Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Current Petitions

Social Rented Housing (Standards) (PE1189)

Tuesday 2 March 2010 Public Petitions Committee About 14:00 Petitions 42 contributions · 11 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

42 contributions
The Convener
link

The first petition for our consideration is PE1189, by Anne Lear, whom I welcome to the meeting, on behalf of Govanhill Housing Association, calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Government to conduct an inquiry into the responsibilities of private landlords, the levels of social housing that are below tolerable standard, the impact that slum living conditions have on the health and wellbeing of residents and the wider community, and whether such conditions should merit housing renewal area status and additional Scottish Government funding.I welcome to the meeting Alex Neil, the Minister for Housing and Communities. From Glasgow City Council, as a substitute for council leader Steven Purcell, we have Phil Braat. I thank him for filling in at late notice. We also have Tom Warren from the Govanhill residents group and Hamish Battye, head of planning and health improvement in NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde. I thank you all for giving your time this afternoon. I know that one or two of you have been in front of the committee before. I should put it on record that I have an interest in that I represent Govanhill in the Scottish Parliament. There are also regional list members with responsibility for Glasgow who have expressed interest in the petition in the past.As you will know, we want to pull together key individuals in the community and in the Government’s and the council’s decision-making process on the issue of the continuing challenges in Govanhill. I will invite comments or suggestions from committee members, which people can then take up. To get a sense of the reality on the ground, I will invite Anne Lear to express the views that she and Tom Warren receive daily in Govanhill. First, though, we will have comments from committee members.14:15

Anne McLaughlin Glasgow) (SNP
link

I will come in again later, but I want to start by welcoming everybody. All committee members have been in Govanhill before, but the recent visit by three of us was very useful, and a very interesting discussion arose from it. I also welcome to the gallery members of Croftfoot housing action group, who have problems in their area that are similar to those in Govanhill.We are all genuinely concerned about unravelling where the problems come from and what we can do at local authority and Scottish Government levels to resolve them. What is needed and what is not happening that could happen? It will be useful to hear what everyone has to say, but I will start with a question to Councillor Braat on the enforcement of existing legislation. There are areas of legislation that need to be tightened up and which will be tightened up. However, my concern is that existing legislation is perhaps not being used as properly as it could be with, for example, private landlords—oh, I should declare an interest at this point, because I am a private landlord. I am not an entrepreneurial one, but I rent out a flat of mine. I think that I was supposed to mention that at the beginning. The flat is in very good condition and has a jolly good, expensive new boiler.

The Minister for Housing and Communities Alex Neil
link

I hope that you have registered the flat.

The Convener
link

We will need to toughen up that register, minister.

Anne McLaughlin Glasgow) (SNP
link

Well, I can tell you how easy it is to register as a private landlord.Anyway, on private landlords, the issues of communal repairs and the power to issue work notices to carry those out are huge issues for people in Govanhill and Croftfoot. Home owners look after their own homes, but their buildings fall into disrepair because private landlords refuse to get involved in communal repairs. What issues do you face that prevent you from issuing a work notice whereby, as I understand it, the council can carry out work and reclaim costs from private landlords? Does the legislation need to be tightened up? Do you need to put in more resources at your end to ensure that private landlords comply with the legislation? What are the main issues around that?

