Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

“Getting it right for children in residential care”

Wednesday 10 November 2010 Public Audit Committee About 09:30 Evidence session 115 contributions · 12 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

115 contributions
The Deputy Convener
link

The committee will take evidence on the Auditor General’s report entitled “Getting it right for children in residential care”. I am delighted that we have with us Bill Eadie, who is head of social care at Stirling Council, Tam Baillie, who is Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People, Peter MacLeod, who is director of social work and head of resources at Renfrewshire Council, and Michelle McCargo, who is principal officer of child care at Renfrewshire Council. We have apologies from Mr Eadie’s colleague Joan Hutcheson, who is not able to join us today.Good morning and thank you all for coming to the meeting. Would any of you like to say something before we ask questions? Does anybody have an opening statement that they would like to make? As the witnesses are indicating that they do not, we will move straight to questions.I will get things moving by directing some questions at Mr Baillie in his capacity as Commissioner for Children and Young People. One thing that came out of the report was the clear message that the long-term outcomes for many looked-after young people are extremely poor. In your experience, do we have enough information about young people leaving care and what happens to them later in life? Is it your understanding that, over time, their prospects are improving or getting worse, or are they just as bad as they have always been?10:15

Tam Baillie Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People
link

I spent half my working life working with young people leaving care, providing emergency accommodation for young people who were homeless and working on the streets of Glasgow. In my estimation, we do not have sufficient information on the outcomes for young people leaving care. We have different bits of information, which are picked up through small-scale surveys.For example, estimates for the percentage of young people in our youth offender institutions who were in care vary, depending on the information that you look at, from around 45 per cent to 75 per cent. I recently visited Polmont and Cornton Vale, where I spoke to groups of young people who were under the age of 21. When I asked how many of them had been in care, most of them put their hands up. I think that we could do a lot better when it comes to the general information.We know from Scottish Government figures that an estimated 12 per cent of our care leavers are reporting as homeless. I think that that is an underestimate because, if you look at the figures, you will see that the unknown group is very large. Those are people of whom we have not kept track and with whom whatever contact we had through throughcare services has been lost. Therefore, the figure of 12 per cent relates to those care leavers whom we know about.When I ran Stopover back in 1986, many, many more children and young people were referred to us for accommodation after reporting as homeless. I operated on the basis that 50 per cent of the children and young people who were referred to us at that time were from care. I had the chance to call Stopover recently, because I had been asked to speak about the national review of residential child care. I phoned up and reassured the manager that I was just looking for information. I asked her how many of her referrals involved people who were from care and she said 50 per cent. That spans a period of more than 20 years. I think that a very high percentage of our young people who have been in care are reporting as homeless.The other thing that we know is that the educational attainment levels of children and young people who are in care are much lower than the attainment levels of those who are not. Great efforts have been made to improve those figures, which are probably the most reliable that we have. They have proved stubborn from the point of view of improvements. This year, we do not have those figures because a lot of time and effort has been put into ensuring that we have much better educational attainment information, and I am encouraged by the efforts that have been made on the detail of that information.Quite simply, we do not quite know enough about what happens to young people who leave care. Some of the figures that I have quoted are anecdotal and some of them are from small-scale surveys. We are not very good at keeping track of or keeping in contact with young people who leave care, in whom we will often have invested many years of time, effort and care. For me, that comes to an end all too abruptly when they leave care at far too young an age. We might get on to that later but, for me, it is one of the main issues. In Scotland, children traditionally leave care at 16, 17 or 18—they might be a bit older if they have been in foster care—whereas young people who leave the family home do so in their mid-20s, and that figure is rising. We expect far too much of our most vulnerable youngsters when they leave care. It is no wonder that we have difficulty keeping track of them if we ask them to move into independence at such a tender age.The answer is no, we do not have enough information.

The Deputy Convener
link

Thank you. That was a comprehensive answer to the question. I can perhaps infer from what you said that we do not know the answer to the second part of my question either. Do we know whether things are getting better or worse over time?

Tam Baillie Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People
link

On the basis that we do not have sufficient information to know what the situation is, that is a difficult question to answer. It is not for a lack of attention or a lack of reports. In appendix 3 of the Audit Scotland report, I counted 30 reports that are all about children and young people leaving care, so the last thing that I will call for today is yet another one. It is time that we put some of the recommendations into action.

The Deputy Convener
link

That is helpful. You talked about the need for action. The Audit Scotland report identified a number of serious issues for councils to address, including the need for a more strategic approach to planning and managing residential child care services. What changes are needed at a council level to improve the lives of the children about whom we have talked?

Tam Baillie Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People
link

The national review that I mentioned made similar recommendations, such as a national approach to commissioning services. Some things are unpredictable at a local level, but history tells us the kind of issues that need to be addressed for young people who come into care, so we should have the capacity to commission services much more strategically.We also know what leads to good outcomes for children leaving care. The Social Work Inspection Agency produced a report called “Extraordinary Lives: Creating a positive future for looked after children and young people in Scotland”. Its main conclusion was that better corporate parenting at a local level was the answer to achieving better outcomes for our children leaving care. That means that the responsibility is not only on local authorities; we should take the responsibility of corporate parenting. We, as the state, have said that we will take care of these children. We must consider how we nurture them and prepare them for adulthood much better. It is not only about local authorities but about health boards and the need to fulfil a range of responsibilities that we would expect a parent to fulfil. A parent not only accommodates a child but takes care of them and considers all their needs. That is the enormous responsibility that is on us when we take a youngster into care.

The Deputy Convener
link

Thank you for that. Will the council representatives comment on some of the things that Mr Baillie has just said? Audit Scotland’s report identified care planning as an issue. What could councils do to ensure that that is more effective and leads to better long-term outcomes for young people?

