Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

“The Scottish Police Services Authority”

Wednesday 10 November 2010 Public Audit Committee About 09:30 Committee business 74 contributions · 13 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

74 contributions
The Deputy Convener
link

Item 3 is a briefing from Audit Scotland on its section 23 report on the Scottish Police Services Authority. I invite the Auditor General to introduce the report.

Mr Robert Black Auditor General for Scotland
link

Good morning, convener. The report, which came out towards the end of October, looks at the development of the Scottish Police Services Authority, its achievements to date and some of the future challenges that it faces.The SPSA was established on 1 April 2007 to provide support services to the police and the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service. The SPSA provides the police with forensics training, criminal justice information systems and information and communication technology services—if you do not mind, I will shorten that to ICT. The Procurator Fiscal Service uses the SPSA’s forensic services and, because many of its systems are linked to police systems, it is also affected by the SPSA’s criminal justice and ICT work.The organisation faced a number of quite serious difficulties in the early days and I suggest that lessons can be learned from the experience when shared services are planned in the future. The report includes at appendix 2 a checklist of questions that organisations should ask themselves when they develop shared services. The SPSA was established with two main purposes. The first was to improve the efficiency and effectiveness of support services for Scottish policing, and the second was to provide more formal governance arrangements for some police services that were already centralised, such as training. In the years before the SPSA was established, there was widespread support for the principle that a single organisation should provide police support services. However, the audit found that it was not clear from the outset how the SPSA was to operate and deliver long-term benefits. That led to different understandings between the SPSA and its customers about what it would do. That difficult start was compounded by the lack of information that was available to the SPSA on the services that it was to deliver. There were also complex service demands and lines of accountability, which are described in exhibit 10 on page 28 of the report. The SPSA had leadership problems, and sometimes difficult relationships with its customers.The sponsor department of the SPSA provided support, but it did not fully recognise all the difficulties that faced the SPSA during its first 18 months. The Scottish Government reviewed its sponsorship arrangements for the SPSA in 2008, and the report that came out of that concluded that the Scottish Government could improve its overall governance by strengthening and formalising meetings and by monitoring progress against the SPSA’s strategic priorities.I will comment on the SPSA’s performance. Despite early challenges and difficulties, the SPSA has improved the service that it provides in relation to criminal justice training and forensic services. For example, it has delivered new training courses at the Scottish Police College, it has reduced the time taken to analyse forensic samples, and it has developed new processes that can make savings for the SPSA and other criminal justice bodies. Exhibit 3 in the key messages report gives a summary of some of the improvements that have been delivered.However, the audit found that supporting and developing ICT systems has been much more difficult, and the SPSA is not yet able to meet its customers’ needs. The difficulties arise for a number of reasons. First, the ICT functions transferred to the SPSA a year later than the other services, so there has not been quite so much time to make changes. Secondly, providing ICT services was made more complex because different forces had different ICT resources and systems, and very different future ICT needs. To give the committee an idea of the scale and complexity of the ICT challenge, the report shows that there are 1,400 applications and 750 different contracts across the eight forces. Finally, demand for ICT support from the forces is increasing. For example, the SPSA now maintains around 2,700 more printers, scanners and monitors for the police than it did in 2008.The SPSA has delivered some improvements in ICT. For example, it helped Strathclyde Police to save £1 million on ICT contracts, and it has established a national ICT helpdesk service, which deals with 3,000 requests a week. However, the SPSA has had problems with prioritising between the increasing number of national and force-specific services that need its input. The SPSA’s difficulty in meeting its customers’ ICT needs is beginning to affect forces’ and the Crown Office’s programmes for increasing efficiency. The audit highlights the need for an effective mechanism to limit levels of demand and to agree criteria that will enable the SPSA to prioritise all the requests for help that it receives. The Scottish Government and the Scottish policing board have a role to play in ensuring that the SPSA is given a clear set of priorities to which to work within the resources that it has available to it.Since 2007, the SPSA has reported efficiency savings of more than £5 million, which is in line with the targets that were set for it. It could deliver greater savings for police forces and other criminal justice partners, but it cannot do that on its own. My report recommends that the Scottish Government and criminal justice bodies need to work together to develop systems to measure performance and efficiency savings across the whole sector.There are significant challenges ahead, and in my report I recommend that the SPSA acts quickly to improve communications with its customers; to align its budget with organisational priorities and develop programmes that can be delivered within whatever budget it is given; to ensure that it develops a workforce that has the skills to deliver those priorities; and to get better financial and performance information across all its service areas, so that it can develop and deliver a long-term and sustainable efficiencies programme.As ever, convener, my colleagues are masters of the detail. We will answer whatever questions the committee has for us.