Councillor Philip Braat Glasgow City Council
link

Thank your very much for your questions, which raised a few key elements. The council has put a significant amount of resources into Govanhill. Through the private sector housing grant, we will have put in approximately £7 million over this and the next financial year. That is a combination of council money and money from private owners who contribute voluntarily. The resources for Govanhill equate to between a quarter and a third of the budget for Glasgow. As everyone around the table will know, resources are very limited at the moment. We are working to the best of our ability within the restricted budget that we have. From the council’s point of view, I do not think that we can contribute anything further at the moment. However, we are considering extending the proposed surveys and works, specifically in the Calder Street area, which could take the resources up to £10 million. It would be fantastic if the minister and the Government could contribute further finances, although I obviously understand the constraints on both the Government and the council.The point about landlord registration is a good one. It is crucial to make it clear that we are not just talking about bricks and mortar—the buildings—as there is also a whole social aspect to the matter. From the various physical and social surveys that have been carried out, we have noticed that more than 60 per cent of properties in Govanhill are in the private sector. There is a distinction between registered landlords, such as Anne McLaughlin, and unregistered landlords, and we need to tackle the situation with unregistered landlords. Anne McLaughlin referred to legislation. In response to the consultation on the draft housing bill, we proposed an increase in the penalty for unregistered landlords to £20,000, which would be very welcome.There are other things that we could do. About a quarter of the approximately 2,000 private sector landlords are unregistered, but the problems stem not only from the unregistered landlords but from the registered ones. We need to tighten up the legislation. We have had some commitment from the Government on certain points in the Housing (Scotland) Bill—the proposed increase in the penalty for unregistered landlords is an example—but our proposal with regard to the private rented housing panel has been rejected at this stage, although we hope that that can be reconsidered. The council has two serious concerns. We are aware that the population in Govanhill is very diverse, with a high level of ethnic diversity. There are people from perhaps 51 different ethnicities there. Many people will not be au fait with English as a first language, and some of them will not be able to cross the language barrier at first. It is more difficult for those individuals to make a complaint against a landlord. We feel that no public agency can take that on, currently. We want the panel to be able to pursue the landlord should the landlord wish to take a matter to court on appeal. We find it completely unacceptable that no public agency can pursue matters on behalf of the tenant.In the first instance, the tenant will be reticent about making a complaint, given language barriers, for instance. Some will have fled from an authoritarian state, and they might automatically have a fear of authority and authority figures. For people in that situation, there is a gap that the panel, the local authority or any other interested public body should step in to fill by taking on issues on behalf of the tenants.As things stand, we still foresee problems in cases where a tenant is prepared to make a complaint about a landlord. Because of the nature of the private rented housing panel, it cannot defend the appeal in court. The onus would rest on the tenant who did not wish to complain about the state of their living conditions in the first place. We therefore want an overhaul of the panel regulations so that the local authority or the panel could step in and defend the appeal by the landlord.It is not an issue of poverty, specifically, but many people will not have the financial acumen to take on a landlord. That is another barrier that prevents people from taking such matters on.

Anne McLaughlin Glasgow) (SNP
link

All that information is useful. I am not easily shocked and I have seen some terrible things but, when we visited Govanhill, I was horrified by the living conditions that some people must put up with. We all felt the same—it was a disgrace.I return to the issue that I want to get to the root of. If a close that is falling apart has four home owners and two private landlords and the home owners are prepared to pay for the communal repairs but the private landlords are not, legislation gives you the power to issue a work notice, under which the work is done and the council takes money from the parties that are involved. What is the issue with that? Why are such notices not being served as much as they should be? I understand that everybody is constrained, but are you prevented from issuing notices by any issue that could be addressed in legislation? I am not sure whether you have answered that question.

Councillor Braat
link

We are doing the best that we can in the current circumstances and with the resources that we have, but there is always room for improvement—absolutely. We issue repair notices and environmental health notices. You are right about the area, which the minister and I have visited. The conditions there are substandard—that is the least that we can describe them as.Within the confines of the legislation, we are doing our best with repair notices. We are creating a database of properties that will state their condition and ownership and the registration and nature of landlords. When that information is fully compiled, we will establish in conjunction with it a maintenance strategy and plan whereby notices will be issued. We will look to recover moneys from landlords—specifically those who treat renting as a business and who use it seriously as a cash cow, and not individual home owners. We do not intend to give such landlords grant assistance. Repair notices will be pursued and will be flagged up on a property title—at least, that should happen.Once we have collated the information through the database, we intend to ensure that the maintenance programme is followed up. Perhaps that has not happened as much as it could have in the past. We will address that, but we must have the correct data in place. Any further information about unregistered landlords or even serial offenders who are registered landlords will be reported to the landlord registration unit.We are not dealing simply with Govanhill; the council still has responsibility for the rest of the city. We have in place a competent and dedicated unit to deal with matters such as houses in multiple occupation, landlord registration and pest control—you name it. I repeat that, unfortunately, we do not have the financial and manpower resources to invest solely in Govanhill at present. We are doing the best that we can with current resources.

