Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Scottish Rural Development Plan (Modulation)

SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Environment and Rural Development

Thursday 21 September 2006 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 6 contributions · 3 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

6 contributions
Richard Lochhead SNP Moray
link
To ask the Scottish Executive whether Scotland is able to set its own modulation rate to fund the Scottish rural development plan. (S2O-10576)

Ross Finnie LD The Minister for Environment and Rural Development · West of Scotland
link
The draft voluntary modulation regulation currently allows for only one rate of voluntary modulation per member state. The Executive is pursuing that point with the European Commission and member states as the negotiations progress.

Richard Lochhead SNP Moray
link
I welcome the fact that the minister is pursuing the issue. Will he acknowledge the widespread feeling in the farming sector that the modulation rate that is set should be the one that is best for Scotland, given that the recent reform of the common agricultural policy was intended to give more flexibility to our ministers to ensure that such deals are the best for Scotland? Is it the aim of the minister's end game to ensure that he has the right to set a modulation rate that is the best for Scotland?

Ross Finnie LD The Minister for Environment and Rural Development · West of Scotland
link
The moment that the European Commissioner for Agriculture and Rural Development, Mariann Fischer Boel, and her officials tabled a revised proposal for modulation we—and, indeed the United Kingdom—made it clear that the present arrangement, which gives us the right at a sub-member-state level to set a modulation rate, is the one that we wish to pursue. This is a complicated matter because the commissioner is also looking at other member states and is apparently concerned that the existence of wide variations and the use of voluntary modulation could constitute a renationalisation of the CAP. We do not share that view and have made it clear to the Commission that we wish to have the status quo, which gives us the absolute power to set an individual rate, as we see fit, here in Scotland.

Alex Johnstone Con North East Scotland
link
Can the minister confirm that if he uses the power to raise the level of modulation, should it be granted, it will not be used as an opportunity to remove money from the current budgets and put it into areas that would divert it away from the current recipients? In other words, will he ensure that the same people get the opportunity to earn the same money for doing different things?

Ross Finnie LD The Minister for Environment and Rural Development · West of Scotland
link
We are quite constrained in what we can do in terms of modulation. If we accept the analysis that a substantial proportion of Scottish agriculture is still incapable of surviving without subsidy, it does not make sense to simply and in an unfettered way transfer funds from pillar 1 to pillar 2, because that would simply remove what is, to many people in Scottish agriculture, an essential support. However, people must prepare for the fact that it might not be in existence by 2013.

I do not think that the money can be given to every area on an annual basis. We have a rural development policy that seeks to improve and enhance rural Scotland over a five or 10-year period and I think that that means that individual farmers have to look to the longer term. If all I do is take X per cent from someone and give it straight back to them, I doubt that that will make a substantial material difference to the fabric of rural Scotland.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 21 September 2006 Debate · 1
  2. Greener, Fairer Scotland Debate · 150
  3. Additional Support Needs Questions · 10
  4. Sporting Attainment Questions · 6
  5. Antisocial Behaviour Roadshow Questions · 8
  6. Youth Disorder (Glasgow Springburn) Questions · 4
  7. Trunk Roads (Signage) Questions · 4
  8. Property Law Questions · 4
  9. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
  10. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
  11. Competitive Advantage First Minister’s Questions · 6
  12. Youth Crime First Minister’s Questions · 8
  13. Football Banning Orders First Minister’s Questions · 4
  14. Genetically Modified Rice First Minister’s Questions · 13
  15. Recycling Questions · 6
  16. Scottish Rural Development Plan (Modulation) Questions · 6
  17. Nuclear Safety (Marine Environment) Questions · 5
  18. Environmental Footprint (Local Authorities) Questions · 7
  19. Organic Agriculture Questions · 6
  20. Pollution (Mobile Crushing Plants) Questions · 6
  21. Dairy Industry (Dumfries and Galloway) Questions · 6
  22. Mesothelioma Questions · 6
  23. Chemotherapy Patients (Wigs) Questions · 6
  24. Dental Services (Western Isles) Questions · 9
  25. Junior Doctors (Training) Questions · 7
  26. General Practitioner Services Questions · 5
  27. Care Home Provision (Highlands) Questions · 4
  28. “Review of the Scottish Diet Action Plan” Questions · 4
  29. Edinburgh Airport Rail Link Bill: Preliminary Stage Bill debate · 87
  30. Edinburgh Airport Rail Link Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 4
  31. Decision Time Decision time · 46
  32. Elgin Bypass Members’ business · 13

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.