The Deputy Convener
link

Thank you very much for that comprehensive summary. This is a timely report, particularly given the political discussion that is taking place about the potential merger of all the police forces in Scotland, which seems now to be promoted by various parties that might form the next Government. Lessons can be learnt from the setting up of the SPSA, which will be important if we are going to pursue the objective of unifying Scotland’s police forces.One of the things that struck me about the report—I refer to paragraph 20—was the challenge of setting up new working practices while there was local concern that autonomy would be undermined. That will be one of the challenges that we will face if we go down the road of unifying the different police forces.The management structure is summarised in exhibit 5 on page 13 of the main report, which shows all the changes in personnel since 2007. When I looked at that, I thought that it was an extremely confused picture, and I wondered how effective the organisation could be when there were so many senior management changes in that period.We seem to have a huge problem across the public sector in dealing with ICT and trying to find systems that are compatible. I noticed that, in paragraphs 32 to 34 of the report, concerns are raised about ICT and the fact that the new financial system was not compatible with the systems used by forces, which seems a strange omission. What work is being done to try to bring all that into line? It seems to be an area that will cause more problems if it is not resolved.

Mr Black
link

I can respond to the narrow but significant point about the lack of compatibility. The SPSA was obliged to adopt SEAS—the Scottish Executive accounting system. We have reported in the past on the problems that exist with that system, which is not really compatible with any of the systems that other public sector bodies use. That is at the core of it. I am sure that colleagues can give you more information about what is happening out there.

Miranda Alcock Audit Scotland
link

The problems with ICT have been recognised for quite some time. As we say in the report, the Government, the SPSA and the Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland commissioned a review that identified many of the same problems that we identified in the report. There is certainly a move to try to converge some of the systems, but some of the difficulties that we outline about getting agreement between the eight forces, the Scottish Government and ACPOS remain a barrier to progress in this area.

The Deputy Convener
link

That does not sound very optimistic.

Mr Black
link

It is difficult for us to comment in detail. The review was of the SPSA, but I was struck by the sheer complexity and diversity of ICT systems currently running in Scotland’s eight police forces, bearing in mind that we are a relatively small country with a population of 5 million people. Some diversity is understandable, but the sheer complexity of the system is quite surprising.

The Deputy Convener
link

Thank you for that. I am sure that we can pursue the matter.

Jamie Hepburn
link

Thank you, Mr Black, for your comprehensive presentation. It is clear from the report that there is a bit of a mixed bag. It identifies some achievements and some challenges ahead. One of the identified achievements is that the target for savings was hit—I believe that £5.3 million has been saved in three years. You suggest that there is potential for more savings to be made, particularly in relation to ICT applications across the police forces if a standard set of applications was used. Are there other examples of savings that could be made?09:45

Mr Black
link

The team might be able to help with that. To set the context, I point out that, on page 8 of the report, the section that describes how the initial budget was set states that the audit found that the “initial budget was based on incomplete information.” The SPSA believes that some of the funding was insufficient, particularly for forensic services. That added to the complexity of the challenge that the SPSA faced as a new organisation when it was first set up. That perhaps reinforces why it is so important that the SPSA’s clients work together with the authority to determine the priorities and fit them within the available budget. However, despite the problems, the SPSA has still reported efficiency savings of about £5 million.

Angela Cullen Audit Scotland
link

The report states that there is potential to deliver additional savings across the criminal justice sector if the SPSA works together with partner bodies. One example that we give is the SPSA’s implementation of crime scene animation, which we estimate has the potential to save about £9,000 a day when a case goes to trial. There are real savings to be made and rolled out across the criminal justice sector, but systems are not in place to measure savings by the other bodies involved. There is potential to deliver more savings, but those savings need to be measured together, and the bodies need to work together to deliver them. Currently, savings targets are set for individual bodies rather than for the whole sector, so incentives do not necessarily exist for the SPSA to work with other bodies to deliver larger and more widespread savings, although the incentives existed to deliver the £5.3 million of savings that it has delivered.

Jamie Hepburn
link

You say that there is potential to save £9,000 a day through something. I have forgotten the term that you used, although you said it only two seconds ago.