Peter MacLeod Renfrewshire Council
link

I emphasise many of the points that Tam Baillie made. The report outlines the fact that residential care is extremely challenging for Scottish society—Government and all of us—given the number of children whom we accommodate and the particularly special needs that they have because of their accommodated status. I am here as a director of social work and a council representative, but I agree that—to coin a phrase—it is everybody’s job to look after the children who end up being cared for by local authorities and their partners. It is not many years since a report called “Edinburgh’s Children: Report of the Edinburgh Inquiry into Abuse and Protection of Children in Care” came to our attention. It outlined a number of issues for those children, including health deficits.It is shocking that, in 21st century Scotland, significant health deficits have been identified among children in our care—and I have responsibility for that, as do others. There are some elements that still have to be taken up. Tam Baillie spoke about the parenting role that many of us have in our private lives, which is not being discharged particularly well in the case of some of the most vulnerable children in our care.Specifically in relation to your question, I think that there must be a proper, co-ordinated, multi-agency approach to care planning. We need to get to know the children and their health needs, including their mental health needs.I will pause on that point. The issues relating to the mental health of children in our care services are legion and they are particular. Our services are not tailored to or meeting those needs well enough, I would argue. I am sure that some of the statistics that Tam Baillie could share with you provide evidence that the mental health needs of the children in our care are sometimes compromised by their early life experiences, and that our services are perhaps not as well tailored as they should be in order to meet those needs. A multi-agency response is critical to care planning.The parenting role that Tam Baillie spoke about must be discharged by councils and partners by way of corporate parenting. My view, as the parent of two young children, is that, for some of the most vulnerable kids in our society, we are all involved in a sort of irrational parenting—if somebody bullies your wean, you will do something about it. If that sort of thing happened in the context of a council service—in the units for children and the homes for children that we run—I would expect our staff to adopt an approach that is similar to that of a parent, to intervene appropriately and to develop relationships that nurture the children and bring them on.I will qualify what Tam Baillie said about corporate parenting being the most powerful driver to better outcomes by saying that it is actually very straightforward: it is about relationships and staff. When we speak to children in our care services, which usually involves some powerful interactions, they often point to the member of staff who has made the difference—who represents the tipping point for them and who has given them the opportunity and the aspiration. In care planning terms, that is a fundamental point.Finally, there is a system called pathway planning, which involves identifying where a child should go on their life journey by way of accommodation, employment, training and other needs that they might have. That becomes fundamental. I agree with Tam Baillie that the age of leaving care can sometimes be too early. Many of the people in this room probably did not leave their family homes at 16. Perhaps some of you did but, if so, it was probably not into a flat up a close. We have changed that now, and things are a bit better than they used to be.Throughcare services are fundamental. We are in the process of building a brand-new unit for 10 young people in Renfrewshire. It is tailor made, and it is a new-build facility. All the wraparound services that are required in addition to that facility are critical. We have schemes that provide training and employment places in our leisure trust, and we have recently teamed up with Enlight, an entrepreneurial foundation, to consider how the private sector can impact on the lives of our most vulnerable looked-after children.All those things are fundamental in care planning.

Bill Eadie Stirling Council
link

The one area that Tam Baillie and Peter MacLeod have not yet picked up on is the getting it right for every child—GIRFEC—agenda. As we proceed, it is clear that early identification of vulnerable children, and early intervention by the range of partners that Peter MacLeod has mentioned, will allow many children to be diverted from the care system or to enter the care system at an earlier stage, which allows us to make appropriate permanent plans for their alternative care. Although I expect that early identification and intervention would make a difference, we are clearly some years away from seeing the impact of that agenda.

Jamie Hepburn
link

This question is directed at the local authority representatives, although Tam Baillie is also welcome to offer his perspective. The Audit Scotland report identifies that, although the number of children who are in residential care has remained relatively static in the past eight or nine years, the expenditure on those places that has been reported by social work services has increased by 68 per cent overall. How do we account for that? Why has that happened?10:30

Bill Eadie Stirling Council
link

I will start on that question. The cost of buying residential placements has gone up significantly, as the report indicates. Part of the problem is that local authorities have not been strategic enough in planning for the accommodation of young people; we have been at the behest of the marketplace—and a significant number of new players have entered the childcare market. Where I am based in central Scotland, four or five years ago three local authorities provided foster care and we probably had three or four providers, largely from the voluntary sector. Now, something like 15 or 16 organisations

that offer and recruit to foster care placements are operating in central Scotland. They offer placements to authorities across Scotland and, as the demand appeared to increase, and possibly as local authorities reduced some of their older provision, other providers have come into the marketplace—and they have set the price that local authorities pay.As the report indicates, it is only more recently that some authorities have started to take a more strategic approach to the commissioning of residential and foster care placements.

Michelle McCargo Renfrewshire Council
link

Traditionally, when we have placed children in external resources we have tended to use what would have been seen as residential schools, such as the Kibble, St Philips or St Johns. There has been a growth in smaller, more independent, four and five-bedded units, which pushes up the cost of care. In our own resources, we frequently have higher ratios of staff to young people.It is increasingly the case that young people who come into our care have extremely challenging and complex needs that cannot be met in-house, so we have to go to the market and place them externally. Those providers set their own prices.

Jamie Hepburn
link

So part of the problem is the fact that there is a range of new providers and they are more expensive. The report also identifies that, despite the fact that local authority in-house provision accounts for about 40 per cent of all residential care places, few local authorities know the full cost of their own provision. Does that tally with your experience? Is it a problem in your area, or are you aware of it in other areas?

Peter MacLeod Renfrewshire Council
link

Given the evidence that has been gathered for the report, it is clearly a problem. I know what the cost of care is in my council area, and how it is broken down. I also know what the budget is.The issue is significant and, as the report indicates, worthy of further examination. There are models from south of the border, where there has been an examination of how care costs are made up.One of the things that we in the Clyde valley area have a lead on—I have a lead on it on behalf of that group—is something called a regional children’s services commissioning framework. Following the Arbuthnott Clyde valley review, we set up a body called the health and social care collaborative, which is effectively a body that is shared between two health boards and eight local authorities. One of the workstreams that we have started relates to that regional children’s services commissioning exercise. We have examined the costs across eight councils and two health boards and the fact that £25 million has been spent on external residential children’s services provision. We have broken down the costs, including the different rates that different providers apply, and we are now working with local authorities, health boards and providers in the private and independent sectors to strategically plan for and commission services. That means, very simply, that we will have a better understanding—the report highlighted the deficits in our understanding—of the needs of children in the Clyde valley and that we can plan to meet those needs. For example, we want to explore non-traditional models of foster care that bring in psychology, mental health and other services as part of the fostering experience for those children who are most in need. We are also examining a variety of other areas, including services for those with autistic spectrum conditions.In answer to your question, there is a need to understand cost better. The costs have grown significantly, for some of the reasons that have been mentioned. As a director of social work, I believe that we need to examine that further. I am not entirely convinced that all those increased costs add to or achieve better outcomes or are entirely justified on all occasions. That has come up in some of the more difficult discussions that we are having with local authorities and providers just now.To reassure the committee—if it appears that way—we are now involved in a much bigger planning exercise than has been seen in Scotland before, with a large population base in the Clyde valley. We are working with providers on proper strategic commissioning and planning, which includes examining costs. That will take us further forward in planning for our children’s future than we have gone for some time.

Jamie Hepburn
link

Mr Eadie, do you have a perspective on the issue?

Bill Eadie Stirling Council
link

Yes. The report is critical of local authorities, but it recognises that we know the costs of our own units. I know exactly how much of a budget I have for my own unit, but I am less clear about the additional management costs and the costs of corporate support for that unit.The report also identifies, with regard to external provision, that there are costs on the local authority in relation to quality assurance and contracting for services in respect of the review of care plans for individual children. Some of those costs are replicated for children who are in local authority units, so there are unidentified costs on both sides. Dealing with that would ensure that there is a more accurate reflection and comparison between in-house and external provision.

Jamie Hepburn
link

Can I ask one final question?

The Deputy Convener
link

I was wondering whether Mr Baillie wanted to come in.

Jamie Hepburn
link

I was going to ask Mr Baillie for his perspective on what Peter MacLeod said about the fact that the increased costs for the provision of residential care do not necessarily result in an improved service. That must concern you, Mr Baillie.

Tam Baillie Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People
link

For me that is one of the most powerful aspects of the report. The report quantifies the amount of money that is being spent: I just checked the figure and it is £250 million, which is an enormous sum of money for us to invest when we do not know what we are getting for it. Any moves or developments towards better commissioning or co-ordination in that regard must, because of that level of investment, involve consideration of how we monitor outcomes for our children and young people who are in care. It would be a really positive development if we built that in, but we would need to reconsider our expectations of throughcare and aftercare services and how we pick up information at different points, such as when people become homeless or are taken into custody. We also need to examine other, positive, outcomes with regard to employment, training and access to those things that will give children and young people a proper investment.Any moves in relation to commissioning must run alongside developments to gather information that will help us to evaluate what we are getting by way of return on investment and the improved outcomes for our children and young people in care.