Anne McLaughlin Glasgow) (SNP
link

I think—

The Convener
link

We will return to this, but I invite Tom Warren to speak as a local—

Anne McLaughlin Glasgow) (SNP
link

I was going to say that I would ask questions later and let everybody else have an opportunity to speak now.

The Convener
link

I am sorry for interrupting.Tom Warren is a local resident who has faced particular challenges, because his tenement was a perfect example of neglect and its consequences, particularly for young people such as him in properties. I ask him to give the committee a sense of that. What is his view on how people can pull together? I know that efforts have been made, which have been like a person pushing a boulder uphill when their ankles are shackled to weights. How can we move the issue forward to help the council, the Government and other interested bodies?14:30

Tom Warren Govanhill Residents Group
link

I guess that I fall into the category that Anne McLaughlin mentioned. I am an owner-occupier in a close of eight flats. We are fortunate in that the majority of flats in the close are owner-occupied, but there is a flat that is privately let and we have never had any communication from the landlord. When problems were discovered in the property, we contacted the landlord registration unit in Glasgow at an early stage but, because the landlord was unregistered, it seemed that little could be done to take forward repair notices.There is a question about the resourcing of the landlord registration scheme in Glasgow. Residents in the area have become active in campaigning and there is a big groundswell of people, particularly owner-occupiers, who are keen to work with the council and the housing association to improve the area but, as Frank McAveety said, it is often impossible to make progress. Even with a simple thing such as trying to get gutters cleaned to catch a problem before it is exacerbated and a whole new roof is needed, it seems that the only route is to go through the court. In an area of deprivation and poverty such as Govanhill, that is not going to happen.

The Convener
link

You have had discussions with other concerned local residents who want a better quality of life. Will you give us a sense of the scale of the challenge that you face? In your discussions with professionals in the housing association, the landlord registration unit and so on, what are you looking for? It would help us to get a sense of that so that we can raise the matter with the Government and the council.

Tom Warren Govanhill Residents Group
link

We are looking for some joined-up thinking about how the issues are approached. As well as making physical improvements to the properties, many of which are in a terrible state, it is important to support vulnerable tenants and owner-occupiers through that process, particularly when private tenants have to decamp and move out during the work. We need an action plan for the area so that, when funding is available from the council’s development and regeneration services department or elsewhere, the work is done in a co-ordinated way and the community understands the processes that are being implemented. Much of the frustration arises from the perception that there is no plan and that there is not a single body that is working with the community to make a difference.

The Convener
link

Anne Lear represents Govanhill Housing Association, which has some 40 years’ experience in the neighbourhood. Will you give us a sense of the practical issues and the possible solutions?

Anne Lear Govanhill Housing Association
link

Thank you for inviting me along today, and thank you from Govanhill Housing Association’s management committee, which is watching today’s meeting. We submitted further written evidence to you in February, at which time we put some practical suggestions down on paper. I should say that we have seen a lot of difference in the area in the past 18 months. Thanks must go to the council for directing resources into Govanhill, particularly to the closes. We spend quite a lot of time taking people on walks to look at the green slime down the walls and so on. Those worst examples of housing that is below tolerable standards have now been addressed through the use of repairs notices, and the council is making a concerted effort to deal with that.I agree with Tom Warren that there are some practical issues to be resolved, but we have good ideas about how we should do that. The partners with whom we are working locally are coming together—without any additional financial support, but with the support of Govanhill Community Development Trust, which is a subsidiary of the association—to work together to resolve some of the worst issues. What we need from the local authority and the Government is the political support to make that new example of how to deal with these complex issues work on the ground.It is not as difficult as might be thought, because we are not asking for new resources. Councillor Braat is right to say that the council dedicates approximately £3 million a year; it must take that out of the budget and recover part of it from other owners. A steady budget of that sort would make quite an impact in Govanhill, but there is no commitment to that. The council has made clear that it is concerned that, with a lack of ring fencing for such funding, there will be a problem in getting the resources on the ground to deal with Govanhill.The management committee and local folk in Govanhill accept that Govanhill should not receive all the resources, but we think that it should receive a special status. We would like to discuss that further with the Government and the local authority after today’s meeting. We propose such a status for Govanhill because nowhere else in Scotland has 1,200 unimproved properties, at least 75 per cent of which are owned by the private sector and not regulated, either because legislation does not allow for that or because landlords are not willing to participate in the process. It is a complex problem, but it can be resolved by working in partnership in the local area. We need support from both the Government and the local authority to do that. We have all the partners on the ground with the expertise to do it, but council resources seem to be limiting our ability to deliver a continuous response. We need to discuss the matter further.

