Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Current Petitions

A90/A937 (Safety Improvements) (PE1236)

Tuesday 2 March 2010 Public Petitions Committee About 14:00 Petitions 88 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

88 contributions
The Convener
link

Thank you very much for your patience, everyone. The next petition PE1236, by Jill Campbell, calls on the Parliament to urge the Government to improve safety measures on the A90 by constructing a grade-separated junction where the A937 crosses the A90 at Laurencekirk. I welcome Stewart Stevenson MSP, the Minister for Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change. Alongside him are Laurence Kenney, who is the strategic transport projects review project manager at Transport Scotland, and Hugh Gillies, who is the development management and strategic road safety manager at Transport Scotland. Mike Rumbles, the local constituency MSP, has expressed support for the petition over a considerable period. I welcome him to the meeting.I invite the minister to make some opening remarks to the committee, after which I will invite committee members and Mr Rumbles to ask questions.15:15

The Minister for Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change Stewart Stevenson
link

Thank you for inviting me to address the petition today. The petitioner, Jill Campbell, is in the gallery. I commend her for her efforts on behalf of her community on a matter that is of interest to them.Safety on the trunk road network is of paramount importance to the Government, which is why it was one of the top items in the outputs from our strategic transport projects review. Safety was project number 1. The STPR was a robust look across Scotland’s road network at its requirements for the years to come. The STPR appraisal process gave specific consideration to the case for grade separation of the southern Laurencekirk-Marykirk junction. Road safety measures were introduced there in 2005, with further measures following in 2007 and 2008, which have resulted in improved accident statistics at the location. Therefore, the STPR did not consider that grade separation was necessary at that time. Our strategic priorities in relation to the A90 south of Aberdeen focus instead on reducing accident rates and achieving national targets for casualty reductions by delivering the strategic road safety plan and proposed safety measures—the first of the STPR interventions.Although the number of accidents at the southern junction fell between 2005 and 2008, the number of accidents at the middle and north junctions increased. After meeting local campaigners at two meetings in February 2009, I instructed a further accident investigation and prevention study to cover all three junctions. All the recommendations that were made after that investigation were accepted and are being programmed for implementation during the course of this year.Following the fatal accident in September 2009 at the A90-A937 north junction with Laurencekirk, officials from Transport Scotland and Grampian Police met to discuss the circumstances of that accident, and our trunk road operating company has conducted a safety review. I believe that the actions that have been taken and the improvements that have been made in respect of Laurencekirk clearly illustrate that its safety record continues to be monitored to determine what further mitigation measures may be required. That is a key part of the STPR.We have had a substantial exchange of correspondence with Jill Campbell over recent times, which has led me to the conclusion that it would be appropriate for us to offer her the opportunity to meet officials to discuss all the detail that has underpinned recent work so that we can more rapidly reach a shared understanding of what has been done. We may or may not share the conclusions that follow, but that would nonetheless be a useful thing to do, so I hope that she will feel able to take up that offer.Mention has been made of Aberdeenshire Council’s plans for development at Laurencekirk. Clearly, those plans necessarily involve reconsideration of road capacity and the associated network layout at Laurencekirk. Through Transport Scotland, we are already engaging with Aberdeenshire Council to discuss the implications of its plans, and that engagement with the council will continue as part of the planning process. Indeed, this week we have provided input to the council on its plans that suggests strongly that, if the plans are brought to fruition, the volume of traffic in the Laurencekirk area will require the introduction of grade-separated junctions.I am happy to answer any questions that the committee and its visitors may have.

The Convener
link

Thank you, minister. I invite questions from committee members initially, although I know that Mr Rumbles will want to ask some questions as well.

Nanette Milne North East Scotland) (Con
link

My colleague, Alex Johnstone, sends his apologies because he is unable to be here today. He was keen to attend the meeting.The local community still feels that a grade-separated junction is necessary, whatever the minister has just said. I know that you have received correspondence from Alex Johnstone, suggesting the possibility of including an upgraded junction at Laurencekirk in the contract and funding arrangements for the Aberdeen western peripheral route. Would you like to comment on that, minister?

