraud and, in 2009/10, claims of four bus companies were under investigation”.What was the total value of what was being fraudulently claimed—or suspected of being fraudulently claimed?

Sally Thompson Audit Scotland
link

We have that information. I am trying to find the piece of paper.

Jamie Hepburn
link

I could maybe ask another question while you look for that. The report also states that two companies were charged. Can I ask what that means? By whom were they charged—Transport Scotland? I see that Transport Scotland also has powers to report directly to the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service. Have the companies been charged by the procurator fiscal?

Barbara Hurst Audit Scotland
link

Yes, under the formal fraud system.

Jamie Hepburn
link

It is reassuring that the sanction that exists has actually been used.

Sally Thompson Audit Scotland
link

Could I provide the information that you asked for in private? I ask that only because some of the information that we were given concerned on-going fraud cases and was not for wider consumption.

Jamie Hepburn
link

I presume that that would be okay.It is right to say that no system is foolproof, and that applies to the ETM system as well. How significant are the concerns that fraudulent activity will continue? How will the situation be monitored? Will claims be monitored in the same way as they are at the moment? Is that robust enough?

Barbara Hurst Audit Scotland
link

Once the electronic ticket machine is in place, some of the risk is removed, as the claims go straight to Transport Scotland. There will still be a risk around the issue of tickets being issued for a distance that is further than the distance that is travelled, but if people notice that and report instances to Transport Scotland, Transport Scotland can look for a pattern and conduct an investigation. Transport Scotland does not rely only on the ticketing machines; it is doing other work alongside that and has improved its fraud management system significantly.

Jamie Hepburn
link

It will always rely on intelligence that is gathered on the ground, as it were. How many fraud investigations have arisen from circumstances in which there has been a pattern of people buying tickets and saying, “Hang on, this isn’t what I asked for?”

Graeme Greenhill Audit Scotland
link

We do not have that information. Transport Scotland might be better placed to provide it.

Willie Coffey
link

Many constituents have shown me tickets for destinations that are far beyond the stop that they wanted to get off the bus at. Nothing in the Auditor General’s report gives me any comfort that this new IT system, which was initially set to cost £9 million and now costs £42 million and is four years late, is going to do anything to sort that. It is extremely concerning for the Auditor General to report that there is a major risk of money being fraudulently claimed and that we do not know the extent of that. That is the most serious message in the report. This is almost like a rerun of the discussion that we had under the previous agenda item, about the importance of defining these types of projects at an early stage, and the problems that arise when that is not done. That is particularly important in projects that have a high reliance on IT and other support services. If we are going to spend £42 million on a ticketing system, we have to ensure, fundamentally, that the tickets reflect the journey that was made by the customer. It is ridiculous that we are in a situation in which that problem has been embedded for such a long time.I look to the Auditor General and his staff to suggest ways in which we can make progress on this issue. Should we bring someone in to talk to us about the IT system that is about to be unleashed on us?

The Convener Hugh Henry
link

We can discuss that later on, when we discuss how we want to take things forward.

Barbara Hurst Audit Scotland
link

The machines are important. However, Transport Scotland is doing other work, which means that it does not rely only on those machines. Transport Scotland is much more rigorous about the investigation of these matters than it was a few years ago. Exhibit 4 on page 11 of the report shows you the sort of things that it has put in place.

Willie Coffey
link

There is nothing rigorous about having a reporting system that relies on wee pensioners coming into my office to tell me that they think that they have been overcharged. The fact that a system that is costing us £42 million cannot spot that sort of problem is a serious matter. Some of the £42 million should be invested in monitoring that problem. I hope that we can pursue that, convener.

The Convener Hugh Henry
link

I have had exactly the same experience with my constituents as Willie Coffey has had with his. The interesting thing is that many of the users value the system, know that it is expensive and do not want it to be withdrawn. We need to come back to this issue, and we will do so.

Anne McLaughlin
link

I agree that a range of fraud management systems needs to be in place. Senior citizens do not like being diddled out of money—even when, as in this case, they are not the ones who are handing over the extra money personally. If it does not do so already, Transport Scotland could print a freephone number on the card with a message that says, “If you experience overcharging, phone us.” The senior citizens would definitely do so. I agree with Willie Coffey that it is important that we have the technology to monitor that situation.Jamie Hepburn has, again, covered most of what I wanted to say—I will have to get in ahead of him in future—but I want to talk a bit more about the ETM technology. I was astonished to read that, a year after the budget for the technology was set at £9 million, it was discovered that that was an unrealistic figure because it was not enough to buy an ETM for every bus in Scotland or cover the back-up costs, and that, in August 2010, Transport Scotland said that the cost would be £42 million. However, what really surprised me was that, according to the report, “it is not clear how”the original budget“was calculated or what cost factors were included”.Is it acceptable for a department to simply pluck a figure out of the air, give no explanation of how it arrived at it and submit it as the budget?

Barbara Hurst Audit Scotland
link

When we asked for some of the back-up information, it was not available. It had been lost in transit, as it were, between the central department and Transport Scotland when the responsibility for the scheme was transferred to Transport Scotland. We were unable to consider any audit evidence that would enable us to examine how the early work was done.

Graeme Greenhill Audit Scotland
link

The information was simply not available because of staff turnover and other reasons that we could not identify.

Anne McLaughlin
link

George Foulkes talked about the research that was done. I, too, was taken aback to read that“recent research shows that NCT has had only limited impact on improving social inclusion, improving health or promoting a shift from car to bus.”I do not believe that, and I would like to see that research. I suspect that what it shows is that the fact that the scheme is national is not making a huge difference from having regional schemes. I do not think that it will show that concessionary bus travel has no impact. I really cannot believe that. I would be interested to find out the reasons for that conclusion being drawn. First is running a pilot scheme to give half-price bus fares to job seekers in a specific area of Glasgow. If that works, the scheme will be rolled out across Glasgow and, hopefully, beyond. I want such concessionary travel schemes to have an impact on social inclusion, so I would be interested to see the research that the report refers to. Is there an indication of whether the research is saying that it is the changeover that is making little difference or concessionary travel itself?

Barbara Hurst Audit Scotland
link

To a degree, it depends on the question that was asked at the beginning of the research. The question, “Does this scheme make much of a difference when compared with the previous schemes?” is different from the question, “Does concessionary travel make a difference to you?”I am beginning to regret our decision not to conduct our own survey. Often, we survey users in situations such as this one, but we knew that relevant research was just sitting there. Perhaps we should have conducted our own survey, as that would have been an interesting additional piece of research. I am sorry that we did not do that, but we can make the details of the research that we used available to the committee.

Anne McLaughlin
link

That would be helpful.

The Convener Hugh Henry
link

This situation raises a question about whether those in Transport Scotland who commissioned the research were robust enough in ensuring that the right questions were being asked. I have no doubt that the research was expensive. It makes you wonder about money being dished out for surveys without any proper thought being given to what questions are being asked, what information is being sought and what the value of it is. I suspect that, when the committee considers this matter in private, we will decide to question Transport Scotland. It will not be the first time that we will have done so in relation to worries about finance.I thank our witnesses for attending. Item 6, to which we now come, is in private.12:30 Meeting continued in private until 12:41.

  1. 09:30 Interests Procedure · 3
  2. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  3. 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 74
  4. 09:30 Section 23 Reports Evidence session · 115
  5. 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 67

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.