Angela Cullen Audit Scotland
link

It was the use of crime scene animation.

Jamie Hepburn
link

Crime scene animation—very impressive. You say that systems are not in place to measure global savings, so you cannot give a more specific, global figure for what £9,000 a day might add up to over a year.

Angela Cullen Audit Scotland
link

No, we cannot. The systems are not in place for that. We have estimated that the technology might save around £9,000 a day. Obviously, we would need to consider individual cases to see how many days a trial might have taken and by how many days the trial was reduced as a result of using the new animation software. It might be one day per case, or it might be 20 days per case. We have not gone that far and looked at the evidence.

Willie Coffey Kilmarnock and Loudoun) (SNP
link

I return to the ICT issues. I draw members’ attention to exhibit 7 on page 19 of the main report, the third paragraph of which discusses Strathclyde Police’s intention to replace its crime management system. The replacement was identified as being required in 2004, but it seems to have been acknowledged five years later that the SPSA—or someone else—did not have the appropriate skills and experience to deliver the solution that was drawn up five years previously. I find it particularly astonishing that such a thing could happen. That is not about integration, crossing over and merging; as I understand the Auditor General’s report, it is about having the fundamental skills to use an operational piece of software. Do you have any more information on what has caused that situation? Is there any confidence that the solution is being found and that the skills are being identified?

Miranda Alcock Audit Scotland
link

The SPSA was formed in the middle of the negotiations on the Strathclyde crime management system. We did not look at that example in detail—we just looked at the issue since the SPSA was formed. The SPSA inherited an ambitious project to roll out something that would converge all the systems in the eight forces in Scotland. That was an overambitious project at the time, and when the SPSA took it on, it realised fairly quickly that it did not have sufficient skills and capability to deliver it, so it had to go back and consider what could be delivered with the resources and capability that were available. You would need to discuss the details of that with Strathclyde Police and ACPOS.

Willie Coffey Kilmarnock and Loudoun) (SNP
link

Does the issue relate to the skills of police in the field using equipment and software or to those of IT staff and their ability to integrate systems?

Miranda Alcock Audit Scotland
link

It involves development skills. The crime management system is a centralised system and the issue has nothing to do with the skills of officers on the street; rather, it is to do with ICT development. ACPOS’s business change programme was quite an ambitious attempt to build systems for the whole of Scotland. However, I think that it would admit that that was overambitious.

Willie Coffey Kilmarnock and Loudoun) (SNP
link

That sounds like something that we will probably follow up.The SPSA is able to access criminal history databases in relation to forensics and, I assume, other related issues for external agencies—that is mentioned in the chart on page 17 of the main report. Can other bodies in Scotland access those systems? I remember discussion about the national health service, for example, being unaware of the criminal histories of some people who had come to Scotland to work. Does the system allow access to such information?Is there an international dimension? Is there an international criminal history database that forces in Scotland, Europe and elsewhere can use to track the movements of criminals throughout the world?

Miranda Alcock Audit Scotland
link

They are two different things. Your question stretches my knowledge of police ICT somewhat but, as I understand it, the police national computer, which is a United Kingdom database, links to European databases. That is different from the Scottish criminal history system, which concerns only offenders in the Scottish criminal justice system. It is accessible to agencies such as social work departments. I am not sure whether it is accessible to the NHS. I know that there are some multiagency initiatives under which, in some areas, NHS officials have access to the criminal history system.

Willie Coffey Kilmarnock and Loudoun) (SNP
link

It is always of interest to this committee to ask broader questions of that nature. Sometimes, the work of the Auditor General for Scotland points us in a direction that we might wish to pursue. If we have a solution in Scotland that would allow us to monitor and track these activities, we would be as well considering opening that out and sharing the information in a broader context, if at all possible.

Anne McLaughlin Glasgow) (SNP
link

It is good that the SPSA has achieved its efficiency savings. However, paragraph 36 of the key messages report says:“Like many other public sector bodies, SPSA does not have baseline information on the quality of the services prior to 2007 and their costs. This means it is not possible to measure whether the savings reported have affected service quality or productivity.”My interpretation of that is that it is not possible to measure whether the changes are efficiency savings rather than just cuts to the service. You can correct me if I am wrong.I am interested in why the SPSA does not have baseline information on the quality of the service prior to 2007 and also in how widespread that is. The paragraph says that the situation is common to many public sector bodies, but how many are we talking about and why is that the case?