Stewart Stevenson
link

As I said in my opening remarks, we envisage that the approximately 1,000 houses that are in prospect for Laurencekirk will mean an increase in local traffic that is very likely to require at least one grade-separated junction. As the situation is examined more closely, it might be that there is a need for more than one. The normal process for funding such changes to the road network that derive from such increased traffic would involve the developers in providing finance. That is the proper way in which to go about securing funding for a grade-separated junction in such circumstances.

The Convener
link

I invite Mike Rumbles to say a few words.

Mike Rumbles West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine) (LD
link

Thank you for allowing me to speak to the committee today. I also thank the minister for coming to speak at the committee’s request.There are a number of issues that must be raised. First, contrary to what the minister has said, Transport Scotland’s published figures show that, in the three years prior to the short-term safety measures that were implemented in 2005, there were only two fatal and serious accidents. However, from 2006 and 2008—the following three years—there were five. Last year, there was another fatal accident.The most important point relating to this matter has not yet been touched on. Let me put to one side for a moment the terrible human cost of the accidents and talk instead about money. All along, the minister has said that there is not enough money in the budget and that it would cost too much to install a grade-separated junction at Laurencekirk. However, the facts should speak for themselves. The figures from Grampian Police and updated figures from the Scottish Government show that it costs all sorts of agencies—the police, the fire service, the ambulance service, the local authorities and so on—a combined sum of more than £2 million to deal with the aftermath of a fatality, and £250,000 to deal with a serious injury. Using those figures, we can see that it has cost the taxpayer £4.3 million to deal with the aftermath of the disasters around Laurencekirk in the past three or four years.The letter that Transport Scotland wrote to the clerk of the Public Petitions Committee on behalf of the Scottish Government in advance of this meeting includes an answer that was given by Stewart Stevenson in response to one of my parliamentary questions. In it, the minister said:“a grade-separated junction with a dual carriageway such as the A90 is typically in the range of £4.3 million to £22 million”—Official Report, Written Answers, 8 October 2009; S3W-8082.That gives the impression that installing such a junction could cost up to £22 million. However, page 24 of the “A90 Laurencekirk Road Safety Review” by BEAR Scotland, on behalf of Transport Scotland, on behalf of the Scottish Government, says quite clearly that“a grade separated junction would cost in the region of £4m to construct”at Laurencekirk. It also says that it would cost a further £600,000 to close the two central reservations. That means that we are talking about a sum of £4.6 million. That document is dated October 2009.In terms of joined-up government and best value for taxpayers’ money—again, leaving aside the issue of the human cost, which is the most important point—I find it inconceivable that we could have built a junction at Laurencekirk for £4.6 million, which would have recouped its cost in the past three years, but have not done so. That is the nub of my question to the minister. I hope that he will not say that there is not enough money in his departmental budget, because we should, as guardians of the public purse, consider the whole expenditure of all departments of the Scottish Government and recognise that this is a win-win situation. It would be a win for local people, as they would not be threatened with death and destruction as they cross this terrible junction, and it would be a win for drivers passing through the area on the road, as it would be safer to do so. It would also be a win for the taxpayer, because it will save money in the long run. However, a grade-separated junction at Laurencekirk is not even in the projections for the future.Never mind the human cost—the Government’s position represents a massive waste of taxpayers’ money, and I would like the minister to address that point.

The Convener
link

Minister, you may respond to the points that have been raised.