Nicol Stephen
link

On that point, convener—

The Deputy Convener
link

I think Frank McAveety was keen to come in—unless you want to comment directly on that point.

Mr McAveety
link

Let Nicol Stephen in.

Nicol Stephen
link

Paragraph 13 on page 7 of the report looks at the £250 million cost and points out that, on average, the cost is £150,000 per child. I think that the actual figure is £156,000 if you divide £250 million by the 1,600 children we are looking at. The report then goes on to talk about the variation in weekly cost between around £800 and £5,500. Could you shine a light on that and tell us the range of placements that children are going to? For example, what placement is costing £5,500 per week?Bill Eadie said that he knows the cost of the placements and the costs that he incurs but that he is not so clear on the management cost, the central cost and the overheads. Are the overheads and the central and management costs included in, or on top of, the £250 million? For example, if you are spending £1,000 per week, is that £750 on the placement and £250 on the management and central costs? I do not expect absolutely accurate detailed responses, but it would be extremely helpful if you could give us a flavour of what is going on.

Bill Eadie Stirling Council
link

If you are looking at the very high-end costs of £5,000 or £5,500 a week—

Nicol Stephen
link

A lot of the costs must be high end if the average is £150,000. By definition, a lot

must be above £150,000 per year, which is pretty expensive.

Bill Eadie Stirling Council
link

Residential schools for young people would generally cost £3,000-plus per week. For children at the very high end of autistic spectrum disorder needs, you are talking about £5,000-plus per week. For secure care, you would be paying between £4,000 and £5,000 a week for a secure bed—the costs vary across the units. That kind of cost accounts for the higher-end placement.For £800 a week, you are talking about a fairly standard residential care unit that is not providing educational support to children. I suspect that the £800 reflects what local authorities would report they are spending on residential care but does not include the central management costs.

Nicol Stephen
link

So they would need to be added to the £250 million.

Bill Eadie Stirling Council
link

Indeed. The £5,000-plus a week would not include the costs of social work contact with the child in the residential unit, costs that the local authority might meet in continuing to provide access and family support to the child—which might involve the child coming home for weekends or periods of leave—the cost of conducting reviews or contract management. The £5,500 a week would be the cost of buying the bed from the unit. The other costs would need to go on top of that.

Nicol Stephen
link

It would not include the cost of schooling when that is non-residential.

Bill Eadie Stirling Council
link

At the bottom end, that cost would not include education. As you move through the middle phase to the upper end, it would include education costs.

Nicol Stephen
link

Thank you.

Mr McAveety
link

I thank the contributors so far for their candid responses on a difficult issue. We have been concerned about the baseline figure of £0.25 billion. Given your responses to Nicol Stephen’s questions, the figure is probably much higher. Cumulatively, the citizen in Scotland is paying a lot of money because of what has happened in families, in the bringing up of kids or in youngsters’ emotional development. That has a massive consequence for us all.I want to ask about two or three things that Jamie Hepburn and Nicol Stephen have already raised. First, we have had a proliferation of new providers. Given your contributions, we are not convinced that that has changed dramatically the quality and range of experience. How do we change that debate with providers to try to get better outcomes?10:45

The second thing—Bill Eadie has touched on this in some of his responses—is the big review of residential care that you carried out. It would be helpful to have a sense of the two or three strong messages that you want to send to us from that. Tam Baillie mentioned the fact that there is no lack of political will around the table and among parties. The proliferation of reports, particularly since the Parliament was established but also before that, supports that. It reminds me of the time in the late 1960s—I know that I am going back a long time, but George Foulkes always keeps me up to date on these matters—when Jennie Lee was the Minister for Arts. She said, “Give us some money and a period of silence.” That is maybe what Tam Baillie was suggesting when he talked about the number of reports that there have been.A lot of money is already being invested and I am not convinced that more money would make any real difference unless we strip things back. It would be helpful to get a sense, from all the witnesses, of how we can really drive that. I know that there are people at local authority level who are absolutely committed to making a real difference. Conveners whom I have spoken to over the years have cared passionately, particularly when they have been confronted with the circumstances that the youngsters arrive in care from. How can we get the drivers for change? There is broad political will and a fair amount of money is going in, and we know from the Audit Scotland report that there are ways in which we can maximise that. Can you give us a sense of that, so that we can take the issue forward?

Peter MacLeod Renfrewshire Council
link

I am happy to start. It is a fairly challenging question, but rightly so given that £250-plus million is being spent on the service.The report confronts the need for greater partnership between the increasing number of providers and councils. A number of us at the table will remember a time when almost all the residential child care in Scotland was provided by councils, trusts or charities of one kind or another. That has changed as the cost has increased. It is challenging to say this, but the reality is that we are now absolutely not convinced that every penny is being spent on achieving an improved outcome. We need to change that, and that is obviously the origin of your question.The national residential child care initiative, to which Tam Baillie referred, was a milestone—or tipping point. “Higher Aspirations, Brighter Futures” tried to corral all the providers and key players in asking what we are driving for and what our key aspirations are. That has been a helpful process. Also, we lead the regional children’s services commissioning planning exercise in Renfrewshire, and I have stood up in front of 50 or 60 providers of residential care and a large number of providers of foster care. It is the first time that we have got together and asked what we are driving towards together, which has been very helpful.I take a slightly different approach—I do not want to use jargon—in that I think that we know what our children who require accommodation need but I do not think that we are delivering it in a consistent, strategic way. Given the fact that we are a relatively small country with a small proportion of children in particular and extreme need, we must be able to plan effectively. We know what the children need because they tell us; yet, we provide relatively costly services that could be delivered on a more outcome-focused basis. That might sound a bit aspirational, but I firmly believe that part of the answer lies in a project that we have launched with lottery funding. It involves one local authority and partners and is called achieving step change. We are using a methodology called logic modelling to look in very great detail at the needs of our child and parent populations in one locality in Scotland. We will then, over a three-year programme and on the basis of those needs, make some radical decisions on and changes in how we use the money—which I reckon is about £300 million of public expenditure on children’s services in one locality.The reality is that services have been put in place as a result of political policies, funding streams of one kind or another or need. In 2010, we need to stop, think about the money that is being spent and how we can spend it differently. That means that we must all get out of our respective agencies—or silos, perhaps—and say that we must be brave in the way we spend that money. If I were a betting person, I would say that most of the money would end up being spent at the preventive end. It costs £250,000 to accommodate a child in secure care in Scotland. The fact that we spend that money is an indictment of our system; it means that that £250,000 is not being spent on preventing that young person requiring to be locked up. That has to change, and it can be done only through a properly articulated understanding of how we can use the money better. My argument would be that if we can use that approach in one local authority area we can perhaps use it nationally.

Mr McAveety
link

I mentioned the review. Can we hear from Bill Eadie on that?