The Convener
link

Before hearing from members, I invite Hamish Battye to give us a sense of the issue. I know that the minister is listening. Can you illustrate for us the pressures that are exhibiting themselves in respect of the health board, support services and care services, given the major change in the demographics of part of the community? New communities have emerged in the area, bringing particular sets of problems that are causing significant difficulties in the neighbourhood.

Hamish Battye NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

Thank you for giving me the opportunity to address the committee today. The

south-east Glasgow community health and care partnership is responsible for managing health and social work services in this part of the city. Govanhill is one of the largest neighbourhoods on our patch. In the three and a half years of the CHCP’s existence, we have been aware of the issues relating to access to services in Govanhill. A couple of Roma community development workers have been appointed, and we have other bilingual staff to assist people to access mainstream services.We are aware of the knock-on effects of issues relating to housing such as addiction, antisocial behaviour and community safety. My former director, who left the CHCP last month, was leading a neighbourhood management approach that the council launched in 2008, to bring together all community partners to address wider health and wellbeing issues in the community. An action plan is in place to address issues relating to security, children attending school, close doors and addiction in the area. Those are some of the wider health and wellbeing issues that we are examining in Govanhill.The committee will be aware that the neighbourhood management approach is part of equally well, the Government’s strategy for tackling inequalities in health and wellbeing. We are a test site for the strategy, which has assisted us in evaluating the neighbourhood management approach. We are engaged in that exercise at the moment, to see what effect the approach might have and whether it could be rolled out to other communities and neighbourhoods in Glasgow and Scotland.Govanhill is one of the five priority areas for health and social care in the south-east of Glasgow. We are keen to work with all agencies in the neighbourhood to address the issues that I have highlighted.

The Convener
link

I know that members are keen to ask questions.

Rhona Brankin Midlothian) (Lab
link

Anne Lear mentioned the current regulatory framework and talked about the legislation not allowing for regulation. Will you expand on that? Clearly, there is the issue of implementing the regulations and the constraints on Glasgow City Council in that regard, such as how it can recover funding for doing so. Are there issues to do with regulation? Are there opportunities for change?

Anne Lear Govanhill Housing Association
link

There are two separate issues: the regulatory framework—the legal framework—and the financial framework. The financial framework is not quite in place yet because the council is not using housing renewal areas and the grant levels are not clear to owners in the area. It is not clear how that will operate in the future.The legal framework that you ask about is under scrutiny by the Parliament. The Housing (Scotland) Bill is going through the first stage of consideration. Under the Housing (Scotland) Act 2006, Glasgow City Council has a responsibility to regulate the private sector. Some of the proposals that the council has made have been accepted in the bill, but there are other proposals that will, I think, be included in a consultation document that is coming out in the near future. Those proposals are about registration, access to property and the panel that was discussed earlier. Within that legal framework, there is a series of regulatory measures that would give the council a bigger stick.As far as I am aware, the issue for the council, as it has suggested in its submission to the committee, is that it cannot achieve its priorities with the resources that are available to it. An issue is the number of staff it has who can look at such matters.A big problem in Govanhill that is extremely difficult to deal with is an environmental health issue that we have brought to your attention—pest control. There is a problem with bedbugs, cockroaches and so on. It seems that the community feels that there are not enough resources at local level to deal with the issue. The reason that has been given for that is that it is a problem throughout the city, so Govanhill cannot receive special resources. However, the problem is widespread and is made more complex because of the involvement of landlords. We have problems getting access to people’s houses. All those environmental issues affect people throughout the community equally. They are definitely spreading and they need to be dealt with.We are talking about a combination of resource and legal framework issues. A housing policy and the legal framework for it must be backed up at local level with the resources to implement it. It is not my place to become involved in the debate about where the resources are. We are merely reporting the facts on the ground. At the moment, some basic issues are not being dealt with.

