To ask the Scottish Executive what action it is taking as a result of the response by the chief executive of NHS Scotland on 17 January 2007 to the Audit Committee's report "Implementing the NHS consultant contract in Scotland". (S2O-11817)
Official Report · Chamber
Consultant Contract
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Health and Community Care
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Andy Kerr Lab 4
- Shona Robison SNP 2
- Duncan McNeil Lab 1
- Dave Petrie Con 1
The record
8 contributionsIt is important to recognise the potential that the consultant contract gives NHS Scotland to remunerate fairly that important group of staff and reward them appropriately for their service to the national health service, and to act as a driver for change and improvement in services to patients. That was acknowledged in the Audit Committee's report on the contract. The Executive is committed to turning the potential benefits that are associated with the new contract into actual benefits for patients, staff and the NHS. We have always maintained that realising the benefits fully will take time and we already have in place a process for planning and delivering the changes locally. We have recently emphasised to boards that their plans should demonstrate increased patient benefits and increased consultant-related productivity from service redesign.
Is the minister aware that, in Dr Kevin Woods's response to the Audit Committee's report, he agrees with the committee conclusion that the consultant contract
"is not being used to best effect"
and states that, in the coming year, boards are being asked to concentrate on developing
"clear plans for achieving the 1% target increase in consultant related productivity"?
Why is it taking so long for work to start on meeting the target and when will the minister be able to confirm what progress has been made towards achieving what must seem to many people a very modest improvement in productivity for a vast investment of resources?
"is not being used to best effect"
and states that, in the coming year, boards are being asked to concentrate on developing
"clear plans for achieving the 1% target increase in consultant related productivity"?
Why is it taking so long for work to start on meeting the target and when will the minister be able to confirm what progress has been made towards achieving what must seem to many people a very modest improvement in productivity for a vast investment of resources?
I must say that that question is somewhat naive. The new contract for consultants is the first such change in more than 50 years and we have never said that the benefits would arise overnight. Before the changes, we heard from members, including Shona Robison, about the recruitment and retention problems in the NHS. The new contract has secured recruitment and retained much-valued staff in our health service and we now have local job planning.
When we talk about productivity, we should mention the increased number of angioplasties and hip, knee and cataract operations and the record reductions in waiting times, which are now the lowest ever in the history of the national health service. There are examples throughout the service of consultants' participation in the re-engineering and redesign process, which is delivering for patients. However, in return, every board in Scotland is working locally to ensure that the job plans, which are a negotiated part of the contract and which will deliver for patients, are in place. The historic low waiting times in our NHS are part of the significant delivery that is coming about through the contract.
When we talk about productivity, we should mention the increased number of angioplasties and hip, knee and cataract operations and the record reductions in waiting times, which are now the lowest ever in the history of the national health service. There are examples throughout the service of consultants' participation in the re-engineering and redesign process, which is delivering for patients. However, in return, every board in Scotland is working locally to ensure that the job plans, which are a negotiated part of the contract and which will deliver for patients, are in place. The historic low waiting times in our NHS are part of the significant delivery that is coming about through the contract.
Does the minister agree that, notwithstanding the long-standing problems with getting the best value out of the contract, it would be unacceptable to pay our consultants less than they would be paid down south, as the consequence of that would be that we would lose further precious clinical staff?
We need to ensure that pay rates in Scotland for such a highly specialised and—to acknowledge what Duncan McNeil says—highly mobile workforce are consistent with those throughout the United Kingdom. Nonetheless, I want our pound of flesh from the consultants, who have better terms and conditions as a result of the new contract. I suggest that the productivity that we are achieving and that we will achieve tomorrow and further in the future will ensure that patients get a better service from our national health service.
How will implementing the contract affect the critical situation in the Oban and Fort William hospitals?
The combination of improved recruitment and retention, which I mentioned, the new training regime that modernising medical careers has introduced in Scotland, the focus of the royal colleges on reducing specialisation and increasing generalisation in health care and our ability to attract internationally qualified graduates into medicine in Scotland and to grow the workforce will enable our community hospitals strategy, which the Deputy Minister for Health and Community Care launched, to pay back in the recruitment and retention of much-valued skills in Scotland, thereby contributing to the success and turnaround of the hospitals to which Dave Petrie refers.
In this meeting
Everything on 1 Feb 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 1 February 2007 Debate · 1
- Green Procurement Debate · 56
- Scottish Water Debate · 80
- Economic Growth Questions · 8
- Planning System (Mediation) Questions · 8
- Gypsy Traveller Sites Questions · 7
- M77 (Barrhead) Questions · 4
- Tourism (Marketing) Questions · 4
- Air Discount Scheme Questions · 6
- Fireworks Ban Questions · 7
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 13
- Catholic Church (Adoption) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Road Safety First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Autistic Spectrum Disorder (Teachers) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Crichton Campus First Minister’s Questions · 7
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
- Accident and Emergency Units (Lanarkshire) Questions · 6
- NHS Lanarkshire (Transport Impact Assessment) Questions · 4
- Motor Neurone Disease Clinical Specialists Questions · 4
- Consultant Contract Questions · 8
- National Health Service (Targets) Questions · 6
- Wet Age-related Macular Degeneration Questions · 4
- Minor Injury and Illness Units (NHS Tayside) Questions · 5
- Midwife-led Maternity Units Questions · 4
- Climate Change (Hydrogen) Questions · 6
- Flood Defences Questions · 10
- Chernobyl Incident (Restricted Areas) Questions · 4
- Food Miles (Young's of Annan) Questions · 4
- Declaration on Climate Change Questions · 4
- Recycling (Household Waste) Questions · 4
- Flooding Questions · 4
- Point of Order Procedure · 2
- Rights of Relatives to Damages (Mesothelioma) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 28
- Statistics and Registration Service Bill Bill debate · 15
- Decision Time Decision time · 44
- Cervical Cancer Members’ business · 17
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.