Bill Eadie Stirling Council
link

Three years ago, if Stirling wanted to accommodate a child and we did not have a foster care placement or a place in one of our residential units, my resourcing officer would have phoned around the various organisations in Scotland to ask whether they had a bed available. That provision might not necessarily have met the needs of the child, unless we had had reasonable warning that the child was going to be accommodated, and the price would have been set by the organisation. The contract that we signed was the one that was provided by the organisation; it generally involved how much it would cost and how much notice we had to give if we wanted to terminate the placement. With support from external consultants, we carried out a review of our commissioning of residential care and arrived at a model that we could use to build in some prediction of the likely need for placements outwith the provision of the authority. We then agreed, across our partners, including health and education, the kind of outcomes that we were looking for. They were largely based around the safe, healthy, active, nurtured, achieving, respected and responsible and included—SHANARI—principles that are in the getting it right for every child programme. We then created a contract and tender document that included what we were looking for. After some soft market testing to find out whether providers would be interested in a shift in the model of commissioning services, we went out to tender. Six or seven organisations came back to us on foster care or residential care—significantly fewer than the number of providers in Scotland—and we narrowed them down through a scoring process and through interviews with the providers. When we issue a contract now, we are clear about what we expect from the providers who enter into a contract with us. Now, there is a more positive response from most of the children—not all, as there are occasional exceptions to the contract level because certain children have more extreme needs. One of the ways in which we measure that improvement is by the fact that we no longer get calls on a Friday from residential care providers, saying, “We can’t cope with this child any more; a member of staff is driving them down to your authority.” Built into the contract is a process of review, consultation and penalties that the provider is subject to if they take that view, so it has stopped. That has made an incredible difference to the lives of children, because it is now possible to plan moves if we do not have the appropriate placement. That is the approach that we have taken to try to improve the situation.

Mr McAveety
link

Both Peter MacLeod and Tam Baillie mentioned relationships. It is a truism in any walk of life that your life can be shaped by the quality of the people who are around you at different stages. How do we build that into spending patterns, to provide much greater consistency? In a relatively small country, with a small number of youngsters, we should be able to find people with the skills to do that.

Michelle McCargo Renfrewshire Council
link

There are people who are willing to do that. We must support them in seeing residential care as a worthwhile career that is meaningful, for which they are properly trained and from which they get job satisfaction. Unfortunately, the job is very demanding emotionally. It is important that councils that still have residential units make the job as attractive an opportunity as possible. In residential care, in particular, in which people are looked after by three shifts a day, it is critical that the people who look after them are committed to them, have the value base and skills to bring them on and aspire for them. Irrational parenting is critical. I want residential staff to fight for young people to the point at which that is irrational, because that is what the young people need.

Anne McLaughlin
link

You referred to irrational parenting. It is clear that people are more likely to be homeless or to have lower educational attainment if they do not have their family’s support. Peter MacLeod asked at what age people left home. I was quite young—I was 19—but I always knew that if I messed up I could go back home or get my mum and dad to sort things out for me. I still know that, although I will not say what my age is. Laughter. It is 34.

Mr McAveety
link

Do not be irrational.

Anne McLaughlin
link

I cannot remember what my previous lie was.When my parents are gone, I will be able to turn to aunts, uncles, cousins, sisters and brothers. That makes a significant difference to my life. It also affects educational attainment if someone is really pushing you when you are at school, telling you that you can achieve and giving you positive reinforcement throughout your life. I was interested in Tam Baillie’s comments on corporate parenting and would like to find out more about that.Frank McAveety asked the bigger question that I wanted to ask, and Peter MacLeod answered it pretty well. I will focus on two shorter questions. The first is directed at Peter MacLeod, who talked about the mental health problems that are particular to children in residential care. Can he tell us a little more about those?

Peter MacLeod Renfrewshire Council
link

When I was last before the Public Audit Committee, it was to discuss mental health issues. We had a lot of debate about adult mental health. I recall saying that the mental health of young people is often an indicator of issues in later life. It is a fact that, as a result of the adversity that many of them have faced, almost half of the young people in accommodation experience issues relating to mental health; Tam Baillie can help us on that point. I am always aware that, as my career in social care has developed, the issues for young people in need have not become less challenging. There is no question but that the difficult circumstances that we sometimes see affect our young people’s mental health.One of the exciting outcomes of the grouping of eight local authorities and two health boards in the Clyde valley has been that the NHS has come on board on alternatives to secure care, especially through the commitment to provide a clinical psychological assessment when someone is being considered for that kind of intervention. We need to engage with such issues much further downstream. It is clear that for some time there have been significant issues across Scotland relating to child and adolescent mental health services. I do not wish to add to the plethora of reports, but reports on those services in recent years have found deficits in resource levels.The deficits have been made up in some localities, but there are still significant issues that we need to deal with when it comes to the mental health of young people. That goes back to my earlier answer: although it is everybody’s job to ensure that children in residential care are okay, there are particular jobs and relationships that deliver that. We must be cognisant of the fact that there are specialist services, such as mental health services, that should be engaged. For my money, for most children who come into accommodation, if not all of them—although that is perhaps slightly controversial—if an assessment of mental health needs is not to be automatic, it should certainly be a consideration that is ruled out rather than ruled in, because of the adversity that those young people have often faced. That might be a mechanism to ensure that the proper supports and services are put in place earlier rather than later.11:00

Tam Baillie Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People
link

One of the reports that Peter MacLeod referred to was produced by the Office for National Statistics in 2004. It reported that 45 per cent of children in care in Scotland from a sample of local authorities were found to have mental health problems. We must set that beside the evidence to the Parliament’s Health and Sport Committee’s inquiry into CAMHS about very long waiting lists for such services for children and young people, particularly children in care. There is a breakdown between what we know about the mental health needs of children in care and our response to it as a society in Scotland. For too long, that has been a running sore in the way we care for our children. The people who care for our children need sufficient capacity to attend to the range of needs, including mental health needs. I note that there are recommendations on the link with the NHS. That came through in the Audit Scotland report and in the report of the national review of residential child care. If anything is going to be done about commissioning, that issue needs to be addressed, because we will continue to have difficulties providing for the range of needs of those children as long as that gap exists.

Anne McLaughlin
link

I have a question about corporate parenting. As I do not have a social work background, I have never heard that term before. We have talked a lot about not having proper information on outcomes because we do not monitor children properly when they leave care. I agree that some children leave far too early. Tam, were you suggesting that the corporate parenting role should last longer? Michelle McCargo talked about irrational parenting. If someone is in care, irrational parenting might be achieved, but it stops at the age of 16 or whenever they leave care. Is there a case for it to go on longer—perhaps not living in residential care, but having a long-term relationship?

