Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Flood Defences

SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Environment and Rural Development

Thursday 1 February 2007 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 10 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

10 contributions
Mark Ruskell Green Mid Scotland and Fife
link
To ask the Scottish Executive what steps it is taking to review the approach to minimising flooding risks to communities, in light of recent incidents highlighting the failure of hard engineering flood defence schemes. (S2O-11894)

Sarah Boyack Lab The Deputy Minister for Environment and Rural Development · Edinburgh Central
link
The flooding issues advisory committee is providing advice to the Executive on the implementation of a more sustainable approach to flood risk management. We plan to launch a public consultation on the issue later this month.

Mark Ruskell Green Mid Scotland and Fife
link
The minister will be aware of the manifest failure of hard flood defences at Milnathort. Will she commit to reviewing what went wrong at Milnathort, focusing not just on those hard flood defences, but on the approach that was taken by Perth and Kinross Council to sustainable flood management? In particular, will she focus on whether part of the problem that we saw at Milnathort recently was the result of planning decisions that may have led to flood waters being pushed away from new housing—built on flood plains—simply for it to appear in another part of the catchment, causing devastation?

Sarah Boyack Lab The Deputy Minister for Environment and Rural Development · Edinburgh Central
link
We need to be able to speak authoritatively on the exact cause of that incident, which is something that I am very concerned about. My predecessor met George Reid, the constituency member for the area, before Christmas. I have spoken to George Reid since then, and I know that he has been trying to keep local colleagues up to speed with the issue. The key thing is that Perth and Kinross Council has produced a preliminary report on the incident and it will now commission a more detailed report, on which we will all need to reflect. There may be lessons to be learned throughout Scotland, and there will definitely be lessons for residents and businesses in Perth and Kinross.

I recognise the wider points that Mark Ruskell makes about sustainable flood risk management. We want a consultation on the issue, gathering experience from throughout Scotland, as the increased incidence of flooding is leading to problems all around Scotland. I am very much looking forward to seeing the results of the Executive's World Wide Fund for Nature scoping study, which is compiling and examining evidence relating to the impact of land-use techniques on flood risk management. The study aims to see the implications of the current situation in Scotland and to look at land uses more generally.

There is a specific issue in Milnathort that needs to be addressed, but there are wider lessons to be learned and we need to think much more about sustainable flood management principles.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link
Does the deputy minister accept that an important factor in minimising flood risk for communities is timely decision making? Does she accept that it is high time that the Executive ruled on the City of Edinburgh Council's flood prevention scheme, which received planning permission in 2004? Although I recognise that the deputy minister cannot be involved in the decision, as it affects her constituency, will she urge the Minister for Environment and Rural Development to make a decision quickly? Will she also ensure that he puts the interests of my constituents in Stockbridge and Bonnington before the self-serving interests of the Scottish Rugby Union?

Sarah Boyack Lab The Deputy Minister for Environment and Rural Development · Edinburgh Central
link
Malcolm Chisholm is absolutely right about my long-term interest in the issue. Having seen the impact of a flood on constituents' businesses and houses, I assure him that it is a matter of great concern to the Executive that it has taken so long for the issue to be resolved. I acknowledge the point that he makes about timescales. It will be my colleague, Ross Finnie, who decides the issue, because of my previous interest. He has reassured me that he will complete his consideration of the matter as soon as he can.

The issue underlines the need for us to review how we deal with flood management. Malcolm Chisholm is absolutely right to say that it is a long time since the flood happened and a long time since the planning application was approved. We need to streamline the process. It is not about having another consultation; it is about looking at our legislative processes, which cut across getting swift, streamlined decisions and robust flood management systems in place. That is something that I am keen to pursue. The process was started with Malcolm Chisholm's work on the Planning etc (Scotland) Bill, and it must now be brought together with our flood management principles. I am keen to pursue that general issue urgently.