Stewart Stevenson
link

I will start by speaking about costs. It is nearly 10 years since we have successfully completed a project to build a grade-separated junction for £4 million or less. In any event, the figure of £4 million is a 2002 price. It is useful to make a comparison with the Forth replacement crossing project, in which the bridge accounts for only £1 billion of the £2.3 billion total cost. Similarly, the cost of a project to construct a grade-separated junction on any road is substantially more than the cost of the bridge over the road as land acquisition must also be paid for, as must planning costs, changes to the road network in the vicinity and so on. The cost of between £4 million and £22 million, which is based on the cost of grade-separated junctions that were built over a 10-year period, is factually correct. The £4 million that was referred to in a document that was produced by a road-operating company is based on 2002 figures, and concerns the bridge alone.I will make a more general point. The most recent annual fatalities figure for Scotland’s road network is 271. Every life that we lose on our roads is an unnecessary loss of life. We will seek to eliminate every cause of accident on our roads that derives from old architecture. Slightly less than one third of fatalities result from accidents in which road design is a contributing factor. We take such issues seriously, which is why the STPR’s top priority for our road network are investments that will improve the safety of roads where there is an identified problem.Mr Rumbles also mentioned figures that he has before him. I think that we are drawing the numbers from the same database—we use the police database—but I have to say that the answers that one gets depend on the questions that one asks. I recall that the first question that Mr Rumbles asked me was about how many accidents there had been at the southern junction, and he was given the answer that is in the database. Subsequently, the petitioner made a request under the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002 seeking information about the stretch of road at Laurencekirk, which produced a different and higher figure.With regard to fatalities at the three junctions in the vicinity of Laurencekirk, my figures say that there was one fatality in 2009, one in 2003 and two in 2001. Going back to 1999, that is it. In the period from 2006-08, there were nine accidents at the junctions and four accidents on the link sections.I absolutely accept that we must address road architecture, where it is a contributing cause of accidents. In very short order, as a result of the work that we did earlier this year, we are putting in place the sort of measures that led to a five-year period in which there were no fatalities after they had been installed at the southern junction. That is the sort of intervention that makes a real difference in terms of road safety, can be done relatively quickly and delivers real value.

Mike Rumbles West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine) (LD
link

Can I follow up—

The Convener
link

I want to let members of the committee speak, then you can come back in.

Mike Rumbles West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine) (LD
link

I want to make one point, because some of the information that you have heard is wrong.

The Convener
link

I will allow you to speak after we have heard from committee members.

Bill Butler Glasgow Anniesland) (Lab
link

These are serious matters, and the evidence base is obviously key.Mr Rumbles said that fatal accidents have more than doubled at the location. Have they or have they not?15:30

Stewart Stevenson
link

To answer that question immediately, at the three junctions—it is proper to look at the three junctions—there has been one fatal injury in recent times, in 2009. The previous one was in 2003 and there were two in 2001. My table goes back to 1999, so in the period from 1999 to the end of October 2009, there were a total of four fatalities at the three junctions at Laurencekirk. If you want to look at the southern junction alone, all were at that junction, with the exception of the most recent fatality, so there have been three at the southern junction.

Bill Butler Glasgow Anniesland) (Lab
link

What is the total figure?

Stewart Stevenson
link

The total is four from 1999 to 10/12ths of the way through 2009. There have not been any others since, but I want to be strictly accurate because there are other parts of the table.

Bill Butler Glasgow Anniesland) (Lab
link

Okay. What you are saying is clear.Secondly, Mr Rumbles said that the cost of an improvement such as the one that the petition is asking for at Laurencekirk would be £4.6 million, £600,000 of which would be to close the central reservations. In reply, you said that he was using 2002 figures and that the cost of a grade-separated junction would be in a range from £4 million to £22 million. If what you are saying is correct, where in that range would such a grade-separated junction at Laurencekirk fall? Can you give us your approximation and that of your officials?

Stewart Stevenson
link

Forgive me, convener, if I do not give an exact figure. I will say, following the discussions that we have had with Aberdeenshire Council on the development of Laurencekirk, that approximately 885 additional houses are proposed and there are 200 in the existing plan, so somewhat over a thousand houses are in prospect.

Bill Butler Glasgow Anniesland) (Lab
link

I just want your best estimation, giving the range from 880 houses to a thousand houses, because that would obviously have an impact.