Tam Baillie Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People
link

Yes. We have tried hard over the years to ensure that young people do not leave care at too early an age. We even changed the rules so that there was a continuing responsibility with throughcare and aftercare. We do not properly analyse the figures on young people leaving care. We have to dig fairly deep to get the average age of young people leaving care. We have to look carefully and consider the different ages at which young people leave different types of care.The simple question that I pose is, what would we say to our children at age 16 when they said they wanted to leave home? I know what my response would be. I certainly would not facilitate that. I would say, “Your place is here.” I would make sure that, as a young adult, they left the family home at a time that was right for them. Some children and young people report feeling that they moved on too early. We are often too willing to go along with a young person who insists that they want to leave care at an early age.That is a rather strange thing for me to say, because in general I want to stress how well we listen to the views of children and young people. However, we need to be realistic about our expectations of them. Anne McLaughlin touched on that earlier. What happens when they leave care? They are expected to leave in a linear fashion and there is no comeback. They move on to supported accommodation, which might provide less support than is provided in care. I illustrated earlier that they might well find themselves in homeless accommodation, which provides even less support, and there is no re-entry to the caring environment that is, in my estimation, what many of those young people need.If we look at the patterns of young people leaving home nowadays, we see that they leave home on several occasions. They leave and they come back. They leave again and spend a little bit longer away, then they come back. Children who leave care do not have the luxury of that pattern, yet they are our most vulnerable youngsters. Entire systems have identified that they are the youngsters who are most in need of support and care. We have to look not only at how we can best prepare them but at the systems that can normalise their experience in relation to that of children and young people who leave the family home, because that is what is asked of a corporate parent.

Anne McLaughlin
link

I know that there is a lack of information and that the report does not cover all the categories, but in looking at children who do not live with their parents, anecdotally, are there different outcomes for those in residential care, those in foster care, those who are adopted and those in kinship care? Is there a significant difference?

Michelle McCargo Renfrewshire Council
link

There will be differences across the piece. We also have to acknowledge that, much of the time, we parent in partnership with birth families. That relates to Tam Baillie’s point about young people who leave care at 16. We do not want them to leave care—we clearly say to them, “Don’t leave care”—but if they do so, they often pull back to the birth family. It is often the first opportunity that they have to make a decision to return to the birth family, and it is sometimes quite overwhelming. As professionals, we know that it will not work out, but we need to get better at being more flexible and responsive when it does not work out. We need really robust throughcare services. It is quite difficult to readmit young people to our children’s units, although we have done that in Renfrewshire on occasion. Often, when a young person leaves, another young person is waiting to move into the unit, so it quickly becomes full and we do not have the flexibility of allowing the young person who has lived there for a length of time to return.Outcomes vary, but we could not say that they are poorer in residential care just because it is residential care. Residential care is right for some young people and they tell us that it is what they want. They do not want to live with a family; they want to be cared for in a group setting, because that is less traumatic for them, given what they experienced at home. We have really good outcomes for some of our young people. I agree with Tam Baillie that how we trail that and how we measure it is a bit ad hoc, but we have young people who are at university, and a young person from one of our residential units worked in partnership with the commissioner and now works for Who Cares? Scotland.We cannot straightforwardly say that someone’s outcomes are poorer because they grew up in residential care. Many adoptions do not work out and many kinship care arrangements are not as great as we would like them to be. We cannot overstate the lifelong impact of the neglect, trauma and abuse that young people have experienced when living with their birth family. Sometimes, by the time they are in the local authority’s care, the damage—for want of a better word—has been so great that it is difficult to undo.

Tam Baillie Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People
link

I started by mentioning “Extraordinary Lives”. That positive report looked at the experiences of children in care and what worked for them. There are some positive signs, and we can see positive outcomes for some children. The issue is that there are just not enough of them, and that is why we need to focus our attention on ensuring that every child in care does at least as well as their peers, regardless of their previous experience.

The Deputy Convener
link

I see that you want to get in, Mr MacLeod, but I ask you to hold on for a moment. I am keeping an eye on the clock, but I am aware that quite a number of members want to ask questions on this matter.

George Foulkes
link

I am most grateful to the witnesses for their very helpful evidence so far. However, I want to ask about prevention, bearing in mind Tam Baillie’s comment that, despite the publication of report after report, things have not improved since 1986, and Peter MacLeod’s point that, although it is right to spend so much money on these issues, the fact that we have to do so is still a terrible indictment of our society. I do not know whether you have heard of George Hosking of the WAVE Trust, but he and others have pointed out that people can make uncannily accurate—indeed, almost 100 per cent accurate—predictions of the children who will go into care and have highlighted the importance of very early intervention. Perhaps you can help us. Is anything in legislation or the administrative structures of the Government or local government inhibiting our moving positively in the direction of early intervention?

Peter MacLeod Renfrewshire Council
link

The issue of prevention and early intervention has been much discussed in many fields, particularly children’s services. George Hosking is right to refer to the predictability of certain outcomes in families with issues, and indeed services such as social work have to deal with issues that move from one generation to the next. As part of our approach to issues arising from the neglect of children through drug and alcohol misuse—which of course are not isolated to Renfrewshire—we recently asked all agencies to highlight the families that they were most concerned about. Now that we have that list, we are looking systematically at intervention, and indeed at earlier intervention if that is what is required. Perhaps as a result of resource constraints, our current systems can be reactive. In other words, involvement is precipitated by an incident, which is not helpful to the child and takes place after the event.Initiatives such as the positive parenting programme, which is currently being rolled out across the west of Scotland, have been utilised very successfully in other parts of the world, including Australia. I believe that such measures have currency, as they are about early intervention and ensuring that parents are equipped. As anyone who is a parent will know, you do not automatically become a complete parent the moment your child is born, and some of our most challenged families face significant issues in that regard.Locally, we are also surveying the community in very great detail about its needs and asking parents and children to tell us what their needs are and what they want from services, and we have committed to reconfiguring those services on that basis. However, the fact is that we probably do not aggregate all the information from our communities effectively enough to target resources at those who are in most need or to see them in any joined-up way.

George Foulkes
link

But that is a practical suggestion. Do you feel that legislation or administrative structures inhibit very early intervention?

Peter MacLeod Renfrewshire Council
link

I am not sure that they do. What we need is a more systematic approach to understanding community needs.

George Foulkes
link

Might the reaction of the media, which can be very unpredictable and inconsistent, also be an inhibitor? After all, social workers can be damned if they do and damned if they don’t.The other issue that I want to raise might be rather more delicate. Religious organisations seem to have some reservations about early intervention, because they see the nuclear family as the best option for the child when that might not be the case.11:15

Peter MacLeod Renfrewshire Council
link

I am happy to follow up on that quickly. We are moving away from ownership of the child in need or the child who has difficulties lying with the social worker. The getting it right for every child initiative is making sure that people view such children as a joint responsibility of education, nursing services, health visiting and social work services. In that sense, our approach has moved on.You made a point about early intervention, the media and religion, and it is controversial. In some families, significant historical events can militate against good outcomes for the children from birth, which is why we have to intervene early. We have moved on a little bit from where we were after the Orkney inquiry, for example, the reaction to which led to children remaining in their families for longer, sometimes with damaging results. Increasingly, the correct balance is being struck, but we still have to deal with some issues.

Tam Baillie Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People
link

We are talking about the earliest years. The starting point is ensuring that we popularise support to parents, because it is not just about people getting support when they are in deficit. The current Administration has done a good job in making the case for why we have to get involved in assisting with the parenting of our youngest children. There is a convincing body of evidence about the impact of attachment and parenting on the child’s emotional, social and cognitive development. The lessons are there for us to learn. The key is to ensure that we implement what is currently called the early years framework. In my view, we must be more assertive about that. Peter MacLeod has mentioned parent programmes, and I have previously stated publicly that we should have a national approach to them.We should also be looking at developing family learning centres that deal with children from age zero to five. In fact, there are already pilots to support our youngest parents through pregnancy and the early years. We must be much more assertive in implementing the current early years framework. That will give us good long-term outcomes for the whole of our population. We have a generational opportunity to look at how we resource that.Part of it is to be brave enough to take on accusations about being a nanny state. I am talking not about a nanny state, but about ensuring that our parents are given the best support that we can give them so that they can nurture and develop our children so that they can enjoy the best childhood. That is a major challenge for our society, and it is not just down to social work, education or health; it is about everyone looking at how we can develop that support.So there are plans, and in my view we should be more assertive. I have been encouraging better articulation of what the early years framework should look like at the local level. The suggestion that we look at children’s earliest years is very helpful.