Angela Cullen Audit Scotland
link

I will kick off; Miranda Alcock and Andra Laird can correct me if I am wrong and help me out. When the SPSA was set up in 2007, not a lot of information was transferred to it. We highlight that as being one of the issues that caused difficulties in the early days. The information that transferred from the police forces was not sufficient for the SPSA to identify what the demand for its services would be. Therefore, the basic information on cost, quality and activity was not there prior to 2007. A lot of work has been done since then to establish much better information to enable the SPSA to run its business, and we used that information in drawing our conclusions in part 2 of our report about the improvements.Real efficiency savings have been achieved through various routes, including staff vacancies, improved procurement, changes to working practices, reduced costs, renegotiating contracts and better facilities management. We are not saying that the efficiency savings are not robust; although we have not undertaken a detailed review of them, the examples that have been put forward suggest that they are reasonable.

Anne McLaughlin Glasgow) (SNP
link

I understand your comment about the transfer of information and realise that we are considering this particular report, but is the reference to“many other public sector bodies”in paragraph 38 meant to suggest that the lack of information on which to base assertions of efficiency savings is widespread in the public sector?

Angela Cullen Audit Scotland
link

One of the main findings in the report that we produced in February on improving efficiency across the public sector was that there was insufficient information in the public sector to record the efficiency savings that were being made and therefore it was very difficult for us to validate them.

Anne McLaughlin Glasgow) (SNP
link

You have already referred to this, but paragraph 40 of the key messages report says:“The Scottish Government has traditionally set efficiency targets for individual organisations rather than for the criminal justice sector as a whole.”Is that widespread? Are individual bodies making their own efficiency savings instead of being motivated to work with similar bodies to create savings across the sector?

Angela Cullen Audit Scotland
link

In our experience, the tendency is to set individual efficiency targets. At the moment, the target in the efficient government programme is 2 per cent. However, local government pulls together, sets efficiency savings for the sector and determines with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities how they will be achieved.The Government’s efficient government programme has three workstreams—better procurement, shared services and asset management—that promote working across the public sector. I am trying to remember the figures, but I believe that the last efficiency outturn report, which was published last month, shows that, although the reported savings from those three workstreams are improving, a lot more can be done in that respect.

Nicol Stephen Aberdeen South) (LD
link

I have two quite general questions about the ICT section of the report. First, is ICT, not only in the Scottish Police Services Authority but in the other public service organisations that Audit Scotland deals with, particularly special or different, or does it simply require a rigour, a discipline, a professionalism and a clarity that are also absent from other parts of public service organisations? In other words, is it the case that other parts of organisations have the same weaknesses but the very nature of ICT, which needs to be got right if things are not to start creaking, means that such weaknesses cannot be hidden?

Mr Black
link

I will give a general response and then invite the team to come in.I must put on record the fact that we have not audited police ICT systems, but what we have seen in the police highlights the need for really effective strategic commissioning of such services. Doing ICT well is always a challenge in the public sector, but the fact that, throughout the police’s history, systems have generally been procured by individual police forces to meet their own needs has contributed to this huge diversity. Certainly, one has to ask how efficient such an approach is. Despite the difficulties that it experienced when it was set up, the SPSA’s early experience confirms that a strategic, shared-services approach across the whole of Scotland has the potential to deliver significant efficiencies linked to quality improvements.10:00

Miranda Alcock Audit Scotland
link

We do not have much to add. The advent of the Scottish policing board is a welcome sign that the police are starting to pull together the strategic approach to which the Auditor General refers.

Nicol Stephen Aberdeen South) (LD
link

My second question is linked to the wider issue of other reorganisations such as the creation of Transport Scotland and Creative Scotland and the big changes that have been made in the enterprise networks. There is no doubt that, in the current public sector spending climate, more reorganisations and significant change lie ahead. Is Audit Scotland planning any work to learn lessons from the various reports that it has done and the various changes that have taken place in the Scottish Government over the past decade and to suggest an approach that will avoid some of the fundamental mistakes that appear to be made every time the Scottish Government or the public sector in Scotland engages in restructuring and reorganisation?