Stewart Stevenson
link

I understand why you are pushing me on the issue. This is at a very early stage and, to some extent, the answer will depend on where in the town the council concludes that the extra housing should be built—whether it is to the north or the south. I was developing my point to say that what we are saying to the council is that at the moment our view is that it is likely that two grade-separated junctions would be required against that sort of development. We have not designed these junctions, because they can be designed only when the capacities that each will be required to meet are known. There are, of course, other roads. Given that there are three junctions at Laurencekirk, should the third junction be closed, thereby diverting traffic? If there were to be two grade-separated junctions, that would probably be the case. It is clear that the kind of junctions that would have to put in are likely to be at the mid-point of the range that we have outlined, but I want to make it clear that that is the minister speaking; it is not the officials telling me that that is the figure that they have worked out. However, looking at the complexity of the junctions that we have built that are in the £4 million to £22 million range, that would be my judgment.

Bill Butler Glasgow Anniesland) (Lab
link

So your judgment, speaking for the Government, is that the cost would be £11 million.

Stewart Stevenson
link

Yes, but times two, because we are talking about two grade-separated junctions. If you were building only a single grade-separated junction, the design would clearly be different from what it would be if there were two.

Bill Butler Glasgow Anniesland) (Lab
link

With the convener’s indulgence, has this been—what is the right phrase?—modelled—

Stewart Stevenson
link

Do you mean are these officials’ figures? No, they are not.

Bill Butler Glasgow Anniesland) (Lab
link

Have the figures been in any way modelled by officials? Have they been modelled in the sense that it has been calculated that, if the housing finished at a certain point, you would need one grade-separated junction, and if it finished at another point, you would need two, or are you simply making an approximation?

Stewart Stevenson
link

Let me be clear, because if I have misled the committee—

Bill Butler Glasgow Anniesland) (Lab
link

I am not saying that there has been any misleading. Minister, remember that I am a words teacher, not a sums teacher, so I need greater clarity and more narrative.

Stewart Stevenson
link

We believe that the 200 or so houses that are in the existing plan are within the capability of the existing road network, so the issue is really to do with the proposed additional 885 houses. However, there would clearly be an interaction between those 885 houses and the 200 that are in the existing plan. Exactly where the houses are built, whether to the north or to the south, will determine the nature of that interaction. There will be a trigger point—beyond the 200 new houses, we think, but well within the 885—at which grade-separated junctions will be required, given our understanding of the traffic flows in the Laurencekirk area. However, the solutions will depend on a variety of decisions that are as yet unmade. Our clear advice to the council is that, if it authorises the additional development that is envisaged in the draft plan, grade-separated junctions will be required. Our preliminary view is that two grade-separate junctions would be required.

Rhona Brankin
link

Minister, you said that there have been four fatalities. How many accidents have there been?

Stewart Stevenson
link

I am entirely happy to share these numbers with the committee and to pass them to the clerk for distribution. I think that they are probably already in the public domain.At the three junctions—I will continue, unless requested to do otherwise, to talk about the three junctions as that seems the relevant thing to do—there were 15 serious accidents over the period 1999 to the end of October 2009. Over that period, there were also 22 slight accidents. Therefore, a total of 41 accidents took place at the three junctions over those 11 calendar years, one of which is slightly truncated.

Rhona Brankin
link

On the criteria that are required in order to consider grade separation, mention has been made of housing volume—which affects the number of people using the roads—and future increases in housing. How does the number of accidents fit into the criteria for grade separation? Are only fatalities taken into consideration, or are serious accidents also considered?

Stewart Stevenson
link

Everything is taken into consideration. Our consideration of grade-separated junctions is based not simply on housing numbers but on a range of factors—

Rhona Brankin
link

Housing is just one factor.

Stewart Stevenson
link

Correct. That is exactly the point that I wished to make.We automatically consider grade separation in areas where there have been three fatal or serious accidents in three years, but that does not mean that we do not consider other circumstances as well. Part of the road operating companies’ duties is to draw to our attention risks that have not yet crystallised into accidents. In the part of the road network that we are discussing, we have just completed a special survey on the behaviour of drivers and the potential risks that are created by the design of the road network at those three junctions where people join the A90 from Laurencekirk or from the eastern side. On the back of that, during the course of this calendar year we will bring forward interventions to supplement those that the previous transport minister successfully implemented in 2005, which led to there being no fatalities until the one that occurred in the second half of last year. We have carried out those studies without regard to the necessity for a triggering number of accidents.