Bill Eadie Stirling Council
link

The committee will be aware that we have new adoption legislation. Under the previous adoption legislation, there were difficulties in getting freeing orders. It will be interesting to see how the new legislation is applied, and whether it has an impact on the small numbers of children who require permanent alternative care.

Tam Baillie Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People
link

I do not want to hog the discussion, but I will add something. We must be much smarter at making permanency decisions at an earlier stage. We cannot have children oscillating between care and the home in the hope that things will work out in the home. We must ensure that we have good assessment. Our efforts must be geared towards the child being at home with support, but if our assessment is that that is not the best place, we must learn to be more decisive and trust in our assessments. We have quite a long way to go. An interesting pilot in Glasgow is examining that model. The starting point is to try to have young people or children properly accommodated at home, but when that is not the best place we must be prepared to make the decisions.

The Deputy Convener
link

Thank you.Willie Coffey has been waiting patiently to ask about commissioning and joint working. Nicol, do you want to ask about the point that we have just discussed?

Nicol Stephen
link

Yes.

The Deputy Convener
link

If you can be brief, I will let you in and then we will move on to Willie Coffey.

Nicol Stephen
link

We must always remember that each of the 1,600 children in residential care is an individual and that they have very different backgrounds and stories. Some, as you have said, have autism or severe special needs. Some have been involved in offending—sometimes extreme offending. I will focus on prevention and support. It is often called early intervention, but I, like Tam Baillie, believe that support is the first stage.I will mention a situation that I was involved with as a constituency MSP. A single mother who looked after her young girl at home had lost control. She was desperate and believed that someone else could do a better job. There had been no offending and the authorities had not been involved. She got in touch with the authorities and a social worker was appointed.In time—this happened over the course of about two years—foster parents got involved. The child ran away from the foster parents to go back home. Because of that, she was put into residential care. Because she ran away from residential care to go back home, she was put into secure accommodation away from the city of Aberdeen. At that stage, it became very difficult to get information about the child. One felt that she was into a process. It was tough for the mother and for me as a constituency MSP to get information, but one sensed that the girl was involved in a downward spiral—things were getting worse and worse. After the child left secure residential care, she was next discovered in the central belt of Scotland involved in prostitution and drugs. She no longer ran away to get home.That is a tragic and terrible story. It is a tragic indictment of the system that we have in the 21st century in Scotland. How many of the 1,600 children are that girl? How many can be saved from going into that terrible downward spiral? Is the number significant or is it small?

Tam Baillie Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People
link

I have met those youngsters. I have not met that particular young woman, but I have met youngsters who ended up in the central belt and on the streets of Glasgow. In my view, the reason we take children into care is that we can care for them and develop them. For every one of those 1,600 youngsters, an individual assessment has been made that it is better for them to be cared for in whatever circumstances than to remain in their home. I cannot possibly comment on that case or anything to do with it, but I trust judgments to be made locally and individually. The key issue for me is that, once those judgments have been made, we must prioritise every looked-after young person. I include not only those in residential care but young people who are looked after in foster placements and at home.One key message that is coming out is that, regardless of the amount of money that we spend on looked-after children, we need to give a higher priority to the things that count. I refer to some of the things that were mentioned earlier. Stability of placement is key. Once we have identified that a young person or child needs to leave home, we must ensure that they go to absolutely the right place and that they stay in that place. That is where the one-to-one relationships are developed, as well as the attachment that counts for so much in the early years of children’s lives—and it counts all the way through. We must ensure that the child has a secure attachment to whoever is charged with the responsibility of caring for them.I do not write off any young person among the 1,600. We have a responsibility to provide for and maximise their development and potential for the rest of their life.

Nicol Stephen
link

Do you think that the right decisions are being made on each of those 1,600 children being in residential care?

Tam Baillie Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People
link

You have to trust the decisions that are taken at a local level.

Nicol Stephen
link

That is not my question—I need to press you on this. Are you saying that, in your belief, in your judgment and with your professional experience, the right professional decisions are being taken at a local level on all those 1,600 children being in care?

Tam Baillie Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People
link

No. Everybody accepts that we could and should do a lot more at an earlier stage.

Nicol Stephen
link

How many of those 1,600 could you divert? Do you have the facts and the information about that? If you do not, would it not be valuable to be able to make that assessment?

Tam Baillie Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People
link

The answer is that I do not have that information. I do not think that anybody, if pressed, could say how many children and young people we should ensure are not received into care. That is effectively the question that you are asking.

Nicol Stephen
link

You could consider international comparisons, and see how other countries do it. There are lots of ways to analyse the issue and to judge whether the figure of 1,600 and the cost of £250 million upwards represents the right sort of approach in a country such as Scotland.

Tam Baillie Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People
link

It is not just a per-head calculation; we also consider the circumstances in which children and young people are living.

Nicol Stephen
link

Exactly. I am not suggesting that it is simply a calculation of that sort, but I am suggesting that such judgments can and should be made.

Tam Baillie Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People
link

They can and should be made at a local level. As I have said, we have to trust the systems that are in place at a local level to make those judgments. There is a common acceptance that earlier intervention can assist in many families and in many young people’s lives. The direction of travel is to try to provide such intervention at an earlier stage. I have already spoken quite a lot about making that stage as early as possible in children’s lives. Right the way through, we should consider intervening where there is an assessed opportunity for the child to thrive and develop in the family.I do not know whether that quite answers your question, but at this stage I am not really prepared to put a number on the children who we would be able to avoid taking into care. I believe—and there is an acceptance—that putting a lot more in at an earlier stage would bring benefits.

Nicol Stephen
link

It would reduce the figure.

Tam Baillie Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People
link

Yes, and if we introduced a range of interventions at an early stage, such as parent programmes and family learning centres—and as long as we looked at the research and provided the measures in the right manner—we would save money in the longer term.

Bill Eadie Stirling Council
link

It is worth reminding the committee that many decisions are subject to scrutiny through the children’s hearings system, so there is something of a balance and a check on many decisions regarding the accommodation of young people. In Stirling, the vast majority of children who are accommodated are subject to statutory measures of care, so our interventions have been looked at by children’s hearings panels and they have reached conclusions on supervision requirements. That also ensures that the children’s continuing care provision is subject to external scrutiny.