Mr Black
link

From the work and knowledge that we have built up over the years, which culminates in this report, we have been able to put together a series of questions that the Scottish Government and public bodies should consider when they are planning shared-services initiatives. Those questions appear in appendix 2 on page 31 of the report. I read them again last night and thought that I would find them really useful if I were in any part of government and were thinking about a shared-services project. It is extremely important that people ask those questions and satisfy themselves that they have answers before they embark on such programmes.One of the many interesting features of the exercise to create the SPSA is that, right at the beginning, the sponsor identified the things that needed to happen to introduce such a body. However, the necessary arrangements were not put in place well, so the organisation hit some challenges. That meant not only that the process was challenging for the organisation but that its capacity was built up and the necessary efficiencies began to be delivered more slowly than might otherwise have been possible. Appendix 2 captures our best thoughts to date on the questions that people need to take into account when planning shared services.

Nicol Stephen Aberdeen South) (LD
link

Could audit either within the organisation or involving Audit Scotland be part of the process of establishing a new structure or organisation? Is that preferable to auditing the process a couple of years after everything has been done wrong? I am not saying that everything was done wrong in this case, but a lot was. Is there a way of forcing people to take the excellent approach that is set out in appendix 2?

Mr Black
link

That is a perfectly reasonable and understandable question. The problem is the limits of our resources to be involved in such projects. As Mr Stephen knows, sometimes I must take the fallback position that audit is independent of the management of public services. If we do not maintain that independence, we cannot do work such as this report, which has integrity because of its independence.We must balance carefully the extent to which we become involved in an advisory and support role with the need to maintain our independence. Fundamentally, it is for managers to manage their services and service development. We can assist by providing guidance in the form that we have set out. In the work that we do, we make available a great deal of guidance that is below the committee’s radar screen.

Nicol Stephen Aberdeen South) (LD
link

I understand that. Advice and support are valuable. Essentially, you are saying that some form of internal audit would be possible, that that might require the permanent secretary or another senior figure in the Scottish Government to say that change is required to prevent mistakes from continuing to happen, and that organisations should adopt the sort of approach that Audit Scotland recommends in the report.

Mr Black
link

Systems that have been introduced for the management of capital programmes over the past number of years allow for what used to be called gateway reviews when a project reaches a critical stage. I would strongly advocate that, in significant, complex projects, such as major shared-services projects, there should be the equivalent of gateway reviews at key points; there should be an independent check, addressing the sort of questions that I have outlined, to establish how the project is going before it is committed.

Nicol Stephen Aberdeen South) (LD
link

Thanks. That is helpful.

The Deputy Convener
link

We might want to follow up these questions with the Scottish Government.

Willie Coffey Kilmarnock and Loudoun) (SNP
link

Such a message is a common one at the Public Audit Committee. When we look back at the origins of a particular piece of work, we often discover that there was not sufficient or early enough planning in a number of areas. That has been a common theme throughout the committee’s work for a number of years. Although I would be delighted if Audit Scotland stepped in to assist, there are established management processes and systems across the business community and the public sector that should enable organisations to do these things better and get them right at an earlier stage. It is perhaps a matter of encouraging the adoption of recognised quality and management standards to address these issues before they become such a problem.

The Deputy Convener
link

I do not know whether that needs a response.

Mr Black
link

I have nothing to add.

Mr Frank McAveety Glasgow Shettleston) (Lab
link

My question follows on from Nicol Stephen’s questions. The SPSA was a turbulent organisation—“traumatic” is probably the best euphemism to describe the history of its management structure. Paragraphs 49, 50 and 51 of the summary report identify the need to get drivers for change and co-ordination, but it seems that we are still a good distance away from that.You have made a series of recommendations. What is the timescale for their implementation? It strikes me as very worrying that the police across Scotland have a call on the SPSA’s services but nobody is shaping and directing those services to get best value for money and to prioritise them so that the SPSA makes a difference. How do we achieve that, given the suggestions in your document? What timescale would be reasonable for trying to remedy the situation, because I do not necessarily think that a minor co-ordinating group—

Nicol Stephen Aberdeen South) (LD
link

Looking over Frank McAveety’s shoulder, I think that he is referring to the summary report rather than the full report.

The Deputy Convener
link

Yes, the paragraph numbers that Frank McAveety gave refer to the key messages report rather than the full report.

Mr McAveety
link

It is the easy-to-read guide for those of us catching up.I am concerned that we could be a distance away from getting something in place that would meet the aspirations of everybody on the Public Audit Committee.