John Wilson Central Scotland) (SNP
link

I thank Anne Lear and her colleagues for the visit for committee members that they hosted, which enabled us to see some of the issues at first hand. I am glad to hear that some of them are being addressed.However, as Anne Lear has just pointed out, there are still fundamental issues, such as cockroach and bedbug infestation, that need to be tackled. As Councillor Braat mentioned, tenants find it difficult to take action against their landlord. A resident whom we visited was facing eviction because she had complained about her landlord. The nature of the tenancy agreement meant that the obvious response was for the landlord to take action to evict the tenant. Such situations bring home the issues that we need to deal with.At this point, I want to bring in the minister. People have mentioned the Housing (Scotland) Bill, which is going through Parliament. In addition, as I understand it, a private sector housing bill will be introduced later this year. What would be the problem in bringing those two bills together to create one comprehensive piece of housing legislation that tackled the private sector issues, so that we would not have to work with two pieces of legislation? Areas of the Housing (Scotland) Bill will deal with some aspects of the private sector, but we will also have a separate bill that deals with other aspects of the private sector. That might lead to confusion. There is currently confusion about the distinctions between the Housing (Scotland) Act 2006, the Antisocial Behaviour etc (Scotland) Act 2004 and the Housing (Scotland) Act 1987. There is confusion about who is responsible for delivering what and what responsibilities landlords have.The other issue that I want to put to the panel is the number of letting agents that exist in Govanhill, which surprised me when I

visited the area. Some members of the committee and the panel are aware of my particular interest in Govanhill—not as a private landlord, I hasten to add; I have family interests in the area. What is the role of the letting agents? My understanding is that, in some cases, the letting agent is a barrier between the landlord and the agencies that want to take action against the landlord. I would be grateful if the panel would address those issues.14:45

The Convener
link

Will you respond specifically to John Wilson’s questions, first, minister? I have a couple of questions, too, but let us see how the discussion goes.

Alex Neil
link

I will first respond specifically to John Wilson’s points and then widen out the discussion after your questions, convener, if that is okay.The reason why we have two housing bills is that each bill is designed to do specific things. We are keen to get the current bill through fairly quickly, because it covers the reform of regulation and of the right to buy. We want to get new council house building going as quickly as possible on as substantial a scale as possible throughout Scotland, and any delay would probably result in a delay in council house building. As long as councils are forced to sell off new stock, they will not build new stock.We need to take our time to ensure that we get the measures relating to private housing correct. Later this month, we are going out to consultation on a range of issues concerning the private housing sector.My view is that once the two bills reach the statute book—as I hope they will—there should be no confusion as to who does what or who is responsible for what. We will issue guidance to ensure that everybody—local authorities, housing associations and tenants—know where their rights and responsibilities lie.I turn to the private sector housing bill. Convener, as you know, the 2006 act introduced significant new powers for local authorities to enforce repairs in a building, especially where there is mixed ownership. To its credit, Glasgow City Council has been using those powers in Govanhill—my understanding from the council is that it has been using them effectively in Govanhill and elsewhere, as local authorities have been doing the length and breadth of Scotland. I have studied carefully the points that Glasgow City Council has made about the powers in the 2006 act not being sufficiently robust to deal with the very difficult situation that we have in Govanhill. I am looking seriously at the council’s recommendations. When we go out to consultation later this month, we will engage in a wider consultation on taking additional powers to deal with rogue landlords.The 2006 act conveyed on local authorities new powers, which Anne McLaughlin mentioned, to ensure that much-needed repairs are done. The council has the power to issue a work notice, carry out the repairs and bill all the owners in the building. However, those powers extend only to repairs and not to improvements, so we want to consult on whether they should be extended to cover improvements. We will also consult on some of the points that Councillor Braat raised.The council and the Government are as one on the need to tackle the problems in Govanhill effectively. I have already given an undertaking that we are prepared to consider the introduction of new legislation with new powers, if that is required, in the private sector housing bill that will go out for consultation later this month.