Rhona Brankin
link

It occurs to me that 15 serious accidents and 22 slight accidents is quite a high number. How does that compare?

Stewart Stevenson
link

I accept that one accident is one too many. However, I would not say that these numbers are particularly high. Slight accidents are precisely that: slight. We have to be very careful about trade-offs—

Rhona Brankin
link

I was thinking more about the 15 serious accidents. That seems to be a lot.

Stewart Stevenson
link

That is a significant number across the three junctions. However, on the southern junction, to which improvements have been made, there have been only three such accidents over the period. Given, as I said in my opening remarks, the number of accidents at the two junctions that were not improved in 2005 by the previous minister—and, by the way, I should say that what the previous minister did then appears to have been perfectly proper—I have felt it only proper to look at the whole interaction between the three junctions at Laurencekirk and the A90. We also put in place cameras to observe driver behaviours and to find out whether there are any observational difficulties to which we might have to respond. We are responding to these matters—and rightly so.As an aside, the Swedes have begun to introduce roundabouts, which historically they had not used, after a lot of very serious accidents at the many traffic lights in Sweden. Although the number of accidents has risen dramatically, the number of serious and fatal accidents has dropped like a stone. Now they are introducing slow speed bumps. Sometimes there is a trade-off with the kind of accidents that happen, although I expect that, in Sweden, there will be fewer accidents as people get used to roundabouts and things begin to happen differently. The interaction between road design and driver behaviour is sometimes quite subtle.

Nigel Don North East Scotland) (SNP
link

Speaking as a local representative among the others sitting around the table, I want to make it clear that I will never be happy with a junction that causes fatalities. However, I was interested in the way that the minister put the issue in perspective when he said that in the most recent year there were 272 fatalities in Scotland. That goes some way to explaining why the Government’s priority might have been to put money in other places. I suppose that we should respect that decision, but the trouble is that, as local representatives and with local residents behind us, we are never going to be happy with it.With regard to the minister’s comment about roundabouts and things, I cannot help observing that we have got used to the idea of grade-separated junctions on high-speed roads, which might mean that some of us are not as good as we used to be at changing lanes, sitting in the centre and waiting for the right moment. Perhaps because such junctions are now relatively rare they appear to us to be more dangerous.Can the minister estimate when the timetable for introducing grade-separated junctions in the Laurencekirk area might be produced? I just do not think that local residents will feel that the road is as safe as it should be until they are introduced.

Stewart Stevenson
link

We need to be careful with regard to Mr Don’s opening comment that junctions cause fatalities. Fatalities happen at junctions, but they may or may not be caused by the junction. I am not referring to any specific accident or junction, but the fact is that road design contributes to only about one third—or at least well under a half—of accidents in Scotland. In other words, a shrinking proportion of accidents are caused by road design.It is worth pointing out that over the past 20 years, traffic levels in the Laurencekirk area have risen by 19 per cent while the accident level has diminished to some extent. Interruption. I beg your pardon—I have just been corrected, which is why I looked to my official. Traffic levels have risen by 19 per cent over the past 10 years. I should also point out that there have been 271, not 272, fatal accidents.As for when we might see grade-separated junctions at Laurencekirk driven by housing developments, that will depend to some extent on the housing developments. We normally expect developers to pay for changes to the road network that are driven by housing developments. That is certainly the case near Ayr, where housing developments will contribute more than £70 million to the road network. Laurencekirk is an attractive place in which to live and work, and from which to commute. As the economy recovers, and with the opening of Laurencekirk railway station, traffic will continue to grow in the area. That will form part of the process by which we continue to examine what is required there.15:45

Nigel Don North East Scotland) (SNP
link

I would like to extend the minister’s point, as I wonder about the timetabling of such developments. I suspect that once a developer had planning permission to build a number of houses around Laurencekirk, it could probably get them up and occupiable within a year. Getting planning permission is always an issue, but once it has been secured the engineering can be done within that timescale. However, I am pretty sure that a substantial alteration to the road network could not be made within that timescale; that is certainly true of a grade-separated junction. At what point do the appropriate authorities build the road network ahead of the houses, once they know that they are coming?