John Swinney SNP North Tayside
link
Is the minister aware of the study that is being undertaken as a joint venture between Network Rail and Perth and Kinross Council, in my constituency, to examine how to deal with flooding in the Dalguise area, where homes and the main rail line between Perth and Inverness are severely affected by the implications of flooding? Given her response to Mr Ruskell's earlier question about the need to examine these issues in a more comprehensive way, is she able to say what further initiatives could be deployed by the Executive to ensure that a wider flood prevention study is undertaken in the whole of the river Tay catchment area? Flooding is now a serious issue in the western part of my constituency.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Deputy Minister for Environment and Rural Development · Edinburgh Central
link
There is obviously the work that will be carried out by the local council, which is taking the lead in such matters. It is for the Executive ministers to work with local councils, once they have worked their schemes up, to find appropriate funding mechanisms. I know that, in his previous conversations with the minister, John Swinney has raised some practical thoughts as to how we might expedite some of those procedures and consider the funding issues. If John Swinney was prepared to put some of those thoughts down in writing, I would be keen to take them forward as I think that they are constructive ideas.

As regards the wider issue of flood management, we hope that the flooding issues advisory committee will be able to help us explore how to use land management techniques more generally to reduce the risk of flooding to communities. If partnership work is being carried out by the local council and Network Rail, I would be keen for it to be passed into the process. If there are good lessons to be learned, I want to ensure that we do not miss out on them.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link
It is the belief of many living in areas—such as Perthshire—that have been affected by flooding in recent weeks that the discontinuation of the traditional practice of gravel extraction from river-beds has exacerbated the problem by raising water levels. Given that the practice has effectively been outlawed by the Scottish Environment Protection Agency, will the minister instruct the agency to reconsider the issue and review the impact that river dredging would have on river levels and on the propensity to flood?

Sarah Boyack Lab The Deputy Minister for Environment and Rural Development · Edinburgh Central
link
I own up to not being an expert on that, but I would be more than happy to ensure that that question is included among the other issues that we are considering, such as using reservoir storage and natural flood attenuation, in examining the implications of different techniques. If Murdo Fraser wants to put a note to me, I will ensure that it goes to the flooding issues advisory committee so that that that issue is taken on board.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 1 February 2007 Debate · 1
  2. Green Procurement Debate · 56
  3. Scottish Water Debate · 80
  4. Economic Growth Questions · 8
  5. Planning System (Mediation) Questions · 8
  6. Gypsy Traveller Sites Questions · 7
  7. M77 (Barrhead) Questions · 4
  8. Tourism (Marketing) Questions · 4
  9. Air Discount Scheme Questions · 6
  10. Fireworks Ban Questions · 7
  11. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
  12. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 13
  13. Catholic Church (Adoption) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  14. Road Safety First Minister’s Questions · 4
  15. Autistic Spectrum Disorder (Teachers) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  16. Crichton Campus First Minister’s Questions · 7
  17. SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
  18. Accident and Emergency Units (Lanarkshire) Questions · 6
  19. NHS Lanarkshire (Transport Impact Assessment) Questions · 4
  20. Motor Neurone Disease Clinical Specialists Questions · 4
  21. Consultant Contract Questions · 8
  22. National Health Service (Targets) Questions · 6
  23. Wet Age-related Macular Degeneration Questions · 4
  24. Minor Injury and Illness Units (NHS Tayside) Questions · 5
  25. Midwife-led Maternity Units Questions · 4
  26. Climate Change (Hydrogen) Questions · 6
  27. Flood Defences Questions · 10
  28. Chernobyl Incident (Restricted Areas) Questions · 4
  29. Food Miles (Young's of Annan) Questions · 4
  30. Declaration on Climate Change Questions · 4
  31. Recycling (Household Waste) Questions · 4
  32. Flooding Questions · 4
  33. Point of Order Procedure · 2
  34. Rights of Relatives to Damages (Mesothelioma) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 28
  35. Statistics and Registration Service Bill Bill debate · 15
  36. Decision Time Decision time · 44
  37. Cervical Cancer Members’ business · 17

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.