The Convener
link

I want to follow up on a couple of things. I welcome the Government’s commitment to work in partnership with the council and others; that message needs to be heard at local community level. The outcomes depend on that change of approach.I heard what you said on John Wilson’s point about the role of letting agents. One concern that has been put forward strongly to the committee is the inspection regime and whether houses are fit to be made available for let. That relates also to the regulatory regime for repairs, which hopefully will also deal with improvements, and recovery of the money, because it is a big risk for any local authority to pay out taxpayers’ money when they cannot guarantee that they will get that money back. I do not wish to pre-empt the negotiations and discussion around the housing bill, but it seems that there is a strong sense of the need for inspection.I heard your welcome contribution today on “Good Morning Scotland”, and I appreciated your comments about the council leader. You touched on the need to be more imaginative and consider other ways to lever in resources—through the European Investment Bank, for example. It would be helpful if you could expand on some of that thinking, even if it is at an initial stage, because we are trying to help the petitioners to move the issue forward in a constructive way that makes them feel confident that the conditions can be materially changed.

Alex Neil
link

As part of the consultation on the forthcoming housing bill, we will consider seriously any recommendations that the committee makes on issues such as letting agents, because the committee is now familiar with the problems in Govanhill. If the committee wants to highlight any particular areas for action, the Government—and, I am sure, Glasgow City Council—will take any suggestions very seriously, because we are determined to tackle the problem.The issue of resources has been mentioned, to which there are two aspects. First, there is the issue of capital resource for new-build housing. It is clear that one reason why there is such a predominance of private sector housing is that, by definition, there is not enough social rented housing. We are working with Glasgow Housing Association and the city council not only in Govanhill but elsewhere in Glasgow to consider how we can further increase the build programme in Glasgow, which will include Govanhill. That is where the European Investment Bank could come in with regard to provision; already, just before Christmas, the EIB announced £70 million of loan funding at a very good rate for eight housing associations throughout Scotland. The EIB is also involved with GHA and provides substantial loan funding for it—that is what I was referring to this morning on “Good Morning Scotland”.The second aspect is funding for services, for example to deal with environmental issues such as cockroaches or to ensure the robust implementation of the current legislation on landlord registration and associated activity. It is fair to say that there is probably a resource issue in relation to that, and I am keen to talk to the council to find out what we can do imaginatively to address the situation.I will give you an example, which I have not had the opportunity to discuss with the council—I am thinking aloud.

The Convener
link

That is very positive.

Alex Neil
link

Absolutely.The unique thing about Govanhill is the combination of factors in a confined area. There is a unique concentration of inward migration populations, of diverse ethnic communities—the figure of 51 communities was mentioned—and of private sector and, in particular, slum landlords. That set of circumstances is unique in Scotland.The imaginative initiatives that I would like us to look at include possibly establishing a special hit squad to work, perhaps over a period of two or three years, to implement the current legislation on landlord registration. It would not need to be a large organisation, and it could break the back of the slum landlord problem in Govanhill.Those landlords are the source of a lot of the problems, and the danger is that, even if we invest heavily in the services that we are talking about, in four or five years’ time we will be back to square 1 if we do not put them out of business. We need to clear them out and sort them out, and we need a special hit squad, which could perhaps then move on to other parts of the city.We should look at whether we can obtain funding, perhaps under the auspices of the community development trust or from sources that we have not tapped into so far. We could perhaps re-employ retired housing inspectors with the expertise to do the job. That may not be possible, but it is the kind of imaginative proposal that we need. Unless we take some innovative measures, we will not break the back of the problem. Both we and the council have shown ourselves willing to work together with the community, which is critical, and to take the innovative measures necessary to try to rid Govanhill of the central problem of slum landlords.