Stewart Stevenson
link

It is worth making the point that, in the present legal environment, the finance from the developer would be tied to planning permission through a section 75 agreement. That is what happens around Scotland. The important point is to get the finance in place so that the road network is adapted to meet need. As the minister responsible for planning, I am not quite as confident as Nigel Don is that the completion of a certain number of houses is likely within one year. In any event, we are talking about the next iteration of Aberdeenshire’s plan—it is not yet the case that someone has come forward with an application for planning permission to build houses.

The Convener
link

I am conscious of the time and know that Mr Rumbles would like to respond to one or two comments.

Mike Rumbles West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine) (LD
link

I am rather frustrated by this process, but I thank the convener for bringing me back in. I am disappointed by the generalisations that we have heard. I would have been much happier if the minister had used his own material—the Government publication that appeared in October 2009. Never mind the generalisations; let us get to the specifics. I challenge the minister on the issue and repeat what I said earlier: his report says that it would cost £4 million to construct a grade-separated junction at Laurencekirk. The minister made a generalisation to obscure that point. He said that because the figure is from 2002 and is out of date, the cost could be up to £20 million and two junctions could be needed. That has clouded the issue.I want to make clear what the petitioners are seeking. The Government’s report says that it would cost £4 million to construct the grade-separated junction. Later in the report, there is discussion of a roundabout; I make that point to ensure that everyone is clear and that there is no clouding of the picture. It would cost only £1 million to acquire the land for and to build a roundabout. The whole grade-separated junction would cost £4 million. That is the latest figure, produced by the Government, and includes the £600,000 to close the central reservations.

Stewart Stevenson
link

No.

Mike Rumbles West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine) (LD
link

I am also frustrated by the Government’s use of its figures for accident rates. Several times the minister said—I wrote it down—that accident rates have improved, but they have not. According to the Government’s figures, in the three years before the introduction of the 2005 safety measures, there were two fatal and serious accidents; Bill Butler asked about that. In the three years after the measures were introduced, there were five serious accidents. In the past year, there has been another fatal accident. Accident rates are increasing, not decreasing.The minister implied that, for any change to happen at Laurencekirk, we must wait for the structure plan to be accepted and for private developers to develop houses in the many years ahead. The Government has no plan to make the money available.The point that I am trying to make to the committee and to the minister is that, using today’s costs, all the accidents will have cost the taxpayer £12 million. To me, this is a no-brainer. Everybody would win if the minister would only turn round and say, “We’ll spend £4.6 million to save lives and to save the public purse.” If he did, we would not have the accidents three years from now that we currently have at the Laurencekirk junction, and the Government and the taxpayer would save money. That is the key point.I have come to this committee before on behalf of Jill Campbell and the other campaigners. Eight thousand people from Laurencekirk and the Mearns have signed the petition—it is a really big issue in the area. Construction of a grade-separated junction is a no-brainer for everybody I speak to. It would be a win-win situation for everybody involved, but all we have had from the Government is generalisations. I am really frustrated that the minister has not used his own report, which was published in October 2009. He has made generalisations from the report’s elements, but let us get to the specifics: please can we have an answer as to why the Government will not spend £4.6 million of Government money on a spend-to-save initiative that will save millions of pounds for the taxpayer and, incidentally, save lives and prevent more of the carnage that has already happened?

The Convener
link

Right. Minister, I know that you want to respond, so I will give you the chance to do so.

Stewart Stevenson
link

It is unhelpful if Mr Rumbles appears to mislead the committee. The numbers that I have quoted are from Grampian Police’s letter to the committee. The report to which Mr Rumbles referred is not a Government report; it was produced by a road operating company, without its having done any research into costs.

Mike Rumbles West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine) (LD
link

I hold up Mr Stevenson’s report so that the committee can see it.

Stewart Stevenson
link

It is not the Government’s report, and nothing that Mr Rumbles says on the matter can convert a report by a road operating company, with a speculative number in it, into a Government report—it is not a Government report.

