To ask the First Minister how the Scottish Executive intends to give Scottish business a competitive advantage. (S2F-2443)
Official Report · Chamber
Competitive Advantage
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Jack McConnell Lab 3
- Alasdair Morgan SNP 2
- Murdo Fraser Con 1
The record
6 contributionsFrom the platform of the success and stability of our United Kingdom economy, we in Scotland will build long-term competitive advantage by improving the supply side of the Scottish economy and investing in skills and transport infrastructure through boosting capital budgets for further and higher education by 300 per cent and revenue budgets by 23 per cent; cutting business rates; attracting fresh talent; creating dozens of new international air routes; building new and better roads; buying new trains; and building new railways, including a visionary new rail route between our capital city and its airport.
Given the fiasco over the Executive's plans to help firms that are investing in research and development by cutting business rates, does the First Minister not wish that the Parliament had the full financial powers of a normal parliament, like those of so many of our small, successful neighbours? Does he not wish that he was able to produce policies that would work to give our businesses a competitive advantage?
I said last year that we would consider carefully how we could use the rates system to assist R and D-intensive companies that could benefit from further assistance. We continue to look at that issue. In addition, the figures that were published this week show not only that research and development in Scottish companies is at a far higher level than it used to be because of our investments and the entrepreneurial culture that is developing in Scotland, but that it is now at a higher level than in any other part of the United Kingdom. That is something of which we should be proud, instead of moaning about it as the SNP did again this week.
To help Scottish businesses, we need decent transport links. Mr Morgan says that he wants Scotland to have the things that a normal country might have. I will read out a list of some of the countries that have a link between their capital city and its airport: Brussels, in Belgium; Copenhagen, in Denmark; Stockholm, in Sweden; Oslo, in Norway; Athens, in Greece; Madrid, in Spain; Vienna, in Austria; Zurich, in Switzerland; Rome, in Italy; and Bucharest, in Romania. Dublin, in Ireland—which the SNP likes to quote as an example—is not on that list yet. Dublin does not have such a link, but it is going to get one. The Government in Ireland has plans to give Dublin a link and it is being supported by the parties in Ireland.
The SNP's announcement today that it is against the Edinburgh airport rail link is one of the most disgraceful not just anti-Edinburgh but anti-business statements that the SNP has ever made. I want Scotland to have the facilities of a normal country—the railways of a normal country—and we are going to deliver them even if the SNP votes against them.
To help Scottish businesses, we need decent transport links. Mr Morgan says that he wants Scotland to have the things that a normal country might have. I will read out a list of some of the countries that have a link between their capital city and its airport: Brussels, in Belgium; Copenhagen, in Denmark; Stockholm, in Sweden; Oslo, in Norway; Athens, in Greece; Madrid, in Spain; Vienna, in Austria; Zurich, in Switzerland; Rome, in Italy; and Bucharest, in Romania. Dublin, in Ireland—which the SNP likes to quote as an example—is not on that list yet. Dublin does not have such a link, but it is going to get one. The Government in Ireland has plans to give Dublin a link and it is being supported by the parties in Ireland.
The SNP's announcement today that it is against the Edinburgh airport rail link is one of the most disgraceful not just anti-Edinburgh but anti-business statements that the SNP has ever made. I want Scotland to have the facilities of a normal country—the railways of a normal country—and we are going to deliver them even if the SNP votes against them.
link
Does the First Minister accept that it does nothing for the credibility of the Executive to announce with great fanfare a policy such as the cut in business rates for companies that invest in R and D without first checking whether that policy could be implemented? Can he tell us who is to blame for that incompetence? Is it the civil servants or the ministers?
We said last September that we would consider carefully the implementation of such a scheme, and we continue to do that. It is important that we are able to help R and D-intensive companies, and it is because we have made that a priority that we have seen such a dramatic increase in the research and development that is being carried out by Scottish companies. Scotland and Scottish companies are now leading the way for the rest of the United Kingdom, which is good news for Scotland. I am afraid that, whatever rebranding we get from the Tories, their same old policies would not have delivered that.
In this meeting
Everything on 21 Sep 2006 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 21 September 2006 Debate · 1
- Greener, Fairer Scotland Debate · 150
- Additional Support Needs Questions · 10
- Sporting Attainment Questions · 6
- Antisocial Behaviour Roadshow Questions · 8
- Youth Disorder (Glasgow Springburn) Questions · 4
- Trunk Roads (Signage) Questions · 4
- Property Law Questions · 4
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Competitive Advantage First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Youth Crime First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Football Banning Orders First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Genetically Modified Rice First Minister’s Questions · 13
- Recycling Questions · 6
- Scottish Rural Development Plan (Modulation) Questions · 6
- Nuclear Safety (Marine Environment) Questions · 5
- Environmental Footprint (Local Authorities) Questions · 7
- Organic Agriculture Questions · 6
- Pollution (Mobile Crushing Plants) Questions · 6
- Dairy Industry (Dumfries and Galloway) Questions · 6
- Mesothelioma Questions · 6
- Chemotherapy Patients (Wigs) Questions · 6
- Dental Services (Western Isles) Questions · 9
- Junior Doctors (Training) Questions · 7
- General Practitioner Services Questions · 5
- Care Home Provision (Highlands) Questions · 4
- “Review of the Scottish Diet Action Plan” Questions · 4
- Edinburgh Airport Rail Link Bill: Preliminary Stage Bill debate · 87
- Edinburgh Airport Rail Link Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 4
- Decision Time Decision time · 46
- Elgin Bypass Members’ business · 13
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.