The Convener
link

Thank you, minister. Are there any other questions? I am conscious that we have a heavy schedule, so I want to pull everything together in the remaining minutes.

Anne McLaughlin Glasgow) (SNP
link

I will speak briefly, and I am not even sure who I am addressing this to.My understanding is that, unless a landlord is letting a property as an HMO, it cannot be inspected. Could changes be made to the legislation to allow for that? The properties that we saw would not pass any inspection and should not be rented out. Councillor Braat may say that there are not the resources to inspect every single property, and I understand that, but the minister mentioned the idea of a hit squad—could the legislation provide the opportunity for something such as a hit squad to carry out spot checks on properties? Even if we did not have the resource to inspect every single property, any landlord who registered would know that their property might be inspected and that they could be prevented from renting out a property that was below a reasonable standard.

Alex Neil
link

There are two issues in that. The first is that there is nothing to prevent a hit squad, or any council officer so authorised, from knocking on the door and checking whether the landlord is properly registered. They can do that under the current legislation. The problem that Councillor Braat highlighted is that such people do not have a right of entry into the property, and Glasgow City Council has suggested that we might want to include in the proposed private sector housing bill a power to give them the right of entry.

Anne McLaughlin Glasgow) (SNP
link

That right would be to enter the property to check whether the landlord is registered; I was talking about a right to enter to check whether the property is below tolerable standard and therefore cannot be rented out.

The Convener
link

We must deal with the issue that we have been presented with by the petitioner. I know that Anne Lear is here, and we might want her to conclude on these points.A series of initiatives needs to be undertaken—practical, everyday activities. Only yesterday evening, there were phone calls from residents who had 14 rats in their back court. The rubbish and detritus had been allowed to pile up out of control because of conduct in the area. More rigorous enforcement is needed around the clock. Whether there is a hit squad or an action plan—whatever we do to pull everything together—ultimately it is a matter of investing the right level of resource. I know that that is a challenge for us all in public service at the moment, but we need to deal with it. I ask Anne Lear to conclude. Anne, you have more than 30 years’ experience. You have not asked me to say this, but it is important: you have a track record that could deliver if we could get people around the table who would do something different. What we are doing at the moment is not sufficient, and that is the real challenge.15:00

Anne Lear Govanhill Housing Association
link

I will quickly answer your point about rubbish, which is a big issue in Govanhill. We have a proposal for a positive scheme that involves Oxfam working with the Roma community. Those people are unemployed people who were brought here by the promise of work but did not receive it when they got here; the scheme would also be for unemployed local people. We seek support to set up with the council a practical scheme to clear up the mess because that is not being done at the moment, and it is a considerable problem that causes many of the environmental issues that I have been talking about.During my 30 years of experience, I was involved in the original rehab schemes in Glasgow. It does not seem to me to be rocket science, and we can do it again. We have dealt with private landlords before. The critical point is that 75 per cent of the property in the area is now privately owned, so I agree with the minister that we cannot wait for new legislation. We have to use Govan Law Centre, which is doing a great job in the area. Govanhill Law Centre has also been set up and we are working in partnership with it. We hope to get support through the council to start using compulsory purchase orders when they are required. However, we need Government support to look at the possibility of valuing property minus the repairs that have to be done. It would be wrong to pay the valuation on a property without deducting the cost of fixing its problems.I am quite positive that we can work with all our partners in the area, all the council departments, the police and fire brigade and everyone else who is involved. We need the support of everyone involved.

The Convener
link

I was going to end on a positive note, but I will let John Wilson in.