The Deputy Convener
link

Willie Coffey has been extremely patient all morning—as usual.11:30

Willie Coffey
link

I am extremely encouraged by the commissioner’s and both local authorities’ comments and submissions.Members have already asked questions about a number of issues that I had hoped to ask about, but I have a question for Peter MacLeod. You have commented on the broader strategic approach to commissioning, but will that lead to better outcomes for kids? Will it reduce some of the ridiculously high costs that we have heard about? Is there any evidence that already points you towards thinking that?I also have a question for Bill Eadie. I was pleased to hear his summary of what is happening in Stirling. As I recall, we invited representatives from Stirling Council and Renfrewshire Council here so that we could hear about what is happening in their areas. I am keen to hear about your plans and the work that is currently being done. Will it significantly affect outcomes for kids? Will we be able to save money on the high costs of the services so that we can invest it at the front, preventative end? From what I am hearing, I think that all members would prefer investment to be made at a much earlier stage in the process.

Peter MacLeod Renfrewshire Council
link

There is already good evidence, at the early stages of the regional commissioning initiative, that we are developing a much better outcome focus on what we want for our children in need in the future. Examples of that link with Nicol Stephen’s last question. One workstream that is being progressed by the councils and two health boards in the Clyde valley is to do with alternatives to secure care. The number of secure beds in Scotland has recently been reduced, of course. That is a good indicator that people are trying to avoid the scenario that Nicol Stephen spoke about, in that it recognises a commitment to avoiding punitive measures being put in place for young people. Of course, such measures are often put in place to protect them from themselves and from self-harming behaviour, rather than to protect others.There is already good evidence that, in the development of alternatives to secure care, programmes such as multisystemic therapy programmes can be utilised to dampen the number of children who come into secure care. Sometimes, the approach is not rocket science; rather, it is about forming relationships and engaging individuals in diversionary and other activities.Equally, there is good evidence that we are seeing a better outcome focus developing around services for children with autistic spectrum disorder. It is often about supporting, through respite and outreach support and programmes of support, parents who are challenged in caring for children.One of the most powerful discussions that I have had recently took place after Hugh Henry and others wrote to me in Renfrewshire to ask me to meet parents of children with autistic spectrum disorder. Those parents said that there is a pre-five parenting programme that they had evidence on and had used, and that it was great. Our staff have now implemented that programme. Parents taught our staff how to develop and deliver it. Therefore, there is a focus on outcomes at the front line. Parents are saying what works for them, and that is being translated into service outcomes. That is a positive development.There is evidence that some things are heading in the right direction, but I agree that we need to reduce costs at the higher end in order to invest at the more preventative end. I equally agree with the point that Tam Baillie made. The approach should not always be based on the deficit model; rather, there should be a more general population-based approach to how we parent and care for children.

Bill Eadie Stirling Council
link

The other challenge that we have is to do with the transparency of the higher cost packages and understanding why care costs should be as high as they are. To date, we have been unsuccessful in trying to understand that, possibly because of the open market in which we are operating. Work is being done around a national contract for secure care, and the Association of Directors of Social Work has raised the issue of trying to understand and get a breakdown of why the costs of secure care for young people are so high. That is in order to get an understanding of how much of the costs are invested in the care of and outcomes for young people.

Willie Coffey
link

Given the review that you have carried out and the more rigorous approach to what you are doing, are your costs getting higher?

Bill Eadie Stirling Council
link

We managed to put a peg on the charges for the period of the current contracts that we put out. We went for a zero increase over the two years of the contracts with the potential to extend that for a further year. We achieved lower prices for foster care than for residential care. Peter MacLeod and I had a discussion about that outside the committee room before we came in, and it was interesting to discover that, although we use the same providers, we pay different charges. There is still very much an element of market operation.Stirling Council is a very small purchaser in comparison with Renfrewshire Council and Glasgow City Council, but I am achieving a better price than Renfrewshire Council is able to get—although I am not going to say from whom. So, there is an element of current providers taking opportunities not to make a profit, but to charge differently for what is ostensibly the same service.

Willie Coffey
link

There is clearly scope for more collaboration. Thank you.

Hugh Henry Paisley South) (Lab
link

I note with fascination Bill Eadie’s comment about his getting a better price than Renfrewshire Council does, which I will ensure is fed into the current discussions on budget cuts in Renfrewshire.I want to ask about secure accommodation. Notwithstanding what Peter MacLeod has said about the need to have alternatives and, where possible, to keep young people either with their family or in the community, Nicol Stephen gave a good example of a situation in which secure accommodation is still necessary. Is it your view that secure accommodation still has a role to play in Scotland? It has been mentioned that the number of secure accommodation places has been cut. Is there a danger that the number could be reduced by too many? What would happen if we went too far in that direction?

Michelle McCargo Renfrewshire Council
link

There is a role for secure care for some of our riskiest young people. Secure care is used for young people who are at risk or who pose a risk, and for young people who are sentenced by the courts because they have committed serious crimes. If we did not have secure care provision, we could have 15-year-olds serving sentences in adult prisons, which would be absolutely unacceptable, in my view.We do, however, need a better range of alternatives for the young people who pose a risk to themselves. Local authorities often use secure care in such situations because they cannot keep the young people safe from self-harming or drug-taking behaviours or because of scenarios such as that which Nicol Stephen presented to us earlier. We have had input from the WAVE Trust that says that we can predict at an early age the young people who might be on that pathway; so, we need earlier and more effective intervention for them.

Hugh Henry Paisley South) (Lab
link

What would happen if we reduced the number of secure places but there was a level of demand that we could not meet? As you describe, young people could be serving sentences in adult prisons, which would be inappropriate. What would happen if we went too far in reducing the number of secure places?

Michelle McCargo Renfrewshire Council
link

Perhaps Tam Baillie and others would be better placed to answer that, but it is my understanding that the beds that are available just now will be mothballed—we are not talking about losing the beds completely. We have used fewer beds over the past couple of years, so what we are doing now is capitalising on that reduction in use and saying that we want to develop alternatives, particularly for young women. At the moment, the children’s panel frequently makes decisions to place young women in secure care, although it would not make such decisions when faced with a young man with the same issues. We must ensure that, when we deny someone their liberty—which is what secure care is—we have no option other than to do that.

Hugh Henry Paisley South) (Lab
link

Are local authorities seeking a different outcome from that which has been recommended by the children’s panel in relation to those young women?

Michelle McCargo Renfrewshire Council
link

If a children’s panel decides to place someone on a secure warrant rather than a secure order—a secure warrant is for a three-week period—the director of social work currently has the authority not to implement that warrant on the basis of a risk assessment. However, nine times out of 10, the warrant is implemented. The directors who are here would be better placed to speak about that. That may be explained by the fact that we are able to put in other measures. When we have not implemented a secure warrant for a young woman, we have used other services to ensure that she is kept safe during the three-week period.

Hugh Henry Paisley South) (Lab
link

My final question relates to finance. I know just how expensive secure accommodation can be, and that social work budgets are under a great deal of pressure. Will that pressure start to cause a problem in situations such as the one that Nicol Stephen described? Should secure accommodation places be funded centrally?

