To ask the Scottish Executive what powers it has to ensure that a local authority contributes fairly to the education of children with additional support needs who attend school in another local authority area. (S2O-10605)
Official Report · Chamber
Additional Support Needs
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE General Questions
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Robert Brown LD 5
- Ken Macintosh Lab 2
- Christine Grahame SNP 1
- Lord James Douglas-Hamilton Con 1
- Rosemary Byrne Sol 1
The record
10 contributionsSection 23 of the Education (Scotland) Act 1980 gives the Scottish ministers the power, on a reference from a local authority and in the absence of agreement between the authorities concerned, to determine the level of contribution that a home authority is to make towards the cost of a pupil's education in another local authority area.
Does the minister agree that an unintended consequence of the Education (Additional Support for Learning) (Scotland) Act 2004 is that some local authorities might not be supporting children with additional support needs whom they previously funded? Does he agree that, given that we are talking about sums of more than £250,000 a year in some cases, the situation is unfair not only on some local authorities, such as East Renfrewshire Council, but particularly on parents and families, who do not wish to be caught up in disputes about funding between local authorities when they are worried about their children's education? Will the minister commit to working with me and the local authorities concerned to resolve the issue in East Renfrewshire, the many other pending cases and those that might arise in the future?
I think that the issue arises not from the 2004 act but from the 1980 act, which has been in place for many years. The central issue is young people's welfare. I expect all local authorities to make appropriate and adequate arrangements for all children in their schools, whether they are placed with them or otherwise. Under the 1980 act and the 2004 act in particular, parents have substantial rights. When necessary, they can enforce those rights in various legal and administrative ways.
We expect local authorities to agree the circumstances in which one authority should make contributions to another. If they cannot agree, the Scottish ministers will determine the contribution under section 23 of the 1980 act. When we make determinations, we expect local authorities to implement them.
As Ken Macintosh suggested, several cases are pending between Glasgow City Council and East Renfrewshire Council, which we hope will be resolved directly. Officials are working closely with the two authorities on that, against the background of the central considerations that I have made plain.
We expect local authorities to agree the circumstances in which one authority should make contributions to another. If they cannot agree, the Scottish ministers will determine the contribution under section 23 of the 1980 act. When we make determinations, we expect local authorities to implement them.
As Ken Macintosh suggested, several cases are pending between Glasgow City Council and East Renfrewshire Council, which we hope will be resolved directly. Officials are working closely with the two authorities on that, against the background of the central considerations that I have made plain.
I ask the minister again to consider rucksacking—if I may use that term—which is a solution that I have proposed before. It would mean that the care package and funding would follow the child, although they might have to be tweaked in another local authority. That would eradicate the conflicts between local authorities and would be a far simpler solution. Will he kindly investigate that?
I am not sure that Christine Grahame's proposal is as simple as she suggests. As she knows, local authorities receive a substantial and non-ring-fenced amount to spend on education and additional support for learning. When placement requests or other arrangements are made between local authorities to educate children from one local authority in a different local authority's area, provision is available to enable contributions to be made. That is where the issue has arisen. The question is how to resolve the issue, rather than taking the broader and somewhat different approach that Christine Grahame suggests.
To what extent do parents of children with additional support needs have a choice as to whether their children should go to a special school, whether it is in their own local authority's area or further afield?
As Lord James Douglas-Hamilton knows from his involvement in the passage of the 2004 act, parents have substantial rights in relation to the placement of their children. Local authorities can refuse a placement request only in some circumstances that are set out in legislation. That arrangement works fairly well. The 2004 act supplemented arrangements by making provision for mediation and early decision making in local authorities.
Does the minister agree that one of the major reasons why children with additional support needs have to attend schools in local authority areas other than those in which they live is to gain access to an educational psychologist? Often the situation is confused, and assessment and review meetings are delayed. Will the minister look into the matter and report back to us on his findings?
I confess that representations have not been made to me on the issue that Rosemary Byrne raises. If the member has particular concerns, I would be more than happy to discuss them with her. I do not think that placement in other local authority areas is the issue per se. There have been problems with the supply of educational psychologists, although numbers have gone up substantially during this session.
In this meeting
Everything on 21 Sep 2006 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 21 September 2006 Debate · 1
- Greener, Fairer Scotland Debate · 150
- Additional Support Needs Questions · 10
- Sporting Attainment Questions · 6
- Antisocial Behaviour Roadshow Questions · 8
- Youth Disorder (Glasgow Springburn) Questions · 4
- Trunk Roads (Signage) Questions · 4
- Property Law Questions · 4
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Competitive Advantage First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Youth Crime First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Football Banning Orders First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Genetically Modified Rice First Minister’s Questions · 13
- Recycling Questions · 6
- Scottish Rural Development Plan (Modulation) Questions · 6
- Nuclear Safety (Marine Environment) Questions · 5
- Environmental Footprint (Local Authorities) Questions · 7
- Organic Agriculture Questions · 6
- Pollution (Mobile Crushing Plants) Questions · 6
- Dairy Industry (Dumfries and Galloway) Questions · 6
- Mesothelioma Questions · 6
- Chemotherapy Patients (Wigs) Questions · 6
- Dental Services (Western Isles) Questions · 9
- Junior Doctors (Training) Questions · 7
- General Practitioner Services Questions · 5
- Care Home Provision (Highlands) Questions · 4
- “Review of the Scottish Diet Action Plan” Questions · 4
- Edinburgh Airport Rail Link Bill: Preliminary Stage Bill debate · 87
- Edinburgh Airport Rail Link Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 4
- Decision Time Decision time · 46
- Elgin Bypass Members’ business · 13
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.