Mike Rumbles West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine) (LD
link

The report is from Transport Scotland.

Stewart Stevenson
link

Ah! The report was produced for Transport Scotland.

Mike Rumbles West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine) (LD
link

Which is your agency.

The Convener
link

Sorry, Mike, but we would like to hear from the minister. On you go, minister.

Stewart Stevenson
link

I accept that the report was produced for Transport Scotland, but it is not Transport Scotland’s report, the minister’s report or the Government’s report. Mr Rumbles simply cannot wish away what the real costs would be for what he wants. I think that I can say without a shadow of doubt that it cannot be done for £4.6 million. All the history and the recent figures on what grade-separated junctions cost indicate that it would cost substantially more than that. Further, if Mr Rumbles has accident figures that are different from those that the police have provided—

Mike Rumbles West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine) (LD
link

They are your figures.

Stewart Stevenson
link

The figures that I am quoting are the same as the police’s figures.

Mike Rumbles West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine) (LD
link

They are from Transport Scotland, which is your agency.

Stewart Stevenson
link

I am sorry, convener, but—

The Convener
link

The minister has indicated his position on the contested figures. If he puts them to us, as he said he would, we will be happy with that.

Stewart Stevenson
link

I will do. Can I just close the issue by saying this, convener? If I am wrong, I will come back and accept that I am wrong. I just do not know where the error is coming from, because I am quoting the figures that the police supplied to the committee in the letter of 29 March 2009. I am looking at the numbers: they are the same.

The Convener
link

Okay.

Bill Butler Glasgow Anniesland) (Lab
link

I am starting to have difficulty here as a simple words teacher, because you are using numbers again, minister. I want to ask you what seems to me to be a straightforward question. Accepting the fact that the report to which Mr Rumbles referred was produced by a road operator for Transport Scotland, do you dispute the report’s conclusions? If you do, do you disavow them?

Stewart Stevenson
link

The project to deliver a grade-separated junction at Laurencekirk cannot be done for £4 million. I say that because we are certain that that costing does not take account of, for example, land acquisition or planning costs. A range of costs are not included in that figure, forby we do not think that the figure is deliverable.

Bill Butler Glasgow Anniesland) (Lab
link

So are you saying that the report’s conclusions are not resilient and do not bear scrutiny?

Stewart Stevenson
link

To be fair to BEAR, it added a figure that it did not research itself—it considered some figures that had been produced elsewhere. No design and no conclusions have been reached. Furthermore, the figure refers only to a single grade-separated junction, and we are considering the necessity for two.

Bill Butler Glasgow Anniesland) (Lab
link

What standing, if any, does the report that was produced by BEAR for Transport Scotland have, in the Government’s view? Does it have no standing whatever? Is that what you are saying?

Stewart Stevenson
link

It is a report to inform the work of Transport Scotland, and as such it reflects the operating experience of the road operating company. The £4 million figure that is quoted for a grade-separated junction was not put forward by BEAR as a robust figure.

Bill Butler Glasgow Anniesland) (Lab
link

Why did BEAR put it forward, then?

Stewart Stevenson
link

Let me quote what BEAR Scotland said yesterday:“With hindsight, although this was understood by those drafting the report and the main readership (i.e. TS) further caveating of the figures would have ensured that this was obvious to external parties who take access to the report ... It was recognised ... that a feasibility study into these options was not to be carried out and that broad brush cost estimates were to be used for comparison purposes.”

Bill Butler Glasgow Anniesland) (Lab
link

Sure, but if BEAR gave such “broad brush” estimates, what validity do they have, even in making a broad comparison? Surely they are useless.

Stewart Stevenson
link

BEAR is saying that, for the purposes of taking consideration forward, the necessary work must be carried out to understand what design of junction is required and what the costs would be. The experience over the past 10 years shows that such junctions cost as little as £4 million—although we have not successfully done one of those for nearly 10 years—and as much as £22 million.

Bill Butler Glasgow Anniesland) (Lab
link

Should Transport Scotland have sought a report from BEAR—which obviously costs money—knowing that it would basically be useless? That is what you are saying, minister.