Peter MacLeod Renfrewshire Council
link

That is a fair question. The cost of a child remaining in a secure placement for a year is £0.25 million. It is extremely difficult to budget for that, because it is difficult to predict that a child will go to a hearing today and end up with a secure order. As Michelle McCargo said, I have a veto on whether a child should enter a secure placement. It is reasonable to ask whether placements should be controlled centrally, but I am not sure that that would contain cost pressure any better. It would give better oversight and managerial control over the allocation of placements, but the main issue is how we develop alternatives.Alternatives to secure provision in Scotland are not as developed as they could be. Initiatives such as those in the Clyde valley and elsewhere are advancing the process. As you are aware, we have intensive support and monitoring systems that have controversial elements, such as the tagging of under-16-year-olds. However, utilising programmes that are often half the cost—or less—of secure placements is better than taking someone’s liberty away from them.I am not sure whether secure placements should be centrally managed, but that could have the effect of containing demand. The costs of secure placements have implications for the rest of children’s services, with some children not getting services that are as good or as intensive as they might be. The committee must also recognise the impact of those costs on the rest of social care. Our demographic is such that the number of older people is burgeoning. The costs of secure placements have significant implications for the costs of social care and related budgets.

Hugh Henry Paisley South) (Lab
link

That is the point that I am trying to make. Removing the financial pressure of funding secure placements from local authorities could allow them to concentrate their resources on alternative methods.

Bill Eadie Stirling Council
link

If funding were centralised and capped, the challenge that chief officers face around decision making would just be transferred to a centralised body. There is an incentive at local level to ensure that we work towards meeting children’s care needs. Members of Stirling Council expect decisions that I make for or against secure accommodation to be based on the care needs of the children concerned. There have been occasions when, as chief officer, I have sought secure placements outwith the children’s hearings system, because the level of risk to the individual concerned was so high that they needed to be somewhere where there was a degree of control to help with their care.Peter MacLeod is right when he says that we need to develop alternatives. However, as someone who makes relatively little use of secure care, I have never had a problem getting a bed when I need one.11:45

The Deputy Convener
link

Nicol Stephen has a brief, final question.

Nicol Stephen
link

The question is on secure accommodation. We send to secure accommodation, at a cost of approximately £250,000 a year each, boys and girls who have committed offences—in some cases, very serious offences. We also send to secure accommodation, also at a cost of £250,000 a year, boys and girls who are vulnerable and at risk of self-abuse. Are individuals in those different groups sent to the same secure accommodation? Is a distinction made between offenders and those who are at risk of self-abuse? Is a distinction made between boys and girls? Will you explain the current system?It is my understanding that, in the case that I described earlier, the young girl in question was sent to secure accommodation—which I think would have been in Montrose—where there were serious offenders. She was sent there because of her vulnerability and because she was at risk of self-abuse.

Michelle McCargo Renfrewshire Council
link

That is the case. Secure units house young offenders and young people who are deemed to be vulnerable. That is one of the main reasons why, as local authorities, we try everything within our power to avoid sending vulnerable young people to secure care.

Nicol Stephen
link

Is not that about the most shocking, disgraceful and inappropriate system that could possibly be constructed?

Michelle McCargo Renfrewshire Council
link

It is certainly a system that presents us with a lot of challenges, although the secure units do everything within their power to manage the situation as well as they can.

Nicol Stephen
link

That is a bit like sending an adult who had serious mental health problems and who was at risk of self-abuse to Barlinnie. Would you send an extremely vulnerable person who was at risk of self-abuse to a high-security prison where they would come into immediate contact with, and mix with, prisoners who had committed some of the most serious offences? That is an exact analogy, is it not?

Peter MacLeod Renfrewshire Council
link

I am not sure whether it is an exact analogy. In the adult justice system, the needs of individuals—

Nicol Stephen
link

I am talking about the practice of sending young people with mental health and self-abuse problems to a place where they will meet and come into contact with the most serious child offenders. Is that not a pretty accurate analogy? I must press you on that point.

Michelle McCargo Renfrewshire Council
link

I think that we must acknowledge that young people who commit offences are not just offenders. Frequently, they will have been offended against and will have suffered abusive and neglectful experiences, to which their offending is often related.

Nicol Stephen
link

I do not doubt that, but the same applies to adult offenders, does it not?

Michelle McCargo Renfrewshire Council
link

Yes it does, but the offenders whom we are talking about are still children. That is why we have a system of secure care for them, instead of sending them to prison-type accommodation.

Nicol Stephen
link

So, you would defend the current system?

Michelle McCargo Renfrewshire Council
link

No, I would not defend it, but—

Nicol Stephen
link

I am asking for your view of that system. Is it acceptable? Is it defensible?

Michelle McCargo Renfrewshire Council
link

I would prefer us to have a range of options to use for vulnerable young people that did not involve their being placed in secure care at all. I have had to use secure care for young women who have been sexually abused while their abuser has been at large. It is difficult to explain to a young person that they require secure care because of the extent to which they are at risk.

Nicol Stephen
link

You could be putting young people into secure care where there are child sexual abusers.

Michelle McCargo Renfrewshire Council
link

That is not the case with young women. When they go into secure care, they are only with other young women.

Peter MacLeod Renfrewshire Council
link

It is obviously a highly challenging situation. Secure care is an option of last resort. Increasingly, we are developing alternatives as, I hope, the committee has heard. One of the real challenges is in providing alternatives for young women who require the highest levels of care because, by definition, they are often at greater risk than young men.Is the current system acceptable? Is it an issue that high-risk offenders are placed alongside very vulnerable people? Of course that is troubling. I am sure that it is a concern that is shared by other members of the committee and other witnesses. A safeguard that is in place in Scotland and not in other parts of the UK or the world is the children’s hearings system. I make it clear that different programmes are available. There would be some separation between the highest-risk offenders and the most vulnerable—that is the case in our secure units.We also have secure units such as the Good Shepherd centre in Bishopton in Renfrewshire, which is a girls-only facility. I do not know the statistics off the top of my head, but I guess that the vast majority of individuals at that centre are not serious offenders but are more offended against.Resources in the system mitigate some of the risks that Nicol Stephen described. From my career, I am not aware that somebody who was vulnerable and in secure care because of their vulnerability has been seriously offended against by a high-risk offender.

Tam Baillie Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People
link

The approach of our children’s hearings system is to treat youngsters on the basis of need, regardless of whether they have been offended against or are perpetrators of offences. There will always be secure accommodation and we will always have children and young people who are a danger to themselves or to others. In my experience, those who are a danger to others have had similarly traumatised lives to those who are a danger to themselves. We must not look at the situation just through the prism of our secure accommodation. The fundamental basis of our children’s hearings system is to deal with children and young people on the basis of need.I will add another point. The numbers in secure accommodation might well be reducing, and it would help to have an analysis of the reasons for that, so that we understand the situation better. As the Audit Scotland report suggests, we should look at and analyse patterns before we make decisions on the type of care, regardless of whether it is secure accommodation or any other care that we develop and commission. Secure accommodation is part of the range of residential accommodation that the report covers.Can I add another point as well?

The Deputy Convener
link

Quickly, please.

Tam Baillie Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People
link

How we deal with our children—I include 16 and 17-year-olds—who are young offenders really needs to be considered. Concern is felt about how we deal with our 16 and 17-year-olds who find themselves in custody. I add that for good measure, as we are talking about secure accommodation.

The Deputy Convener
link

The session has been long, but I am sure that committee members found it extremely helpful for understanding the issues. I thank all the witnesses for giving up their time to come along and answer our questions.11:52 Meeting suspended.

11:57 On resuming—

  1. 09:30 Interests Procedure · 3
  2. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  3. 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 74
  4. 09:30 Section 23 Reports Evidence session · 115
  5. 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 67

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.