Mr Black
link

In a perfect world, we would not set up an organisation in 2007 and then in 2010 be in a position where, as we say in the report, the“SPSA, the Scottish Government, the Scottish Police Authorities Conveners Forum and ACPOS have agreed in principle to set up a customer commissioning and monitoring group to help develop service priorities.”That seems to me to be a cart that is well ahead of the horse. We have not been in a good place. The establishment of the Scottish policing board is an encouraging development, but there has to be a sense of urgency about this now, particularly given the forthcoming spending challenges. Perhaps the team could update us on what progress has been made on all this.

Angela Cullen Audit Scotland
link

As this is an Auditor General for Scotland report, it comes to the PAC first and you get first bite at it. We follow up all our reports through the local audit, and Audit Scotland auditors for the Government and the SPSA will follow up with them how they plan to implement the recommendations. We have not set timescales, but we may be able to feed back to you on that at a later date.

Mr McAveety
link

The caveat in paragraph 50 in the slimmer document is that the“SPSA is not a member of the SPB” and“does not always have the opportunity to provide informed input to discussions on the practical implications of adopting different strategic priorities.”Is that paragraph really telling us that the SPSA has little or no input to strategic priorities?

Angela Cullen Audit Scotland
link

The SPSA is not a member of the Scottish policing board, although it can be invited to its meetings. As far as we are aware, it has been invited to meetings, although not necessarily all of them. Miranda Alcock can give more information on that.

Miranda Alcock Audit Scotland
link

The SPSA was invited to the April meeting of the SPB to talk about itself. However, it was not at the June meeting of the SPB, for example, in which efficiencies that could be generated across the criminal justice sector were discussed, as it is not a member of the SPB. Obviously, it has a role to play in that, and it could make a contribution. That is why we recommended that it should be a full member of the SPB. It seems to us that such an organisation has a role to play.

Mr McAveety
link

That is helpful. Thanks.

George Foulkes Lothians) (Lab
link

I apologise for arriving late. I had transport difficulties.Has any member asked about forensic services?

The Deputy Convener
link

No.

George Foulkes Lothians) (Lab
link

You have some positive things to say about forensic services on page 17 of the main report. I presume that all of that was done before the current review. Is that right?

Andra Laird Audit Scotland
link

Yes. That is all work that has been done up to this point in time. The current review is to do with efficiencies on top of those improvements.

George Foulkes Lothians) (Lab
link

Improvements?

Andra Laird Audit Scotland
link

Yes. I am referring to the improvements in exhibit 6.

George Foulkes Lothians) (Lab
link

I understand that a number of options are being considered in the current review, some of which might be improvements. Other options might save more money. Have you considered them?

The Deputy Convener
link

George, if you look at exhibit 8 on page 25 of the report, you will see that the options are set out there in detail.

George Foulkes Lothians) (Lab
link

Yes. Those are the options in the current review.

Mr Black
link

That is correct.

George Foulkes Lothians) (Lab
link

But you have not analysed them and commented on them.

Mr Black
link

No. We simply attempted to give an objective account of the Government’s assessment of the advantages and disadvantages of each option that is currently being considered.

George Foulkes Lothians) (Lab
link

But you have not made an assessment of them.

Mr Black
link

No. That is a policy matter for the Scottish Government.

George Foulkes Lothians) (Lab
link

Does the SPSA normally publish reports of its activities and reviews?

Mr Black
link

Can you help my understanding of the question? What sort of reports do you have in mind?

George Foulkes Lothians) (Lab
link

Does the SPSA produce regular reports that it makes public?

Angela Cullen Audit Scotland
link

It publishes annual reports that give an overview of what it has delivered. Those reports include their annual accounts.

George Foulkes Lothians) (Lab
link

Its report and recommendations and the decision that it has made on forensic services have not been published. Some of us are concerned that they have not been. Is it unusual that they have not been?

Mr Black
link

It would be best if you raised that matter with the Scottish Government.

George Foulkes Lothians) (Lab
link

Fortunately, I can raise the matter with a question that I will ask tomorrow.

The Deputy Convener
link

As there are no more questions, I thank the Auditor General and the Audit Scotland staff. We will discuss in private later how we will progress the matter.I invite the witnesses for the next item to come forward.

  1. 09:30 Interests Procedure · 3
  2. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  3. 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 74
  4. 09:30 Section 23 Reports Evidence session · 115
  5. 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 67

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.