John Wilson Central Scotland) (SNP
link

I am sorry convener; some of us have that role in life.I want to get the issue clearly on the record. It is not just about the flats, but about the condition of the communal areas. When we went on the visit, we saw the problems with the staircases leading up to some of the properties. Many of them would have been condemned by health and safety years ago because of their condition. Some of those communal areas need major improvements.I have tried to encourage members of other committees to visit Govanhill to see for themselves the conditions that people are being expected to live in. Unfortunately, vulnerable families are moving into the area and are being offered such accommodation—at very high rents, I hasten to add. We need to ensure that we are talking about improving not just living conditions in the flats, but the communal areas such as the staircases and back courts.I am concerned about a new building programme taking place in Govanhill. If some of those existing properties could be relocated to other parts of the city, they would command high prices, especially if they were improved. At present, Anne Lear is right to say that private or rogue landlords should not be allowed to profit in any way from the investment that is put into those properties to bring them up to standard.

The Convener
link

I want to conclude on that, and I hope that it will inspire further contributions from the council and the minister. I invite Phil Braat and the minister to give us their final comments.

Councillor Braat
link

I completely agree with what I have just heard from Anne Lear and the minister, and I welcome the minister’s comments. As he said, the issues that have arisen in Govanhill are not unique by nature; they happen elsewhere in Glasgow as well. The uniqueness of Govanhill is to do with the concentration of specific problems, which is what we need to tackle. We have already heard about the specific problems that are concentrated in Govanhill, and I do not need to rehearse them.On environmental health issues, we are talking not just about rat and cockroach infestation but about general littering and refuse. We need to tackle people’s behaviour, and the role of everyone around this table, including the CHCP, is to engage with the local community and to try to change the behaviour of certain people.John Wilson mentioned another crucial point, which is not just living standards in the internal parts of the flats, but the common areas, including outside the blocks. The amenity of the area needs to be tackled. That is why I welcome the minister’s comments about a hit squad—let us call it that—which should look at not only the fabric of the buildings but the overall social fabric of the community. I welcome the minister’s comments, and I hope to speak to him in more detail about that so that we can continue the concerted efforts that have already been made in our positive dialogues to date, including those with the housing association, the CHCP and other relevant parties. We need to include the local community and ensure that people are fully aware of what we are trying to do.

The Convener
link

Thank you. Minister, I am conscious that you have other commitments, but if you would like to make any further comments, please do.

Alex Neil
link

I have two points to make. The first has not yet been mentioned but it is important and is one of the reasons why time is of the essence. Some slum landlords are buying up property as it goes up for sale in Govanhill. Obviously, that will further erode community solidarity in Govanhill. We must arrest the decline and see what we can do as quickly as possible. Secondly, I repeat what I said on “Good Morning Scotland” this morning. Steven Purcell has been very committed to Govanhill. He has worked closely with the Scottish Government on the area and many of the improvements that have been made during the past 18 months are due to his work. I pay tribute to that and, as the minister, I am seeking an urgent meeting with Mr Purcell’s successor and Councillor Braat so that we can proceed with an active agenda to address the issues. No one, no matter where or who they are, should be living in such conditions in the 21st century.

The Convener
link

Hamish, I know that the discussion has centred on housing, but you got a flavour there of the experience on the people side.I thank everyone for their patience on this issue. Petitions go into the system and take a long time to come through, but the fact that senior figures from the Government and the council have come to the meeting with the petitioners means that, although it does not feel like we are at the sharp end, we are moving things forward where we can. There are issues around resources and about the right direction in tackling issues and asking people to change their behaviour and sorting them out if they do not change. We need to work on the issue and make progress. I thank everyone for their time.We will take a brief comfort break before we discuss the next petition.15:08 Meeting suspended.

15:13 On resuming—

  1. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  2. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 42
  3. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 88
  4. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 12
  5. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 9
  6. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 6
  7. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 7
  8. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 6
  9. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  10. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  11. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  12. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 13
  13. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  14. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 13
  15. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  16. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 9
  17. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  18. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  19. 14:00 New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 1

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.