Stewart Stevenson
link

No. That is a very small part of an overall report. The report is about what is happening at the junction. The important thing is to examine the behaviours of drivers and the incidents, accidents, serious accidents and fatalities at the three junctions in the area of Laurencekirk, and to develop from that the appropriate response to improve the performance of the junction—as we have now done. The work will be done over the course of this year. It builds on the work that successfully addressed the accident figures at the southern junction, which was previously the focus of attention. The last fatality there was in 2004. We are now considering the three junctions together, and we seek to deliver similar improvements in the operation of all the junctions to Laurencekirk.

Bill Butler Glasgow Anniesland) (Lab
link

What is the timescale for delivery?

Stewart Stevenson
link

We will complete the work before summer is out.

Bill Butler Glasgow Anniesland) (Lab
link

Thank you, minister—I think.

The Convener
link

Are there any other questions or comments from members? The committee has spent a fair amount of time on the issue.

Stewart Stevenson
link

May I make some brief concluding remarks? They will be brief. We see the need to have absolute clarity on the factual basis of the matter. It will be useful if Jill Campbell can sit down with Transport Scotland and go through the detail of why we have got to where we are. It is entirely for the committee to come to its own conclusions, but I suggest that she would be unlikely to be comfortable with your closing the petition today—were you even to think of doing so—until the process is complete. I think that that is the right way forward as the next, but not necessarily the final, step.16:00

The Convener
link

Two or three issues arise from what we have heard. We would like written submissions to provide clarity on the statistics that have been bounced about. If committee members contest those statistics, I am happy to receive those submissions so that we can deal with the issues.The minister has extended an invitation to Jill Campbell. If she takes up that invitation, the committee would, obviously, appreciate an update on the discussion that takes place and the points that are identified in it.On Bill Butler’s points, it would be useful to clarify the confidence that there is in achieving the delivery timescale that has been discussed.We want to keep the petition open until those things are concluded. Have I missed out any points in that summary?

Rhona Brankin
link

Like many people, I have driven on the road in question over a number of years, and I find the junction difficult and challenging. I always approach it with great care, because I am aware of the accidents and fatalities that have occurred around it. I support keeping the petition open until we get clarity on the statistics.

Bill Butler Glasgow Anniesland) (Lab
link

I, too, support keeping the petition open. The minister’s offer of a meeting involving him, his officials and the petitioner could be productive, and that option should be explored. Perhaps it is just in my mind—or what passes for my mind—that the different statistics that the minister and Mr Rumbles have advanced could be clarified. That may be possible.

Mike Rumbles West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine) (LD
link

On that point, the statistics are the minister’s statistics. There is no dispute about them, but the minister is interpreting them slightly differently from how I am interpreting them. The statistics exist, and the committee already has them.

The Convener
link

The minister and Mike Rumbles have expressed opinions. If the figures are contested, they should be furnished to members of the committee. We will then arrive at a judgment.

Mike Rumbles West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine) (LD
link

I hope that the committee has a copy of the report that we are discussing. I am not quoting my own statistics; the facts are in a report for the Government.

John Wilson
link

I want to make a suggestion to the minister that I hope will be helpful. Transport Scotland should be more careful in future about the reports that it receives from operators, and it should ensure that they contain factual information. Our difficulty is that we have not only different interpretations of the statistics that are before us but different interpretations of the report that BEAR Scotland produced. In future, it would be useful if the Government ensured that reports that are commissioned or produced for Government departments accurately reflect the costs and implications of proposed changes.

The Convener
link

I am conscious that the discussion on the petition has been lengthy, and I appreciate the forbearance of Jill Campbell and her family, for whom the matter is obviously sensitive. I hope that we can continue to keep the matter open and explore issues that the constituency member and committee members have raised.I thank the minister and his officials for their attendance.

  1. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  2. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 42
  3. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 88
  4. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 12
  5. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 9
  6. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 6
  7. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 7
  8. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 6
  9. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  10. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  11. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  12. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 13
  13. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  14. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 13
  15. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  16. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 9
  17. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  18. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  19. 14:00 New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 1

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.